Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Turin Turambar]

 

@Lenlo, For Thane in these circumstances I would say it is reasonable. It was off the cuff and seemed to be his actual thoughts. It is still more than Mynd has given.

 

You have Mynd as town correct? What town reasoning would you give for him to use his only power to challenge Ithi? on D1? over something trivial in his mind? 

 

He hasn't given his motivation for this either even though he has been asked for it. 

 

Speaking of motivation. What motivation would Hallia have for claiming Governor when she did? also her initial claim was to derail the challenge but what she actual does is pardon the condemned making it a no lynch for the day in effect.

 

@ Hallia, Why did you claim the way you did and at that time? Also since you don't think character claims mean anything then kindly give us yours. 

 

Actually, I have. 

 

I think you and Ithi went batshyte berzerker over something very trivial.  I assumed most of the roster would have seen the same crazy push that I did and vote Ithi out.  If you both are town, we don't need this kind of extreme tunnel vision with rabid, almost vindictive commentary. 

 

You say it isn't personal? Ok.  Then you are truly convinced that I am scum simply because I disagree how Irene Adler would be portrayed in this game.  I don't think there is a word to describe how embarrassed I feel for you if you truly believe that this is how you play the game.

 

If you both are truly town, then this game you and Ithi played today only helped the scum team.  You are both clearly working together.  I am assuming then that it is allowed to PM each other and discuss the game with each other then?  Fine.  But if you and Ithi are truly town, your narrow minded and vindictive assault is only helping the scum team.  Your basis for me being scum is that I disagreed with how Irene Adler would be portrayed?  Seriously?

 

Now Turin, how foolish will you feel if it turns out that Ithi is scum and has been playing you this whole time?  Would you say that such a scenario is impossible or have you even considered that she is railroading you?  I actually think that this might be the case.  I really doubt that a mafia team would be this blatant about working together.

 

And then the third alternative is that you and Ithi are both scum.   If that is the case, then I gladly fall on my sword because my body won't even be stiff before the two of you are in the noose. 

 

Quote the post please. And where there was ANY personal attacking towards you. Oh yeah  you can't because it doesn't exist. 

 

call me crazy. Not the first time not the last. All you had to do was admit that you were pushing bad info to push the lynch. But that wasn't your plan was it?

 

Not personal for me. Again it is not how she is portrayed it is how you were using the portrayal as a fact that pointed to someone being mafia. I been called a bad player loads of times. usually by mafia that are looking to discredit me. You should read Csarmi's Mass Effect game. 

 

You want yo continue to call our play bad but who was the one that started this 1v1 which is going to result in your lynch? Look in the mirror. i haven't discussed this game with her anywhere and for you to insinuate it is low. very low. Desperate low.  For someone that doesn't like to make things personal you don't mind accusing do you. (OOG: I expect an apology when this is over. For me and ithi)

 

If she is mafia then she will have fooled me. i think I read her pretty well. Of course I don't even remember the last time she was mafia in a solo team game. (she was mafia in last year's WW2 game and I knew it but I was a mafia symp that didn't know what team she was on. By the time I found out it was my team She was killed. I did get the person who lynched her lynched the next day, but then got NK'ed by the other team)

 

I know I am town. No way in heck you gonna get me lynched. Mafia is gonna have to NK me this game.  So it looks like you will be dead by nightfall. maybe you will convince Hallia to save you, LOL. 

[Turin Turambar]

That is it for me tonight. I need to sleep as I think  I have to work in the morning.

[Lenlo]

That was an annoying read. Turin I only have 3 slots filled with mafia suspects because the rest of the people actually playing the game at the moment I think are town. Probably the last scum is somewhere in the no posters. Also Adler, again, I never said she was bad. I said she wasnt good. There are grays you know. And I didnt say Thane should feel bad for those reads or lack-there-of! (Though he should  )

 

I want to thank you for the concise sum up of everything, but its not concise, so ill just thank you for the sum up. Its nice to have the last 10 pages condensed somewhere even if its ended with a conspiracy theory. And your right it does look like I have to pick between those two, though I was hoping Hally could somehow pull this tailspin up with whatever she planned to do with her Governor role. 

 

If I have to pick between Ithi and Mynd though then ima going to [v]Mynd[/v]. In terms of helpfulness, Ithi has been much more so with explaining herself in an easy to read manner imo. In the scenario I believe most likely, them both being town, I think Ithi would be the more valuable than Mynd because of this.

 

Sorry if I missed a question or two directed at me Turin, there was alot of text.

[Hallia]

If everyone's fairly confident they're both town, I'll save them both.  I know there are a couple of people on both sides who think one or the other is scum, but I'd like it if everyone would chime in if they want me to stop the lynch or let one of them go down.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Morning.

 

I can't get that spoilered post of Turins to open on my phone.

 

 

I see that Mynd has said I'm crazy, rabid, bad at playing and that I'm PMing Turin. If he believed we were on a team together then surely he would say we had a QT. Unless he's accusing us of cheating.

 

So. Who's getting personal and vindictive here?

 

Hallia - I do not think Mynd is Town. I don't think he should be saved.

[Ithillian Turambar]

If everyone's fairly confident they're both town, I'll save them both. I know there are a couple of people on both sides who think one or the other is scum, but I'd like it if everyone would chime in if they want me to stop the lynch or let one of them go down.

My tone is wrong. You don't think I'm Town. Your're voting me. But you'll save me?

 

I still don't get why a Town Governor would reveal the way you did. If someone got Lynched and then didn't die - you'd be able to take the applause after the fact.

 

It seems to me you want EVERYONE to know that you're a governer because that HAS to make you Town.

 

I had a governor in my Star Wars game. He was the Emperor. Just people people are in power doesn't mean they are good.

 

Maybe you that git of a Prince who doesn't want his reputation sullied?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Also Mynd has not responded to my request to quote the posts where he's saying I'm attacking him personally.

 

This is because they don't exist.

 

I'm well aware of how my normal conversational style can be interpreted by some people. I've asked the Mods if anyone has complained about me this Game - because I do not like to offend unintentionally - and they say everything is fine.

 

So I have to assume that Mynd's rant about me is either trying to get a reaction from me or is actually trying to make sure he gets Lynched. Because I can't see any other reason for all the name calling and accusations.

 

I'm off to work now and it's monday and will be hellish.

[dicetosser1]

If everyone's fairly confident they're both town, I'll save them both.  I know there are a couple of people on both sides who think one or the other is scum, but I'd like it if everyone would chime in if they want me to stop the lynch or let one of them go down.

 

let it go.

[hazelkrs1]

Sorry everyone (but not that sorry)- I am going to be absolutely useless tonight, absorbing literally every mote of this incredibru Spurs win from last night (imo the sweetest, most rewarding championship of the Duncan era). It seems the thread exploded so if anyone wants to gimme cliffs that would be spectacular for when I am able to get back on track this game. Thanks in advance and oh yeah...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO READY FOR MORE OF THIS:

 

 

 

 

CINCO!

 

       

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Vote count:

 

Mynd (7): Ithi, Turin, Tsuki, Chae, Pral, dice, Len

Ithi (3): Mynd, Hallia, 鲍勃不是我的名字

 

 

Not Voting (6): everyone else

 

 

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch. A deadline is now in effect.

 

DL is set for Tues. June 17th at 9 PM EST.

[Basel Gill]

My girl is fast.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

[Ithillian Turambar]

And she can write in Chinese. I'm ver impressed

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Lol I was terribly proud of that

[Tsukibana]

Pretty sure that is Japanese...

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Still proud

[Tsukibana]

Darn tootin'

[Myndrunner]

To those of you playing mafia, I ask you this:  does the reason Ithi and Turin came at me make any sense?

 

If you believe that both of us are town, then it would be a smarter move to lynch Ithi because you still have Turin, one half of this two-slotted hydra.  If you believe me to be scum just because I disagreed with Irene Adler's role and alignment in this game, then lynch me. 

 

Here is the thing.  I feel like many of you are ignoring how blown out of proportion they made this whole thing.  How blindly the came at me and why?  Sure, maybe the gladiator thing wasn't as good a call as I thought at the time, but I trusted the mafia game instincts of the rest of you to see what this was.  If I was wrong about that, then I don't know what else to say.

 

I have stated my character and alignment.  I have given my reasons for the Gladiator thing.  I have TWICE reposted my reasons for voting thane and doubting his claims.  The guy QUIT BTW and voted himself.  Do you remember that?  IS that a town thing to do?

[Hallia]

I think you're right Mynd, it did get blown up. It's trivial, I mean look at Csarmi's game where Arthur Dent was a serial killer.

[Myndrunner]

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction.  Such a co-hesive reaction among two players. 

 

Ithi and Turin are working together.  There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game.  Masons or Mafia.  I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well.  I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

[Turin Turambar]

I think you're right Mynd, it did get blown up. It's trivial, I mean look at Csarmi's game where Arthur Dent was a serial killer.

LOL. That sounds just like a bad infomercial.

 

I know I'm not mafia. I am pretty sure Ithi is not either.

 

Mynd should have used his shot at Thane if he really wanted to live.

 

But you can always pardon him hallia. So no worries right?

 

And I have to drive now. Talk later.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I'm not Mafia.

 

I am Town

 

I am not in communication with Turin about this game.

 

I am not cheating.

[Hayl3y]

To those of you playing mafia, I ask you this:  does the reason Ithi and Turin came at me make any sense?

 

If you believe that both of us are town, then it would be a smarter move to lynch Ithi because you still have Turin, one half of this two-slotted hydra.  If you believe me to be scum just because I disagreed with Irene Adler's role and alignment in this game, then lynch me. 

 

Here is the thing.  I feel like many of you are ignoring how blown out of proportion they made this whole thing.  How blindly the came at me and why?  Sure, maybe the gladiator thing wasn't as good a call as I thought at the time, but I trusted the mafia game instincts of the rest of you to see what this was.  If I was wrong about that, then I don't know what else to say.

 

I have stated my character and alignment.  I have given my reasons for the Gladiator thing.  I have TWICE reposted my reasons for voting thane and doubting his claims.  The guy QUIT BTW and voted himself.  Do you remember that?  IS that a town thing to do?

 

well Thane was really pissed off. I think that his decision to vote himself was made because he was very frustrated not to be believed.

 

now for the character claims, i still remember how csarmi and I randomized the characters and the roles in HHGG  ... i guess we are not the only crazy people who like to surprise the players.

[Myndrunner]

I'm not Mafia.

 

I am Town

 

I am not in communication with Turin about this game.

 

I am not cheating.

 

Who said you were cheating?  Implying that you and Turin are working together means one of two things...you are mafia or masons.  Which is it?

 

Also, i've claimed.   How about you?

[csarmi]

Or one of them is Mafia piggybacking on the other.