Danger in Demons Cove GAME OVER Villains win

[Ironeyes]

 

Oh shoot. I meant for you to be town, which means I'm missing someone in the null read section. I'll fix it!

just don't edit your already posted post. When you say fix it makes me worried.

I remember that rule. Almost got mod killed for it in my first ever mafia game.

[Ironeyes]

 

Ok, thoughts! No quotes because I'm on mobile but I will summarize.

 

Town reads: in no particular order

Niniel, because I think the comment about the paper and pencil was a Freudian slip and she hasn't done anything to raise my suspicions since

Sooh: intentionally drew suspicion to herself to try and draw out scum. Not something I would expect scum to do

Nynaeve: I don't have a good reason for this, she just feels good to me

Tress: seems towny when she is available. But why did she suspect Talmanes when he had hardly even said anything yet? And she didn't even throw up the lame excuse of voting for inactivity, either

Pral: Well reasoned reads, I agree with him on most counts

 

Null reads

1. WiFi: seems to be flip flopping but I dunno

3. Hallia : I'm not really sure

8. Talmanes : Just haven't seen enough from him yet

10. Sooh : I keep seeing both scum and town tells from her

 

Scum reads

12. Dice: I don't like sussing people for inactivity, but this seems abnormal for dice to say so little. But it's not enough of a ping for me to vote him.

Clov: I stand by my opinion that this guy is going for the easy lynch. His behavior is very similar to my own in the recent Disney game when I subbed in as SK. First thing I did was find an easy lynch and drill down on him.

Cool. I'm both a town and a null read!

That was supposed to be Kat who was a null read

[Katiora]

Question: How does everyone feel about Dice?

I feel like I suck at reading him... 

[Katiora]

 

 

Ok, thoughts! No quotes because I'm on mobile but I will summarize.

 

Town reads: in no particular order

Niniel, because I think the comment about the paper and pencil was a Freudian slip and she hasn't done anything to raise my suspicions since

Sooh: intentionally drew suspicion to herself to try and draw out scum. Not something I would expect scum to do

Nynaeve: I don't have a good reason for this, she just feels good to me

Tress: seems towny when she is available. But why did she suspect Talmanes when he had hardly even said anything yet? And she didn't even throw up the lame excuse of voting for inactivity, either

Pral: Well reasoned reads, I agree with him on most counts

 

Null reads

1. WiFi: seems to be flip flopping but I dunno

3. Hallia : I'm not really sure

8. Talmanes : Just haven't seen enough from him yet

10. Sooh : I keep seeing both scum and town tells from her

 

Scum reads

12. Dice: I don't like sussing people for inactivity, but this seems abnormal for dice to say so little. But it's not enough of a ping for me to vote him.

Clov: I stand by my opinion that this guy is going for the easy lynch. His behavior is very similar to my own in the recent Disney game when I subbed in as SK. First thing I did was find an easy lynch and drill down on him.

Cool. I'm both a town and a null read!

That was supposed to be Kat who was a null read

 

so i'm supposed to be where sooh is with that comment? 

[alannalynn]

Dice: Tone is good. Nothing is blatantly screaming scum to me. Therefore slightest town read

[Ironeyes]

 

 

 

Ok, thoughts! No quotes because I'm on mobile but I will summarize.

 

Town reads: in no particular order

Niniel, because I think the comment about the paper and pencil was a Freudian slip and she hasn't done anything to raise my suspicions since

Sooh: intentionally drew suspicion to herself to try and draw out scum. Not something I would expect scum to do

Nynaeve: I don't have a good reason for this, she just feels good to me

Tress: seems towny when she is available. But why did she suspect Talmanes when he had hardly even said anything yet? And she didn't even throw up the lame excuse of voting for inactivity, either

Pral: Well reasoned reads, I agree with him on most counts

 

Null reads

1. WiFi: seems to be flip flopping but I dunno

3. Hallia : I'm not really sure

8. Talmanes : Just haven't seen enough from him yet

10. Sooh : I keep seeing both scum and town tells from her

 

Scum reads

12. Dice: I don't like sussing people for inactivity, but this seems abnormal for dice to say so little. But it's not enough of a ping for me to vote him.

Clov: I stand by my opinion that this guy is going for the easy lynch. His behavior is very similar to my own in the recent Disney game when I subbed in as SK. First thing I did was find an easy lynch and drill down on him.

Cool. I'm both a town and a null read!

That was supposed to be Kat who was a null read

so i'm supposed to be where sooh is with that comment?

Yes

[Katiora]

So exactly what scum tell are you reading? 

[Sooh]

The fact that Ironeyes reads me both as town and null screams fishy to me. It's like scum trying to fabricate reads and he can't make up his mind. Just listen to the two reasons as well. The null read goes "Does both towny and scummy things", while the town read goes "Was scummy, but that was to draw out scum so she's towny". 

 

I don't see anyone reading this game as a townie having those two thoughts so close together and not being able to differentiate like that. 

[Talmanes]

@Clov - I don't have votes but wasn't exactly regarded highly on the Town list either. Your reasoning makes sense though.

 

@Alanna - I know you just kind of voted me, I wants referring only to you. Just noticed I was high on some lists and wondered at the reasoning. Wouldn't call that defensive, more curious. I don't mind people suspecting me, I just like to know why.

 

@Ironeyes - Your post seems to just beat some dead horses. Really not seeing much being added.

[Hallia]

Up to page 25 WOOO - But got 18 quotes, don't wanna press then I'll be on mobile.

Gun to the head I would [v]Clov[/v] today. 

 

Uh....what?

 

 

 

I kind of like Tress's reads list.  Other than Nienil being higher than I'd have her and Hallia probably being a bit too low, nothing about the order stands out to me as too bad.  Her read on me is a bit surprising, I guess?

 

 

Tress - who of those are you willing to lynch?  Where's the separation?  

 

Surprised I'm willing to be even cautiously optimistic on you?  

 

Niniel I'm having a hard time with placing, gut says I think she's being genuine although some things strike me as weird.  I could just think she's weird ...  but since I'm gut reading her posts as genuine, Hallia's vote on her without taking her explanations into consideration looked pretty opportunistic.  Since I'm town reading Nyn, her read on Hally i probably coloring mine as well.  if Hally comes in here tomorrow and bowls us over with towniness, that read could change quickly.

 

Most willing to lynch Ironeyes right now, Hally a bit less so - she's kind of tied with Talmanes  -- but he's one of those "I don't remember exactly why I felt bad about this one" gut reads I'd have to go back to and ehhh.  I will if I need to and I have time to before deadline, but it falls smack dab in the middle of my work day.  

 

 

btw   its nice to know I can sneak one by you lol!!

 

Red   when i unvoted earlier I also remembered my rule about reading Ninel.  its the same as reading thane   if you have tilt ure head and squint at it cause its a bit odd then they are town.

 

O.o How sure are you there?  

 

interesting to see prals vote.

 

i have this crazy thought in my head.  Clovs talk about ninel??  currently has my gut saying to lynch him.  its kinda convoluted tho.

 

nyn   just saw ure post. when u iso please look at the bits he is saying just before i unvoted nini??  See what you think

Why does your gut say that?  I'm on the fence/slight town on him atm.

 

So I ISOed Clov. I feel pretty much the same?  Yes, he seems undecided on Tina and Sooh through it all. Lands on a conclusion on Sooh eventually... not so much on Tina. The wifi point wasn't a bad one in itself, cause I do feel like Wifi had been a bit on the sidelines commentary wise at the time, even though there were players about, talking. I've been sorta struggling myself, weighing it all in too and considering things cause I wasn't sure how to interpret Sooh's and Tina's behavior and their consequent interaction. So I don't really mind his evaluation, because I was doing the same thing.

 

Bottom line is, Clov could very well be scum. Or he might be town. But I don't feel comfortable making that call atp, personally. He's a difficult read and not someone I'd rush with. Made that mistake before lol >.>

 

He is so good as wolf it took Lily viewing him to get a lynch. XD

 

Morning lovelies... *waits for timer to go off that coffee is ready*

 

Pral looks pretty good - it's usually a positive Town!Pral sign when he comes in with a couple of non-consensus reads that aren't so WTF that you wonder what game he's been reading.

 

It is?  Because I'm not seeing it.

 

 

And I personally would have liked it if Zander was playing 

I thought about doing a post by post quote catch up in his honor... but I was afraid ya'll would just policy lynch me so i didn't. But I did just finish a re-read. But I'm fixin to go ISO Hallia and Marsh now as they stick out to me slightly, with maybe a side of Sooh or someone else if I find something suspicious along the way. What time is day over? give me EST or CST or something cause you get much away from that and I get slightly befuddled. 

 

Currently there's not anything overly telling that i've seen.

 

Hallia jumping on a train early with no explanation doesn't mean anything. She just did the same thing to me as town.

 

I suck at reading Clov and have heard horror stories about how good a wolf he is so that makes me wanna tinfoil him.

 

Nini I'm horrible at reading. I always think she's wolfy, so I probably won't vote her D1 unless she does something seriously, horribly wolflike. I do kind agree with Clov on her being perhaps townspewed. I don't think she goes for that as Mafia. 

 

Nyn - seems townish. Gun to head I don't think she's wolf, but I think she could fool me and it's only d1. 

 

Wifi - eh *shrugs* who knows. She does seem a bit more.... subdued this game but it could just be she's bitten off more than she can chew *shrugs* 

 

Sooh - honestly have no clue. I'm a sucky sooh reader. I'll defer to Nyn for that read for now. I doubt they are W/W. They seemed too buddy buddy for that. But the possibility of one trying to pocket the other isn't out of the question. 

 

Prayla - I didn't think much of until his recent stuff but it seems decent. I'd like more thoughts. 

 

Marsh - started out strong but then kinda died off. I plan on ISO'ing him and reading him in vacuum to see if I feel the same. Nothing particular he said is standing out to me now that I'm thinking about it. 

 

Talmanes is definitely too quiet. I'm not sure what to think of that... 

 

Dice - i'm not sure of either. He always seems to play the same which makes it hard for me to get any kind of read on him. 

 

Tress isn't pinging me but hasn't done a lot that I remember either. So I'm not sure about her either. 

 

Alanna I'm so glad is confirmed town because I SUCK at reading her lol at least this time I know I have one read right lol 

 

 

I like that Kat put these out, even if they're kinda middle of the road.  Look forward to the ISOs

 

I always am wrong about her but if nyn says so then [v] hallia [/v] besides I think I have her as slightly town so that means I am wrong

 

Um.  Every time I want to give you the benefit of the doubt...

 

 

 

In any case, according to the rules, the player with most votes gets lynched. So this basically never goes to random. Which means people should prolly start voting at some point. Just sayin'. There isn't even a risk of hammering because it's a deadline game.

I don't mind hallia either. We have time for that.

The question is if hallia comes into the game and claims something, what would you do? What is your alternative?

 

 

I know how Hallia plays as a PR and this is not it. And no, I don't have an alternative atm. 

 

 

Also, do we even have PRs at the moment, I was under the understanding everyone got the Adventurer role and based on events we were given powers.  I could be wrong.

 

 

I am not asking you to pursue anyone else. I am saying there is already lot of sheeping going on :)

 

You have said yourself that you find Hallia suspicious, though. But you seem to have a problem with her train building cause you think I'm being sheeped? So which one is it? do you think Halli is rand to be town or scum? Because you're sending some mixed signals here.

 

 

I agree.

 

 

My morning routine consists of a lot of staring at the computer screen waiting for caffeine to work its way into my system and produce some semblance of coherent thought...  followed by about half an hour of frantic action trying to get ready for work and then breaking the speed limit to get to my desk on time.

 

I'm about to hit that frantic half-hour, and I don't remember how much is on my calendar for today once I get to the office.  I should be around a bit here and there before deadline and will try to read up on the game whenever I get a couple of minutes, if the data signal in my building doesn't suck today.

 

I think I feel best about voting Marsh at this point, pending further posts from Hallia and a chance to process them.

 

[v]Ironeyes[/v]

 

Because he's been quiet? Or?

 

1. WiFi - I didn´t like the way she suspected me and then voted Hallia for weird reasons. Just following others. Don´t know how much of this is because she is in two games at the same time. 
2. Niniel - town. 
3. Hallia - I´ll wait for her catch up. Didn´t like her vote on me. 
4. Ironeyes - I´ll wait for his catch up too. Not sure I understand why others have suspected him. 
5. Clovr - not sure that I understand his yolo vote on Ironeyes. 
6. Pral - I like what he has written today. I will be very vary of him though because he did a great job pocketing me last game we played together and seem townie there too. 
7.  Kat - posted a list that didn´t say anything really. 
8. Talmanes - hasn´t been here much at all. 
9. Tress - her list seemed okay. 
10. Sooh - still not sure but the activity level is good. 
11. Nyn - looks good. Towniest after Alanna. 
12. Dice - looks okay but I would like more. 
13. Alanna

 

How do you feel on my catch-up?  I also like that you say kat's list didn't say anything really when you did the same.

 

 

Niniel can you elaborate on how Kat is less focused?

 

I can understand the whole "not being able to read someone"... I'm glad I'm IC this game or Hally woulda already tried to lynch me twice! LOL

 

Did I say that? I meant Wifi. 

 

 

I find this odd wrt Kat or Wifi for that matter.  Have you had an instance where Wifi has been focused?

 

I will be away for a while but I´ll be back. I feel that I need to place my vote first.

 

[v] Wifi [/v]

 

 

I´ll see what Hallia has to say when she has read the whole thread. I don´t like her vote on me. 

 

See above, what say you now?

 

Just got caught up, would like to reread a bit if I have time.

Anyone have any suspicions of me besides the fact that I haven't been active over the weekend? I'm really not seeing anything but that and I am seeming to be the top of quite a few lists here.

I still really don't like the push in Niniel. I still think she is Town at this point and even if I didn't, the main point against her seems to be reading Nyn as Town for the exact same reason I did and no one has questioned me on my exact same read. Seems pretty off.

I also don't like the push on Hallia by Nun (the unvote makes me feel better) because she did the exact same thing last game I played and Hally got lynched just because she wasn't around much. I this KT he people bandwagoning this one look a bit scummy.

I'm really not getting the confirmed Town feel from Sooh like a lot of others seem to but that's still really just a feeling and not concrete so I'm not willing to vote there.

I liked Pral's reads and am going to be watching Clov based on his reads.

At this point I'm going to [v] WiFi [/v]. I was willing to give some benefit of the doubt to her as she is new, and as I commented her play seemed similar to what I've seen, but I can't get over the bandwagon vote on Hallia. Did not back it up at all, just saying well Nyn said so it must be right. Could be too much on the plate but I can't let it slide especially on D1 without much else to go on.

 

I'm not WTL Tal today, his catchings up aren't terrible.

 

I really feel like Ironeyes hasn't been around enough or done enough to merit a vote for that matter either. I feel like he is being voted simply for not being around (seems to be the only real reason anyone is looking at me too) and I don't think that is really a viable route.

 

*nodnod* No info to get really from him.

 

Okay, just powered through everything.  I don't have the time to respond to everything that I'd want to, but the short version:

 

-Mixed feelings on Pral.  I like that he's getting involved finally and his willingness to start a push is a good sign, but the things he's pushing me confuse me.  He uses the thing about Alanna and my post towards WiFi out...immediately after commenting that he felt similar.  

 

He's not wrong about voting an easy target, but pretty much everybody is an easy target.  I can't push Alanna.  I couldn't easily push Nyn.  After Sooh started digging in, she wouldn't really be so easy to push.  But why would I?  Confirmed town, somebody that's playing incredibly protown, and somebody that has been increasingly townie since deliberately acting off to get things going.

 

If the giant group of nulls start posting, I can evaluate better.  In the mean time, I have to make due with what I've got.

 

-The vote for IronEyes was somewhat for inactivity, but more how it came.  He was very fluffy early and I dragged him into contributing.  He said he needed more information to make a decision.  That's fine - not everybody thinks 'quickly'.  So what did he do?

 

 

Morning everyone! Glad to see you haven't added twenty more pages while I was asleep.

 

 

Okay...again, that's fine...

 

And nothing.  He said he needed more information to figure something out and then completely avoided trying to GET that information.  If somebody needs more information to evaluate people, then shouldn't that person try to GET more information?  

 

I saw he said he was busy earlier today, but I would think if he was available to post about there not being new pages he'd be able to post something that contributed to the game without having to be directly asked.

 

-Tress made a point about Pral I liked and agreed with, which is why I didn't feel completely awful about his push on me.  Town!Pral is going to give you his thoughts.  He's not afraid to go completely against the grain on a read or disagree with somebody.  I still want to see more from Tress because she's usually pretty obvious to me when she's town, and she hasn't been.

 

-Hallia is looking just a little worse, just because it seemed most of her posts when she was going back through were just agreeing/saying she liked things.  I know she does that as town, but I'd expect something unique from her.  Everything was just piggybacking what everybody else said.

 

 

I saw Alanna voted Talmanes.  I wouldn't vote there over Iron, but I have no issues with his lynch.  I'd certainly prefer him over Hallia.

How is it piggybacking when several people have changed their minds on things I initially agreed with, but I haven't?

 

So does it strike anyone as odd that Pral was rambling about sheeping and asking for competing trains and bla bla bla.... but then votes Hallia?

 

Yes.  I'm wtl Nini or Pral atp

[Ironeyes]

Yeah, I know, my read list is crap. I'm just trying to contribute to the game. I'm not the mafia player I used to be any more. Kat, tbh, I don't remember why I wrote that about you. It was copy pasted from the notes I took as I skimmed the game.

[Talmanes]

On Dice I always read him as scummy so try to withhold judgement unless I have evidence.

[Nynaeve]

The fact that Ironeyes reads me both as town and null screams fishy to me. It's like scum trying to fabricate reads and he can't make up his mind. Just listen to the two reasons as well. The null read goes "Does both towny and scummy things", while the town read goes "Was scummy, but that was to draw out scum so she's towny". 

 

I don't see anyone reading this game as a townie having those two thoughts so close together and not being able to differentiate like that. 

 

He says the "sooh" in null is Kat. And Kat doesn't appear on his list at all so..... maybe?

[Niniel]

 

I will be away for a while but I´ll be back. I feel that I need to place my vote first.

 

[v] Wifi [/v]

 

 

I´ll see what Hallia has to say when she has read the whole thread. I don´t like her vote on me. 

 

AND you're voting me: WHY??

 

 

Well, Nyn gave a good answer: 

 

 

AND you're voting me: WHY??

 

I know this wasn't directed at me, but off the top of my head? You haven't been doing much if any scumhunting of your own and just keep saying that there's nothing to comment on or that it's already been commented on. I find this odd cause you tend to have your own interpretation usually. And you've been corrected twice already over your read list... first on your town lean on Ironeyes for a reason that doesn't exist... and then a null read on Hallia, that you claimed turned into a town read over a reason that doesn't exist.... which made your vote on Hallia seem somewhat awkward.

 

 

If you look at my recent post I found your reason for voting Hallia really odd. 

 

OMG WHAT IS THAT DOING THERE?!?!?!   

 

:D

 

Question: How does everyone feel about Dice?

 

Okay, but I wish he would post more.

 

 

Kat, doing any more iso?

[Nynaeve]

NOT OFFICIAL - VoteCount

Ironeyes (3): Clov, Sooh, Tress

Niniel (1): Hallia

Hallia (2): WiFi, Pral

Talmanes (1): Alanna

WiFi (2): Niniel, Talmanes

Not voting (4): Dice, Ironeyes, Katiora, Nyn

[Sooh]

 

The fact that Ironeyes reads me both as town and null screams fishy to me. It's like scum trying to fabricate reads and he can't make up his mind. Just listen to the two reasons as well. The null read goes "Does both towny and scummy things", while the town read goes "Was scummy, but that was to draw out scum so she's towny". 

 

I don't see anyone reading this game as a townie having those two thoughts so close together and not being able to differentiate like that. 

 

He says the "sooh" in null is Kat. And Kat doesn't appear on his list at all so..... maybe?

 

So thin though. The fact that the numbers are still on just tells me that he wanted to make sure he had a comment on everyone, and he just took out those he could remember and generate an opinion on without the numbered list, and then he filled in with the rest.

 

I don't know obviously, but to me this list is meh.

[Sooh]

Also I feel like Dice is doing that whole sliding under the radar thing right now. 

[Niniel]

 

 

 

 

1. WiFi - I didn´t like the way she suspected me and then voted Hallia for weird reasons. Just following others. Don´t know how much of this is because she is in two games at the same time. 

2. Niniel - town. 

3. Hallia - I´ll wait for her catch up. Didn´t like her vote on me. 

4. Ironeyes - I´ll wait for his catch up too. Not sure I understand why others have suspected him. 

5. Clovr - not sure that I understand his yolo vote on Ironeyes. 

6. Pral - I like what he has written today. I will be very vary of him though because he did a great job pocketing me last game we played together and seem townie there too. 

7.  Kat - posted a list that didn´t say anything really. 

8. Talmanes - hasn´t been here much at all. 

9. Tress - her list seemed okay. 

10. Sooh - still not sure but the activity level is good. 

11. Nyn - looks good. Towniest after Alanna. 

12. Dice - looks okay but I would like more. 

13. Alanna

 

How do you feel on my catch-up?  I also like that you say kat's list didn't say anything really when you did the same.

 

 

Niniel can you elaborate on how Kat is less focused?

 

I can understand the whole "not being able to read someone"... I'm glad I'm IC this game or Hally woulda already tried to lynch me twice! LOL

 

Did I say that? I meant Wifi. 

 

 

I find this odd wrt Kat or Wifi for that matter.  Have you had an instance where Wifi has been focused?

 

I will be away for a while but I´ll be back. I feel that I need to place my vote first.

 

[v] Wifi [/v]

 

 

I´ll see what Hallia has to say when she has read the whole thread. I don´t like her vote on me. 

 

See above, what say you now?

 

 

 

 

I don´t know what this will look like. I tried to remove everything but what was aimed at me. 

 

I definitely don´t like your vote on me. You have not once (what I can see) commented on my post where I tried to explain myself. It seems like you have already made up your mind. 

 

I don´t agree with you about Kat´s list either. You don´t think my list said anything at all? 

 

 

Bold = don´t understand. 

[Nynaeve]

So thin though. The fact that the numbers are still on just tells me that he wanted to make sure he had a comment on everyone, and he just took out those he could remember and generate an opinion on without the numbered list, and then he filled in with the rest.

 

I don't know obviously, but to me this list is meh.

 

It's possible. Just not sure.

[Hallia]

Got stopped; I'll comment on this when I get back from lunch

Hallia - Can you give reasons for basically anything?  You said you agree with me about Sooh and disagree about Niniel.  What do you disagree with?  Nothing in that post was directly about her - it was about Sooh's chances to be mafia.

 

What of Dice's posts do you disagree with?  You thought Sooh trying to get activity going by randomly voting seems genuine?

 

Ok, thoughts! No quotes because I'm on mobile but I will summarize.

Town reads: in no particular order
Niniel, because I think the comment about the paper and pencil was a Freudian slip and she hasn't done anything to raise my suspicions since
Sooh: intentionally drew suspicion to herself to try and draw out scum. Not something I would expect scum to do
Nynaeve: I don't have a good reason for this, she just feels good to me
Tress: seems towny when she is available. But why did she suspect Talmanes when he had hardly even said anything yet? And she didn't even throw up the lame excuse of voting for inactivity, either
Pral: Well reasoned reads, I agree with him on most counts

Null reads
1. WiFi: seems to be flip flopping but I dunno
3. Hallia : I'm not really sure
8. Talmanes : Just haven't seen enough from him yet
10. Sooh : I keep seeing both scum and town tells from her

Scum reads
12. Dice: I don't like sussing people for inactivity, but this seems abnormal for dice to say so little. But it's not enough of a ping for me to vote him.
Clov: I stand by my opinion that this guy is going for the easy lynch. His behavior is very similar to my own in the recent Disney game when I subbed in as SK. First thing I did was find an easy lynch and drill down on him.

 

 

Question: How does everyone feel about Dice?

 

 

The fact that Ironeyes reads me both as town and null screams fishy to me. It's like scum trying to fabricate reads and he can't make up his mind. Just listen to the two reasons as well. The null read goes "Does both towny and scummy things", while the town read goes "Was scummy, but that was to draw out scum so she's towny". 

 

I don't see anyone reading this game as a townie having those two thoughts so close together and not being able to differentiate like that. 

[Katiora]

 

 

I will be away for a while but I´ll be back. I feel that I need to place my vote first.

 

[v] Wifi [/v]

 

 

I´ll see what Hallia has to say when she has read the whole thread. I don´t like her vote on me. 

 

AND you're voting me: WHY??

 

 

Well, Nyn gave a good answer: 

 

 

AND you're voting me: WHY??

 

I know this wasn't directed at me, but off the top of my head? You haven't been doing much if any scumhunting of your own and just keep saying that there's nothing to comment on or that it's already been commented on. I find this odd cause you tend to have your own interpretation usually. And you've been corrected twice already over your read list... first on your town lean on Ironeyes for a reason that doesn't exist... and then a null read on Hallia, that you claimed turned into a town read over a reason that doesn't exist.... which made your vote on Hallia seem somewhat awkward.

 

 

If you look at my recent post I found your reason for voting Hallia really odd. 

 

OMG WHAT IS THAT DOING THERE?!?!?!   

 

:D

 

Question: How does everyone feel about Dice?

 

Okay, but I wish he would post more.

 

 

Kat, doing any more iso?

 

yes... isoing you right now

[Niniel]

Great. :)

[Nynaeve]

lol

[Nynaeve]

I'm so freaking conflicted right now.

 

Zander, halp? 

[Wildfire Sedai]

Hallia - Can you give reasons for basically anything?  You said you agree with me about Sooh and disagree about Niniel.  What do you disagree with?  Nothing in that post was directly about her - it was about Sooh's chances to be mafia.

 

What of Dice's posts do you disagree with?  You thought Sooh trying to get activity going by randomly voting seems genuine?

 

Just got caught up, would like to reread a bit if I have time.

 

Anyone have any suspicions of me besides the fact that I haven't been active over the weekend? I'm really not seeing anything but that and I am seeming to be the top of quite a few lists here.

 

I still really don't like the push in Niniel. I still think she is Town at this point and even if I didn't, the main point against her seems to be reading Nyn as Town for the exact same reason I did and no one has questioned me on my exact same read. Seems pretty off.

 

I also don't like the push on Hallia by Nun (the unvote makes me feel better) because she did the exact same thing last game I played and Hally got lynched just because she wasn't around much. I this KT he people bandwagoning this one look a bit scummy.

 

I'm really not getting the confirmed Town feel from Sooh like a lot of others seem to but that's still really just a feeling and not concrete so I'm not willing to vote there.

 

I liked Pral's reads and am going to be watching Clov based on his reads.

 

At this point I'm going to [v] WiFi [/v]. I was willing to give some benefit of the doubt to her as she is new, and as I commented her play seemed similar to what I've seen, but I can't get over the bandwagon vote on Hallia. Did not back it up at all, just saying well Nyn said so it must be right. Could be too much on the plate but I can't let it slide especially on D1 without much else to go on.

 

I don't feel you've been at the top of anybody's list.  Alanna specifically stated she wanted competing wagons when she voted you.  Nobody else has voted you, and I know a couple of people mentioned they'd be willing to, including me.  But why shouldn't we?

 

I don't remember anything you've contributed before this.  You said you did the same thing as Niniel with Nyn - I'd have to go back and check, but I feel like she was much more concerned with it than anybody.  As for the rest...I don't agree with everything you've said, but I like where your head's at.  Hallia's trending downwards recently for the reasons I've already stated, but I don't think she should have gotten the pressure she did when she started to.  Not sure what the bold is supposed to say, though.

 

I'm fine with the WiFi vote and agree with the reasoning.  I know WiFi is still a newer player and it's good to work with townreads, but it's like she's completely discounting the possibility Nyn could be wrong (and technically that Nyn could be mafia, though I'd be surprised if she is).  Very interested to see how WiFI adjusts now.

 

I am not discounting the possibility that nyn could be wrong.  I had hallia as null then I very tiny bit slightly townie, however nyn knows hallia better than me, so I was sheeping her for now, I was waiting for hallia to come along and change my mind, she didn't.  Yes, she made some more posts but I didn't get anything out of them.  Nothing sang to me. So I am keeping my vote where it is.  If I am wrong, I am wrong.  It is not a hammer game, so you do not need my vote to reach a majority. as for niniel and talmanes: voting me for my playstyle wtf  even I don't know what my playstyle is Yes I have been a light poster this game.  I apologize.  and yes I have made a few mistakes but: that's me...I've made mistakes in every game I've played in.  I don't keep notes or anything, its a game.  I try to keep everything in my head...hasn't quite worked that well but I also don't have a lot of space I am willing to use, either.  I have an art table, but that is for art and I can't sit at it to type cause I can't get close enough to type. I use a bedside table and I have papers that I need next to puter/laptop...so...