[Blue Ajah Harry Potter Week] HP Mafia 2016 - Gilderoy Lockhart and the Cult of Personality - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Hallia]

I'm vicious! Rawrrrrr

[Wildfire Sedai]

LOL  I wasn't one who first used the word smear...just reiterating what was used.   and yeah you are vicious

[alannalynn]

Can I just say it feels "off" and leave it at that for now? Because that's what I'm doing regardless of approval 

[Hallia]

*ferocious growls*

[Kaylee]

I'm vicious! Rawrrrrr

Yeah you are.

[Wildfire Sedai]

of course lainey. 

[Andrej]

I have to agree to disagree about hallia: I think she would go on a smear campaign first post of the game.  hallia <3 just saying.  she is very outspoken and gets right to the point.  so why not.

 

What gives you that idea?

 

Do you think that's what she was doing this game?

[dicetosser1]

 

You tried lol

 

 

i couldnt find the flashy one like u and halli used lol but this one fits

[Verbal32]

You kind of answered yourself in your own post.

 

I have no issue with Hallia bringing it up. I am still saying it's not that indicative on your part, just very pointless.

 

What's pointless is the discussion about whether she lied about reading her role PM.  I can't see any possible reason why she would as either alignment, so it seems pretty clear (to me) that this discussion is "pointless".

 

If town:  she didn't read her role PM yet and posted.  Doubtful she lied.  Ok, null....moving on.

 

If scum:  she either did or didn't read her role PM yet and posted.  Doesn't matter if she lied, because her post was fluff and was not game-related.  Ok, null....moving on.

 

 

 

Everybody with me?  Good.

[Andrej]

Yep.

 

Onto actual discussion.

 

Do you agree with Laine that Hallia could've been angling to smear her?

[Kaylee]

Yep.

 

Onto actual discussion.

 

Do you agree with Laine that Hallia could've been angling to smear her?

If this is for anyone to answer, no I don't think so. I think Hally was just eager to play, saw something that stood out to her and said as much.

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

I have to agree to disagree about hallia: I think she would go on a smear campaign first post of the game.  hallia <3 just saying.  she is very outspoken and gets right to the point.  so why not.

1.What gives you that idea?

 

2.Do you think that's what she was doing this game?

 

 

1. I have very little experience in mafia, however hallia has played in all but 1 game that I have ever played in.  It seemed to me that early on Hallia grabbed at someones post and ran with it.

 

2.Yes, but I don't know the reasoning behind it. It is only d1 after all.  Also I don't know if "smear" is the right word..."dig" might be a better word.  She is digging to find stuff out...maybe

[Andrej]

Ok - but do yon think she does that as scum or town? That's what I was asking you.

 

"Smear" would generally mean Hallia was intentionally trying to make Laine look bad.

[Kaylee]

Ok - but do yon think she does that as scum or town? That's what I was asking you.

 

"Smear" would generally mean Hallia was intentionally trying to make Laine look bad.

Really loving AJ so far.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Ok - but do yon think she does that as scum or town? That's what I was asking you.

 

"Smear" would generally mean Hallia was intentionally trying to make Laine look bad.

 

scum because why would a townie want to start trouble? 

[Andrej]

I don't really know what to do with you WiFi.

[Wildfire Sedai]

what  ????  

[Andrej]

You're just a nut I've yet to crack.

 

You seem to think Hallia could be scum but you're not treating her that way. I'm not sure how to take it.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT (unchanged):

 

Verbal (1): AJ 

 

Not voting (8): Dice, Hallia, Rhea, Alanna, Luthine, WiFi, Kaylee, Verbal

 

 

Deadline for Day One is Tuesday, 8/2/16 at 9:00 PM PDT/midnight EDT.

 

[Andrej]

24 hours till DL

 

Really not sure who I wanna vote atp. We really need to step up the content

 

Does anyone have any reads/peeks/thoughts they wanna add?

[Hallia]

Yes, I agree.  There are a lot of nulls.

[Andrej]

9 pages and have to lynch in 24 hours.

 

I guess we could go NL but meh

 

Who do you have feelings about in either direction Hally?

[Hallia]

I do not like the idea of no lynch, it provides nothing.  

 

I know if I say Wifi, it will be because I don't understand her playstyle yet...still...I know that is why she always comes across as scummy to me. v.v' it's hard.

[Kaylee]

9 pages and have to lynch in 24 hours.

 

I guess we could go NL but meh

 

Who do you have feelings about in either direction Hally?

Says the guy with a joke vote still in place.

[Kaylee]

I feel good about Laine and Hally. AJ and Verb to a lesser extent. Won't vote in the first two today.

 

Don't have a strong enough feel to place a vote on anyone. I'll be going to bed soon.