[Basic] Supernatural Mafia ~ Game Over ~ Town Wins!!!

[Zander?]

Alanna, I replaced into a slot that was the defacto lynch for today based on someone else's actions. I believe that my literal first post in this slot was to claim and state the circumstances. Even willing to be one of the trains for the day. I got met with derision and more votes and no one looking anywhere else with any serious intensity. If no one is looking to do the town thing then I can't really think anyone is obvious town from my POV. At that point.my job as a town player is to try to survive and at worst give town the most information I can. That is what I have done. No one seems to.be listening As no counter train built in the past two days. Now the pushers are putting out feels that allow them to try to shirk the responsibility for their votes and actions today. The least I can do.for my town is point them.out as I die.

 

Vote lily with me.

 

 

Youre not surviving today.

[Shad_]

Vote Count

 

Turin(5): Zander, Nynaeve, alannalynn, Pralaya, Eldrick

bgrishinko(1): Lily

Eldrick(1): Thane

Thane(1): bgrishinko

Lily(1): Turin

 

Not Voting: BFG

 

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

 

[Thane Vakarian]

 

Sooh and Eld, perhaps. I recall you posting about it. But Turin and Eld? The only thing i remember Eld is doing now is commenting on events, not trying to #solve and go after me. Don't recall his stance on Turin, though. 

 

 

DUDE TURIN 2 IS SOOH

 

I look at the interaction from D1/Sooh and D2/Turin seperately. It's the same slot, but not the same player.

 

 

So what are your other reads?

 

quickly assembled list:

 

Turin: not thinking that Turin 2 is a wolf here. One of few, I know. Sooh left a wolfy slot, he replaced back in and has been getting it. Don't think his posting is that bad myself. Sounds more frustrated townie in the most recent posts than anything else.

 

Zander/Laine/Nyn:   these three are connected. Should Turin flip town, which i think will happen, there's (at least) one deep wolf among them. That's my impression on them. Which one of them, i don't know. All three are good players and quite capable.

 

Pral: actually like his posts. It's been quite refreshing to read so much of him in a go today. Feel good about him, not likely to be wolf this game;

Eldrick <- need to lynch

Lily: Eldricks' gameplay should have alarmed her sooner, I think. Kept him too long as a null to my liking. Can't really say she's a wolf for it, but would not put her 100% clear as town 

 

BGrishinko: Dunno what to make of the guy. At one point, I think he's reasonable and solving. And other moments have me raising eyebrows... Could be 'cause it's our first game together and i have a hard time reading him. Not a cleared townie, not not wolfie enough to accuse at this point.

BFG: BFG is the greatest. You make reading you a pleasure, and easy. Highest town read on this slot.

[bgrishinko]

Didn't really answer my question there Zander.

[Turin Turambar]

 

[unvote]

 

[V] Lily [/v]

 

She has been pushing my lynch as inevitable all day while voting BG. Then trying to say I was mafia because he was.

 

She us a wolf I.think.

Now, you're just flailing.

Ooh. Hurt me with your buzzword.

 

Eldrick why vote me now? It's hybrid. You wanna hammer to shut this discussion up?

 

Not very townie. Maybe it was zander bussing both teammates in his first post. i dunno. All I.know is I'm town.

 

I regret I had just two.lives to give to.my fair town.

[Zander?]

Thane....brother...if you think there was a connection between Sooh and Eld....theres still a connection with Turin 2 its the same slot man.

 

Turin 1 way way less scummy then Turin 2.

 

That should tell you something,  both players scummy from the same slot....prolly not a Town slot.

 

So are you willing to vote Turin or not?

[bgrishinko]

Odd read on me Thane. Where am I reasonable and where am I raising eyebrows? Cause I've been voting you for a while.

[BFG]

 

Why isn't Thane around?

Thane is getting a bloody headache reading through the thread. The honest impression i am getting here is that, even when Turin or Pral make good points, you (meaning you, Zander and Laine) basically gun those points down and want to convince everybody that you're absolutely right. Basically that made catching up after a no-computer-day no fun to read at all. I love the three of you as people, i really do, but the attitude, i have to say, could be dimmed a bit in the game.

 

That having been posted, I still think we should go Eldrick over Turin today. CFD if you like, and you'll have a wolf *nods*

 

On the other hand, i don't think my opinion is being viewed that highly this game. I just know that, if Turin would flip town, then it'd be likely that there's at least one wolf among the three of you, working with the others. That's what I think and the genuine impression that i got from reading the last couple of pages..

 

This is probably the first thing you've posted that makes me think you ~could be town and I sort of like Lily's instantaneous response to it

 

Can you separate Zander/Nyn/Laine any? What if Turin flips mafia

[Zander?]

 

 

[unvote]

 

[V] Lily [/v]

 

She has been pushing my lynch as inevitable all day while voting BG. Then trying to say I was mafia because he was.

 

She us a wolf I.think.

Now, you're just flailing.

Ooh. Hurt me with your buzzword.

 

Eldrick why vote me now? It's hybrid. You wanna hammer to shut this discussion up?

 

Not very townie. Maybe it was zander bussing both teammates in his first post. i dunno. All I.know is I'm town.

 

I regret I had just two.lives to give to.my fair town.

 

 

 

Or it could just be CoanderGOAT Reads.

 

I legit lolololololol'd in RL

[Zander?]

Didn't really answer my question there Zander.

 

 

Remember that time when I asked you about lurking....it had a purpose.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

[unvote]

 

[V] Lily [/v]

 

She has been pushing my lynch as inevitable all day while voting BG. Then trying to say I was mafia because he was.

 

She us a wolf I.think.

Now, you're just flailing.

Ooh. Hurt me with your buzzword.

 

Eldrick why vote me now? It's hybrid. You wanna hammer to shut this discussion up?

 

Not very townie. Maybe it was zander bussing both teammates in his first post. i dunno. All I.know is I'm town.

 

I regret I had just two.lives to give to.my fair town.

Because you're scummier than thane. I shouldn't have moved off of you in the first place.

[Turin Turambar]

Cory has blatantly come out and said he can't read me due to my personality type.

[bgrishinko]

 

Didn't really answer my question there Zander.

 

 

Remember that time when I asked you about lurking....it had a purpose.

 

 And?

[LilyElizabeth]

Hammer time.

 

Unvote

Vote Turin

[Thane Vakarian]

Thane....brother...if you think there was a connection between Sooh and Eld....theres still a connection with Turin 2 its the same slot man.

 

Turin 1 way way less scummy then Turin 2.

 

That should tell you something,  both players scummy from the same slot....prolly not a Town slot.

 

So are you willing to vote Turin or not?

Same slot with two different players is never an easy thing. Both playing scummy on the same slot could be unlucky play. His posts, as i've said, don't seem that bad to me. I don't think i'll move away from my vote. Just be ready to vote with me tomorrow if you want to catch a baddy, ok?.

 

Odd read on me Thane. Where am I reasonable and where am I raising eyebrows? Cause I've been voting you for a while.

I'm trying to let the fact that you're voting me not mess up my reads and prefer to look upon your play towards other players. In general, i like your play, but there's frowning at some points.

[Zander?]

Cory has blatantly come out and said he can't read me due to my personality type.

 

Point is? 

[Eldrick4221]

Actually, now that I think about it, my reason for unvoting you was precisely discussion. It has dried up. I'm still convinced you're scum and therefore I moved back.

[Zander?]

LETS GET THE FLIPPPPPPPPPPPPP


SURVEY SAYS................

[BFG]

<snip> 

Odd read on me Thane. Where am I reasonable and where am I raising eyebrows? Cause I've been voting you for a while.

I'm trying to let the fact that you're voting me not mess up my reads and prefer to look upon your play towards other players. In general, i like your play, but there's frowning at some points.

 

Can you be more specific?

[Shad_]

Vote Count

 

Turin(6): Zander, Nynaeve, alannalynn, Pralaya, Eldrick, Lily

Eldrick(1): Thane

Thane(1): bgrishinko

Lily(1): Turin

 

Not Voting: BFG

 

That's a lynch!

[Shad_]

Turin has been lynched. He was:

Charlie Bradbury – Vanilla Town

You have 24 hours to submit night actions.

[Zander?]

I dont even have the words

[Thane Vakarian]

 

 

Why isn't Thane around?

Thane is getting a bloody headache reading through the thread. The honest impression i am getting here is that, even when Turin or Pral make good points, you (meaning you, Zander and Laine) basically gun those points down and want to convince everybody that you're absolutely right. Basically that made catching up after a no-computer-day no fun to read at all. I love the three of you as people, i really do, but the attitude, i have to say, could be dimmed a bit in the game.

 

That having been posted, I still think we should go Eldrick over Turin today. CFD if you like, and you'll have a wolf *nods*

 

On the other hand, i don't think my opinion is being viewed that highly this game. I just know that, if Turin would flip town, then it'd be likely that there's at least one wolf among the three of you, working with the others. That's what I think and the genuine impression that i got from reading the last couple of pages..

 

This is probably the first thing you've posted that makes me think you ~could be town and I sort of like Lily's instantaneous response to it

 

Can you separate Zander/Nyn/Laine any? What if Turin flips mafia

 

Alright, I'll try.

 

Zander: seems most aggressive in his hunt of the three. His early game posting made it near impossible to get a good read on him, after all the mutual games we had. I know he said he would play differently, but it could well have been a smokescreen. Loudest going after Nolder (my  impression) who flipped town. Again loudest (also, my impression) against Turin, which could well be another townie. His reads this game would be horribad if town.

Laine: of the three, middle spot. I know she can be a bit of a bulldog when hunting wolves, which is good. But here i'm missing the bulldog some and am looking at more of a sheepdog. Feels like she's depending too much on Zander

Nyn: of the three, i get the impression she'd be least likely to be wolf. Or she's just that good (which is possible). Tone in the game is alright, except when teaming up with the other two. I would have expected a tad more openly hunting (but, i know she's good and i have high expectations so she solves and we win)

[Zander?]

Consider my vote on Eldrick already.

[Nynaeve]

 

I honestly don't know what to say at this point. If I'm wrong again, then I suck at this game and that is that. But I'd choose making a stand over being afraid of being wrong any day so.... *shrugs* I dunno.

Now that you are pretty confident this lynch is going thru you have doubts of finally thinking you could be wrong but unwilling to do anything about. Ques the "whelp, I was wrong but he was scummy" line for post flip. It would be really funny if it wasn't so tragic. Just please look at these posts of Z lily and Nyn. At least 1 wolf here. Most likely 2.

 

 

Did I unvote? no. That says it all.