[Game Over] Cliche Mafia - The Death of Meta - Sooh Wins!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Awesome :)

[Leyrann]

Maybe we should just lynch Tina for being useless and the possibility she is mafia hiding behind only posting pictures as a cliché.

[Leyrann]

[unvote]

[Niniel]

RTE, you have played enough with me to know that I am NOT playing like I normally would, right? For example look at my post #778. I would NEVER word it like that if not for my cliché. Apart from maybe not having voted Panchi in the first place (reminder: everyone has two clichés), I would more likely have replied with an explanation for why I voted her plus asking what he then thought about Hallia (who I don't exactly trust).

 

Also, you're talking about Tress looking at least as scummy as last game, maybe even more. Last game she was non-town. If she looks even scummier than that, why aren't you voting her?

 

Good post!

 

 

 

I read the whole thread!

 

 

 

 

List coming up. 

[Niniel]

[Niniel]

Okay. My own as well...

[Leyrann]

I'm waiting...

[Leyrann]

And please, be honest about me. Enough people already are not.

[Niniel]

People that I won´t vote:

 

Ley - mega townie and I love his posting this game!

 

Panchi

Hally

Turin

 

 

People that I´m meh about:

 

BFG

Yates

Darthe

 

 

People that I´m willing to vote:

 

Sooh

Dice

Tress

Shady

RTE

 

 

 

I think the "rl mafia help" is worthy of a vote. 

 

 

[v] Shady [/v]

[Niniel]

And please, be honest about me. Enough people already are not.

 

You´re the towniest townie!

[Niniel]

[Turin Turambar]

@Tina, does it concern you that hallia is voting Ley?

 

How did you get her in your no vote group?

[Darthe]

@Darthe, so why are you voting Ley?

Yeah I'll be honest it just kinda slipped my mind to vote when I made that last night.  [v] Hally [/v]

 

People that I won´t vote:

 

Ley - mega townie and I love his posting this game!

 

Panchi

Hally

Turin

 

 

People that I´m meh about:

 

BFG

Yates

Darthe

 

 

People that I´m willing to vote:

 

Sooh

Dice

Tress

Shady

RTE

 

 

 

I think the "rl mafia help" is worthy of a vote. 

 

 

[v] Shady [/v]

This list is like halfway backwards for me.  ATM I stand:

 

Yates

BFG

Shady

Panchi

Turin

Dice

Sooh

RTE

Ley

Tina

Tress

Hally

[Darthe]

@Tina, does it concern you that hallia is voting Ley?

 

How did you get her in your no vote group?

I think her cliche is to portray Cuba Gooding Jr. in Radio.

[Niniel]

@Tina, does it concern you that hallia is voting Ley?

 

How did you get her in your no vote group?

 

I haven´t thought about that. I guess she is on my town list since she is so much more active than she usually is. 

[Niniel]

 

@Darthe, so why are you voting Ley?

Yeah I'll be honest it just kinda slipped my mind to vote when I made that last night.  [v] Hally [/v]

 

People that I won´t vote:

 

Ley - mega townie and I love his posting this game!

 

Panchi

Hally

Turin

 

 

People that I´m meh about:

 

BFG

Yates

Darthe

 

 

People that I´m willing to vote:

 

Sooh

Dice

Tress

Shady

RTE

 

 

 

I think the "rl mafia help" is worthy of a vote. 

 

 

[v] Shady [/v]

This list is like halfway backwards for me.  ATM I stand:

 

Yates

BFG

Shady

Panchi

Turin

Dice

Sooh

RTE

Ley

Tina

Tress

Hally

 

 

Mine is not in order. I guess your are. What about Hally? And why are Ley so far down?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Vote Count

 

Darthe - 1 (Turin)

Leyrann - 1 (RTE)

Turin - 1 (Hallia)

Shadar - 1 (Tina)

Hallia - 1 (Darthe)

 

Not Voting - 8 (Sooh, Panchi, BFG, Tress, Shadar, Yates, Dice, Leyrann)

 

 

With 13 alive it takes 7 to Lynch.

 

 

 

 

Day 2 Deadline Ends Monday 23 March 2015 @ 9.15pm GMT (so it doesn't hit a weekend)

 

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20150323T2115&p0=136&msg=end+of+day+2

[Darthe]

 

 

@Darthe, so why are you voting Ley?

Yeah I'll be honest it just kinda slipped my mind to vote when I made that last night.  [v] Hally [/v]

 

People that I won´t vote:

 

Ley - mega townie and I love his posting this game!

 

Panchi

Hally

Turin

 

 

People that I´m meh about:

 

BFG

Yates

Darthe

 

 

People that I´m willing to vote:

 

Sooh

Dice

Tress

Shady

RTE

 

 

 

I think the "rl mafia help" is worthy of a vote. 

 

 

[v] Shady [/v]

This list is like halfway backwards for me.  ATM I stand:

 

Yates

BFG

Shady

Panchi

Turin

Dice

Sooh

RTE

Ley

Tina

Tress

Hally

 

 

Mine is not in order. I guess your are. What about Hally? And why are Ley so far down?

 

If you have to ask about Hally you might move below Tress.  Ley is practically interchangable with RTE/Sooh, just people I don't have a good read on but he sticks out to me a bit more.  It's difficult to measure the difference.

[Darthe]

The problem with your list is that it makes more sense if you're mafia and put a teammate in each of them for cover.  

[Ithillian Turambar]

You have just over 48 hours

[Niniel]

 

 

 

 

 

 

@Darthe, so why are you voting Ley?

Yeah I'll be honest it just kinda slipped my mind to vote when I made that last night. [v] Hally [/v]

People that I won´t vote:

 

Ley - mega townie and I love his posting this game!

 

Panchi

Hally

Turin

 

 

People that I´m meh about:

 

BFG

Yates

Darthe

 

 

People that I´m willing to vote:

 

Sooh

Dice

Tress

Shady

RTE

 

 

 

I think the "rl mafia help" is worthy of a vote.

 

 

[v] Shady [/v]

This list is like halfway backwards for me. ATM I stand:

 

Yates

BFG

Shady

Panchi

Turin

Dice

Sooh

RTE

Ley

Tina

Tress

Hally

Mine is not in order. I guess your are. What about Hally? And why are Ley so far down?

If you have to ask about Hally you might move below Tress. Ley is practically interchangable with RTE/Sooh, just people I don't have a good read on but he sticks out to me a bit more. It's diffi

cult to measure the difference.

Then move me down and tell me about Hally.

[Darthe]

Tress does look scummy and is a good alternative.

 

Until then: Hally has 20 posts. She has voted ten people. She clearly has a cliche to FoS everyone but she has yet to reinforce whether those were made up or legitimate with any reasoning or explanation, instead choosing to either FoS and vote or FoS and not vote. Many of you may not be aware of this but Hally has been playing well enough on VS to be invited to a champions tournament there. That should give some perspective on how she is no longer the bubbly newbie. Her largest legitimate scum tell is that when she is mafia she "safes" things which we can see her doing here by hiding exclusively behind her cliche's. This fact, combined with blatant bandwagon voting and a few posts quoted below are the basis of my reasoning.

 

 

 

 

 

 

I feel up until recently it was all playing up cliches. I'm sliding into actual gameplay.

Never happens with one (negative) exception.

At work, I can't play on Wednesdays, it is known. But I haven't played a BT game in forever, so maybe not by all. Currently though, I'm at work.

Which would matter had she done anything of note in the three days between claiming she was sliding into gameplay and this post.

[v] Turin [/v]

 

You seem to be too confidant that Panchi is town. It almost seems like insider knowledge

This is out of order and comes later. Please read the post below here to see what makes this so awful.

 

 

I just dont see panchi as mafia. I think she would be more active if she was anyway.

No I just know how Panchi is from other theads. Everone else I have only had a small bit of conversation here and there. So I am skeptical of panchi being mafia is all. More of a gut feeling.

As you will learn from playing more mafia, this is certainly not always so. What you're describing is meta, which we're trying to break this game.

 

FOS THE NEWBIE.

 

But seriously, with the competing trains, and her flipping town, I'm going to re-nudge the

 

Vote:Panchi

 

train. I didn't really see her come out and defend herself at all, it seemed like everyone else doing the scrambling for her.

First thing's first: Nobody here is going to try to break meta too much as town. People can screw around and play with the theme and whatnot but ultimately the scum have a lot more to gain from pursuing this.

 

Secondly, she votes on Panchi to "RE-NUDGE" that train. AKA I want to get this moving (This is my reason for not going Panchi today btw) and then follows it up by providing reasoning. There is a conflict there where she is providing opposing two reasons for one action, something that tends to be wolfy. This post alone should incriminate Hally but should that not do it I remind you all that she was the third vote on Verb, he drove lynching her for it and then he was NK'd.

I'm able to play at work again! We passed survey the other week, they've been more lax on us >=D

 

Verb - that seems like good reasoning, Maybe Poking her will draw her out

 

 

[unvote]

[v] Tress [/v]

Considering that Tress is a likely teammate if Hally is scum this is getting quoted. Looks like an easy way to sheep a vote on someone who was gaining a lot of negative attention.

 

 

 

 

We all do. Ithi says she isnt enforcing them though so we can use them as often or sporadically as we wish.

Yes, but I'm having fun with mine, so I've been trying to use it as much as possible. But I don't like the blatant push to 3 votes that Hallia just did - makes me the leader when nobody else has more than 1......which to me is taking the game out of the RVS and into the actual game. I'm ok with that, but people were still kinda messing around and her vote is pinging to me as a result.

I'd vote you but I'm already voting you. ><

 

 

 

 

We all do. Ithi says she isnt enforcing them though so we can use them as often or sporadically as we wish.

Yes, but I'm having fun with mine, so I've been trying to use it as much as possible. But I don't like the blatant push to 3 votes that Hallia just did - makes me the leader when nobody else has more than 1......which to me is taking the game out of the RVS and into the actual game. I'm ok with that, but people were still kinda messing around and her vote is pinging to me as a result.

You are right with getting the game going, yeah. If we don't do that we'll end up just randomly lynching every day.

 

Just don't lynch me. I know you're planning on it.

Unvote

Vote: Ley

 

Who said they were 'planning on it?'

I'm quoting one of these jokey posts because, despite being unable to explain it, it doesn't sit well with me on a gut level.

 

READ MY POSTS

[Niniel]

Sorry, must have missed it. Or maybe I just skipped it because it was hidden. Will read ir tomorrow when I have my computer. Good night!

[Shadar Alantin]

I tell you the story is true, I could not come up with something like that.

[Darthe]

Try to not say ambiguous or innocuous things in mafia games until we are comfortablewith you. It muddles reads and upsets those who take the game more seriously.

 

Also, inb4 advice giving being scummy