[Advanced] Monty Python and the Holy Grail Mafia (Game Over)

Niniel · June 21, 2011

Good luck, Sakaea!

Sakaea · June 21, 2011

Thanks to you both!!!!

Krakalakachkn · June 21, 2011

"Bring out your dead!

Bring out your dead!

Bring out your dead!"

*A man approaches the Dead Collector with another man over his shoulder. As he starts to set his burden down, it suddenly speaks*

"I'm not dead!"

"Yes you are!"

"Look, I can't take him unless he's dead."

"Well it won't be long."

"I think I'll go for a walk!"

"You're not fooling anyone! Look, can you do us a favor?"

*The Dead Collector thumps the man on the head and lays him on the cart*

"Thanks mate, same time next week?"

"Right."

*The Dead Collector trundles on his way, doing his job and collecting the dead. Night falls on the village; hiding the dead and dying from the sight of the living. The Dead Collector clucks his reigns and the horses start to cantor. Slowly and silently, the shadow of a figure moves in the cart. It rises up behind the Collector and wraps its hands around his throat. The Collector struggles, but to no avail.*

JenaLenMom, the Dead Collector, Vanilla Town, has been Nightkilled

It is now day two. With 24 alive it takes 13 to lynch.

Sedai · June 21, 2011

vote Charis

I'd also be willing to vote Moon or Key today

Minuet · June 21, 2011

Vote Red

As stated during the night, I have my reasons. She can try to back peddle all she wants.

Tiinker · June 21, 2011

On 6/21/2011 at 7:46 PM, Jack_D said:

vote Charis

I'd also be willing to vote Moon or Key today

Key? I haven't seen much of her or looked too deeply into her posts but maybe I've missed something. What's pinging you?

Sedai · June 21, 2011

Hoof half claimed. He was lying at the time but that was irrelevant. Key then came in and voted without pause after his half claim. It looked scummy to me.

JenLenaMom · June 21, 2011

Da---Ack!

keyholder21 · June 21, 2011

On 6/21/2011 at 8:29 PM, Tiinker said:

On 6/21/2011 at 7:46 PM, Jack_D said:

vote Charis

I'd also be willing to vote Moon or Key today

Key? I haven't seen much of her or looked too deeply into her posts but maybe I've missed something. What's pinging you?

I agree with this statement, why me? I posted at the beginning of night that I don't like to talk game at night so that's why I haven't been around much.

keyholder21 · June 21, 2011

nm, I must have missed your explanation post somehow.

? I voted for consolidation. I said as much in my vote post.

Leelou · June 21, 2011

Ok...I'm back now. I need to play catch up. From what I could see from a quick read through, Red and Charis are sticking out.

Sedai · June 21, 2011

On 6/21/2011 at 9:40 PM, keyholder21 said:

nm, I must have missed your explanation post somehow.

? I voted for consolidation. I said as much in my vote post.

The reason being is, when you voted for consolidation, not why you voted. You voted after a semi reveal. You voted without pause.

keyholder21 · June 22, 2011

did I? Check out the time stamps Jack.

On 6/17/2011 at 3:21 AM, keyholder21 said:

On 6/17/2011 at 3:11 AM, Jack_D said:

UNVOTE and vote hoof

One word, five syllables, con-sol-I-da-tion

Fair enough. Unvote, vote Blackhoof.

On 6/17/2011 at 3:34 AM, Blackhoof said:

indeed we shall, sakky.

ooh, a lynch is forming. interesting....

well, i would rather you did not lynch me, as it would be detrimental to the town. because.... i have a power role. not a massively good one, but a power role all the same. it seems fun, so please do not lynch me until i have been able to use it.

Blackhoof - revealing he has a role since 1995

Sedai · June 22, 2011

On 6/22/2011 at 12:00 AM, keyholder21 said:

did I? Check out the time stamps Jack.

On 6/17/2011 at 3:21 AM, keyholder21 said:

On 6/17/2011 at 3:11 AM, Jack_D said:

UNVOTE and vote hoof

One word, five syllables, con-sol-I-da-tion

Fair enough. Unvote, vote Blackhoof.

On 6/17/2011 at 3:34 AM, Blackhoof said:

indeed we shall, sakky.

ooh, a lynch is forming. interesting....

well, i would rather you did not lynch me, as it would be detrimental to the town. because.... i have a power role. not a massively good one, but a power role all the same. it seems fun, so please do not lynch me until i have been able to use it.

Blackhoof - revealing he has a role since 1995

Sorry about that key. Someone else posted just after hoofs semi reveal. I thought it was you

keyholder21 · June 22, 2011

No probs, it's cool.

berf · June 22, 2011

I propose Red and Charis have a Tequilla fuelled dance-off contest.

We lynch the loser.

Of the two, I am leaning towards Charis. Though it appears Moon has pretty much upped and gone after a few started eyeing her? I could be wrong though, and Day has only started.

Berf - Beating dead horses for years and years...

bgrishinko · June 22, 2011

Well. here's the thing.

I'm not convinced Red or Charis are scum right now. There is no need to link to their respective posts, since they've said enough and linked to pretty much every important post the game has had so far.

Red uses wall o' text posts as both Mafia and Town. I've seen it both. She hopes to draw in skimmers to believe there is a very damnable case early on, even when much of what has been said is just average early scum hunting and randomness. She'll find something to latch onto. Then someone invariably gets caught up in the wall o' text accusations and Red latches on to that person, for better or worse. In this case, Charis. Charis feels the need to vehemently defend himself, and does so. A natural response for some people.

I think the major take away here is that they both can't be on the same team... whether that be a mafia team, a mason team, or whatever. Either one is mafia, or they are both innocent. And from that, the chances of trying to puzzle out which one is which is rough, and I think that we will have better luck searching elsewhere today.

So, to follow Red's train of thought... among other people's suspicions I want to start by applying Moon pressure. Vote Moon

Sakaea · June 22, 2011

I think I agree with BG so far. I'm not going to vote til I do a re-read, which shall be tomorrow. I shall then make a case against who I think is a witch.

NI!!!!!!

Christine · June 22, 2011

Not voting till I do a full reread either, but in looking at Red and Charis's posts, I think that either that both have to be mafia, or neither are mafia. It's one or the other, and obviously two mafia members aren't going to make a stink at each other. I am leaning towards thinking they are finders, perhaps? Idk. Going to pocket my thoughts on this one for a while.

Alanna · June 22, 2011

Charis and Red could both be mafia if this was some kind of gambit between them. Not saying I think it is, but a couple people now have said they can't both be mafia, and that's not true.

alannalynn · June 22, 2011

Mornin'! Going back to do a more thorough read of the past two/three pages (of 40ppp) before attacking. :unsure:

csarmi · June 22, 2011

On 6/22/2011 at 4:55 AM, Alanna said:

Charis and Red could both be mafia if this was some kind of gambit between them. Not saying I think it is, but a couple people now have said they can't both be mafia, and that's not true.

Agreed.

trench · June 22, 2011

On 6/21/2011 at 8:56 PM, Jack_D said:

Hoof half claimed. He was lying at the time but that was irrelevant. Key then came in and voted without pause after his half claim. It looked scummy to me.

I know Jack was mistaken about who he was talking about here. But I looked back and saw that it was Min who first posted after Hoof's half reveal. I also notice she has not had anyone actually focusing in on her today. Her and Red went back and forth for most of yesterday, but today the focus has moved onto other candidates. Min was on the Wombat lynch, and voted Blackhoof despite the half-reveal. With no one having brought this up it makes me wonder if her teammates are trying to shift focus off of her.

FOS Min

I also agree with Alanna and Csarmi about Red and Charis possibly being on the same scum team. In the last game I played as Mafia me and my teammate went back and forth for most of the game, so ruling out that they couldn't possibly be on a team is a mistake IMO.

killuliu · June 22, 2011

I think that Red is not mafia, but that's just impression from his posts, even though they have been kind of.. hmm.. lacking.

I agree with trench here, and to add some pressure:

vote Min

I'm sorry I've been kind of silent, but I didn't come back before the day ended and I try to avoid speaking during the night :)

Red2111 · June 22, 2011

*Red walks around in her heavy black armor, blocking the way of those who wish to cross the river*

i also agree with Alanna, just becuase two people are goign back & forth on the game thread doesn't mean it's not a gambit; so even though you guys are right in this case and Charis & i aren't on a team, that wont be the case in every game.

i'm good with a lynch on either Min or Moon.

Min when have i backtracked in this game? please post atleast some proff with your accusations; you have yet to do so in anything you've thrown at me btw and obviously it's not doing you any good

Kill - i'm a she, not a he :laugh: though i'm very tom-boyish in nature :tongue: