Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

Tarmon Gaidon [Advanced Mafia] Game Over


BFG

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

My concern here is that tho Shad does read me very well as Town!Shad he will still have some posts the he wavers a bit on.  And he posts them so you can see him working through the read.  Even after hes stated hes very sure on me.  And a Town read D1 is common place from Shad on me, it still takes a little bit for it to come.

 

Look at Overwatch for an example.

 

Here he's just like he's Town and thats it.

It varies a lot from game to game.

 

Your push on Wifi at the beginning of Overwatch was super wolfy and it took me catching up to get over that. Wolf!Cory kept trying to shake my trust in my read of you and it made me reconsider a lot but I never had you out of my top 3 villagers after like page 30.

 

In Julius Caesar when you soft claimed I had you as obvious town even faster than I did in this game, and I never wavered from that once.

 

Lost I called you a villager pretty much straight out the gate and never backed off of that. Within a day of you resubbing into a wolf slot I was screaming for your head.

 

Dragon Reborn I wavered a bit.

 

It varies but this is hardly the first time I had you as solid villager early and stuck to it all game.

 

Bruh, this is exactly what I was talking about when I said the meta game was mad here and you guys play vs each other so much. 

  • Replies 3.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Posted

 

 

Anyone yet find a reason Hellian is a villager?

 

Anyone have a better suggestion?

It's not that I have a better suggestion it's that I have a problem with approaching trying to solve a game from the perspective of " how do we not lose". Bad reason to push a lynch. I'd prefer dice tbh

Thats not the perspective Im approaching it from.

 

Hellians done nothing,

 

Fails at voting me out of the gate cause i was top poster

 

Has like focused on NOTHING AND NO ONE ELSE.

 

Has misreped and threw shade at me all game

 

Avoids answering questions addressed to him.

 

Prolly a villager?

Idk I havent noticed, but its easier to see that sorta thing when youre the person getting targeted

Posted

 

 

...Snow didn't really post much of anything.

 

What is your read on John?

 

He's played enough games of Mafia in this more intensive era to know that chatting about people's potential roles for a while and then dropping three town reads and two wolf reads without explanation is a one way ticket to the dead thread.

 

Villagers will vote that.  Wolves will vote that if you're a villager.  Wolves will vote that if you're a wolf and they have no faith in your ability to step it up.

 

Does it make him a wolf?  I have no idea.  I don't know if he'd dig in more as scum or go out in a puff of smoke.  I know that I'm not going to resolve his alignment without a flip or a peek at this rate.

 

 

Well when you put it like that....

Posted

 

I totally suck at reading Hallia.  Keeping this foremost in mind regarding her.

 

First, did Ironeyes say that myself and John could be on a team?  Literally makes no sense.

 

I'm out for tonight.  Will check back tomorrow. 

 

For now [v]vote Zaner[/v]

 

And yes that is pure OMGUS. 

OMGSUS is never pretty.

 

Now I seem to remember a game, one of my more recent ones too, where I said a vote was total OMGUS and everyone said that was the wolfiest thing I could have said.  Here Hellian does it and its taken in stride.  Yes Hallia says its never pretty, but she doesn't go out of her way to say it's wolfy either.  Where if I had posted that and said it was OMGUS she would have been all over me?  What's the difference?  unless Hallia and Hellian are teammates? Maybe? possibly?

 

Does it need to be said if I just said it wasn't pretty??? o.O  And why would I have been all over you- guilty conscience already?

 

 

@ Wifi, a policy lynch is basically saying "if a player does x I will lynch that player regardless of their alignment".

 

It's the most anti-town thing in the universe, but some villagers love to do it.

 

Funny thing about Nolder's policy lynch self-voters stance is Nolder has a habit of self-voting.  :rolleyes:

 

Did you catch that in my initial response to Nolder.  Ive since followed up on that during my catch-up.

 

I pretty much just policy lynch AJ if he's in the game.. it doesn't matter what he does... >.> 

 

 

I kid I kid... kinda. Though I've joked about policy lynching him in almost every game since the one that we wolfed together in.. and every game I didn't.. and every game he was scum lololololol

 

 

Ok so as far as reads. I'm not gonna quote the whole list, so if I leave someone off they're Null, cause I"m lazy and busy. 

 

 

Zass (Zander/Cass) - It's hard for me to imagine Zander as anything but town from his play so far. Of course that could just be because I wanna sheep him *shrugs* 

 

Hallia - I want to see more from. She does seem towny from what she's posted, but I know from experience she's good at appearing towny d1 as scum. So Town lean but that's about it. 

 

WIfi - seems her usual self. This is reassuring after the last game she came in and at first didn't know how to act, which for me was a bigger give away than most took it as. Most likely she's town here. Though the last game could have just taught her how to fake it better lol 

 

And it goes downhill from here lol. 

 

Darthe I'm just not sure about. I always have a hard time reading him though, mostly I think because he's slightly..... abrasive? That word will work.. *shrugs* 

 

Shad - Seems slightly defensive, but I've seen him do that as town so idk. It'd be an easy thing to do as scum to though so he's mostly null. 

 

Nolder - meh. He came in seemed to pick a bit of a fight and then said he was gonna put someone on ignore and I haven't seen a lot more out of him. Maybe he accidentally put the whole thread on ignore?? lol idk. 

 

Marsh - I don't think i'll ever be able to read him on D1. Or maybe ever... Both games I've played with him he's looked fairly similar and seemed scum, but last game I know he was town so maybe i'm just reading him wrong. 

 

Hellian - I don't know. He's new so I don't know how to take him yet. I'm currently reserving judgement because I think some of his stuff that "seems" scummy could just be from him being new and not knowing people and not knowing how to take different people, but could come from scum. 

 

 

 

Who else is in this game? I just went totally blank. 

 

 

And I missed like 4 people so I pulled the list after all cause some of these people I just didn't remember was even here... Like Pral or John Snow. 

 

1. Tiinker -  He played a mean mafia game so I'm kinda hesitant to give him any kind of town lean until I feel much mo betta about him. I should have remembered he was in the game though... I blame just eating lunch and only getting about 3 hours of sleep lol

2. Nolder

3. Kat - lock town

4. Dice - seems very diceish. I'd say probably town lean. 

5. WiFi

6. Hallia

7. John Snow - I had forgotten he was here. 

8. Darthe

9. Zander/Cass

10. Pral - I can't even remember when he posted... and I don't care enough to go back and find it. 

11. Hellian

12. Believer - Don't really know how to take him. He was very..... carefree last game but I don't think that's his normal game. I think he had a IDC attitude because he could be mod cleared at any time. He has been very absent from thread, but he did explain and I"m willing to give more time. 

13. Ironeyes

14. Shad

 

Everyone else I think I covered in the other one. 

 

Kat can be a D1 villager.

 

 

I missed these reads.  Yeah I'm ok with the super trifecta once more.

 

Really want to see more Hallia too!!!

Who doesn't?

 

:wub:

 

I'd consider going off of Snow onto Hellian - Would prefer Snow still, though.

Posted

Ive never ONCE this game mistook you for Hallia.

 

The shade and misrepping sound be pretty apparent to everybody atp.

 

Can we just lunch Hellian now????

The whole thing confused the hell out of me at a glance but I'd figured you two would sort out whatever you were talking about.

 

Looked at a little more closely. Here's the trainwreck of a post:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I might just give up. This village is pretty hopeless.

 

[v]Shad[/v]

 

I will not address any further idiotic suspicion on my slot. I"m going to state my reads and you can all piss off.

[v] unvote [/v]

 

[v] Hellian [/v]

 

I'll admit to reading backwards, but I see no case here. If this is supposed to be an OMGUS, then you didn't read that I did not think my vote on you had counted because I hadn't followed protocol.

 

Its 100% not OMGUS

 

I know you mentioned your vote. Im the one who told you how to properly do it and that your vote likely didnt count.

 

Well, when you lay out your case so clearly like that, how could I possibly defend myself?

 

You could I dunno I suppose read the thread and address questions and concern addressed to you?

 

I could if you didn't spam up the thread. Again, something that pings my scumdar about you, but I chalk it up to too much time on your hands. TBH, much of the past 20 pages has been LOLing at eachother and talking about past games. If there was a question in there I more than likely missed it. So I'll be online for about 10 more minutes. Ask, and I will answer.

 

This sounds like a you problem.

 

 

I'm out for tonight. Will check back tomorrow.

 

For now [v]vote Zaner[/v]

 

And yes that is pure OMGUS.

lololololol

 

 

First, did Ironeyes say that myself and John could be on a team? Literally makes no sense.

 

 

wrong

 

i voted you for that then ive been catching up and evaluating while putting these posts up

 

im not moving my vbote simply cause you went all fake ate. You wanna do that? you wanna vote ureself cause people are sus of you in a game where you have to be sus of pretty much everyone if ure town? then im more then happy to put you out of your misery and take you out of the game.

 

 

that ATE blast says NOTHING for your alignment. Its the easiest thing to do as scum. Thats why its styupid for Zander to instantly unvote for it.

 

 

so no im NOT tunnelling you for claiming mafia on page 2, tho i will say that, particualrly for you Mr Spreadsheet, that if ure stupid enuff to claim mafia in a game im in then you should be expecting me to go you for it, I am staying on you for that little blow up

I do NOT see that coming from scumDice

 

I'm out for tonight. Will check back tomorrow.

 

For now [v]vote Zaner[/v]

 

And yes that is pure OMGUS.

OMGSUS is never pretty.

 

Can you elaborate please on the bold??

 

 

 

 

Char claiming this early is disgusting.

my first thought on seeing this was that snow was spewing halli pulled a strong character so thats gonna make her harder to mislynch

 

my second is thats hallia. Deal with it.

 

For me that claim almost locks her in blue will take something big for me to lynch there

Char claiming this early is disgusting.

 

I said it was disgusting. I think it's antitown. Claiming doc day 1 is always bad for town.

 

It's not scummy, just bad play.

 

-snip-

John Snow: Pops in, votes me for lame/unexplained reasons, disappears. Pingy for sure, and like I said before this reminds me of Scum!Clovdyx in the beginning of Demons Cove. He directed all of the attention toward me right from the start and not only gained towncred for it, but was able to keep the heat off of his lurky teammates. They won that game in part because of his calculated risk there.

 

A) I gave a reason.

 

B) I said I would be sparse for 12 hours (aka until about now)

 

C) I'm not Clov

 

Also, Zass is 26 posts from cap lmao. It's been barely 24 hours.

 

You keep talking about the cap and not much else.

 

FYI- (therers no real cap)

 

You cant hide from me.

 

The bold you keep referring to is a post from Hallia. Are you deliberately trying to confuse us?

 

 

 

You post a multiquote that comments on Hellian twice, then asks Hallia a question, then comments on Snow.

 

Hellian takes you to be directing the Hallia question at her.

 

Hellian Hallia 328954892 multiquotes my head hurts.

 

Looks like the confusion is on her end though.

Posted

 

Well when you put it like that....

wut I do?  :unsure:

 

We could lynch him. Even if he turns out to be town (which I don't think he will) all we lose is an apparently uninvested player. 

Posted

In Zander's defence I actually thought Hellian was a hydra of Hallia plus other but since I'm not a hyperactive hamster I went and double checked what I was reading.

Posted

On closer analysis these questions are easier to answer than I thought. I snipped the ones I already talked about, which leaves Zander/Cass, Nolder, and Believer. The latter two were just gut reads at the time, although since then Believer solidified my read on him with his vote-flip-flopping after I challenged him for leaving his first vote where it was. Nolder hasn't changed much. And Zander is the main reason I'm reading their Hydra as town. He seems normal and doesn't feel like he has any ulterior motives.

If I'm ever a wolf against you I'm going to get you mislynched.  :hopper:

 

My head initially thought "wow that's a weak justification for saying you didn't need to explain yourself before", but the fact of the matter is he was thread consensus villager by then so in terms of your reads mattering you really didn't need to explain it.  Wolf might be a little more self-conscious to justify themselves initially anyway.

Posted

D1 Votecount

 

 

 

Shad (2): Dice, Nolder

 

Ironeyes (1): Snow

 

Snow (4): Ironeyes, Hallia, Believer, Tiinker

 

Hellian (1): Zass

 

Zass (1): Hellian

 

Not Voting (5): Darthe, Katiora, Pralaya, Shad_, Wildfire Sedai

 

 

cya_1474581600.png

 

You have just over 24 hours to choose between the stedding and Tel'Aran'Rhiod

Posted

In Zander's defence I actually thought Hellian was a hydra of Hallia plus other but since I'm not a hyperactive hamster I went and double checked what I was reading.

 

I guess I should have been more explicit in saying: it looks like Zander was just commenting on a bunch of separate things in a single post to avoid post-cap, but Hellian took the Hellian--Hellian--Hallia sequence to mean the whole thing was addressed to her.  But it clearly wasn't because the last comment is @ Snow.

Posted

 

 

 

 

I feel I've stuck up for Shad a decent amount this game and I don't like it. But he's been one of the main contributors to the game and it seems like a lot of nitpicking. I really hope I'm not wrong.

If this is a fake wolf post its a good one, should be regarded as objectively townie

 

 

Another couple of posts that I am going to keep in mind!

 

 

Why? What are you thinking? 

 

I think I like WiFi. I can't understand where she's going with things, but nearly everything she's said I can see where she's coming from. She basically feels agendaless and that feels good here. Am I being naive? 

 

 

 

I feel I've stuck up for Shad a decent amount this game and I don't like it. But he's been one of the main contributors to the game and it seems like a lot of nitpicking. I really hope I'm not wrong.
 
So you want to get into the mind of Wifi, what are you: CRAZY!  :laugh: 
 
So here goes:
Tiink's post seems pretty straightforward at first just like you read it.  However if you as he puts it, nitpick:
 
stuck up for shad but didn't like it, so why stick up for him? especially a decent amount of time? Well he does give us an answer: Shad's been one of the main contributors of the game and it seems like a lot of nitpicking.  Now we have to wonder: what seems like a lot of nitpicking? then we figure it must be what tiink is defending shad from. pretty obvious, right. or is it?  no it is.  :smile: I can't remember what I was thinking when I wrote that so I am trying to jog my memory by going through it word by word.  not really helping but I think I am on the right track.  :dry: I really hope I'm not wrong.  Here is the kicker.  Now he could have just said: I hope I'm not wrong and left it at that...but he said REALLY...adding an adverb that packs a lot of punch.  Yes, I am doing semantics.  :tongue: you wonder if he could be stretching it a little to make it seem like he actually cares but in reality doesn't.
 
 OR this whole paragraph could be a waste of time and its said from the heart straight and true.  However, we have yet to deal with the second quote....
 
If this is a fake wolf post its a good one, should be regarded as objectively townie
 
So now we have the second post, which is why I did the first paragraph....I am going to split this one in two.  First: If this is a fake wolf post its a good one, 
here we have darthe questioning tiink's post.  Now, yes it is the beginning of the post and there is a second half to it but I am going to ignore that second half for now :smile:  Darthe is saying that tiink's post can be a fake wolf post.  With that in mind, is the reason I did the paragraph above. [i forgot to copy both quotes together and color code them separately.  I forgot they played a role in interpreting each other :angry: ] I just knew that I had to pick apart the first one but not WHY.  :dry:  so that being said:  
 
Darthe and Tiink could easily be wolves together.  I know cause I was just wolves with Darthe.  This is totally something that he would do, and I know tiink is a very good wolf as well.   
 
Posted

 

On closer analysis these questions are easier to answer than I thought. I snipped the ones I already talked about, which leaves Zander/Cass, Nolder, and Believer. The latter two were just gut reads at the time, although since then Believer solidified my read on him with his vote-flip-flopping after I challenged him for leaving his first vote where it was. Nolder hasn't changed much. And Zander is the main reason I'm reading their Hydra as town. He seems normal and doesn't feel like he has any ulterior motives.

If I'm ever a wolf against you I'm going to get you mislynched.  :hopper:

 

My head initially thought "wow that's a weak justification for saying you didn't need to explain yourself before", but the fact of the matter is he was thread consensus villager by then so in terms of your reads mattering you really didn't need to explain it.  Wolf might be a little more self-conscious to justify themselves initially anyway.

I'd better pray you're never a wolf against me then! TBH I do in fact feel self conscious about explaining my gut reads, because since they're gut reads, I can't properly explain them. But since I play this game "in the moment," I can't always point to specific reasons why I feel one way or another about a player. 

Posted

I want to see more from Hellian. I understand his rationale against Zander early game and don't mind it, but sticking to the narrow focus and only pushing that or defending himself isn't a good look.

 

AFAICT his game related posts have been:

 

- FoS Zander for high content

- Caveat/talk about watching player interactions (Ok, but no follow up besides questionning me for pressing Shad)

- Misc stuff about D1 being random and differences between sites and catching up etc

- Would look for wolves in high post/low cotent or low posters (Ok but generic)

- Non-current game talk about policy lynches/play as SK with Nolder

- Sees no case for Zander's vote of him

- Responds with reasonable comment/attitude to Dice's push of him

- Agrees with Nol's push at Shad for self vote

- Puts Shad Town - more content in his high post count (fair assessment), reading him as a hyperactive townie

- FoS at Zander for spamming up the thread, but chalks it up to too much time on Z's hands

- Votes Zander, for 'OMGUS'.

- Asks doesn't Shad find Zander wierd

- Questions me, suggests Shad's behaviour would be to OTT for Wolf

- Is sensitive/?shading that Zander may be mistaking him for Hallia

 

The bold's the posts that stick out to me. Overall it's very narrow/ignorant of the rest of the thread and based heavily on generic tells, which I find scummy and out of context with the way he started out ITT.

 

Specifically there's a decent amount of early fluff which I took for being eager to be involved but then it kind of peters down to only pushing Zander. He could just be a player that works through one slot that pings him at a time. He does differentiate between Zander and Shad for content in their high volume which could be Towny consideration but it's pretty thin when the post immediately before he agrees with Nol against Shad.

 

Happy with him in the WTL for now.

Posted

THIS IS THE POST HELLIANS REFERRING TO:

 

ITS A MULTIQUOTE AND I POST QUESTIONS?RESPONSES TO NOT ONLY HELLIAN AND HALLIA BUT JOHN SNOW TO.

See this guy knows what's up.

Posted

I randed town, feels reinvigorating after being dark for a bit.

 

Im still not feeling this post like at all.

 

 

 

 

Anyone yet find a reason Hellian is a villager?

 

Anyone have a better suggestion?

It's not that I have a better suggestion it's that I have a problem with approaching trying to solve a game from the perspective of " how do we not lose". Bad reason to push a lynch. I'd prefer dice tbh

Thats not the perspective Im approaching it from.

 

Hellians done nothing,

 

Fails at voting me out of the gate cause i was top poster

 

Has like focused on NOTHING AND NO ONE ELSE.

 

Has misreped and threw shade at me all game

 

Avoids answering questions addressed to him.

 

Prolly a villager?

Idk I havent noticed, but its easier to see that sorta thing when youre the person getting targeted

 

 

True.

 

You could iso him and see yourself.  Its not gonna take you long.

 

 

 

 

...Snow didn't really post much of anything.

 

What is your read on John?

 

He's played enough games of Mafia in this more intensive era to know that chatting about people's potential roles for a while and then dropping three town reads and two wolf reads without explanation is a one way ticket to the dead thread.

 

Villagers will vote that.  Wolves will vote that if you're a villager.  Wolves will vote that if you're a wolf and they have no faith in your ability to step it up.

 

Does it make him a wolf?  I have no idea.  I don't know if he'd dig in more as scum or go out in a puff of smoke.  I know that I'm not going to resolve his alignment without a flip or a peek at this rate.

 

 

Well when you put it like that....

 

 

So still got nothing to say?

 

I mean this is a pretty recent post so you are following along...

 

 

 

I totally suck at reading Hallia.  Keeping this foremost in mind regarding her.

 

First, did Ironeyes say that myself and John could be on a team?  Literally makes no sense.

 

I'm out for tonight.  Will check back tomorrow. 

 

For now [v]vote Zaner[/v]

 

And yes that is pure OMGUS. 

OMGSUS is never pretty.

 

Now I seem to remember a game, one of my more recent ones too, where I said a vote was total OMGUS and everyone said that was the wolfiest thing I could have said.  Here Hellian does it and its taken in stride.  Yes Hallia says its never pretty, but she doesn't go out of her way to say it's wolfy either.  Where if I had posted that and said it was OMGUS she would have been all over me?  What's the difference?  unless Hallia and Hellian are teammates? Maybe? possibly?

 

Does it need to be said if I just said it wasn't pretty??? o.O  And why would I have been all over you- guilty conscience already?

 

 

@ Wifi, a policy lynch is basically saying "if a player does x I will lynch that player regardless of their alignment".

 

It's the most anti-town thing in the universe, but some villagers love to do it.

 

Funny thing about Nolder's policy lynch self-voters stance is Nolder has a habit of self-voting.  :rolleyes:

 

Did you catch that in my initial response to Nolder.  Ive since followed up on that during my catch-up.

 

I pretty much just policy lynch AJ if he's in the game.. it doesn't matter what he does... >.> 

 

 

I kid I kid... kinda. Though I've joked about policy lynching him in almost every game since the one that we wolfed together in.. and every game I didn't.. and every game he was scum lololololol

 

 

Ok so as far as reads. I'm not gonna quote the whole list, so if I leave someone off they're Null, cause I"m lazy and busy. 

 

 

Zass (Zander/Cass) - It's hard for me to imagine Zander as anything but town from his play so far. Of course that could just be because I wanna sheep him *shrugs* 

 

Hallia - I want to see more from. She does seem towny from what she's posted, but I know from experience she's good at appearing towny d1 as scum. So Town lean but that's about it. 

 

WIfi - seems her usual self. This is reassuring after the last game she came in and at first didn't know how to act, which for me was a bigger give away than most took it as. Most likely she's town here. Though the last game could have just taught her how to fake it better lol 

 

And it goes downhill from here lol. 

 

Darthe I'm just not sure about. I always have a hard time reading him though, mostly I think because he's slightly..... abrasive? That word will work.. *shrugs* 

 

Shad - Seems slightly defensive, but I've seen him do that as town so idk. It'd be an easy thing to do as scum to though so he's mostly null. 

 

Nolder - meh. He came in seemed to pick a bit of a fight and then said he was gonna put someone on ignore and I haven't seen a lot more out of him. Maybe he accidentally put the whole thread on ignore?? lol idk. 

 

Marsh - I don't think i'll ever be able to read him on D1. Or maybe ever... Both games I've played with him he's looked fairly similar and seemed scum, but last game I know he was town so maybe i'm just reading him wrong. 

 

Hellian - I don't know. He's new so I don't know how to take him yet. I'm currently reserving judgement because I think some of his stuff that "seems" scummy could just be from him being new and not knowing people and not knowing how to take different people, but could come from scum. 

 

 

 

Who else is in this game? I just went totally blank. 

 

 

And I missed like 4 people so I pulled the list after all cause some of these people I just didn't remember was even here... Like Pral or John Snow. 

 

1. Tiinker -  He played a mean mafia game so I'm kinda hesitant to give him any kind of town lean until I feel much mo betta about him. I should have remembered he was in the game though... I blame just eating lunch and only getting about 3 hours of sleep lol

2. Nolder

3. Kat - lock town

4. Dice - seems very diceish. I'd say probably town lean. 

5. WiFi

6. Hallia

7. John Snow - I had forgotten he was here. 

8. Darthe

9. Zander/Cass

10. Pral - I can't even remember when he posted... and I don't care enough to go back and find it. 

11. Hellian

12. Believer - Don't really know how to take him. He was very..... carefree last game but I don't think that's his normal game. I think he had a IDC attitude because he could be mod cleared at any time. He has been very absent from thread, but he did explain and I"m willing to give more time. 

13. Ironeyes

14. Shad

 

Everyone else I think I covered in the other one. 

 

Kat can be a D1 villager.

 

 

I missed these reads.  Yeah I'm ok with the super trifecta once more.

 

Really want to see more Hallia too!!!

Who doesn't?

 

:wub:

 

I'd consider going off of Snow onto Hellian - Would prefer Snow still, though.

 

 

Im not feeling the appropriate amount of WIM Hallia.

 

You claim to have randed Nyn, have me as Town and now Kat....THE TRIFECTA!!!!!

 

This is very worrying to me.

 

sadface.gif

Posted

-snip-

 

-snip-

So still got nothing to say?

 

I mean this is a pretty recent post so you are following along...

-snip-

 

Just got off work when I posted that. Doing a full reads list and ISOs. I've got 7 done so far, calm your tits. 

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...