Frozen Mafia Game Thread--GAME OVER--MAFIA WIN

[Zander?]

thoughts on a Poss Mass CHARACTER CLAIM to see if that helps us?

 

if we want ill go first.

[Sooh]

Vote me if you need me to be cleared up, but that makes Pral's sacrifice null and void.

 

I'll claim sooner than I let myself be lynched. Please let me do that before you hammer. I will be on and off for the next hour or so. Still cleaning the house.

[Kaylee]

thoughts on a Poss Mass CHARACTER CLAIM to see if that helps us?

 

if we want ill go first.

I don't know that'll help. After all the scum team had fake claims.

[Shad_]

thoughts on a Poss Mass CHARACTER CLAIM to see if that helps us?

 

if we want ill go first.

 

I assume scum have fake claims.

[Kaylee]

Vote me if you need me to be cleared up, but that makes Pral's sacrifice null and void.

 

I'll claim sooner than I let myself be lynched. Please let me do that before you hammer. I will be on and off for the next hour or so. Still cleaning the house.

I'm willing to wait Sooh.

[Shad_]

I have to leave for a while.  I'll try to wrap my head around this later.

[Zander?]

 

thoughts on a Poss Mass CHARACTER CLAIM to see if that helps us?

 

if we want ill go first.

 

I assume scum have fake claims.

 

 

prolly but we can see what characters make sense?

 

we all should agree on this on way or another

 

so just say yes or no peeps.

[Shad_]

 

 

thoughts on a Poss Mass CHARACTER CLAIM to see if that helps us?

 

if we want ill go first.

 

I assume scum have fake claims.

 

 

prolly but we can see what characters make sense?

 

we all should agree on this on way or another

 

so just say yes or no peeps.

 

 

I'm really just not sure I follow your line of thinking here.  The whole point of a fake claim is that it's meant to be viable cover.  I just see this leading to a bunch of WIFOM.

[Zander?]

maybe.  thats why i asked.  just thought with people being familiar with the Movie we could have seen which characters made the most sense.

[Kaylee]

I agree with Shad on this

[Kaylee]

Reason is because Razen claimed Marshmallow which to me makes sense to be in the game. I'll claim if that's what we decide, but I'm not sure we gain anything from it.

[Aiel Heart]

Sven looks at the carrot that had once been Olaf's nose. He considers whether to eat it. The day continues

[Kaylee]

AJ, ant thoughts?

[Kaylee]

*any

 

Autocorrect you are weird

[dicetosser1]

 

now I WANT you to hammer

 

why not you Dice?

 

 

Cause she made me suspicious

 

 

 

3p I guess maybe possible? But an SK + scum get a nightly kill + Pral's role means we could have lost an entire day phase. That would be pretty wild.

I'm thinking either 4 scum or a survivor maybe.

 

Yeah I'm lost on who to vote but thinking it should be either Zander or Sooh. If it's one of you other three then very well done.

 

 

ive been on ALL scum all game.  odds if i were scum id buss the ENTIRE team?

 

 

and if ure a SK or a survivor you can do that. Especially as SK you dont care WHO dies

 

 

Why would I want another Day phase if I was wolf or 3p?

 

3p who cant kill wouldnt care.

 

Zander already stated the other reason

[dicetosser1]

Soohs hesitation made me think she thought pral was a bomb and she was worried about dieing.

 

Now im leaning that she DID think that but then realised why i wanted her to hammer and figured she had to play the odds

 

 

intent to vote sooh

[Kaylee]

Soohs hesitation made me think she thought pral was a bomb and she was worried about dieing.

 

Now im leaning that she DID think that but then realised why i wanted her to hammer and figured she had to play the odds

 

 

intent to vote sooh

You may be onto something. I just don't know.

[Kaylee]

If like to hear from AJ.

[Shad_]

 

 

 

That means scum killed Pral.1 then

Or Pral 1 protected the right person.

I was responding to Shad's 4-man scum team comment to supply themselves with a vig fake claim. Would imply Hallia is scum and they intentionally shot Pral and there was no other bullet. Sounds like a long shot imo

 

Pral could've very well stuffed the mafia NK but that doesn't make Hallia town with a gun. Either way, she's pigeonholed into that claim now.

 

I see what you're saying. And yes, if the game doesn't end when one more scum is caught it would be fair to assume Hallia is SK instead of vig.

 

 

I don't think that Sooh would ever say this as Hallia's scum mate.

 

We don't know for sure if we're hunting a 4th scum or a 3p, but Sooh is not 4th scum imo.

[Kaylee]

Well then I'm thinking Zander or maybe Dice as the final scum.

[Kaylee]

Shad: what type of 3p would make sense at this point? We know it's not a killing role or survivor.

[Sooh]

3p who has holstered all three nights so far doesn't really make sense either. I think pretty much all 3p I have seen have kills. I may be wrong though. I'll go read the wiki.

[Sooh]

Neither of the roles I have found matches that of a 3p non-kill role. 

 

I'm inclined to think there's a deep wolf somewhere.

[Sooh]

Soohs hesitation made me think she thought pral was a bomb and she was worried about dieing.

 

Now im leaning that she DID think that but then realised why i wanted her to hammer and figured she had to play the odds

 

 

intent to vote sooh

Bomb says that it kills whoever NKs it. I wasn't even aware of any such role until you mentioned it. I haven't perused and read about every role there is in mafia games, nor have I encountered all of them. 

[dicetosser1]

some bombs take out the hammerer