[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

[ed2funy]

I voted for you because you had been in the game, several times, up until then, and just made a short joke or snippet and then left without attempting gameplay.

 

You're right, I could have voted a number of other people, but like I said to BFG, I only have two votes.

Hell of a NON explanation, Sooh.

 

Why didn't you pursue the other non-posters as hard?

[ed2funy]

 

Are you implying you're always drunk, Crusher?

Of course not. At night I sleep.

[DPR]

 

 

Limited value today but may be of use

 

 

 

 

Vote Count!

 

• Cuth - 2
• DreadPirateRoberts - 2 - BFG

The fight ends at 5:00 PM Eastern on Sunday, 3/19.

 

 

 

Vote Count!

• Dreadpirateroberts - 3 - BFG
• Cuth - 1
• No lynch - 3

 

 

Vote Count!

• Dreadpirateroberts - 1 - BFG
• Cuth - 1
• No lynch - 6

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 1 - Ironeyes
• No Lynch - 8 - Dreadpirateroberts, Ed2funy, Crusher, Sooh, Darthe, Songstress, BFG, Wildfire Sedai 

Nobody died.  It is now Night One!  Night One ends at 5:00 PM Eastern on Monday, 3/20.

Everyone may now post.

 

 

 

 

What's the purpose of posting this? If you didn't want to change your vote, why did you?

 

What do you mean?

 

As I said, there's limited value today as the votes seemed relatively static, there may be value later, there may not.

 

If I didn't want to switch I wouldn't have

 

 

 

Why post it like that? The implication is that you didn't want to change your vote... still didn't want to change your vote... really didn't want to change your vote... changed your vote.

 

By posting your hesitancy, you make it clear you didn't want to.

 

So why post it like that? And I'll change up my second question - what changed your mind?

[Wildfire Sedai]

Okay, It wasn't as bad as I thought it was. I was just  coming off of sleep and trying to read it fast to vote.

[Wildfire Sedai]

I also hate those huge multquotes.  

[BFG]

 

 

 

Limited value today but may be of use

 

 

 

 

 

 

Vote Count!

 

• Cuth - 2
• DreadPirateRoberts - 2 - BFG

The fight ends at 5:00 PM Eastern on Sunday, 3/19.

 

 

 

Vote Count!

• Dreadpirateroberts - 3 - BFG
• Cuth - 1
• No lynch - 3

 

 

Vote Count!

• Dreadpirateroberts - 1 - BFG
• Cuth - 1
• No lynch - 6

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 1 - Ironeyes
• No Lynch - 8 - Dreadpirateroberts, Ed2funy, Crusher, Sooh, Darthe, Songstress, BFG, Wildfire Sedai 

Nobody died.  It is now Night One!  Night One ends at 5:00 PM Eastern on Monday, 3/20.

Everyone may now post.

 

 

 

 

What's the purpose of posting this? If you didn't want to change your vote, why did you?

 

What do you mean?

 

As I said, there's limited value today as the votes seemed relatively static, there may be value later, there may not.

 

If I didn't want to switch I wouldn't have

 

 

 

Why post it like that? The implication is that you didn't want to change your vote... still didn't want to change your vote... really didn't want to change your vote... changed your vote.

 

By posting your hesitancy, you make it clear you didn't want to.

 

So why post it like that? And I'll change up my second question - what changed your mind?

 

Odd interpretation

 

I switched when I read that no lynch was allowed, that was a few hours after it was posted as a possibility in thread. I have no real read on you, I have vague problems with how static/baseless votes were in the runup to end of the nomination phase which applies to all the main wagons, I also vaguely agree with Sooh that posting reads in the run up to end of day was townie, but I disagree with enough that I'm hesitant

[Songstress]

I'm feeling less horrible today, yay... head is no longer fuzzy so I'll try to reread during night phase and see if things make more sense.   I can't possibly be more useless than yesterday

[BFG]

I'm feeling less horrible today, yay... head is no longer fuzzy so I'll try to reread during night phase and see if things make more sense.   I can't possibly be more useless than yesterday

<3

[ed2funy]

BFG, I get what you're saying about timeframes and you reading No Lynch was allowed, but throwing when your vote changed in that post was a bit odd. Have to agree with DPR on that.

[BFG]

BFG, I get what you're saying about timeframes and you reading No Lynch was allowed, but throwing when your vote changed in that post was a bit odd. Have to agree with DPR on that.

Lol, I'm ~trying to build 'normal' VCs, so I'm just filling in where my vote was during the posted VCs

[dicetosser1]

i didnt vote cause I thought i had more time. Mod didnt start throwing up those counters until 430 this morning  #grumble

[BFG]

Not enough discussion imo, but I feel good about dice, Ed, Darth and bfg to some extent. [unvote] ed.

 

I know it's only 9 pages and I forgot how long the day phase is while typing this but [v] crusher[/v] I had some problems with his intro

Was a easy post on a holiday and bounces. We will see but I definitely want a interactive crusher!

 

[v]dpr [/v] dpr was you post where you voted wildfire a serious one? I read two people viewing it differently.

Can you explain your votes here any more?

[Darthe]

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

[BFG]

I disagree on Seph. Plus it's night phase, so voting is rather pointless unless you just want to show us who you'd vote if it was day.

Why Seph specifically? He's not on your reads list later, what's your read on Darthe now?

[BFG]

WiFi do you have any reads?

[BFG]

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

More detail would be appreciated, or reads, or both :p

[Hallia]

Hey hey; catching up on what I've missed today

[BFG]

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

• Cuth - 1 - Ironeyes
• No Lynch - 8 - Dreadpirateroberts, Ed2funy, Crusher, Sooh, Darthe, Songstress, BFG, Wildfire Sedai

Nobody died. It is now Night One! Night One ends at 5:00 PM Eastern on Monday, 3/20.

Everyone may now post.

Seph, Cuth, Dice and Hallia didn't vote.

Seph probably stands out the most in this group

 

Seph, can you explain?

[DPR]

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

 

 

Of course it has merit. Why don't you go ahead and explain your vote on me and I'll point to the merits you're looking for. 

[BFG]

Thread feels woolly

 

Dice

Sooh

Ed

Seph?

[BFG]

He said that my (very recent) game with you as partners could be coloring my perceptions. That's something I hadn't considered and it's probably true. I have a chronic case of recency bias, where what happened in the near past weighs more heavily on my reasoning than the more distant past.

What's your read on Cuth/DPR now?

[BFG]

Hey hey; catching up on what I've missed today

Hey :)

[Darthe]

 

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

 

Of course it has merit. Why don't you go ahead and explain your vote on me and I'll point to the merits you're looking for.

My vote on you? Early it was a joke vote, later it was self pres. Who else was I gonna switch to when I returned DPR?

[DPR]

 

 

The push against me doesn't have merit. I don't see points being made, just quoting a post of mine and going "if darthe is a wolf heres what he is doing".

 

Of course it has merit. Why don't you go ahead and explain your vote on me and I'll point to the merits you're looking for.

My vote on you? Early it was a joke vote, later it was self pres. Who else was I gonna switch to when I returned DPR?

 

 

See, there's the merit. Don't know that we have much use for a self-preserving jokester who won't make actual cases.

[Sooh]

 

I voted for you because you had been in the game, several times, up until then, and just made a short joke or snippet and then left without attempting gameplay.

 

You're right, I could have voted a number of other people, but like I said to BFG, I only have two votes.

Hell of a NON explanation, Sooh.

 

Why didn't you pursue the other non-posters as hard?

 

I had two votes. I placed them on people who were barely here and who I expected more from. I could have picked other people as well, but I didn't. There will be more days and more votes. 

 

I can't push people who aren't here with anything but my vote, and I can't vote more than two at the same time. If either DPR or Tress who I voted D1 had come into the thread and responded to me in such a way that I didn't think my vote should be there anymore, I would have moved it to someone else. I didn't really have a suspect among the more active people D1.