[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Sakaea]

1. Ishy, Tyrion, Motivator, Town, NK’d Night 6

2. Kaylee, Sansa, odd night doctor, town, Lynched Day 7

3. Songs, Commander Mormont, Cultmaster, Lynched Day 4

4. Razen, Jaime, roleblocker, Mafia, lynched Day 5

5. Peacesells, Daenerys, Lover Mason, town, NK’d Night 3

6. EP, Jon Snow, Jailer, town, NK’d Night 8

7. Red 2.0 (replaced Lenlo), Catelyn, even night doctor, town, NK’d Night 7

8. Darthe, Lord Petyr Baelish, two shot gladiator, mafia, Lynched Day 3

9. John Snow, Eddard, lie detector, town, NK’d Night 5

10. Basel, Jaquin H'Ghar, SK, one time BPV, Lynched Day 1

11. Verbal, Hodor, Guardian Angel

12. Dicetosser1 (replaced Lolguy), Shae, Framer, Mafia,

13. BG, Cersei, silvertongue, mafia turned Night’s Watch, Night 4

14. Rand, Syrio Forel, Jack of all Trades, town, Lynched Day 2

15. Nightstrike, Khal Drogo, Lover Mason, town, NK’ Night 3

16. Red, Brienne, role cop, town, NK’d Night 1

17. Misheru (replaced LZM), Joffrey, 2 shot janitor, mafia turned Night’s Watch, Night 3

18. JLM, Bronn, Survivor, one shot BPV, Lynched Day 6

19. Rand 2.0 (replaced WoT13, Night 2), Podrick, vanilla town, Lynched Day 8

20. Nightstrike 2.0 (replaced Cyan, Day 6), Pyat Pree, Nexus, mafia

21. Eds, Robb, cop, town turned Night’s Watch, Night 4

22. Basel 2.0 [replaced Leelou (replaced Lessa)], Jorah, roleblocker, town, Lynched Day 8

23. Despo, Bran, vanilla town turned Night’s Watch, Night 1

24. Nolder, Rickon, innocent child, town, modconfirmed as town Day 1, NK’d Night 2

[Sakaea]

Night 1:

Songs, N1, recruit Despo

Eds, View Despo

Red, role cop on EP

Kaylee: self protect

Basel 2.0 block Nightstrike

EP, Jail Verbal

Razen, block EP

Rand, doctors himself

John Snow, Despo statement, “Red is also scum this game.”

Misheru, Kill Red

Misheru, No Janitor

Dice, frame Nightstrike

Ishy, motivate EP

 

Night 2:

Eds: View Ishy

Red: protect peace

Basel: block Darthe

EP: Verb and Darthe

Razen: block John Snow

John Snow: LD, Darthe “BG is obv scum”

Misheru: Janitor peace

Dice: frame Despo

Ishy: motivate EP

Cyan: Kill Nolder, Kill peace

 

 

Night 3:

Eds, view Tress, anti-town

John Snow, true statement

Cyan Kill peace

Songs recruit Misheru

Kaylee protect Ishy

EP jail Verb and Despo

Basel block Ishy

Razen block peace

Dice frame Verbal

Ishy motivate EP

 

Night 4:

EP, Jail Kaylee

Eds, view EP

John Snow, EP statement “I never got any notice that I was in the Night's Watch this game”

Ishy, Motivate EP

Cyan: Kill JLM

Basel: block Razen

Despo, recruit Ed

Misheru, recruit BG

Red, protect Despo

Razen, didn’t get his action in

Dice, frame Verbal

 

Night 5:

EP: Jail Dice and Basel

Ishy, motivate Basel

Kaylee, protect Ishy

John Snow, LD, doesn’t matter

Dice, frame Red

Cyan, kill John Snow

Basel, RB Verbal

 

Night 6:

Red: protect Kaylee

Ishy: motivate Ed

Basel: RB Red and Ed

EP: Jail Basel

Dice: Frame Verbal

Nightstrike: Kill Ishy

 

Night 7:

NS: Kill Red

Dice: Frame Verbal

Basel: Block Ed

EP: Jail Basel

 

Night 8:

NS: Kill EP

Dice: Frame Verbal

EP: Jail Dice

[Sakaea]

Those of you with QT's, if you wish to post them you may do so.

 

Thanks Key-sis, for co-modding with me. Your scenes were awesome; we shall have to do this again

 

Thanks everyone for playing, feedback is most welcome!!!!!

[bgrishinko]

I was actually quite sad I was recruited. I kept playing to protect mafia and cult. In my opinion the extra 2 recruits after Tress died made cult overpowered in terms of balance.

 

Good game. Quite fun.

[Songstress]

 

GAME OVER!!!!!!!! THE NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

 

Verbal, Hodor, Guardian Angel, last surviving town member.

 

Dice, Shae, Framer, and Nightstrike, Pyat Pree, Nexus, last surviving mafia

 

And your winners are:

 

BG, Cersei, silvertongue, mafia turned Night’s Watch, Night 4

Misheru, Joffrey, 2 shot janitor, mafia turned Night’s Watch, Night 3

Eds, Robb, cop, town turned Night’s Watch, Night 4

Despo, Bran, vanilla town turned Night’s Watch, Night 1

 

 

Muahaha... Victory!!

[bgrishinko]

Good job staying alive Verb.

[bgrishinko]

Darthe deserves credit in this game for making me nigh unlynchable.

[RandA lThor]

Dang it, Ed really was Night Watch! Good game Night Watch!

[JenLenaMom]

Good game everyone.

[Kaylee]

Good game, it was fun!

[Darthe]

Meh. Good game.

[michellem]

Wohoo! We won!

 

Darthe, all cred to you man, you did your very best! He stayed in the QT trying to help us as well as he could, and if BG and me hadn't gotten converted, mafia probably would have won. So I dub Darthe honorary winner *nods*

 

 

And yay, this is the first game I've been where I've survived to the end!

[hazelkrs1]

Woot!

 

I don't think the two extra recruits were unfair. Tress could only recruit odd nights, and started out solo. Without the extra recruits Mish and I wouldn't have stood a chance

[michellem]

Mafia QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/fcq3R34wGDD6

 

Cult QT:

http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/xJNngX9Sf6K

[keyholder21]

Hope everyone had a good time :). I had a really fun time modding!

 

I didn't really see that it overpowered the cult - for the reasons Des already stated heh.

[John E. Kelley]

Good game my ladies.

 

*returns to Mafia retirement*

[Darthe]

Feedback: I think the game went well and was a bit heavy handed in the beginning with the town confirmations. I would have probably made mafia unrecruitable to fix this (if the cult tries to recruit one then they know a mafia member so it is self balancing) and beyond that I like your setup, though I am being difficult at the moment due to the effort I put in (read the QT if you don't understand). BG, you've played well.

[Darthe]

forgot to mention, the reason cult recruiting mafia is a broken mechanic is that it allows cult to influence the NK, thus deciding who is left in the game, and also since no mafia expects it to happen it allows cult to manipulate the mafias vote. IE: cult vs. mafia = doomed mafia 100% of the time. Even if the cult doesn't use its freaking obvious advantages there (cult is more hidden than mafia, is able to turn claims against people where mafia isn't etc) they still know who the entire mafia is the second they get a recruit on their side and can use that to gain infinite town credibility. /end

[Sakaea]

Next time I do a cult game I will definitely take that into consideration, Darthe, thank you

[hazelkrs1]

The mafia we recruited couldn't tell us who the other mafia were Darthe, which I think was def fair.

 

And if cult can't recruit someone, they can't automatically assume that that person is mafia since some mods make certain town roles unrecruitable. You're right in that recruiting mafia can lead to cult possibly controlling the NK, but that's just something you have be to be aware of if you're mafia and you find out cult is in the game.

 

Had we only recruited one mafia, you might have figured out something was up, we kinda just got lucky in recruiting two diff mafia

 

Also, you're right in that cult does have certain advantages over mafia in some situations, but conversely mafia has some advantages over cult as well. The fact is, once our recruiter was killed we were put at a big disadvantage, two extra recruits or not. We got lucky and made some good choices with our recruits overall tho, which is what made the difference I think

[Darthe]

I would disagree that cult has any disadvantage except that it can lose its night ability. It eliminates power roles, bypasses claims, upstarts mafias, and misleads games.

[Verbal32]

Were the 2 recruits baked into their roles, or added once Tress was dead early?

[Darthe]

Added.

[dicetosser1]

good game all

 

 

Darthe man "bows Thanks."

 

Im curious if ed viewed despo n1 hed have seen the recruiting why didnt he say something?

[Verbal32]

Added.

 

Then I'm removing myself from further discussion, as adding things to a game that has already been balanced as well as it could be is fundamentally flawed.

 

Good game, folks.