November 7th, 1606: Day 4 (CONCLUDED)

[lolguy26]

 

 

this whole page has been spam, and spam that i dont even understand.......

 

You don't understand....

 

FREEEEEEEEEEEEEDOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOM! ?

 

 

I cried a little during that scene. 

 

 

despo, dude, all the threads you've been starting and now this

 

 

is it that time of the month again .......

[Niniel]

Men are allowed to cry too. Cried a lot at that scene. 

[The Crusher]

 

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

This. Call Salami out on doing it, yet Des gets a pass?

 

You're all idiots.

 

 

 

Easy there macho man.  I'm still catching up.  Salami never had a chance.  Still think scum sits in the meat of the Slalami train.

[_CLOUD]

Ok I have caught up in this thread again.

 

 

 

Vote Yates
 
For self voting. Ugh.

  

Vote Csarmi
 
Let's just run him up and see what comes out of it.

Vote Csarmi
 
He must be scum in at least one of them or he wouldn't use the same strategy three times, heh.

Leelou I was wrong
This is where cloud is mafia. Csarmi and cloud are both mafia in this thread IMO
Bag 'em and tag 'em

(For kinda evidence. Look at the clod votes. This is the only thread he attempts to vote elsewhere and he is trying to be as nonchalant as possible in this thread)

vote salami

Also isnt it amazing that cloud went from thread to thread at the same time, making sure to read them all equally rather than concentrating on a specific thread at a time. Trying to have a nice even meta
Wait...
Didnt he accuse Csarmi of that and dub him mafia over it? I think he did lol

 

 

Check the time tags on the posts you just quoted. My first vote on Csarmi (11:02) had nothing to do with him trying to cover his meta, I only thought about that stuff later on post 11:06 and then I voted for him in all three threads. My vote on Yates in this game wasn't that serious, but I still disliked how he self voted and that's why I placed another vote on him. You are right though that I was reading all three threads at the same time and commented on all three of them, I think that analyzing people's meta and comparing them from all three games is a good way to play this game. It's true that I might have gotten a little carried away for pushing Csarmi's lynch on all three threads, but I was still trying my best to see them as three different games.

 

 

 

 

This is game 2 right?
Cloud has been pretty scummy in this thread. He is one of my top pics

I even quoted him and explaind in my first post. How do you not see clouds scummy?

 

A couple of things wrong with your statements here.  First...All those quotes I made came long before your first post in this thread.

 

Second...If Leelou is distancing from Cloud that makes him scum right?

 

 

He was coming off scummy in this thread, he deserved a vote. I think he's the best bet for scum in this thread. 

 

 

From what I have read the only reason you think I'm scummy is because of my early vote on Yates.

 

 

So what do you guys think about calling people like Nolder#1, Nolder#2 and such?

 

I like this idea from Csarmi because it would prevent a lot of confusion.

 

 

Sigh. Thought I would end up quoting less from this one since I caught up in the other one first, and I ended up quoting more. Will have to trim some of the fat... anyways yeah I'll once again try to keep responses to each concise:
 
 
 

Vote Yates
 
For self voting. Ugh.

 
Man... pinging in this thread too Cloud. Are you implying that a self-vote is a scumtell?
 
It was a blatant bandwagon vote man. No need to overjustify it.
 
You later bandwagon to Csarlami as well. 

 

 

 

 

Yes I'm implying that self-voting is a scumtell. It's an easy way to be seen as pro-town because why would a scum vote for himself? I'm not saying that I think Yates is scum, but I certainly didn't like his early self-vote and that's why I also voted for him.

 

I wasn't bandwagoning on Csarmi at all. At the start of the game I was one of the first to notice him trying to cover his meta between the three threads and I was quite vocal in pushing for his lynch and also gave my reasonings why I thought he was scum in one of the threads (it had to do with him changing his story).

[_CLOUD]

Ok and now I have to go read the other threads.

[Pralaya]

My vote on Yates in this game wasn't that serious, but I still disliked how he self voted and that's why I placed another vote on him. Y

 

 

From what I have read the only reason you think I'm scummy is because of my early vote on Yates.

 

 

I think dap and Leelou have a valid point. Even a newbie like me can see that Yates self-vote was a joke and was just the first day fun. Converting that to a serious post and voting based on it does look scummy to me.

[Nolder]

I own a copy of Catcher in the Rye.

 

 

Just because I am paranoid doesn't mean they aren't after me.

No no no you have it backwards. If they are actually after you then you aren't paranoid!

[michellem]

So now self-votes are a scumtell eh Cloud? I seem to remember a game not long ago where I self-voted and you argued quite loudly that wasn't reason enough to lynch me. Then again, I seem to remember you being scum then and probably wanted to buddy up to me so I didn't notice you; since it wasn't me this game that didn't matter as much?

[Yates]

So now self-votes are a scumtell eh Cloud? I seem to remember a game not long ago where I self-voted and you argued quite loudly that wasn't reason enough to lynch me. Then again, I seem to remember you being scum then and probably wanted to buddy up to me so I didn't notice you; since it wasn't me this game that didn't matter as much?

OOHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!

[michellem]

I use this one, it's pretty darn good

 

[_CLOUD]

So now self-votes are a scumtell eh Cloud? I seem to remember a game not long ago where I self-voted and you argued quite loudly that wasn't reason enough to lynch me. Then again, I seem to remember you being scum then and probably wanted to buddy up to me so I didn't notice you; since it wasn't me this game that didn't matter as much?

 

Yeah I think that self-votes are a scumtell. Not a strong one mind you, but reason enough to place an early vote on someone and see how they react. I remember that game well and I was indeed scum in that one. Once I started defending you from Ithi and things started escalating there was no going back for me so I kept defending you even more to try and gain as much town cred as possible. Your logic doesn't make much sense right now though. You accuse me of thinking that self-votes are scummy, while I said otherwise in a previous game where I was scum and was buddying up to you. Which do you think is more probable?

[serra]

RVS self votes are not a scum tell. Particularly not from Yates.

 

Why start catching up in this one, cloud, when the other two were still in day-phase?

[_CLOUD]

RVS self votes are not a scum tell. Particularly not from Yates.

 

Why start catching up in this one, cloud, when the other two were still in day-phase?

 

It's because this one is in the Night fase. I wanted to see what happened so I started catching up to this one first.

[_CLOUD]

I also started reading the other two but I'm having major troubles with this three thread system because I can't differtiate between the differen't plays of the same people. I only have global reads. I fear I have to start keeping notes with this game and I'm hopeless with those

[Nolder]

I generally prefer to policy lynch self voters. It is never a pro town move as it is usually an appeal to emotion.

[Verbal32]

I generally prefer to policy lynch self voters. It is never a pro town move as it is usually an appeal to emotion.

 

Even D1 silly ones?  You'd have to lynch Hess and 80 and awful lot in that case......

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

This. Call Salami out on doing it, yet Des gets a pass?

 

You're all idiots.

 

 

 

Easy there macho man.  I'm still catching up.  Salami never had a chance.  Still think scum sits in the meat of the Slalami train.

 

 

Dammit now I really want a sub.

[Tiinker]

6inch Big Beef Melt + 6inch Meatball Sub = footlong orgasmic sandwich.

[Darthe]

I use this one, it's pretty darn good

 

If you know what I mean

[bgrishinko]

In completely unrelated news, it is my duty to do the following....

 

EARTHBOUND RELEASED TODAY ON WII U VIRTUAL CONSOLE!!!! WOOOOO! Go play it now if you can.
 
[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=am8VkDjNN08[/media]

[Nolder]

 

I generally prefer to policy lynch self voters. It is never a pro town move as it is usually an appeal to emotion.

 

Even D1 silly ones?  You'd have to lynch Hess and 80 and awful lot in that case......

 

Sometimes. It depends just how silly. I have voted 80 more than once for self voting knowing full well he was more than likely town.

 

If you've seen my past arguments for this policy lynch you'd know that it's a case of, well if that person is going to be so stupid as to be a detriment and distraction I would rather just get rid of them on the offchance they are mafia than leave them alive to screw up endgame for the rest of us.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

I generally prefer to policy lynch self voters. It is never a pro town move as it is usually an appeal to emotion.

 

Even D1 silly ones?  You'd have to lynch Hess and 80 and awful lot in that case......

 

Sometimes. It depends just how silly. I have voted 80 more than once for self voting knowing full well he was more than likely town.

 

If you've seen my past arguments for this policy lynch you'd know that it's a case of, well if that person is going to be so stupid as to be a detriment and distraction I would rather just get rid of them on the offchance they are mafia than leave them alive to screw up endgame for the rest of us.

 

 

 

I'm not sure how you can get detriment and distraction from a day one vote.  Maybe if they self-vote 15+ pages into Day 1 and don't give a reason.

[Yates]

Sometimes. It depends just how silly. I have voted 80 more than once for self voting knowing full well he was more than likely town.

 

If you've seen my past arguments for this policy lynch you'd know that it's a case of, well if that person is going to be so stupid as to be a detriment and distraction I would rather just get rid of them on the offchance they are mafia than leave them alive to screw up endgame for the rest of us.

As the moderator of the game that precipitated my self vote, do you think I did it to be a detriment to the Town/distraction *OR* for the lulz?  For those of you not familiar with the game in question; I promised to self-vote if Des flipped Town.  Of course, I was scum in that game and it was a gambit that helped us to win the game.  I'm pretty sure this post made it apparent that my self vote was a meta lulz post:

 

Who am I to disagree with a wagon of such magnitude?

 

Vote: Yates

 

At least you've done the self-vote you promised, hehe.

 

Context is everything, Nolder.  You know this.  So I'm not buying your argument in post 321.  Why did you make an abstract argument about a specific example in the game?  Looks weird, bro.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Sometimes. It depends just how silly. I have voted 80 more than once for self voting knowing full well he was more than likely town.

 

If you've seen my past arguments for this policy lynch you'd know that it's a case of, well if that person is going to be so stupid as to be a detriment and distraction I would rather just get rid of them on the offchance they are mafia than leave them alive to screw up endgame for the rest of us.

As the moderator of the game that precipitated my self vote, do you think I did it to be a detriment to the Town/distraction *OR* for the lulz?  For those of you not familiar with the game in question; I promised to self-vote if Des flipped Town.  Of course, I was scum in that game and it was a gambit that helped us to win the game.  I'm pretty sure this post made it apparent that my self vote was a meta lulz post:

 

 

 

I still cannot believe that it wasn't incredibly obvious when Verbal claimed I was scum.  THE NIGHT AFTER YOU PROMISED A SELF-VOTE!  

 

Hiding in plain sight I guess.

[Yates]

I still cannot believe that it wasn't incredibly obvious when Verbal claimed I was scum.  THE NIGHT AFTER YOU PROMISED A SELF-VOTE!  

 

Hiding in plain sight I guess.

Like a ninja...