The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Mafia--Game Thread--Day 3

[Niniel]

Zander

 

Thinks Sooh is townie. Questioned Ley but says that he hasn´t got any meta on him. Questions AJ´s vote on Pral. 

 

Zander has a lot of posts but most are joke posts. Has he said that he will be gone before the game? There is nothing wrong with his posts but I´m more used to Zander being more investigative.

[Hallia]

I like your reads, they make sense and I like that.

[Leyrann]

You don't know me well then Ley, I'm the queen of soft claiming

 

Doesn't mean I like it any more.

 

Can you tell me why you did it? I mean, you were not in danger of getting lynched or something like that. It just feels too random for me.

[Niniel]

Wifi

 

Her first post could be a sign of her being town. I know she hasn´t played a lot and Rey´s game had a lie detector (or was it just a claim? Didn´t read all of it.). It doesn´t mean a lot but I guess it´s minor townie points as well. 

[Niniel]

It wasn´t much to work with but I will vote Kat. It´s because she doesn´t feel as involved in the game. I understand her vote on AJ but ut was kind of late for it, considering dl is soon. The case is super thin but it´s all I have so far.

 

 

[v] Kat [/v]

[Katiora]

Nin the timing of my vote wouldn't have made sense at any other time... until RIGHT before I voted I didn't have that reason to vote. I will take it off.. When I find a better candidate. currently I am not a good candidiate for me, but I do think you're town from the work you put in. 

[Hallia]

I like that response, Kat.

[Leyrann]

I like that response, Kat.

 

You just straight up ignored my question?

[Hallia]

I dont know why you want to discuss it so deeply. Any one could say that and it wouldn't necessarily be a claim of any kind. It could just be confidence speaking. Fishing?

[Pralaya]

You are ignoring my question too

[Hallia]

You asked a question? Can you link?

[Pralaya]

Nin the timing of my vote wouldn't have made sense at any other time... until RIGHT before I voted I didn't have that reason to vote. I will take it off.. When I find a better candidate. currently I am not a good candidiate for me, but I do think you're town from the work you put in. 

 

What do you mean by "better candidate"? Why keep a vote if it was only a joke vote? 

[Hallia]

 

 

 

Also, did you just say I sheeped, Kat? I was the first to vote. I am unclear what you mean.

You did sheep though. AJ mentioned tone, and you agreed with a vote.

Actually he asked what I thought. I said my thoughts, then voted for pressure. He followed suit.

Still didn't get from you what your thoughts on Nini's post were. As pointed out (by Zander, I guess), your post implied that you agreed with AJ about his thoughts about Nini. Am I correct in that understanding?

Here?

 

Agreeing with is not sheeping. What do you mean?

[Leyrann]

I dont know why you want to discuss it so deeply. Any one could say that and it wouldn't necessarily be a claim of any kind. It could just be confidence speaking. Fishing?

 

No, not fishing. I don't care wheter or not I know any role you might have. I just want to know why you would do a soft claim.

 

Let me phrase it differently, as this is what I actually want to know: What did you want to accomplish by soft-claiming?

 

(of course, this could be "making something happen" as well as "avoiding something happening" (like a hard claim cop (slightly different example) would maybe be "avoid getting lynched))

[Pralaya]

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/98528-the-league-of-extraordinary-gentlemen-mafia-game-thread-day-1/?view=findpost&p=3691390

 

This post. You were trying to talk as if my views about Nini was wrong and her vote on dice was more than just a joke post. Is that what you were saying?

[Niniel]

Nin the timing of my vote wouldn't have made sense at any other time... until RIGHT before I voted I didn't have that reason to vote. I will take it off.. When I find a better candidate. currently I am not a good candidiate for me, but I do think you're town from the work you put in. 

 

It´s less than 10 hours to dl. 

[Hallia]

It's pretty irrelevant now, because with Nini's catch up I feel pretty good about her.

 

It was something to go off of at the time. And so I think that even makes me feel better about you, because you might have seen something I didn't.

 

[unvote]

 

Considering a switch to Ley.

 

I wasn't really trying to do anything except continue conversation. But your continued pushing on it doesn't exactly make me feel good about you.

[Leyrann]

Well, you got your continued conversation. What you don't have, is a good answer. I mean, claim (even soft claim) just to get the conversation to continue? That's just [something with a bull].

 

Strongly considering a Hallia vote for Day 1 because of the continuous evading and empty answers of simple questions.

[Katiora]

 

Nin the timing of my vote wouldn't have made sense at any other time... until RIGHT before I voted I didn't have that reason to vote. I will take it off.. When I find a better candidate. currently I am not a good candidiate for me, but I do think you're town from the work you put in. 

 

What do you mean by "better candidate"? Why keep a vote if it was only a joke vote? 

 

It's only kind of a joke vote. I will never trust AJ this game unless he's mod cleared. And by a better candidate I mean until I see something that makes me suspicious of someone I don't know that I will change. *shrugs* Right now I'm not sure that Ley and Hallia are t/t *shrugs* the way they're going at each other over nothing makes me think that at least one of them has an agenda... seems to be Ley, but I can't be sure. 

[Leyrann]

So it's kind of a joke vote.

 

But you're leaving it on 9 hours before deadline.

 

What?

[Leyrann]

I really hope I'm remembering something wrong or understanding something wrong here...

[Pralaya]

 

 

Nin the timing of my vote wouldn't have made sense at any other time... until RIGHT before I voted I didn't have that reason to vote. I will take it off.. When I find a better candidate. currently I am not a good candidiate for me, but I do think you're town from the work you put in. 

 

What do you mean by "better candidate"? Why keep a vote if it was only a joke vote? 

 

It's only kind of a joke vote. I will never trust AJ this game unless he's mod cleared. And by a better candidate I mean until I see something that makes me suspicious of someone I don't know that I will change. *shrugs* Right now I'm not sure that Ley and Hallia are t/t *shrugs* the way they're going at each other over nothing makes me think that at least one of them has an agenda... seems to be Ley, but I can't be sure. 

 

 

I am sorry, but with less than 12 hours to deadline, that is not a good enough reason .If it was made early in the game, it would be fine. Not now.

[Pralaya]

Anyway, I won't be there for the deadline. It is early morning Saturday morning, no way I am waking up at that time.

 

Not a lot of content, so I am trying to get reads as much as I can. 

 

1. Niniel - From what I remember, plays kind of safe if she is scum. I don't see that tone in this game. She is more natural and trying to solve. Feels townish

2. Ley - Slightly rolefishing. But that is what Ley does. Right now null but should be able to read him better as the game goes on.

3. dice - Has felt good so far. Saw him as scum in the Julius Caesar game. He is different here. Questioning more, reading people better . Townish 

4. WiFi (mentored by Sili) - Have mo idea how to read her. Her posts still feel newbish. Null

5. Kat - Didn't like her vote on AJ. It came at a time when there was a bit of pressure on her and about a day to deadline.  Also her repsonse wasn't any better. If she says she wants to vote a better candidate, then her vote on AJ is more than just a joke vote and that feels off. 

6. Aj  - Was trying to start the game and I did find some of his initial reads odd. It was at the start of the game and he feels better now. Null to townish

7. Zander - Much less posts this game compared to his usual. Haven't read him well in any games. None of his posts have stood off this game. So, that's good. Null

8. Hallia - Her play kind of feels different. Sparse, and seems to be making her own points and ignoring those pointed at her. Her vote on me felt opportunistic. She does have her softclaim - but not thinking about it right now. Null to scummy

9. Sooh - Has been active and on top of the game. Good tone overall. Townish

 

I will still be around an hour more and then go to sleep. Given the slow pace of the game so far, kat does sound to me as the best bet

[v]kat[/v]

[Sooh]

Initial posts by Pral made me feel sort of good about him.

 

The only two I'm having some inclination about as scum right now are Ley and Kat.

 

Ley has been sort of fishing for things to see as scummy if that makes sense? First his questioning about my mock reads, and then his insisting that Hallia explain about her soft claim. 

 

Kat I'm not feeling as strongly about. I still feel like she's a bit on the defensive, and I didn't like the sudden "backtracking" as I would call it. 

 

These are both soft scum reads, but I think they are the best I can do today. 

 

I feel good about Niniel and Hallia (which is like a new world to me, we never read one another town like this. I like it!).

 

Zander hasn't been very active, but I'm going to ask everyone not to lynch him D1. He has his reasons for not having been super active in the game so far, and I am convinced he will come back more strongly as the game goes on. 

 

I don't think I'll ever not tinfoil on AJ now. It's your own fault dude. Currently null to me though. 

 

Same with Dice. I'll keep my eyes open. The moment I feel like I'm starting to forget that he's in the game I'm voting there, because that's him slipping under my radar. 

 

This game I feel like I need more time to assess Wifi. She feels differently than last game, but then again, this game start has been vastly different from Rey's game. I want to give her more time.

 

[v]Leyrann[/v]

[Andrej]

[unvote]

 

Pral's posts are starting to look better imo. I think perhaps he saw my observation about Tina and thought I was trying to build a weak case or something. He's starting to engage pretty regularly this game which is something I'm not used to, probably because of the slow pace, but I'm happy that he's able to be more involved than usual.

 

Tina's involvement and reads are looking good as well.

 

I don't know Ley well enough whether to say the pressure about Hallia's soft claim is normal or not. I really don't have an issue with it because this game is kitchen sink and likely most if not all players will have some kind of power.

 

@Kat - you're serious about wanting to policy lynch me?