[Game Over] Cliche Mafia - The Death of Meta - Sooh Wins!

[BFG]

Hello :)

 

I'm having some trouble with DM :/

[Turin Turambar]

I would look at those that jumped on Panchi making her a viable alternative to Cass.

[Darthe]

What you would do doesn't help me and that wouldn't really matter without a Panchi lynch tbh.  Cass just isn't viable and the train on her (which Panchi was a weak part of) was bad.

[Darthe]

Hello :)

 

I'm having some trouble with DM :/

Panchi or Cass?

[Turin Turambar]

 

If Cass is out then wtl Tina or dice.

Are you Town reading Panchi or do you have some reason not to just join the biggest wagon this close to deadline?

Wagons are 5-5 so try again.

[Turin Turambar]

Repeat. Who is here?

[Darthe]

Me for about 15 more.  We need to move in a direction and we need to do it now.  DM always craps out for parts of the East Coast at around 5 so likely people won't be able and get on at DL.

[Turin Turambar]

Well. We need more than that.

[BFG]

Null on both but at this stage it doesn't matter.

 

Cass has been putting more work into this game, so for that reason I'd vote Panchi. But I'm more spooked by the people on Panchis's train.

 

You say that the votes on Cass don't have much basis, but you're the only one on Panchi that's made a case, other than that it's Dice's gut and sheeping.

 

Either way I loathe blinds lynches

[Darthe]

Gonna have to do it.  I don't want a Cass lynch but we need momentum and need it now.

[Cass]

 

Darthe number of games doesn't equal skill. Panchi could well.be mafia but it is known she is not a real veteran. I am finding this CFD highly questionable. Your stated reason of "I don't have a reason not to lynch" could be used on several people.

 

Cass have you answered Yates question about what reactions you got and what they mean to you when you floated the no lynch idea?

 

If Cass is out then wtl Tina or dice.

 

Blue - Me too. Mostly because of the spam and the fact that Darthe and Yates agree. If Panchi turns out to be Town then I think there would be significant reason to be concerned that Darthe and Yates are W-W, and that they're using both Panchi and I fantastically. And if that is the case I will congratuhate both of them forever. They started the CFD/train, and are both happy to vote Panchi over the others on my train without posting specific reasons in the thread and they're both working hard to make me want to trust them, in ways that make my skin crawl. (Darthe is explaining, on D1; Yates asked a heap of questions that had the subtlety of getting me on side/buddying me up before he voted Panchi). I've only played with these two when they are mafia, and whilst I acknowledge the chance that they could be Town and the CFD could be legit, they're both gutsy enough to try and pull something like this off, it feels slightly too neat, and I really don't like the spam. I'm don't think I'm a fan of CFDs in general. 

 

But I know I'm Town, and I don't know Panchi, why you're defending her or why she voted for me on a train I don't believe had any legit reason to gain traction, and that Tina/Dice are not going to be a viable alternate option.

 

Your answer is coming for the no lynch idea. Wanted to get this out first.

[Darthe]

Null on both but at this stage it doesn't matter.

 

Cass has been putting more work into this game, so for that reason I'd vote Panchi. But I'm more spooked by the people on Panchis's train.

 

You say that the votes on Cass don't have much basis, but you're the only one on Panchi that's made a case, other than that it's Dice's gut and sheeping.

 

Either way I loathe blinds lynches

Be less wishy-washy.  

[BFG]

Anyway, here *raises hand*

 

[v]Panchi[/v]

[Ithillian Turambar]

Me for about 15 more.  We need to move in a direction and we need to do it now.  DM always craps out for parts of the East Coast at around 5 so likely people won't be able and get on at DL.

I forgot about that. I'll extend the deadline by 15 minutes.

 

You now have 25 mins.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Vote Count

 

 

Dice – 2 (Tina, Tress)

Leyrann - 1 (Pralaya)

Tress - 2 (Verbal,Hallia)

Cass - 5 (RTE, Shadar, Turin, Panchi, Leyrann )

Panchi - 6 (Darthe, Dice, Sooh, Yates, Cass, BFG)

 

 

Not voting - 0

 

 

Day one ends 9.15 PM GMT 18 March 2015

 

with 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20150318T2115&p0=136&msg=end+of+day+1

[Darthe]

 

 

Darthe number of games doesn't equal skill. Panchi could well.be mafia but it is known she is not a real veteran. I am finding this CFD highly questionable. Your stated reason of "I don't have a reason not to lynch" could be used on several people.

 

Cass have you answered Yates question about what reactions you got and what they mean to you when you floated the no lynch idea?

 

If Cass is out then wtl Tina or dice.

 

Blue - Me too. Mostly because of the spam and the fact that Darthe and Yates agree. If Panchi turns out to be Town then I think there would be significant reason to be concerned that Darthe and Yates are W-W, and that they're using both Panchi and I fantastically. And if that is the case I will congratuhate both of them forever. They started the CFD/train, and are both happy to vote Panchi over the others on my train without posting specific reasons in the thread and they're both working hard to make me want to trust them, in ways that make my skin crawl. (Darthe is explaining, on D1; Yates asked a heap of questions that had the subtlety of getting me on side/buddying me up before he voted Panchi). I've only played with these two when they are mafia, and whilst I acknowledge the chance that they could be Town and the CFD could be legit, they're both gutsy enough to try and pull something like this off, it feels slightly too neat, and I really don't like the spam. I'm don't think I'm a fan of CFDs in general. 

 

But I know I'm Town, and I don't know Panchi, why you're defending her or why she voted for me on a train I don't believe had any legit reason to gain traction, and that Tina/Dice are not going to be a viable alternate option.

 

Your answer is coming for the no lynch idea. Wanted to get this out first.

 

 You're pushing for W-W from two people because they agree on someone looking bad, because one of them explained things and because one asked questions?  The entire paragraph you just wrote has made this thread worse for its' presence.  Similarly you were gunning at me for NOT explaining before I responded to you.  

[Darthe]

 

Me for about 15 more.  We need to move in a direction and we need to do it now.  DM always craps out for parts of the East Coast at around 5 so likely people won't be able and get on at DL.

I forgot about that. I'll extend the deadline by 15 minutes.

 

You now have 25 mins.

 

Thanks =) in reparation you could give us a scum.

[Turin Turambar]

Wanna change your vote Darthe

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

Me for about 15 more.  We need to move in a direction and we need to do it now.  DM always craps out for parts of the East Coast at around 5 so likely people won't be able and get on at DL.

I forgot about that. I'll extend the deadline by 15 minutes.

 

You now have 25 mins.

 

Thanks =) in reparation you could give us a scum.

 

if you don't achieve a lynch you'll never know :)

 

I'm gonna eat my sandwich now

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Darthe number of games doesn't equal skill. Panchi could well.be mafia but it is known she is not a real veteran. I am finding this CFD highly questionable. Your stated reason of "I don't have a reason not to lynch" could be used on several people.

 

Cass have you answered Yates question about what reactions you got and what they mean to you when you floated the no lynch idea?

 

If Cass is out then wtl Tina or dice.

 

Blue - Me too. Mostly because of the spam and the fact that Darthe and Yates agree. If Panchi turns out to be Town then I think there would be significant reason to be concerned that Darthe and Yates are W-W, and that they're using both Panchi and I fantastically. And if that is the case I will congratuhate both of them forever. They started the CFD/train, and are both happy to vote Panchi over the others on my train without posting specific reasons in the thread and they're both working hard to make me want to trust them, in ways that make my skin crawl. (Darthe is explaining, on D1; Yates asked a heap of questions that had the subtlety of getting me on side/buddying me up before he voted Panchi). I've only played with these two when they are mafia, and whilst I acknowledge the chance that they could be Town and the CFD could be legit, they're both gutsy enough to try and pull something like this off, it feels slightly too neat, and I really don't like the spam. I'm don't think I'm a fan of CFDs in general. 

 

But I know I'm Town, and I don't know Panchi, why you're defending her or why she voted for me on a train I don't believe had any legit reason to gain traction, and that Tina/Dice are not going to be a viable alternate option.

 

Your answer is coming for the no lynch idea. Wanted to get this out first.

 

 You're pushing for W-W from two people because they agree on someone looking bad, because one of them explained things and because one asked questions?  The entire paragraph you just wrote has made this thread worse for its' presence.  Similarly you were gunning at me for NOT explaining before I responded to you.  

 

I really get the sense that you didn't read my ISO on Panchi Cass.  It's pretty clearly the best case in the game thus far.

 

@Turin/BFG if either of you are more comfortable with a Cass lynch I can go back that way.  I cared before but this post is mind-boggling to me.  

[Songstress]

At lunch, just finished catching up.

 

I'm slightly uncomfortable because Darthe's statement about Panchi's experience level looks like a blatant misrep to me - she's played a few games over the last couple of years, but very few and she's never been comfortable in a game from what I've seen.

 

That said, her "if Cass is mafia Tress must be also" was a huge ping.

 

And we need to achieve a lynch.

 

[unvote]

[V]Panchi[/v]

[Darthe]

Wanna change your vote Darthe

[Darthe]

At lunch, just finished catching up.

 

I'm slightly uncomfortable because Darthe's statement about Panchi's experience level looks like a blatant misrep to me - she's played a few games over the last couple of years, but very few and she's never been comfortable in a game from what I've seen.

 

That said, her "if Cass is mafia Tress must be also" was a huge ping.

 

And we need to achieve a lynch.

 

[unvote]

[V]Panchi[/v]

Cass is currently using that logic to try and incriminate both Yates and I if this is a townie lynch.  Does that influence your read of her?

[Darthe]

[v] Cass [/v]

[Ithillian Turambar]

Vote Count

 

 

Dice – 1 (Tina)

Leyrann - 1 (Pralaya)

Tress - 2 (Verbal,Hallia)

Cass - 6 (RTE, Shadar, Turin, Panchi, Leyrann, Darthe )

Panchi - 6 (Dice, Sooh, Yates, Cass, BFG, Tress)

 

 

Not voting - 0

 

 

Day one ends 9.15 PM GMT 18 March 2015

 

with 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20150318T2115&p0=136&msg=end+of+day+1

 

 

You have 17 minutes