The Blue Ajah's Harry Potter Week: Mafia Game ON!

[ed2funy]

Unless the people Ed has named cannot confirm that they had items stolen from them? It's tough to ask them to name the items themselves and get a confirmation from Ed as that could be contrived. So, all 3 of the people that Ed stole from could have potentially Imperiused me if Ed got the item second-hand. In which case, one of them is probably scum trying to keep me from letting others know that I had the Stone taken from me. I'll wait for more before thinking of changing my vote, though. Someone this greedy to steal so many items cannot be good for the Town.

 

Since Red was Town, I'm assuming AJ stole from you. You should probably check your posts from Day 1 and see if Ithi posted after her.

 

 

 

Yea, I know Tina. I don't like that idea any more either. Was just a thought tho. >.<

[ed2funy]

TOWN:

1. Ed

16. Red

POSSIBLY TOWN:

 

POSSIBLY SCUM:

14. AJ

6. Tina

10. Tynaal

12. Key

SCUM:

 

UNKNOWN:

3. Lessa

4. Daruya

7. Lia Player

8. Zosime

13. Ithillian Charis

 

 

 

Updated thoughts at the moment. Will revise it after I read through my recap I am about to post.

 

 

[ed2funy]

Day 2 and Night 2.

 

Jack - Elder Wand stolen

Me - Very contrived statement. lawls

Jack - FOSs me.

Key - Suggests looking at Jack's post to see who stole it.

Key - Welcomes Player

Me - Asking Jack which part.

Jack - Bolds it. Says it's contrived.

Jack - Says he knows one player who didn't have an item. WOnders at setup.

Jack - Votes Key. Tells Big Three not to reveal. FOSs me and Key for lynch. Jack - Maybe Red.

Dar - Says she won't be here.

Me - Have fun Dar. Saw movie. Reply to Jack, trying to take heat off because I did have the items.

Key - No defense because Jack already knows who she is. Asks why her.

Tyn - Votes Key.

Sak - Bah post.

Bela - Deflects from Key, asking why her. That she is not 100% sure she is Hermione, but Jack and Tyn need reasons.

Tyn - Already built her case and Key countered but doesn't buy her reveal.

Tina - Will post her thoughts tomorrow.

Jack - Does his LD lie.

Jack - Key revealed too easily.

Key - Already discussed it. References her repsonse to Tynaal. "If I were mafia, why would I claim so soon?"

Charis - Post quoted. Doesn't seem like a post a mafia member would give to someone who is Imperioused.

Jack - Tells Key about her early reveal if she is scum. Tells me to write the LD statement.

Tina - Quotes Jack. Doesn't know where he changed his mind on Key. FOSs Key, Charis, and Lessa. Will be on mini LOA.

Me - Reply to Key's question. Say Charis' post in contrived to give Jack something to lay off of me. Give "I am Town" statements.

Jack - Admits no LD action.

Lessa - posts dead pun and says she'll reread.

Me - Snort at Jack and FOS myself. o_O I have a habit of doing that.

Jack - Figures I would have put up a kick, but likes me for a lynch.

Key - Flatters Jack. Uses her "role" to try and push votes off her: "Other than why go after a(n alleged) townie than an unknown?"

Jack - Explains why.WIFOM in game. Willing to let her slide another day. Mafia might take out Ron or Harry and give her more credence. Likes me for lynch.

Dapiano - Game hasn't been updating in comments. Will catch up now.

Lessa - Saw movie. Cried. Going to bed and will read up later. What happened to that reread?

Me - More of a spammy post to Lessa as well as snort at Jack.

Dapiano - Thread still not updating.

Tynaal - Questions where everyone is. Asks Jack why I'm sus.

Me - Spammy pic response.

Jack - "I just do tbh." Votes me.

Tina - Posting from vacation. Something about Ithi's post from Day 1. "Noone seems scummy." Votes Charis.

Me - Going to sleep and busy next day. Don't let Jack lynch me, would rather be able to post. Didn't realize Charis replaced Ithi.

Tina - Charis replaced Ithi.

Me - Oh.

Me - Comments on lack of posts. OMGUS's Jack. Questions his motives then more than gut.

Ask for people to green vote someone.

Me - Work time

Lessa - Asks if I think she is mafia or if was purely example.

Lessa - Votes Jack.

Jack - Why scummy to Lessa?

Dar - Will post later if baby she is sitting will sleep.

Lessa - Jack first to comment on Song's death as random. Then tells us he did it.

Jack - Mentions Lessa's weak reasoning. Spells my name wrong when asking if we're scummates.

Key - Finds Bela's "items can kill. Or mafia has Day AND Night Kills." statement odd. Asks Jack why commented on randomness.

Key - Corrects sentence.

Lessa - How is reasoning weak?

Me - Example to Lessa. I hint rather obviously at Elder Wand.

Lessa - says if she were mafia, associating with me is stupid. :/

Me - Offended at her remark. :P

Dapiano - Doesn't get point of my experiment.

Me - I can kill and revive. Should have done it then.

Bela - Asks about if I kill someone, what happens to their items. Says we all have weak reasons before voting.

Me - No control over items. Might just kill someone.

Tina - Asks if I can bring someone back properly. FOSs Charis again.

Me - quotes Deadline.

Me - Tell people I got 3 items. Who I think I did steal from. Posted my thoughts.

Tina - Encourages to vote. Mentions Charis again.

Jack - Tells me to kill him. Or Lessa.

Red - Wall of Text! Mentions Bela's Day & NK post as well. FOSs Tyn for the Scene of Song's death. FOSs me because everyone else agreed about his role fishing. Sorta FOSs Jack for revealing (why and the time he did). Asks Key why she revealed her item. FOS Sak (who is already dead). FOSs Key for later saying "If I actually have one". Says Tina brings up a good point about Keys reveal. Says I'm putting myself on fence for Key. Says Tyn is sus for trying to align with Nolder. Tells Jack she also didn't think Zo was scummy either. Comments that Lessa's recap is scummy because there is no opnion. Says how Tyn is scummy because she didn't vote Nolder because she had a Thief Play on him. Says Jack could use WIFOM if he is scum. Dar's reaction to Nolder's death feels forced. Asks me about kill/revive. Says Key would be good. Asks me to reveal other items.

Dar - Says I should have worked in secret. Needs to do a reread. Big post without saying much.

Red - Explains abbrv. Says she suspects Tyn for voting Key using Nolder's alignment.

Tyn - Says she didn't say Nol was scummy. And that she was exciting over her thief play.

Red - Shows Tyn how she indeed implied she thought Nolder was scummy. Also explains further how she thinks Tyn was trying to clear herself.

Red - She was looking for people who would benefit from Noldy's death.

Red - Votes Jack.

Tina - 8 people not voting.

Dar - Haven't been able to review. Votes Jack. Won't be on.

Tina - Votes Jack, slow day.

Me - Low activity. PM Alanna.

Jack - Glad no one tried to justify bandwagon. Lessa and Dar are two top suspects.

Jack - And Zo.

Dar - Asks Jack why she is sus.

Me - PT test results.

Key - says "If I actually have one" was sarcasm. I really don't see it. Says I should kill her.

Dar - Tells Key she can still vote prolly.

Me - Painting room. No reply yet.

MOD - Bela randomly killed.

Me - Actually suspected her. Will send kill in after reread.

Dar - Didn't. Glad random good for town.

Charis - Says she was Imperioused. Thinks she knows who did it.

Lessa - One mafia down. Reread.

Bela - Bah

Me - Asking Charis who was FOSing her. Pokes mod.

Red - Glad her thoughts about Bela were right. Asks Jack to clarify why he suspects Dar and Lessa.

Red - asks me if I can still kill and revive.

Me - Waiting on mod. Already sent in Kill.

Key - Thought Elder Wand was only one shot. Asked who I killed.

Key - Random awesome.

Dar - Explains her reaction to Noldy's death. Sus of me, but not enough for a FOS.

Jack - Tells Dar Imperious could be from anyone. Items game. Sus of Dar for suggesting alignments.

Dar - Says everyone else has implied same (actions attached to roles).

Tina - Thinks Charis is FOSing her.

Red - who did I kill, and other items? Reaction to Coroner report made Dar ping.

Lessa - Mentions she always recaps. Asks why Jack thinks she is scum. Says Key already defended herself against Tyn.

Dar - Book talk.

Red - Book nerd.

Tina - Thought Charis was silenced. Asks why Zo hasn't voted at deadlines. Would be interesting to see if Elder Wand can kill. Odd if Jack lied.

Me - Would rather not say yet, about items.

Red - Wants to know my items. Asks Jack to clarify Elder Wand.

MOD - Jack dies.

Red - asks why I killed Jack. Asks me to revive.

Jack - Bah.

Tyn - Game going nowhere.

Charis - Not suspecting Tina. Not silenced. Can only post what told to. Says I stole her item and bragged about it. And says I Imperioused her to keep her saying anything about it. Votes and FOSs me.

Charis - Says I was the only one to remark on her post.

Red - Says me and Charis are good to look at tmr.

Charis - Says Red is lying or someone stole from her before I stole from them.

Key - Surprise at Draco being Town. Asks what Red is lying about.

Me - Might vote Red. Explain why I chose Jack and that I already sent it in. Tell Charis I didn't steal from her. FOS Red for asking for items and knowing that Charis had Stone.

Charis - Says one of the people I stole from prolly Imperioused her. Says I'm greedy.

Charis - Not including Jack, so Red or AJ.

Me - See Charis' point. Will post third item later. Agree to being greedy, but not that it's scummy.

Me - Night should be over. Revive should have gone through.

MOD - Red is NKed.

MOD - AJ and Zo will be replaced soon.

Me - Stone was stolen. Lost Cloak and Sword. Felt so cool.

Me - Post all my posts and who could have stolen items. Vote Tina.

Red - Bah

Me - Bat Boogey?

Me - Post people.

Me - Bored.

[Niniel]

Tina - lol

 

I will see if I can find a vote count.

[Niniel]

I only found this:

 

Key(1) - Ed

Lessa (1) - Tina

 

It takes 6 to lynch!

 

 

I don´t know exactly when deadline is because I´m to lazy to check the timezones. But it is today, people!

[Alanna]

The deadline has passed.

 

Do you guys actually want to play this game anymore? I typically feel like 2 random lynches in a row = you guys obviously don't want to play, so I end the game.

 

I am going on a LOA starting today and ending August 5th, which is why the deadline was this afternoon, right before I left. I had thought I could get online in the Sydney airport to end the Night Phase, and then you'd have about 4 days for the following day phase. But no lynch, twice in a row, has me wondering if you all even want to continue.

 

So if you guys want to keep playing, you can have the rest of the week - til August 5th - to try and reach a lynch. Or you can decide not to play anymore. It's up to you.

 

I have to leave for the airport in about 15 minutes though, so it's up to you.

 

BTW, you can always find the current deadline in the OP.

[ed2funy]

:/

*sigh*

 

I'd rather play...but I feel that many in this game just don't care.

 

[Niniel]

I agree with Ed. I hope we can continue.

 

I understand you, Alanna. I know it takes a long time to work on a mafia game so it´s not fun when people just stop playing.

[keyholder21]

I've been trying to keep up and play, though admittedly lacking especially on the weekends. It's hard bc they're busy lol. I'm much better with deadlines that are set during the week.

 

I will attempt to ramp up my game if we keep playing (though I know it will mostly be me defending myself lol).

[keyholder21]

Also, sorry Alanna - like Tina says I know a lot of work goes into making a game. :/

[Lessa Nikia]

I agree with Ed and I still want to play. I like this game, alot cause it's different. Items instead of roles.

[Charis alAslan]

Because you posted after him sometime today and his stuff was stolen, which can only be done when you post after the person you want to steal from.

 

Read below

 

That's gifting Em. He would have to post after her for a steal.

 

Exactly.

 

For now.

 

Unvote

Vote Key

Late with this post - been out all day, sorry:

 

Jack, it rather makes sense for someone to steal the elder wand to confirm it is a one-shot item. If it is a one shot item, it's a wasted thief play but if that person speaks up and confirms it's a one shot, that vindicates you somewhat for that claim.

Pulling Charis's quote up in case I don't finish this reread in one sitting.

 

Yes, this was what I was told to post.

 

Unless the people Ed has named cannot confirm that they had items stolen from them? It's tough to ask them to name the items themselves and get a confirmation from Ed as that could be contrived. So, all 3 of the people that Ed stole from could have potentially Imperiused me if Ed got the item second-hand. In which case, one of them is probably scum trying to keep me from letting others know that I had the Stone taken from me. I'll wait for more before thinking of changing my vote, though. Someone this greedy to steal so many items cannot be good for the Town.

 

Since Red was Town, I'm assuming AJ stole from you. You should probably check your posts from Day 1 and see if Ithi posted after her.

 

Yes, I was also thinking AJ. But I still FoS you because you did have the Stone, However, since you named who you stole from then it's obvious one of them had it and it got passed to you.

 

Also, for your later post on everyone which I wont quote - you said that the post I was made to give does not seem like mafia would give it. That's a very interesting assumption. I'm not sure a mafia DID Imperius me. However, since you were the only one to comment on it and you had the Stone, I am leaning my FoS on you. I'm still unsure why you FoS me since I couldnt have stolen from you. I also have no items since you've taken (or someone took) the Stone.

 

I thought I officially voted Ed and now I see that I think it was done in the Night phase when I could finally speak freely again so it didnt count.

 

ALANNA, I DO WANT TO PLAY!! It's just tough with my 10mth old and being pregnant as well. But I'm here til the end, I promise!! <3

[Daruya]

I'm here and hope to continue playing.

 

Do we want to take a break for a couple days or keep hashing things out till August 5? I don't get to be online much on the weekends lately and have some stuff going on this week that might keep me off in the evenings on Tuesday and Wednesday.

 

And no, I haven't done my re-read yet and don't have time to do so at the moment, so I am not ready to cast a vote.

 

Charis, I did remember you were Imperiused and you saying you were told to say that but I remember odd things! LOL! I remembered that but forgot the difference in how to gift and steal . . .

 

I wonder where Red is? She's been revived but hasn't been active since then, which is unusual for her. I wonder if she was Imperiused, too? I just checked and she hasn't been active at DM since July 28. I also wonder where AJ is; she hasn't been active on DM since July 26. Has anyone heard from either of them offline (FB or MSN or something)?

[Niniel]

I think I have read somewhere that Red can't be very active in weekends. Shall we wait until Monday and hope the other ones come back? It will be hard for Alanna to replace players when she are away.

[keyholder21]

Well, Red is generally active on Friday morning/afternoon iirc. I hope she's all right! I don't know about AJ - hope she's ok too.

 

 

this game has been difficult for me to get a handle on. Probably partially because of the items vs roles thing, partially because people aren't talking that much, and partly because I go in and out (my fault) which doesn't help me any.

 

I have a suggestion, which of course we don't have to do, but if someone gifted the stone then you could lynch me, revive me, and then you would know that I'm telling the truth. That might help things along as a) we keep talking about my reveal/character, b) it would give some good insight on people who have been going after me.

[Red2111]

 

In memory of Red. :/

 

EW EW EW EW YUCK YUCK YUCK YUCK!! *goes to burn her lips off with acid* i don't care that i'm GInny in this game, i'd never NEVER kiss that potter brat, you here me!! NEVER!!! i'd rather snog Nagini!!!

 

 

/ semi humorous rave

 

 

so anyways yes people, i'm not active on the weekands, i rarely get on because it's my only time to catch up on house work and bug bubba (whcih is my favorite hobby btw) my weekands start on friday too *nods*

 

also, i'd like to keep on playing, i got resurrected on the weekand, otherwise i woudl have been posting before now

 

 

How about everyone gift their items to Red and post after her.

Alanna told me that there was no trickery involved in resurrecting and it's a small chance there is a recruit item.

 

 

yeah, thanks for putting that target on my back. isn't it enough i was Nkd once ... now you want to tempt the scum again by suggesting everyone sends their items to me.

 

honeeslty FoS @ Ed over this.

 

 

By the time I did, it was the next day and I was still trying to figure out if I should use the Stone to bring back Song or Nolder (both Town and both good options). Then I found out the Stone had been stolen and I had been Imperiused! >_< The worst part was that I couldnt post anything I wasnt told to and the whole Day phase I was only given ONE post. *facepalm*

Well, I'm glad I stole it from you if that is what you were planning.

Also, gonna go check your post out. Because if you only got one post, most likely it was an inactive person who Imperioused you. But that is only if it's true.

 

 

Vote Tynaal, for now, for being very insistent to lynch me, then disappearing only to reappear when people were talking about lynching you, now OMGUS voting Lessa. I know it could just be coincidence but it seems very scummy.

Leaving yourself a way out?

 

(Tynaal) Neville Longbottom, Town, has been killed.

 

This player had an item. It will be randomly assigned to another player.

I'll try and go through her posts later and she where her posts fall....she could have been stolen from or been gifted, imo.

 

Not good! My first thought was that it should be someone that wanted to throw suspicions of me, Key or Lessa because we were the ones that voted Tynaal. But it could of course be Key or Lessa who did it knowing that some of us would think like that. If the Elder Wand only works for each player ones we could skip Ed at least.

Not liking this post.

 

 

i agree with what Ed said.

[dapianoplay3r]

It's ok red. Noone can gift or steal items at night and you weren't here during the day so you wont be targeted.

 

also Ive just moved into my new place so this evening ill be back in action and posting again (This is a quick post as I get ready in the morning)

[Niniel]

So do we agree to have a new deadline at Friday? (I think that was what Alanna suggested.)

[ed2funy]

It was a good idea at the time!

lol

 

 

I agree on the new deadline. And I've stated my points. Is it possible to get some more opinions from everyone else on the game, yo?

[keyholder21]

lol, that picture of Ginny and Harry is so weird.

[dapianoplay3r]

I want to keep playing

[Niniel]

Then 8 out of 10 wants to continue. Right now we need 6 votes to lynch. We were 16 players when we started. Only one have turned out mafia. I think that would make three non town players left. Now if all of them is on the same lynch then it will be impossible to lynch mafia. Even if it are only two mafia it would take all the rest of us to lynch another player than the one that mafia have chosen. Do you understand what I´m saying?

 

But this hasn´t happened jet and that is why I´m thinking that Zosime or AJ could be scum. The problem is that if we lynch one of them and they turn up town then we get no information out of their kills. I will see what they have posted in this game.

 

Key, you seam eager to get killed. Why is that? I don´t think we have been talking much about your Hermione claim lately?

[dapianoplay3r]

I think that the hermione thing has become a bit of a WIFOM

I think it's unlikely that she is mafia though

Seems bad odds to be playing that game

[Charis alAslan]

Well, I still have my eyes on Ed, but I'm also willing to go with AJ for the way above convo that Ed and I had after me coming out of my curse. I'm willing to go with either on a lynch today.

[keyholder21]

Key, you seam eager to get killed. Why is that? I don´t think we have been talking much about your Hermione claim lately?

 

Not really. Just trying to further the game along and also clear my name at the same time lol. And I suppose not lately, but it was a big deal earlier in the game and things can and usually come back.

 

It could be AJ and/or Zo, though you're right that they wouldn't get us much information, I think Zo posted on like the first two days only and I don't know if I've seen AJ all game. However, we do seem to be doing a lot of the mafia's work for them - lynching townies I mean.