Multiball Mafia - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS

[Niniel]

@ Dice - no, I consider it an honor to be thrown into the lake. Just missed the salt and lemons. :p 

 

[unvote]

 

 

I find two things vote worthy so far. 

 

1. Kat answering for Wifi. I think Nyn´s questioning was good.

 

2. Hallia´s vote on Luthine. I agree with Zander that her reason is bad. We have 19 pages so far and most of it is bla bla so I don´t see why it´s distracting.

 

 

[v] Hallia [/v]

 

 

I like several players so far but it will be hard to trust people when we have different mafia teams. My experiences tells me that it´s much easier to look town as mafia in a multiball game since you are actually hunting for mafia. 

[Nynaeve]

 

I don't give noobie passes

 

The reasoning especially atp is bad tho too.

 

Id be a little less concerned perhaps if I wasnt sussing you some.

 

 

Part of me is wondering if it was an act of solidarity towards me. Kinda muddles things.

[Talmanes]

@WiFi - Not saying that I simply read her as less of scum, just that due to being argumentative being in her usual play style, I read her as less scummy than I would have otherwise. Important distinction.

 

It's D1 so as far as I'm concerned you're all scum until you do something to make me feel otherwise.

[Zander?]

@ Dice - no, I consider it an honor to be thrown into the lake. Just missed the salt and lemons. :p 

 

[unvote]

 

 

I find two things vote worthy so far. 

 

1. Kat answering for Wifi. I think Nyn´s questioning was good.

 

2. Hallia´s vote on Luthine. I agree with Zander that her reason is bad. We have 19 pages so far and most of it is bla bla so I don´t see why it´s distracting.

 

 

[v] Hallia [/v]

 

 

I like several players so far but it will be hard to trust people when we have different mafia teams. My experiences tells me that it´s much easier to look town as mafia in a multiball game since you are actually hunting for mafia. 

 

Not a bad post.  Dont know if it means anything for your alignment but not a bad post nonetheless.

[Zander?]

 

 

I don't give noobie passes

 

The reasoning especially atp is bad tho too.

 

Id be a little less concerned perhaps if I wasnt sussing you some.

 

 

Part of me is wondering if it was an act of solidarity towards me. Kinda muddles things.

 

 

Is this solidarity alignment indicative of her?

 

If so how and why?

[Nynaeve]

Is this solidarity alignment indicative of her?

 

If so how and why?

 

 

It's not. That's kind of the point.

[Zander?]

 

Is this solidarity alignment indicative of her?

 

If so how and why?

 

 

It's not. That's kind of the point.

 

 

Ya that was the response I was hoping youd give.

[Andrej]

 

Finally home from class but I'm showering and going to sleep since I've got work in the AM.

 

Thus far I have a few I feel okay about. Most people haven't posted much so I'll hold off until things pick up a bit.

 

Goodnight

Who are these people and why AJ?

Going off the cuff from yesterday I had you, Nyn and Dice as early town leans. You for stirring the pot early and asking pointed questions versus questioning just to look busy. Nyn for asserting herself early and giving unsolicited observations. Dice for his immediate directness on entry.

 

Talmanes also but that's more gut from his tone by itself. I don't really agree with his stance on Dice but I'd prefer to let them hash it out first so I can get a better perspective.

 

I'm still having to skim a lot while I'm at work so these are just general impressions. As of yesterday I noted Hallia was around but not really doing anything that stood out to me as towny yet. The Kat/Lily/Hallia interaction didn't serve much purpose imo. Don't really have an opinion on Kat or Lily yet except that Kat seems to be pandering a lot and Lily said some stuff.

 

From today I think Luthine looks alright and explained herself well. Taking into consideration she's using generic tells I'm okay with the vote on Nyn and her responses afterwards. Not sure what to think about Hallia's vote yet.

 

I'd like to see more from Tina (who is Nini now?) to get a better read. I noted yesterday that she commented a few times early but not much since (probably time zones). The vote on Hallia is kind of naked by itself. I'd like to see her interact more.

[Wildfire Sedai]

@WiFi - Not saying that I simply read her as less of scum, just that due to being argumentative being in her usual play style, I read her as less scummy than I would have otherwise. Important distinction.

 

It's D1 so as far as I'm concerned you're all scum until you do something to make me feel otherwise.

Thank you for correcting me.

[Zander?]

@ AJ

 

Some solid points in your response post to me.  Especially irt Nyn.

 

Also if youre Scum, and Im not saying i think you are my reads are still prolly good.

 

lololololololol

[Andrej]

Also I'd be okay with the DL staying as is. I'll be more available over the weekend and would like an opportunity to read the thread more thoroughly.

 

But if not, I'll just suck it up.

[Eldrick4221]

Vote Count

 

Lily (1) : Dice

Nyn (1) : Luthine

Luthine (1) : Hally

Hally (2) : Zander, Nini

 

Not Voting : Sooh, AJ, Talmanes, Lily, Wiffy, Kat, Nyn

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to reach majority.

 

Deadline is Monday @ 6pm

 

[Eldrick4221]

Also I'd be okay with the DL staying as is. I'll be more available over the weekend and would like an opportunity to read the thread more thoroughly.

 

But if not, I'll just suck it up.

Then it will. I was only gonna change it if everyone was ok with it.

[Andrej]

 

Also I'd be okay with the DL staying as is. I'll be more available over the weekend and would like an opportunity to read the thread more thoroughly.

 

But if not, I'll just suck it up.

Then it will. I was only gonna change it if everyone was ok with it.

It's cool, I don't want to hold the game up if everyone else agrees to shorten it. Thanks for the consideration though.

[Andrej]

@ AJ

 

Some solid points in your response post to me. Especially irt Nyn.

 

Also if youre Scum, and Im not saying i think you are my reads are still prolly good.

 

lololololololol

lol part of the reason I like multi ball games is because scum have to hunt scum too.

 

But, I'm town and if my reads are good then I think we could wrap this up pretty quickly if we can get the scum to kill each other.

 

I'm gonna try to narrow it down to a pool of suspects to vote from since the odds should be pretty good - but that'll come later after I can read more.

 

Until then try not to flood the thread too much, buddy

[Zander?]

I WILL NOT ALLOW THIS GAME TO BE HELD UP!!!

 

D1 is awful enough as it is.

 

A few RL days should be more then enough to figure things out and after flips and N1 we should be fine moving forward imo.

[Zander?]

 

@ AJ

 

Some solid points in your response post to me. Especially irt Nyn.

 

Also if youre Scum, and Im not saying i think you are my reads are still prolly good.

 

lololololololol

lol part of the reason I like multi ball games is because scum have to hunt scum too.

 

But, I'm town and if my reads are good then I think we could wrap this up pretty quickly if we can get the scum to kill each other.

 

I'm gonna try to narrow it down to a pool of suspects to vote from since the odds should be pretty good - but that'll come later after I can read more.

 

Until then try not to flood the thread too much, buddy

 

 

You know I pretty much stopped reading this post after the bold.....

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

 

@Nyn - We have played together before and I'm also familiar with you on general. Doesn't mean you're necessarily Town in my book, just gives you less of a scum read to me.

At this point my strongest scum read is Dice. The more I think about it the more I don't like his early 100% reads. It's giving me flashbacks to Verb doing that the whole last game I played to make himself seem innocent. The only way to 100% know if someone is Town D1 is if you are scum. And on this game there are two teams so even that can be a stretch.

 

 

To clarify it's mainly the Zander read. I haven't played a ton if games with Zander but so far he seems exactly the same as I've ever seen him whether in Mafia or in general.

 

It jumped out to me too and I commented on it.  Ive seen Dice do this as Town more then once tho and was correct like just a few posts/pages in.  He tends to be one of the best Zander readers on the site, along with Cory and Shad and even Hallia.

 

But....this is obv something easy for him to do as Scum as well.

 

I guess what Im saying is that by ITSELF is null.  The other part about him also having a Scum lean on Lily which was something I commented on already as well on top of that concerns me a little too but again he's done as well as Town.

 

So Im wary atp but he's certainly not out of his Town!Dice range at all here.

Looking at this very seriously.

 

3. Trying to figure this out

[Nynaeve]

Kat, thoughts so far?

[Zander?]

Nyn thoughts on AJ?

[Nynaeve]

Nyn thoughts on AJ?

 

He sounds better than earlier, but he always does, that's kind of the problem with him. He's very well spoken, regardless of alignment. I always maintain a healthy suspicion in his general direction for that reason. And it takes me a while to feel comfortable with him. So basically taking my time with him. We'll see what he brings to the table.

 

I feel comfortable with you atp, fwiw. 

[Zander?]

 

Nyn thoughts on AJ?

 

He sounds better than earlier, but he always does, that's kind of the problem with him. He's very well spoken, regardless of alignment. I always maintain a healthy suspicion in his general direction for that reason. And it takes me a while to feel comfortable with him. So basically taking my time with him. We'll see what he brings to the table.

 

I feel comfortable with you atp, fwiw. 

 

 

Ditto

[Hallia]

I love Nyn, and I got defensive. ;_;

 

Now that my other game is over I should have more time to play

[Nynaeve]

I love Nyn, and I got defensive. ;_;

 

Now that my other game is over I should have more time to play

 

Halli could you please answer what I asked you?

[Nynaeve]

Its a personal feel mainly. The way he did it, and the follow up afterwards.

 

Oh