Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[Rhea]

And yes, perhaps I should have said RVS joke votes, redundant as that is, but I assumed it would be understood.

 

Had to look up RVS! First time I saw that acronym. Got it now! 

 

So I did Mish!  Despite what they're saying, I don't see you as scummy, because his reasoning was spotty.

 

Unvote

Vote Thorim

 

Buddying is noted.

 

 

I like how the countertrain to Kaylee is on Thorum, the biggest D1 lynch target in the history of DM mafia. That's not transparent at all.

 

i didnt know that. and neither would half the players in the game

 

 

I didn't either so not sure how it can apply at this point. What I think is we have an old player returning after a long absence and playing with a lot of new players who don't know him. 

 

 

That is pretty weak wombat and is a defense as well.

You can chalk me up as having defended Thorum if you want. I haven't seen anything out of the ordinary from him. Kaylee is a much better lynch.

 

 

I saw this as more of an explanation and not a defense.

 

 

 

 

I like how the countertrain to Kaylee is on Thorum, the biggest D1 lynch target in the history of DM mafia. That's not transparent at all.

i didnt know that. and neither would half the players in the game

Which is what makes it even more telling imo. The mafia may not have known not to do it.

 

 

dude thats BS, your assuming too much and basing it all on nothing

 

but saying that, i agree that kaylee seems a better lynch than thorum now 

 

 

Agree to the underlined.

 

Nobody else finds it odd that Hally seems to be blatantly buddying up to Mish?  Spotty reasoning or not, she just fired up the proverbial chainsaw as well.  Noted.

 

 

 

Nobody else finds it odd that Hally seems to be blatantly buddying up to Mish?  Spotty reasoning or not, she just fired up the proverbial chainsaw as well.  Noted.

I went back and looked at Hally's posts:

 

So I did Mish! Despite what they're saying, I don't see you as scummy, because his reasoning was spotty.

 

Unvote

Vote Thorim

I'm with you there 100% Mish. Why that one person instead of any of the other people who would be on that lynch?

I could be agreeable to a Hally train if it happens.  I definitely read these as buddying.

 

 

I read it that way too. 

 

Of course you would be, it'd save your skin.  If given the choice between Basel and you, I would say you're the better lynch candidate for the day.

 

Unvote

Vote Kaylee

 

Nice OMGUS there. 

 

 

As far as lynching inactives, that may be better later in the game. Harder to get good information from thier lynch D1. Weekends tend to be slow and some can't get online on the weekends.

That's ridiculous. Lunching inactives is a hard thing to do regardless. The further into the game you go the harder it gets cos the mafia have a greater majority % compared to the start (most if the time)

So instead of aiding them 1/12 or whatever's it is, it ends up as 1/6 th

A far greater blow to the town if its an inactive town (which is always more likely)

 

 

Why do we have this debate in every game? 

 

Unvote, vote Hally. I've been pondering this for a while as it seems the Tiink train has derailed. Hally keeps pinging for me, though. I really don't like the buddying act.

 

 

 

 

I was kind of back and forth on the Hally thing until she went for Kaylee like that and it pinged me as a scummy vote. So Vote Hally. 

[WWWwombat]

Choo choo

 

Sounds like Hally's getting railroaded.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Choo choo

 

Sounds like Hally's getting railroaded.

 

Was wondering who would apply the brakes.  Noted.  Thank you.

[WWWwombat]

You're welcome.

[Tigraine]

Railroaded how?

[lolguy26]

derailing the lynch is my guess 

[WWWwombat]

She's got a fast moving train for buddying and OMGUS. Those moves were a bit scummy for sure but this smells terrible. IIRC, Kaylee's last two cases have been on AJ and Hally. Looks like she's throwing crap against the wall and some of it just stuck.

[WWWwombat]

Unvote, vote Hally. I've been pondering this for a while as it seems the Tiink train has derailed. Hally keeps pinging for me, though. I really don't like the buddying act.

This is crap imo btw. The Hallia suspicion didn't start in earnest until shortly before this post. If Basel was thinking of switching a vote because the Tiink train derailed, why would he be thinking about someone who had very little momentum at the time? My assessment is that Basel is trying to save his own skin and for some reason doesn't want to vote Kaylee.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Unvote, vote Hally. I've been pondering this for a while as it seems the Tiink train has derailed. Hally keeps pinging for me, though. I really don't like the buddying act.

This is crap imo btw. The Hallia suspicion didn't start in earnest until shortly before this post. If Basel was thinking of switching a vote because the Tiink train derailed, why would he be thinking about someone who had very little momentum at the time? My assessment is that Basel is trying to save his own skin and for some reason doesn't want to vote Kaylee.

 

 

Coastin'

[Kaylee]

She's got a fast moving train for buddying and OMGUS. Those moves were a bit scummy for sure but this smells terrible. IIRC, Kaylee's last two cases have been on AJ and Hally. Looks like she's throwing crap against the wall and some of it just stuck.

Yes they have been. That's who stood out the most to me. I make cases and vote accordingly, that's how I play. I aslo said I'd be willing to vote for Razen because of his play. He, besdies what you pointed out, parroted my case on Hally and voted her. (As did Basel). I'd be willing to listen to cases against others as well. Have I done one of everyone? No. I tend not to have that kind of time. As the game goes on I watch how people play and interact.

 

This is actually the most active I've been on a D1 since I'm off work this week. On that note: Tomorrow I won't be around much until the afternoon. I have some RL things to take care of.

[Razen]

 

She's got a fast moving train for buddying and OMGUS. Those moves were a bit scummy for sure but this smells terrible. IIRC, Kaylee's last two cases have been on AJ and Hally. Looks like she's throwing crap against the wall and some of it just stuck.

Yes they have been. That's who stood out the most to me. I make cases and vote accordingly, that's how I play. I aslo said I'd be willing to vote for Razen because of his play. He, besdies what you pointed out, parroted my case on Hally and voted her. (As did Basel). I'd be willing to listen to cases against others as well. Have I done one of everyone? No. I tend not to have that kind of time. As the game goes on I watch how people play and interact.

 

I never voted for Hally.  I just pointed out what I saw as a very obvious point of buddying.  She's a lot better than that - but I am a lot more comfortable with my vote on Basel now.  I find it fascinating how many people took off down that road using that line of reasoning.

[Hallia]

Lynching me'll be a mistake. 

[wheeloftime13]

Official Vote Count

 

Mish (2/11): Darthe, peace

Kaylee (4/11): Thorum, Womby, Player, Hallia

Basel (3/11): Razen, Kraka, Tiink

Thorum (1/11): Mish

Wombat (1/11): TG

Hallia (6/11): Kaylee, Despo, Bob, Chuckles, Basel, Rhea

 

 

Not voting (2/20): Tigraine and alannalynn.

 

Deadline!!! Monday 20:00 EST http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20130610T20&p0=263&fg2=9acd79&msg=Merlin+Mafia+Day+1

[dapianoplay3r]

Lynching me'll be a mistake.

 

More of a mistake than soft claiming at only halfway to a lynch?

 

 

Anyway. Work submitted, now I sleep.

Hopefully for longer than 2 hours

[WWWwombat]

 

Lynching me'll be a mistake.

 

More of a mistake than soft claiming at only halfway to a lynch?

 

 

Anyway. Work submitted, now I sleep.

Hopefully for longer than 2 hours

Oh boy she's soft claiming town. What a scandal!

[Hallia]

I know, right?

[Darthe]

Did anyone notice that deadline is in 20 hours?  God I am f888ing sucking.  Sorry all, I may need to replace if I can't be active enough.  I've never done that before.

 

 

This is brief, but I really hate how Hally says soft things to the effect of "You'll really dislike it if you lynch me" and then goes back to being jokey.  If you need examples, read this page.  Post 312 and 316.  

In addition she is the closest to lynch and we have under a day.  Vote Hallia.

 

If you are worth derailing the day then you should reveal as soon as you get online.  

[Tigraine]

With us being this close to a lynch looks like you would remember to unvote Darthe.

[Tigraine]

Deadline is in less than 20 hours and Hallia is the closest we have to a lynch so vote hallia

 

For all the people votin for Hallia because she was seen as buddying, I see an awful lot of it from others as well.

[Hallia]

I tried to refrain from fully claiming, but that didn't work. =/ I'm cop.

[Tigraine]

unvote

[Tigraine]

Well then vote kaylee

[Vambram]

If I can believe Hallia's claim that she is the cop, then it appears at this time there is only one other lynch train which has a good chance of being completed. 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Unvote

 

Vote WWWWombat

[Vambram]

Kaylee has been one of the most active posters in this game. However, the cases and/or votes made against her by three veteran players and also by Hallia who is claiming cop gives me reason to look to her with more than just a casual FOS.