[Advanced] Once Upon a Time Mafia- Game Over, Town Wins!!!

[Ithillian Turambar]

Tsuki saying he's gonna vote Basel and then not is a bit suspect, perhaps he knew Basel was gonna pull Cinderella, a pumpkin and a couple of mice out of his hat.

 

What's he gonna say now I wonder.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Nikon is active in the game and not voting too.

 

Interesting.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Anyways I'm gonna leave my vote there and see what comes.

 

Because I need to sleep.

[BFG]

Ha ha ha. That's funny. You should know better.

 

Better than dawn even. Guess that makes you suspect number one.

 

vote Andrej

 

Thanks for your honesty. Now why would you jump on a train like that? Bad scum Andrej!

Interesting, AJ didn't join the train, he started it. Besides didn't you have him as 'fine' a few posts ago? So since this was already on thread, why change your opinion?

 

 

I was enjoying the show. Knowledge is power.

 

What's the issue? We don't even have a deadline yet.

 

Why should a deadline affect your scum-hunting? 

 

Dawn: Actually, I find them BOTH scummy... The RTE vote because it was a so-called "jokevote" with no joke, and your vote against Basel almost seems like he's coaching

you into coming after him. The only thing that is saving you right now is that I don't think Basel is inexperienced enough to make that error.

 

Chels/Thane: One of you is scummy, and I'm not sure which. Or maybe it is the whole "bro-mance" you have, what with the massive amounts of facial and chest hair between you.

 

RTE: Showed a cool reaction to being trained, didn't get defensive, or counter-attack immediately - reads Town.

 

Tina/Basel: Once again, seems scummy, but both are to experienced to make it that obvious this soon... who wants to SEEM scummy but isn't... One of you is Rumplestiltskin!!! Bwahahaha

 

Basel: Seems Town

 

If my reads are completely wrong, then Scum is Basel/Tina/Dawn/Thane/?? (5 is massive, but 4 seems right, to me), because they have done such a good job pointing fingers at each other and

keeping the distractions coming...

If my Reads are right, I'm leaning Thane/Dawn/??/??, maybe Chels, although I can't see her boy-toy being coached that badly if she is, so not looking TOO hard at Chels, atm. But she's pinging slightly.

 

So either Thane or Chae is scummy and likewise Tina/Basel? Don't like this at all.

 

Also Basel is town, unless you're wrong in which case he's mafia? Lul whut?

 

i'll try to keep that in mind....

 

any thoughts on dice/ice/hallia ? can't make anything out of them, since their activity hasn't been that high. Though, hallia's vote on Chae sticks a long time for an alledged joke-vote....

 

I'm actually finding some of the rapid unvotes of a joke vote scummier than the holding one, particularly given that a deadline has only just been set.

 

Dawn - I don't know how well you know RTE to make a joke vote against him. I can understand ur vote against Basel better, as he seemed really willing to defend u.

Nikon - I have to take into account the fact that u are a new player. You tried to make some reads at least. Leaning town.

Dice - U need to post more.

Tina - Seeing you are going to be replaced unvote I didn't like the fact that you pointed out Thane's vote and not Dawn's.

Thane -  I don't like the fact that you switched votes after people react to it. you're pulling a lot on the noob card too. Leaning scum. 

RTE  - I don't see much material behind your vote against AJ. I don't really understand ur post n°199 where it seems that everybody looks supa good. There u even said that AJ looked fine.Leaning scum.

TGlems - nice jokes... but where are ur reads ?

Ice - waiting for posts ...

AJ - I am suspicious of u ... but because of the Clash of the Ancient game that I followed behind the scenes (where i didn't suspect u being mafia). Otherwise, I have nothing against u at the moment.

Basel - u defended Dawn very fast ...

ed - i need to see more of u

Hallia - i'd like to read u more. You are joking around but not making reads unless asked for it.

Talmanes - i need to read u more

BFG   - need to read u more too

Tsukibana  - I quite agree with u on most of ur post.

 

Also, to reply to Thane's last post, it's wayy too early to make any read against Dice and Ice they barely posted

 

Chae sees it.

And I'm working on it.

 

 

Dawn, any serious thoughts? Reads, whatever? Jokes won't carry the game...

Basel's quick defense on me seemed scummy. 

 

I would read Thane as scum, but I can't be too sure because he is even newer than I am.

 

 

What's your reason behind thinking Thane is scummy?

 

But WHY is it scummy?

 

 

It's called White Knighting Tsuki.

 

Scum already know who the town are. They can defend townies so that they look good when/if that player dies, it's a fairly common tell.

 

Not sure why you answered for Dawn here.

 

 

 

Exactly. And he had no good reason for defending me. He was just defending a newbie from another newbie, and automatically assuming I am town just because I'm new, but not Thane for some reason.

 

Now I'm starting to think both Thane and Basel could very likely both be mafia together.

Dawn, have you actually been reading my posts where I laid out a case on Thane? I think you are town because you have been behaving town. IMO Thane hasn't been behaving town.

 

Yes...and this is exactly what I'm saying. Not sure why you are pointing this out, makes you look even scummier.

 

 

Why is this scummier?

 

note to self    when mafia kill AJ first.     you made me laff for real AJ

 

Lol

 

Fair enough, just curious. Like I said I've played enough games on both sides that it sticks out a bit to me when people are sure others are Town. It could well be genuine, but there is always the possibility of a cover.

 

I would like to add that, in the interest of reaching a majority before deadline, and in keeping the game active, if we don't have an agreement I would be fine with voting for Ice, as I checked and did not see any posts whatsoever (unless I missed something).

If they aren't going to post, then they don't do us much good.

 

Voting inactive is a bad idea Day 1, it doesn't give anywhere near as much information as people voting for the people they think are scummy.

 

Ice has ONE post so far... if consensus isn't reached, I'm all for a policy lynch, though I'd rather not "waste" it...

 

@Tal - thanks for sharing.

 

@dice - have I misunderstood - you say basel is the one with the typo (should have put "not" in his post), and that it is BASEL making an excuse for thane? you are saying THANE is the one who should have been coached (if he is scum), NOT basel? So, your post is not an accusation, but rather attempting to clarify what BASEL meant?

 

Same as above.

 

It's a little early for that, don't you think?  D1 can be like that sometimes, not that we shouldn't press for more out of him.

 

But that seems like picking the low hanging fruit

Low hanging because he's not here to defend himself, or because he's a new poster?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Deadline is in 2 hours @ BFG

 

It's not only just been set - although it might have been just set in relation to the post you were replying to.

 

I can't stay awake anymore. I'm sorry.

[BFG]

I'm keeping an eye on it, but want to try to get through a read first. On page 15 or so and so far RTE is standing out the most. Yes, the deadline comment was in reference to the post I was talking about.

[Nikonis]

Time is allowing Character claims so she feels quite confident we won't solve the game with them.

 

Perhaps she did give fake claims.

 

Does anyone actually watch this show?

 

Is anyone there?

 

Once Upon a Time Characters (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Once_Upon_a_Time_characters)

Emma Swan (Daughter of Snow White & Prince Charming)

Neal Cassidy (Baelfire, son of rumplestiltskin)

Henry Mills (Son of Emma Swan and Neal)

Mary Margaret Blanchard (Snow White)

David Nolan (Prince Charming)

Regina Mills (Evil Queen)

Mr. Gold (Rumplestiltskin/The Beast)

Lacey (Belle)

Dr. Archie Hopper (Jiminy Cricket)

Ruby (Little Red/The Wolf)

August Booth (Pinocchio)

Sheriff Graham Humbert (The Huntsman)

Leroy (Grumpy)

Tom Clark (Sneezy)

Walter (Sleepy)

Widow Lucas (Granny)

Dr. Whale (Dr. Victor Frankenstein)

Marco (Geppetto)

Sidney Glass (Genie/Magic Mirror)

 

I think there are more but that is a decent list and I remember most of them from the part of season one that I saw.

[Nikonis]

Nikon is active in the game and not voting too.

 

Interesting.

Sorry, was trying to answer your question on characters from someone having seen the show (Though I haven't seen the ending of season one now many episodes since)

And check out #395 and #417 before accusing me of being active yet not voting.

 

And since there's only 90 minutes left might as well throw mine in now: VOTE Basel

[Nikonis]

Correction: nor many episodes since.

[Tsukibana]

Returning...

[Tsukibana]

 

Tsuki saying he's gonna vote Basel and then not is a bit suspect, perhaps he knew Basel was gonna pull Cinderella, a pumpkin and a couple of mice out of his hat.

What's he gonna say now I wonder.

I simply believe in not jumping to conclusions... Basel is L-1.

I don't watch the show, that doesn't help, but it could be a safe-claim. ABC and Disney have literally HUNDREDS of characters...

BFG - Quote something a little newer, why don't ya. Basel could've been town at that time, but it seems my main reads are being ignored (which is cool, I am definitely not GOAT)....

CInderella sold her baby to Rumplestiltskin... not sure if that matters.

 

Tsuki is gonna hold to what he said he would do. Basel has been less than forthcoming, claims so late as to make it suspicous, has never moved off my list. The only thing I can say good is that 

the Thane accusation was held to with great tenacity. But that actually hurts, since the vote was made waaayyy too soon. Claimed an hour ago, has not returned...

 

Sorry, Cinderella. The Ball's over.

 

VOTE BASEL

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

 

 

RTE has four votes already?

 

Vote Thane

 

Why are your bandwagoning already?

 

unvote RTE vote Dawn

 

i was jokevoting, what were you doing?

 

 

For Basel, why is Thane's vote worse than Tina's?

 

I felt Tina didn't make a scummy vote. She saw something about Thane that I also found suspicious. It was way too early for anyone to have four votes at the time and there was undoubtedly bandwagoning. Thane's vote was opportunistic and reeked of bandwagon.

 

 

So why does Thane's stand out above Dawn's, 3 votes that quickly is also very unusual Day 1.

 

AJ, just like that? wow... any specific reason, or it's 'because he's AJ'?

??? 

 

And you still haven't answered my question. You just ask me more questions.

I like Dawn's tenaciousness here, still leaning Town.

 

 

No, I'm not on a team with anyone. I'm just saying that we are probably the ones with the most posts.

 

And then this :(

 

Good to see you Señor Ed! And welcome Ithi! I think I was referring to Thane regarding voting in actives, Talm, but I see your point, it's just a liiiittle early for that kind of talk. That's why it pings to me.

 

It was Tsuki and Talmanes that suggested voting inactive as an idea, why mention that you're suspicious of one but not the other? 

 

@ Dawn - i'm not convinced that ur vote against RTE was a joke... most of all because u didn't interact much with him after. It makes me wonder if u knew him well enough  to make a joke vote against him.  The vote you made against Basel can be interpreted 2 ways. Either u genuinely think he's scum. Either you are, and you're trying to appear town by ur vote.  When Tsuki asked for u and where u were, u appeared a bit later giving excuses about what you were doing... like u were feeling the need to justify urself.

 

@ Tal  - you started by some nudges like against Nikon for his wall of texts, then against AJ for mentioning BFG twice. Then, there's that buddying with Ithi that makes me suspicious

 

 

 

 

You guys are all crazy.

 

Thane is noob. Nikon looks town. Basel looks just fine with his qualms about people voting noobs. Not sure he's town yet but none of that stuff looked scummy to me. Tsuki is sticking his neck out to me, looks town. Tina defended the train on me, so town or looking to get town cred as scum. Chae is still scummy. Not due to her play but because of her fascination and obsession with all things pink. Dawn is still a noob in my books but posting well. Which either means she's a good player or is being helped by her team or both? Andrej looks just fine. Hallia's doing her Hallia thing. Ed is alive (Hi Ed, missed you!). TG is getting his EBromance on with AJ from the Hydra game. I can respect that. No read yet but I'm awful at reading the TG. Talmanes is new to me. Hallo der Talmanes. No read on Dice. BFG is just fine (and I still can't get a decent read on her for the life of me) and that's everyone.

I don't like this post of RTE. There's a mention of Dawn being in a team, or playing well.

 

Nah not fussed. Biut of the 4 votes yours is the most suspicious if I count dawn's as bad noob play. Otherwise Dawn's vote reeks.

 

You on the other hand have played a ton of games here. You know how people feel about two joke votes on one person in a big enough game. It's pretty rare and always draws a lot of notice. 4 on the other hand... Ha ha well you all know how I make a guy feel special

then she's doing bad noob play...

 

@ RTE - i really don't understand your vote against AJ that came after those  posts ... (AJ only voted second against you, he can't really have jumped on a train)

 

 

@ Tsuki, you said that RTE  looked town to you as he reacted well on the train against him... but what about his vote on AJ?

 

 

 

vote RTE

 

 

I'm liking Chae for Town as well.

 

and this: "Is he on your Team or do you know he's Town?" is a nice question to hammer somone. If i say he's on my team, it might be read as if him and i are both scum. If i answer that he's town, that makes me scum. And i'm not.

 

Or that you don't know, it's not a hard question to answer.

 

 

 

I DID NOT DECIDE TO LEAVE.

 

I explained why I needed to leave.

 

Okay - fair enough. The last time I'm going to talk about it.

 

Still doesn't explain why you haven't given your thoughts.

 

EXPLAIN YOURSELF. HOW DO YOU THINK YOUR PLAY IS BEING VIEWED BY OTHERS AT THIS MOMENT?

 

MAFIA IS A GAME OF PERSPECTIVE AND IF YOU ARE TOWN YOU ARE MAKING YOURSELF LOOK HORRIBLE BECAUSE YOU WOULD RATHER BE STUBBORN AND SHOW OFF YOUR CLOUT BECAUSE THIS IS A BT GAME.

 

You vote one of the bigger fish for reactions, okay fine. I would say that you got them, and yes, both of them questioning your vote COULD indicate that they know my alignment but that isn't the only conclusion possible here and it's also faulty to assume it is. Your lack of an explanation was what drew the attention in the first place, so no, people questioning it doesn't automatically make them guilty.

 

 

 

Wanna know how im viewing here?  I wanna take bets on how many scum she finds D1 amd how many she gets lynched before they kill her. This is town Ithi.

 

my mafia list is currently standing at AJ Dawn and the possible addition of Thane

 

vote AJ

 

 

Awful sheeping from Dice.

 

I know that. I'm just wondering why you think I am in some sort of team with AJ so that I know for sure he's town....

 

Why are you defending AJ of you don't know what team he's on?

 

 

oh no ithi simply has style. Occasionally i can tell when she is town.  this is one of those times.

 

Buddying much?

[dicetosser1]

waves hands at nikon   Im pretty sure im here so why do i keep getting left off these lists?

 

@mod  can we have an official VC  please?  wanna make sure bas is lynched or if he is one short

 

 

I'll tell you something else too @ Dice. My Town-ness must be ingrained by now as the last time I was actually Mafia was in Basel's WW2 game.

Who you voting for @ Chae? I'm just wondering why you're following up nudging at me?

 

the Mods are too scared to make you mafia       is too unfair to town   nods

[dicetosser1]

@BFG  Ithi is making me smile. Want more do you want?  and after that i do give my reasons for AJ so you know

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

mods please delete out of body iPad sharing experience

[wheeloftime13]

Official Vote Count

Basel (9/9): TG, dawn, AJ, Chae, Thane, Ithi, Hallia, Nikon, Tsuki
Thane (2/9): Basel, Talmanes
Talmanes (1/9): ed
AJ (2/9): RTE, dice



people not voting (2/16): ice and BFG

Lynch achieved!!! scene coming up...

[Basel Gill]

 

Tsuki saying he's gonna vote Basel and then not is a bit suspect, perhaps he knew Basel was gonna pull Cinderella, a pumpkin and a couple of mice out of his hat.

What's he gonna say now I wonder.

That's an awfully big hat. Do you think I'm actually the Mad Hatter?

ooopsie... wrong account. That was me on Cindy's iPad.

[dicetosser1]

lmao   nah they must think your mynd bas.

[wheeloftime13]

 

People had been meeting at Granny's diner all day. As people came and went, most stayed toward the end of the day to wait for everybody else. As Ashley (Cinderella) stepped into the diner, her heart stuttered at the sight of the people staring at her. "Get her!" they rushed forward to grab her despite her protests that she was innocent. It wasn't long before they demanded her death and took her to the jail where they executed her.

 

Basel Gill- Cinderella, town vanilla has been lynched...

 

It is now Night 1... Deadline: Saturday May 3, 20:00 EST http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140503T20&p0=814&msg=OUAT+Mafia+Night+1

[BFG]

Fell asleep in front of TV

 

@BFG  Ithi is making me smile. Want more do you want?  and after that i do give my reasons for AJ so you know

 

I saw.

 

I had AJ as a town read, he reacted the same way to a lot of stuff that I did up until the Ithy argument. I'm not sure that makes him scummy or being a derp though. Watching for now.

[ed2funy]

Today. Sucked.

I'm getting medically discharged out of the Army guys! Yay me. *sigh*

 

Coming back later on my computer to compose thoughts. Ya I know I missed the lynch. Would have voted Basel or pushed for Thane or Dawn most likely.

[Thane Vakarian]

SO... that's not good. I was prety certain that Basel was scum to me. I'll have to see where i went wrong.

 

And, i have no idea why people always claim when they're about to get lynched.At that time, it might be a bit late.

[Thane Vakarian]

Once the night is done, it'll probably be 10 town vs 4 scum. Means that, if town works correctly, scum should be found and lynched. Hope for more activity on D2 from certain people.

[Ithillian Turambar]

fyi - my son has just been taken to hospital. I don't think I'll be posting much if anything in the Game till his condition improves.

[Hayl3y]

Ithi, best wishes to you and your son.