The Ultimate Mafia Showdown - Town Wins

[Leyrann]

Why would it be interesting?

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Why wouldn't it be? Almost 100 pages in and we're a little lacking on solid leads at this point. Not ideal but says something about where this game is at.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I really didn't like that Maw - Ley exchange. Maw definitely came off the scummy end of that. Kind of posting thoughts as I go through. Maw do you have anything more to add this close to deadline other than "Ley is playing a clean game so my gut tells me that is suspicious"?

[ReleaseTheEvil]

So this is my understanding of where everyone sort of stands:

 

Maw - Going after Ley based on a gut feeling (weak)

 

WBK - Going after Hallia, feels strongly about it, cites her weak, fence sitting play and her interactions with Cyan. Has no one really barking up his tree or putting pressure on him except Hallia.

 

Kaylee - Was supposed to case everyone, has more or less stopped at me and Ley, placing FoS on us both. Not committing to anything yet.

 

Hallia - Very weak defense of herself, basically seems like she has nothing else to add. Has what I consider a OMGUS vote on WBK.

 

Song - Waiting on a re-read and case. Hard to read due to inactivity in the last little while. Want to see what she has to say.

 

Hallia is at L-1. Technically anyone can hammer her right now but no one will look very good doing it without a strong case. I want to see what Song has to offer.

 

Also, Hallia, you may want to try to save your skin. I've given hints at my role, and in a game where characters match alignment, I think it's in the best interest of your survival to help yourself here with giving us some info of some sort...

 

Am I asking you for a reveal? No. Do I think you should try to save your a$$? Yes.

[Leyrann]

RTE, I'd call Song confirmed town. She said she was the balefiring Vig.

[Darthe]

Official Vote Count:

 

WBK (1/3): Hally

 

Hally (2/3): Ley, WBK

 

Ley (1/3): Potato

 

Not Voting (3/7):

 

Kaylee, RTE, Song

 

About 4 hours til night.

[Leyrann]

Only 4 hours?

 

Wow... I thought we had more time.

[Darthe]

About 34 hours until Night.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

RTE, I'd call Song confirmed town. She said she was the balefiring Vig.

 

Ah right. All the more interested to see what she has to say then.

[Kaylee]

RTE: I stopped there because it was late for me. I didn't FOS anyone, just stated my thoughts.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Fair, but given the limited casing you were able to do it seemed so. Who are you suspicious of?

 

If my counting is right we have less than an hour...

[Kaylee]

Ley: you could have done it on thread to look town. (Not saying that's what you did). I have an it done.

[Kaylee]

Of the three with votes, Ley. However I don't want a random. Either.

[Kaylee]

RTE: who do you think is mafia? You are also not voting.

 

The rest of my casing/thoughts will have to come next day phase as it's too close to deadline. I believe Song to be town.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I haven't voted because of how precarious it is with only needing 3 to lynch.

 

Honestly Maw is coming off as most scummy to me based on his posting, and why he'd be posting that way is really intriguing me.

 

There is a fair chance that most of us here have roles. I'd like to get some incentive as to why to keep people around.

 

Right now my town read would be Ley and Song. Kaylee and Hallia can go either way, and WBK I'm just not sure. Not enough of a read really... This is such an important vote though....

[Kaylee]

I will be looking more at Maw and Kronos tomorrow.

 

I find it funny that I said I wasn't going to vote before hearing from people, esp since it only takes 3, yet you called me out for not voting. You just gave the same reason for not voting.

[Leyrann]

30 minutes until deadline.

 

Last vote count:

 

WBK (1/3): Hally

 

Hally (2/3): Ley, WBK

 

Ley (1/3): Potato

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I didn't call you out for not voting, I asked who were you suspicious of. It seems I'm alone in my scum read of Maw then, at least for today?

[Kaylee]

Well there's not a lot of time left. I'm not sure of Hally but I don't want a random either. Vote Hallia

[Leyrann]

I'm not sure about Maw, to be honest. He was going really hard at me with as only reason his gut, but he hasn't been particulary scummy either, imo.

[Leyrann]

Aaaand...

 

That was the hammer.

[Kaylee]

 

I didn't call you out for not voting, I asked who were you suspicious of. It seems I'm alone in my scum read of Maw then, at least for today?

I'll find the post where you mentioned me not voting. As for Maw: it's to close to deadline to start a new train when at the moment there was just us two posting.

[Kaylee]

Ley had posted while I was posting my vote. If I had known others were around I'd have been willing to talk it out first.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I said you weren't committing to anything in my summary of where people stood. I was hoping for more people to be around so we could have a lot more discussion, but oddly quiet around deadline. 

[Kaylee]

So this is my understanding of where everyone sort of stands:

 

Maw - Going after Ley based on a gut feeling (weak)

 

WBK - Going after Hallia, feels strongly about it, cites her weak, fence sitting play and her interactions with Cyan. Has no one really barking up his tree or putting pressure on him except Hallia.

 

Kaylee - Was supposed to case everyone, has more or less stopped at me and Ley, placing FoS on us both. Not committing to anything yet.

 

Hallia - Very weak defense of herself, basically seems like she has nothing else to add. Has what I consider a OMGUS vote on WBK.

 

Song - Waiting on a re-read and case. Hard to read due to inactivity in the last little while. Want to see what she has to say.

 

Hallia is at L-1. Technically anyone can hammer her right now but no one will look very good doing it without a strong case. I want to see what Song has to offer.

 

Also, Hallia, you may want to try to save your skin. I've given hints at my role, and in a game where characters match alignment, I think it's in the best interest of your survival to help yourself here with giving us some info of some sort...

 

Am I asking you for a reveal? No. Do I think you should try to save your a$$? Yes.

I bolded it for you. Saying I'm not committing is calling me out on not voting. If you meant something else I'd like to hear it please.