Pokemon Mafia III: The Treasure of Heart Island--GAME OVER--TOWN WIN

[Turin Turambar]

BG, Are you willing to lynch RTE also.

[Darthe]

Well this went wonderfully, ya'll!

 

I saw an RTE train with little chance of another push elsewhere in the day and realized that that was bad mojo for a game that the mod has defined as experimental, so I fake claimed a viewing on someone who was suspect of me.

 

Here is what I now know:

 

Ithi, Suchmadness, TG, and Dap are town.

 

Turin is mafia (when does turin not defend Ithi if he has a chance to believe she is town (hence my 10% wrong thing))

 

BG looks interesting.

 

You can all stop voting her now.

[Darthe]

oh and unvote vote Turin

[Niniel]

 Unvote.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Tina is very quick to vote ... And then unvote.

 

Turin defends me regardless. I ignore or kill him. I don't know what he is but defending me doesn't really mean much. If he is still alive near the end he is probably Mafia - unless I get killed at some point.

 

Also so funny people who say - well just saying you are Town isn't helping. What exactly are you supposed to say I wonder?

 

And Darthe could have just done all that to look super Town. Am just saying.

 

So - who is everyone's top picks now and why?

 

RTE still for me - car crash play that had no value to Town. Spilling wifom and claims and false claims and then actual real claims and all that stuff I put in the post where I voted.

 

Time for complete unwillingness to take a stance.

 

Dap for blatant awful buddying of me because he thinks that means I won't lynch him.

 

I think Maddy is Town - confused but Town.

 

I haven't really paid attention to the others sorry.

 

But we did see lions, a tiger, a leopard and all sorts of other stuff. Good times.

[Luciena]

 Oooh fun! *giggles* I'm here !

 

vote RTE

[Panchi]

RTE- I am not certain which way to lean but high on suspicious list

 

Darthe- all I know is that his playstyle is different and that is not much to go on. The Ithi is mafia made sense but then fake claim and Ithi is town confused me a bit.

 

Two fake claims on Day 1, a bit out of ordinary

[Turin Turambar]

 

Why is RTE not more concerned about people voting without giving a reason.

 

In fact the two people who are voting me at the moment have vote just said 'Vote Ithi - she is Scum' or 'Vote Ithi - She is Mafia'

 

That's RTE and Darthe btw.

 

 

 

RTE ... why do you think it is ok for Darthe to not give a reason for his vote, and also ... what is the reason for your vote?

 

I think it's ok because I don't think it's a serious vote.

 

He voted you for the same reason I voted you: see you panic under pressure.

 

You never disappoint love.

 

 

RTE, you are standing on dangerous ground... that last word is coming across as condescending or worse.

 

I apparently missed this entire page. phone mafia fail

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well this went wonderfully, ya'll!

 

I saw an RTE train with little chance of another push elsewhere in the day and realized that that was bad mojo for a game that the mod has defined as experimental, so I fake claimed a viewing on someone who was suspect of me.

Here is what I now know:

 

Ithi, Suchmadness, TG, and Dap are town.

 

Turin is mafia (when does turin not defend Ithi if he has a chance to believe she is town (hence my 10% wrong thing))

 

BG looks interesting.

 

You can all stop voting her now.

I don't think I was suspicious of you? Wasn't your Ithi is Mafia your first post? Or thereabouts anyways.

 

Why did you say I was suspicious of you?

[Turin Turambar]

Well this went wonderfully, ya'll!

 

I saw an RTE train with little chance of another push elsewhere in the day and realized that that was bad mojo for a game that the mod has defined as experimental, so I fake claimed a viewing on someone who was suspect of me.

 

Here is what I now know:

 

Ithi, Suchmadness, TG, and Dap are town.

 

Turin is mafia (when does turin not defend Ithi if he has a chance to believe she is town (hence my 10% wrong thing))

 

BG looks interesting.

 

You can all stop voting her now.

 

You are saying I am mafia because I didn't defend Ithi? I would say you have that wrong. I have stated clearly that I think she is town. If I were mafia I would have been more than willing to "follow the cop" and vote her as it would have been a pretty safe move. (as Tina is following).

 

Oh BTW TG isn't even in the game. step up your game darthe. You are nearly as much of a mess as RTE. I rescind my earlier belief in you. Since you were sefl admittedly lying about the entire view on Ithi. Question: if it took off when were you going to reveal that the view was a lie?

 

Current mafia reads:

RTE - too much to list

Darthe - trying to completely stall RTE train with fake cop view

Cyan - stalling RTE train, earlier comments about it going too fast

Time  - fence sitting. saying that she finds RTE scummy but unwilling to vote 

Dap -  extreme buddying. saying RTE is mafia but putting others in front of him. classic distancing without voting

Berf ?? he said it himself. plus a few other comments

Tina?? Following blind

Kronos?? questioning RTE lynch speed

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

The more RTE posts his emo "I'm going to die anyway" posts the more I think he is mafia.

Well as vanilla town I'd rather die in a blaze of information than get nked

 

 

Problem is, when you set yourself on fire, the information becomes useless because people all have a good reason to vote you. Heck, sheer annoyance policy lynch is a fair enough reason.

 

saw this on reread earlier and just wanted to comment. First, agreed with BG here. Vanilla town playing scummy in order to get lynched for "info" doesn't work because everyone will be willing to lynch you and will be able to justify it using your play. so just don't do it.

 

as to the bold. it is your job to get NKed if you are vanilla town. you are protecting the town power roles in that manner. Every night a vanilla dies is another night the cop has to search for mafia. The only death more glorious for a vanilla town is to die in such a manner that one or more mafia are outed.

 

*gets off soapbox*  does that make me "The Lecturer"?

[bgrishinko]

Welp. In light of the new info... I'm keeping my vote on Darthe.

[Ithillian Turambar]

This is what I think happened.

 

RTE got made Mafia Godfather and made the usual 1st time GF mistake of think woo hoo! I'm untouchable and then started with all the confusion sowing and wifoming he could possibly do - plus destroying any actual game content. He did this without he team knowing about it - cos they american. And then they wake up and go, what the! Omg dood you like totally got Ithi's Eye of Sauron locked on you and she's like totally terrierising you! And then Darthe rolls up in the QT and twirls his moustache and says that it's ok because he's got a cunning plan. He will fake claim an instant view on me - but include a plausible denial clause - and whoomp! Attention totally distracted from RTE.

 

Apart from RTE was clumsy and signposted the plot.

 

So. Well done. Nice plan.

 

I'd still rather Lynch RTE though - you don't get a major plot brought in to save the behind of a goon.

[dapianoplay3r]

My vote stays

a train on darthe as well as RTE is a grand idea

 

they need to sweat and think abbout what theyve done

[Darthe]

 

 

Some of you have ridiculous suspicions.  I could care less about RTE, believe it or don't.  I wanted info from the day and I have it.  Btw, Ithi, I mean to and accidentally typed of.

[dapianoplay3r]

That info inncludes naming someone not in the game town (you seem to of mossed that when someone else pointed it out)

[Turin Turambar]

 

Some of you have ridiculous suspicions.  I could care less about RTE, believe it or don't.  I wanted info from the day and I have it.  Btw, Ithi, I mean to and accidentally typed of.

So are you ready to vote RTE now then?

 

Would you like to share your information with the rest of the town?

[Turin Turambar]

That info inncludes naming someone not in the game town (you seem to of mossed that when someone else pointed it out)

Well we do KNOW that TG isn't mafia.

[Hisoka Al'Raer]

Red Herring? Hmm... I am not a terribly big fan of fish!

[Darthe]

 

That info inncludes naming someone not in the game town (you seem to of mossed that when someone else pointed it out)

Well we do KNOW that TG isn't mafia.

 

 

Totally meant chuckles.. jackasses

[suchmadness]

Yes Tina I use 'big words' in rl. This is the way I think because I learned English from reading the dictionary and LoRT. It's actually an effort for me to think of smaller words when the words I'm using is more concise. I wont apologise for it and I don't care if that makes me sound like a wanker.

 

That being said playing this game really reminds me of Midsomer Night Murder and it's English show set in a village where the most innocent and innocous person could be hiding a secret that would derail the town. As I said before I feel like Columbus the bumbling the detective. That doesn't mean I'm confused however merely questioning other's motives is not being confused. I'm winnowing down the chaff to find the kernel of truth.

 

So far I think Dap, Time, Despothera and BG is town. I can't read subterfuge on BG's text. He's pretty straight forward to me. While being a fence sitter can irk some people is not actually a crime and it's still early days yet so I stand by Time's prerogative to witheld her vote.

 

I am I'm unsure about Ithii's motives however. As she said claiming to be town is not a town makes. By this argument the more she claimed to be town the more I looked at her with my beady eyed squint.

 

Turin I'm pretty sure is mafia. More gameplaying will tell however.

 

As for Darthe he proved to be a liar and admitted to lying just to get another person's motivation. However I also did this when it comes to chuckles. I want to see which way he flips.

 

RTE just paint himself too convinient a target for me that's why I'm reluctant to go with this easy option.

[dapianoplay3r]

 

 

That info inncludes naming someone not in the game town (you seem to of mossed that when someone else pointed it out)

 

Well we do KNOW that TG isn't mafia.

 

Totally meant chuckles.. jackasses

TG

Chuckles

 

Autocorrect right?

[lolguy26]

 

 

That info inncludes naming someone not in the game town (you seem to of mossed that when someone else pointed it out)

Well we do KNOW that TG isn't mafia.

 

 

Totally meant chuckles.. jackasses

 

 

your saying you think im town?!

 

the one thing that worries me more than being called scummy is being called town by someone who seems to have a knack for lying and making random crap up 

[dapianoplay3r]

Why are you so worried about that chuckles?

[Turin Turambar]

Darthe you mad? You gotta laugh at a mistake like that. You answer my questions please?

 

Chuckles, you feel like you have received the kiss of death?

 

Maddy, game on!!