The Ultimate Mafia Showdown - Town Wins

[beanie]

Uh I cant get to the first page. The sacrificer can die in place of someone durong the night?

[Kaylee]

During the phase of their choice

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Neil: any comments on the game thus far? I know you questioned why you were seen as suspicious. What are your thoughts? Who do you think is mafia?

Also interested. I'd like to hear who RTE and Hallia think are scum too. I'm leaning towards Neil today.

[lolguy26]

so dap sacrificed himself to stop all NA's?

 

oh and Vote Niel

 

as much as i hate doing it, dude i know how hard school is (wait till you get to grade 11), but you havent helped town, you're either unhelpful townie or scum laying low....

[Hallia]

I've gone back over the last few pages, and it doesn't seem like anyone in particular is sticking out.  It has been a little quiet, but I am back full force! *triumphant pose*

[lolguy26]

your thoughts so far hal?

[Hallia]

So a lot of people I don't really have much in the way of a read on.  Cyan and WBK recently joined, so I'm not sure on them.  Leyrann I'm leaning towards town.  Niel's argument that he's never been mafia makes me think he might be (That he has never been mafia before in I don't know how many games makes me think the odds are higher for him to be mafia.)  I think Song is town.  For the rest, I don't know yet.

[Leyrann]

The odds aren't higher, Hallia. Every game has the same odds (well, as long as every game has an equal amount of town and mafia). However, that comment "I have never been mafia" is really scummy. He's trying to clear himself by saying he was no mafia in previous games.

 

To be honest, this is the only thing really standing out to me at the moment. I mean, everyone else who has said things that stood out to me are on the graveyard.

[Kaylee]

The odds aren't higher, Hallia. Every game has the same odds (well, as long as every game has an equal amount of town and mafia). However, that comment "I have never been mafia" is really scummy. He's trying to clear himself by saying he was no mafia in previous games.

 

To be honest, this is the only thing really standing out to me at the moment. I mean, everyone else who has said things that stood out to me are on the graveyard.

I agree with the parts about Neil.

[Kaylee]

I also, believing her claim, get a town vibe from Song.

[Niel an' Tyomn]

 

There's a first tiiiiime for everything!

 

Just have fun with it! :)

 

And actually I've never been mafia ... ever.

 

Hahaa, I'm still not mafia.

 

Glad to see the quiet ones show up and post. RTE, Neil, why no vote?

 

I had no clue who to vote for .. 

 

Neil: any comments on the game thus far? I know you questioned why you were seen as suspicious. What are your thoughts? Who do you think is mafia?

 

No one is sticking out to me but ... I have no clues at all.

 

so dap sacrificed himself to stop all NA's?

 

oh and Vote Niel

 

as much as i hate doing it, dude i know how hard school is (wait till you get to grade 11), but you havent helped town, you're either unhelpful townie or scum laying low....

 

 

It's ok ... I'm a bit overwhelmed at the moment ... 

[WolfbrotherKronos]

The odds aren't higher, Hallia. Every game has the same odds (well, as long as every game has an equal amount of town and mafia). However, that comment "I have never been mafia" is really scummy. He's trying to clear himself by saying he was no mafia in previous games.

 

To be honest, this is the only thing really standing out to me at the moment. I mean, everyone else who has said things that stood out to me are on the graveyard.

 

I think it's this as well as not much posting with little thoughts added.  Seems to be fence sitting to me.

[Niel an' Tyomn]

 

The odds aren't higher, Hallia. Every game has the same odds (well, as long as every game has an equal amount of town and mafia). However, that comment "I have never been mafia" is really scummy. He's trying to clear himself by saying he was no mafia in previous games.

 

To be honest, this is the only thing really standing out to me at the moment. I mean, everyone else who has said things that stood out to me are on the graveyard.

I agree with the parts about Neil.

 

 

Lol, I've never been mafia on DM before! Weird right?! And I am trying to clear myself ... Don't want to be  a wate of death for le Town. 

[Kaylee]

Wouldn't be a waste. Every lynch gains info. Your suspicious for the little input over all that's happened so far. No opinions on who you think is mafia? Nobody stands out to you?

[Niel an' Tyomn]

Well, Red stood out to me before ... And she was .... now no one really seems to be looking scummy ... Not with enough evidence that I should or could prosecute them with ...

[hotpocket2006]

So you're okay with doing nothing niel?

[Niel an' Tyomn]

Lol! No ... I just don't know what to do .. or who to blame .... Do you guys have any ideas?

[Kaylee]

Yes and we've posted thoughts throughout the game.

[Kaylee]

Cast:

 

1. Lenlo - Titania (A Midsummer Night's Dream), Town Neighbor Lynched Day 1.

2. Misheru WBK

3. Smiley - Hannibal Lectar (Hannibal), Mafia Targeted Janitor Killed Night 2.

4. TinaHel Cyan

5. Leyrann

6. Mawthrex

7. Basel - Jeff Goldbloom (Actor), Town Backup Killed Day 3.

8. Dap - The Oracle (Matrix), Town Vanilla (2 shot oracle) Killed Day 1.

9. RTE

10. Turin - Mr. Rogers (Mister Rogers' Neighborhood), Town JoaT Killed Night 2.

11. Ithi - Dr. Gregory House (House MD.), Town Bi-phase Doctor (1 shot rolecop) Killed Night 2.

12. Cloud Kaylee

13. Niel an' Tyomn

14. Lolguy 

15. Bgrishinko - Cthulhu (The Weird Tales), Third Party Dreaming God Killed Day 3.

16. WoT - Vin (Mistborn), Town Neighbor Lynched Day 2.

17. TG - The Witch King of Angmar (The Lord of the Rings), Mafia Goon (Absorber) Killed Night 2.

18. Ruh - Santa Claus (Folklore), Town Death Gifter Killed Night 2.

19. Hally

20. Tiink Dap 2.0 - Mahatma Gandhi (History), Town Sacrifice Gone Night 3.

21. Red - Mechagodzilla (Godzilla), Mafia Anti-JoaT Killed Day 3.

22. Song

23. Rand

24. Dice - Tiberius Julius Caesar Augustus (History), Town Redoubler (1 shot Gladiator) Lynched Day 3.

[Kaylee]

I copied the above from the OP. Rand is still unCC'd cop, Song I beleive to be town based on previous reasons listed, Neil I've given thoughts on. The remaining 7 (Hally, Kronos, Cuckles, RTE, Cyan, Ley and Maw I'd have to look back over.) Unfortunately I'm not really feeling good so I won't be doing it tonight.

 

Neil: Thoughts at all on things that have happened? Any gut feelings even?

[Kaylee]

So you're okay with doing nothing niel?

 

 

Lol! No ... I just don't know what to do .. or who to blame .... Do you guys have any ideas?

Most of us have given thoughts recently. Even giving a gut feeling is good because it gives a starting point. Not contributing doesn't help.

[RandA lThor]

Mafia view on Cyan.  I think that was too random for them to godfatherize, so vote Cyan

[Hallia]

Mafia view on Cyan.  I think that was too random for them to godfatherize, so vote Cyan

 

What a twist!

[beanie]

I'm Ishy. Announcing that your going to choose someone random Rand is a good way to get them to choose random too I suppose.

 

And actually I'd prefer to go for Hali over Niel. Niel pings but it feels more like he's just not paying enough attention to actually form opinions on people. I am by no means defending him, Niel if you dont have time to play properly then dont sign up. But I think either Hali or Niel are mafia so I'm gonna go with Hali... Niel could be third party.

 

I almost forgot Maw was in the game. Awful quiet. Care to share thoughts?

 

Vote Hali

[Hallia]

I'm Ishy. Announcing that your going to choose someone random Rand is a good way to get them to choose random too I suppose.

 

And actually I'd prefer to go for Hali over Niel. Niel pings but it feels more like he's just not paying enough attention to actually form opinions on people. I am by no means defending him, Niel if you dont have time to play properly then dont sign up. But I think either Hali or Niel are mafia so I'm gonna go with Hali... Niel could be third party.

 

I almost forgot Maw was in the game. Awful quiet. Care to share thoughts?

 

Vote Hali

 

Could I get some reasoning as to why you think I'm mafia?