[TOWN WINS!] BG's Basic Wheel of Time Books Mafia

[peacesells]

Do you still think I'm a Witch, Peace lol.

 

yes

[Ithillian Turambar]

There's a Dead Thread?

[peacesells]

Yup..here.

 

http://quicktopic.com/48/H/9ZrrnxX8wbK

[Turin Turambar]

Ooh, I wanna see the dead thread. See My ploy wasn't unplausible. I guess I killed the wrong people.

[Ironeyes]

Fantastic game, everybody. I really enjoyed watching this one from above.

[peacesells]

can we see the scum qt?

[bgrishinko]

If they all ok it, I'll post it. Or one of them can post it.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Turin you bad mafioso you. Can we see the mafia QT please?

[Turin Turambar]

I wanted to wait for the others to say okay. If they don't say no by the end of the day I will post it.

[Nolder]

I didn't think my Unlyncher + Miller combo twist was too much for basic. They were a balance and an interesting little thing I think. Opinions?

It was.

Basic implies an expectation of learning the flow of the game and not having overly complicated roles.

No one would suspect an Unlyncher. That's not even rare in advanced games, it's almost unheard of.

So right off the bat whoever gets that role is at somewhat of a disadvantage.

Now I get what you tried to do with the Miller/Unlyncher dynamic but given that this is a basic game we can't really expect the players to use advanced tactics and think ahead.

What is likely to happen more often than not is the Unlyncher will never vote the Miller and have an unreasonble belief in their towniness. This will probably make everyone suspicious when they notice. The mafia might NK the Unlyncher thinking he's a cop, the cop might investigate the Miller or Unlyncher, and either of them might get lynched because of that behavior. It worked out fine this time but I don't think that was entirely balanced.

 

Anyway good game everyone and thank you for modding BG. It was a cool theme and I had a lot of fun.

And I'd again like to apologize for bailing on the first day. Really not cool and I'll try not to let that happen anymore.

[Nolder]

I don't mind if the scum QT is posted

[michellem]

YES! Good job town! It was a great game, I've learnt loads.

[Graendals favourite]

I didn't think my Unlyncher + Miller combo twist was too much for basic. They were a balance and an interesting little thing I think. Opinions?

It was.

Basic implies an expectation of learning the flow of the game and not having overly complicated roles.

No one would suspect an Unlyncher. That's not even rare in advanced games, it's almost unheard of.

So right off the bat whoever gets that role is at somewhat of a disadvantage.

Now I get what you tried to do with the Miller/Unlyncher dynamic but given that this is a basic game we can't really expect the players to use advanced tactics and think ahead.

What is likely to happen more often than not is the Unlyncher will never vote the Miller and have an unreasonble belief in their towniness. This will probably make everyone suspicious when they notice. The mafia might NK the Unlyncher thinking he's a cop, the cop might investigate the Miller or Unlyncher, and either of them might get lynched because of that behavior. It worked out fine this time but I don't think that was entirely balanced.

 

Anyway good game everyone and thank you for modding BG. It was a cool theme and I had a lot of fun.

And I'd again like to apologize for bailing on the first day. Really not cool and I'll try not to let that happen anymore.

But I did get one more point on the scoreboards! :)

[dicetosser1]

congrats town!! ithi FANTASTIC work well done Wot!

 

BG can we see the stories for the remaining books? ive really been enjoying them!

 

 

Turin good try but i still think its implausible killing that many of ure own scum is suicide.....if it hadnt been for them being gotten so easily i wouldve been onto you before i let you slide cause they seemed unorganized

[Darthe]

Well done to both teams! Turin, guess who I viewed the night I died :)

[Kaylee]

Congrats town! This was fun to be a part of.

[Songstress]

Indeed... That was down to the wire. Great job by all!

[dicetosser1]

Well done to both teams! Turin, guess who I viewed the night I died :)

 

 

this would be why i wanted to know darthes view back then lol

[JenLenaMom]

I'm very upset you all speed lynched me! J/K great game guys!!

[Ironeyes]

Hey, I need 2-4 more people for my game which is next, so please come sign up! It's based on Brandon Sanderson's Elantris.

[Gabriel Kross]

I quit for 2 reasons, 1 I really felt the cases on day 1 were just way to farfetched. None of them really had any substance except for Wombat's case on Rand which annoyed me. 2 I had to cut back on games for personal reasons so I quit this one, until I quit only 1 person really suspected me so I didn't think it would turn out the way it did and for that I'm sorry JLM.

[Sakaea]

Cool game, BG. I had a lot of fun^_^