[LIGHT VS SHADOW]: Black Tower Mafia Game

[ed2funy]

Pretty much what BG said about it being a null tell. I disagree with him doing it, but it is quite possible that it is true.

 

BG, why do you think it's cult?

I kinda like that idea, as in it makes sense, with Taim converting all the Asha'man he can.

[bgrishinko]

Pretty much what BG said about it being a null tell. I disagree with him doing it, but it is quite possible that it is true.

 

BG, why do you think it's cult?

I kinda like that idea, as in it makes sense, with Taim converting all the Asha'man he can.

 

Pretty much this. It makes too much sense not to be true.

[Ithillian Turambar]

The first game I ever played with Tina had no Mafia, just Seanchan who could recruit and then use Channelers as Damane. I guess that was cultafia too.

[Turin Turambar]

Darthe is stirring away. If you took the people as they are at the end of ToM at the BT then you would lean Pevara to be Town, or at worst some sort of survivor type. Since their are 18 people in the game it would follow that some of the AS at the tower would also be present in the game. /setupdiscussion.

 

Darthe was forced to role reveal cause EP couldn't due to his modding. Well you could claim Saidin EP.

 

Could be Maw. Ithi is firmly showing her town meta with looking for little slips and pushing at the cracks to see if they split open.

 

Is this sarcasm or humor? Or did I miss something? Didn't look like there was a need to reveal at all.

 

I still don't think Darthe is scum based on his reveal, odd as it seems. But this comment struck me odd

Yes random it was a joke. EP is fairly well known for character hinting or claiming really early in games.

 

 

[randomh3r0]

Gotcha, thanks for the clarification.

 

This is my first time playing with 80% of the people here, so I may miss jokes

[ed2funy]

You won't miss my jokes. And I won't miss your face.

 

Ithi is Mod-metaing?

[Ithillian Turambar]

People are more likely to use roles they are familiar with :)

[randomh3r0]

I don't think anyone will miss your jokes Ed...

 

:)

[ed2funy]

Ouch.

[Niniel]

The first game I ever played with Tina had no Mafia, just Seanchan who could recruit and then use Channelers as Damane. I guess that was cultafia too.

 

That was such a fun game. It was the first time that I false claimed and got away with it. For a whole day. :) I think it might have been Nolder´s first DM game?

[RandA lThor]

Don't worry Ed, I'll miss your jokes.

 

not really

[John Snow]

Well, I suppose there's no rule against gaming the mod, but still. I think doing that is in poor taste.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I've never understand why some Mods include that rule. From experience, people are never right and their various theories make for a good old Modly giggle :)

[bgrishinko]

I've never understand why some Mods include that rule. From experience, people are never right and their various theories make for a good old Modly giggle :)

 

Agreed.

[Darthe]

I don't consider game speculation gaming the mod. I consider attempting to manipulate the moderator to gain an unfair advantage to be gaming the mod.

 

Anyhow, how many votes did I garner for my character reveal and why did I get them? Better, who has been here and not reacted at all?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Hardly anyone is reacting about anything.

[Darthe]

I noticed. It is kinda a bummer. Why sign up if you don't want to play? And it is a freaking Tuesday. Oh well, I am going to go try to make a D1 case.

[Darthe]

Is it weird that I got through page one and EP already pings to me? As Moderator I think he wants the mafia to win.

[Ithillian Turambar]

It gets even better when BG votes him and then complains that his vote has not been counted.

[bgrishinko]

Told ya he was pinging.

[randomh3r0]

There were reactions Darthe. Most of them seemed to be saying your reveal was kinda null. I say it doesn't make you scum, but it was an interesting choice, as truth or a lie.

Has everyone even checked in yet?

[dicetosser1]

of course EP pings darthe right now he's cclaimed the creator and a lot of us ARE shadowies after all...

[Ithillian Turambar]

Random and John Snow are on the mafia team btw. See how reasonable he is being.

[Gabriel Kross]

Is it weird that I got through page one and EP already pings to me? As Moderator I think he wants the mafia to win.

 

I just want to write everyones death scenes! They may be a little icky you may get splattered with blood, but hey Halloween is right around the corner.

[Darthe]

Quoting for analysis and reads.

 

BG is Bela, the secret DO?

Vote BG

*sigh* Had I known that you were going to be in this game, I would've voted you TRL.

Tinaaaaaaaa!

checkin in!!

So vote him?

vote John Snow

 

For being easily led and clearly feeling so guilty about being Mafia he thought his none vote on TRL would point a big finger at himself, which it did.

vote rand

For leaving the BT to the M'Hael's ministry (irony)

Voting Ithi with poor reasoning and because he is mafia.

So lets get this rolling. 18 town is 4-6 scum, 0-2 symps, and perhaps a third party or SK. Canon dictates a Logain and a M'Hael who we now know SPOILER

has been made one of the chosen

. as well as some others. I am Pevara of the red ajah. Yet I am town. Discuss.

Shhh....

 

That was for Tina.

 

 

My money is 100% on there being a cult in this game.

You know, generally when someone reveals early, it's scum eager to use their fakeclaim, in my opinion.

Unvote vote Darthe

John Snow could not be more Mafia. He actually is dressed like this at the moment.

 

 

He did really well at completely ignoring my last mention of this and is no doubt hoping that I will just go away. Him and Random are probably on the Mafia Team together and thing it is just the most brilliant fun ever.

 

BG voted the Mod. Epic.

Ithi, me joke voting random is something I do whenever possible. It's part of our friendly rivalry. Yeah, I don't like changing my joke votes, but I thought "Aw, heck, why not do it."

I don't do joke votes and don't actually believe they exist. They should be banned because they allow Mafia like yourself to plave a vote and say, oh but it was just a joke.

 

I saw your mock outrage at not voting him, followed by BG say why not do it, and then you voted him. And then you completely and utterly ignored my genuine vote on you, until I mentioned that you were ignoring it a little too much and abracadabra ... Here you are explaining yourself.

 

It's almost too easy.

But it remains that it was said and lo, john Snow did place his vote upon the Random one, and then he did sayeth that it mattered not.

 

At which point he was struck down by an almighty explosion for fibbing his head off.

I hesitate to buy Snows opinion that only Scum would claim so early. Darthe is more experienced than that. There was no pressure on him, with everyone joke voting so far (Ithi notwithstanding). But it's an interesting move. Darthe?

Dudes, why wouldn't I character claim? We are getting this game going. Also,Unvote Vote Ithi. See above.

Unvote

 

Vote Ithi

 

Ithi is trying to hard and has played her hand early

Dudes, why wouldn't I character claim? We are getting this game going. Also,Unvote Vote Ithi. See above.

This says to me that he's just looking for an easy bandwagon. VOTE DARTHE

He did indeed.

Darthe is stirring away. If you took the people as they are at the end of ToM at the BT then you would lean Pevara to be Town, or at worst some sort of survivor type. Since their are 18 people in the game it would follow that some of the AS at the tower would also be present in the game. /setupdiscussion.

 

Darthe was forced to role reveal cause EP couldn't due to his modding. Well you could claim Saidin EP.

 

Could be Maw. Ithi is firmly showing her town meta with looking for little slips and pushing at the cracks to see if they split open.

Darthe, are you refering to Nolder's reasoning?

 

 

It is a dangerous game the mafia are playing if they are gunning for Ithi right now. Curious why Ithi's questioning of Snow is gaining so much attention.

Of course I am referring to Nol's reasoning! And Turin, have you ever initially thought Ithi was mafia? I have. But why I am voting her isn't that important atm. Of course, I am not crazy, I wouldn't instantly character claim without some purpose. But why truly isn't that special. It gets a game going and sets up reactions early. Look at the votes after all. Let's see what happens

I asked because nolder's "trying to hard" reasoning doesn't seem to hold water. I admit that I don't think Ithi initially mafia(well except the game we were mafia together, but that was a while ago) But tbh, I don't lean mafia on anyone (yes even you Despo) until I hear them say things that make the mafia alarms go off. Asking questions and trying to get people to give their opinions is a good way to search out the mafia. That Snow has used the "it was strictly a joke vote" defense and there has been so much attention given to Ithi along with a little defense from Maw and myself(I admit mine, not sure if Maw wants to be characterized as such or if he will say it is just seeing you as out for an easy lynch)

 

You might even be right and Ithi is just sticking to her meta in order to hide in amongst the town. It would be hard to do here but never underestimate the mistress of mafia. I will see what your scheme produces for now. If you are Pevara then this is suitably twisted AS reasoning.

I have absolutely no problem with Darthe's claim as Pevara being town. The decision to claim now, kind of questionable, but honestly, half the time it takes something questionable or intentionally scummy to kick start the discussion to useful game related things.

 

@ Snow: People who character claim early with little to no pressure generally fall into one of two camps. Either noob scum who are super excited about their fake claim and can't wait to use it.... or someone with a more considered plan that may not be immediately apparent. I'm guessing Darthe falls into that second camp.

Unvote

Vote Darthe

 

I didn't actually think it would be that easy

Trying too hard? Playing her hand? The only person who would follow that is overeager scum trying to get rid of a contender ASAP

So, wth?

Darthe, why claim early? Arguing Pevara being Town could have been done had you needed to reveal in the future.

 

Sleepy and just skimmed through another game. Will post more tomorrow. A little slow on the uptake for this game, methinks, but I will be here to ever be on watch for Lord Noldermort's scumminess.

Darthe is stirring away. If you took the people as they are at the end of ToM at the BT then you would lean Pevara to be Town, or at worst some sort of survivor type. Since their are 18 people in the game it would follow that some of the AS at the tower would also be present in the game. /setupdiscussion.

 

Darthe was forced to role reveal cause EP couldn't due to his modding. Well you could claim Saidin EP.

 

Could be Maw. Ithi is firmly showing her town meta with looking for little slips and pushing at the cracks to see if they split open.

 

Is this sarcasm or humor? Or did I miss something? Didn't look like there was a need to reveal at all.

 

I still don't think Darthe is scum based on his reveal, odd as it seems. But this comment struck me odd