Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins!

[Turin Turambar]

Bah!!! Dead.

 

GO Town!

[Eldrick4221]

Eldrick - VT

 

Niniel - Town bomb
Nikon - VT
Dice - Slimer - Town - Treestump
Sooh - Town Jailkeeper
Alanna - VT
 

 

.....

 

Anyone care to explain the second death?

[Sooh]

Ok I have no idea what just happened.

 

I jailed Turin and I will stand for that, but I have no kill power. 

 

From what I was told by mod nobody could touch the person I jailed, nor could they hurt anyone else, so either there's a mod error or there's a strongman kill.

 

I'm assuming that it isn't Ithi's mistake, and as such I want to vote Niniel or Laine.

[Eldrick4221]

A strongman kill would still not explain the second death.

 

I was kinda hoping you did have a kill, cuz that would explain it.

[Eldrick4221]

Why not Nikon?

[Niniel]

First - sorry Dice. 

 

Second - ???? 

 

Does this mean we have a sk? And if Sooh is telling the truth then someone can break through jailing (or whatever the right word is).

 

 

We need to think about this. 

 

 

One the good side - Tsuki was not a naive cop so unless Eld is gf he is clear. I have liked his play so I doubt he is a gf but I will have it in the back of my head as I go forward. 

 

 

My main targets yesterday was Dice and Nikon. Dice was town but Nikon remains. Before doing any re-reads he is my main suspect. But someone who I have had a good feeling about is probably also mafia or sk. Maybe it´s 2 mafia + symp and a sk?

 

Laine - has had a town feeling on her all game. Need to take a new look at Turin´s suspiciouns of her.

 

Sooh - I liked her posts from yesterday better. She gave a good impression.

 

Eld - it has looked like he has been trying to solve. 

 

I need to do another re-read.

[Niniel]

Suspiciouns arises - Laine never claimed for a long time. SK? She has played so well but if she is third party then it would look like she played like a townie. 

 

I really don´t know how to look for third party. 

[Eldrick4221]

The problem with the SK idea is why haven't they killed until now?

[Sooh]

No clue why there were two kills. I assume a vig would have killed by now already. Same with a SK, so could scum have an extra 1x strongman kill in their arsenal of JOAT actions?

[Niniel]

Because Sooh jailed her? Didn´t she jail Laine last night?

 

Could that be it? But that doesn´t explain the other nights.

 

Or it´s a survivior with only one kill?

 

 

Question for Ithi is she wants to answer: In your games does the cop get to ask 

 

a) Are X town?

b) Are X mafia?

[Niniel]

No clue why there were two kills. I assume a vig would have killed by now already. Same with a SK, so could scum have an extra 1x strongman kill in their arsenal of JOAT actions?

 

That is possible but doesn´t that look like too overpowered? 

[Eldrick4221]

If there is an SK and 4 mafia.

 

We are 2 town - 2 mafia - 1 SK

 

We cannot be SK hunting right now. Our only hope is to lynch a mafia, and have the remaining 2 non-towns not kill town tonight.

 

Cuz if they both kill separate towns, we lose anyway.

 

If they kill the same townie, we are 1v1v1 tomorrow and that's a no-win for town.

 

Our only chance for a win is for them to kill each other, and honestly...how is the target not gonna be me?

[Eldrick4221]

No clue why there were two kills. I assume a vig would have killed by now already. Same with a SK, so could scum have an extra 1x strongman kill in their arsenal of JOAT actions?

 

....maybe

[Sooh]

Laine was gunning for Turin all day yesterday. I'm having trouble seeing why a scum Laine would kill Turin right after that, but that's just wifom on my part.

 

I'm tempted to say Niniel/Nikon are the two remaining, but I have really no clue.

[Eldrick4221]

It does make more sense to save your extra kill until later.

[Sooh]

 

No clue why there were two kills. I assume a vig would have killed by now already. Same with a SK, so could scum have an extra 1x strongman kill in their arsenal of JOAT actions?

 

That is possible but doesn´t that look like too overpowered? 

 

Against Town neighbors, doc, cop, jailkeeper and stump?

[Eldrick4221]

You JUST said it was Niniel and Laine.

[Eldrick4221]

Because Sooh jailed her? Didn´t she jail Laine last night?

 

Could that be it? But that doesn´t explain the other nights.

 

Or it´s a survivior with only one kill?

 

 

Question for Ithi is she wants to answer: In your games does the cop get to ask 

 

a) Are X town?

b) Are X mafia?

 

Do they get to ask? OFC

 

Do they get an answer besides PAFO?

[Niniel]

If there is an SK and 4 mafia.

 

We are 2 town - 2 mafia - 1 SK

 

We cannot be SK hunting right now. Our only hope is to lynch a mafia, and have the remaining 2 non-towns not kill town tonight.

 

Cuz if they both kill separate towns, we lose anyway.

 

If they kill the same townie, we are 1v1v1 tomorrow and that's a no-win for town.

 

Our only chance for a win is for them to kill each other, and honestly...how is the target not gonna be me?

 

Or 3 town - 1 mafia - 1 SK

 

But it makes sense to look for mafia first. 

[Niniel]

 

Because Sooh jailed her? Didn´t she jail Laine last night?

 

Could that be it? But that doesn´t explain the other nights.

 

Or it´s a survivior with only one kill?

 

 

Question for Ithi is she wants to answer: In your games does the cop get to ask 

 

a) Are X town?

b) Are X mafia?

 

Do they get to ask? OFC

 

Do they get an answer besides PAFO?

 

 

My questions is in regards to third party.

 

Because if you are allowed to ask the mod if X is town - then a no answer will show third party or mafia.

 

But if you are allowed to ask the mod if X is mafia - then a no answer will not show third party. 

[Eldrick4221]

Ok. Theory here.

 

Each night they get to do 2 actions. A kill action and a something from their list.

 

N1 (Shad) kill tsuki (healed) + Block tsuki

N2  Kill Rey + (Shad) Block tsuki (Jailed)

N3 Kill Hally + ?

N4 Kill Tsuki + Strongman Turin

[Sooh]

Ok. Theory here.

 

Each night they get to do 2 actions. A kill action and a something from their list.

 

N1 (Shad) kill tsuki (healed) + Block tsuki

N2  Kill Rey + (Shad) Block tsuki (Jailed)

N3 Kill Hally + ?

N4 Kill Tsuki + Strongman Turin

I assume something like this is the case.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Because Sooh jailed her? Didn´t she jail Laine last night?

 

Could that be it? But that doesn´t explain the other nights.

 

Or it´s a survivior with only one kill?

 

 

Question for Ithi is she wants to answer: In your games does the cop get to ask 

 

a) Are X town?

b) Are X mafia?

 

Do they get to ask? OFC

 

Do they get an answer besides PAFO?

 

 

My questions is in regards to third party.

 

Because if you are allowed to ask the mod if X is town - then a no answer will show third party or mafia.

 

But if you are allowed to ask the mod if X is mafia - then a no answer will not show third party. 

 

 

Oh. Ok. You mean as thier NA they ask a question.

 

See I've always thought it was

 

Submit a name: Receive an alignment reading

[Eldrick4221]

I'm gonna hope that that is the case, cuz if there's a SK lurking out there, we already lost.

[Niniel]

I think I´m confused about what happened during the nights. Sooh can you repeat what you did.

 

Tsuki only got a view on N2, right? (Eld = town)

 

Who did Hally protect? Did she say?