Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[csarmi]

Its a clearly anti-town policy. Keep doing it if you wish, but don't be surprised to get flak for playing anti-town.

[Tsukibana]

when a day is 24 hours, and most people take spend the first 24 posting joke-votes and gifs, I will keep doing it, thank you.

Make the deadline 24 - 48 hours, and it would change.

[Tsukibana]

Edit: When a day is 72* hours...

[dicetosser1]

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction.  Such a co-hesive reaction among two players. 

 

Ithi and Turin are working together.  There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game.  Masons or Mafia.  I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well.  I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

 

dude its ithi and turin. shrugs   its always like that. No matter what team they are on.

[Myndrunner]

 

Why would Mynd do this as scum? I just don't understand.

 

He was in no real danger of getting lynched. If he were, I could think of at least two targets he'd win the thunderdome against, with hands down. Why would he suicide on Ithi? He can't be that stupid?

 

I think he is town. But, so is my read on Ithi.

 

The only choice is between Ithi and Mynd and I personally feel that there was no personal attacks on Mynd by Ithi and Turin. It is, but, natural to suspect someone who is using character as a basis for scum reads. 

 

 

I don't think I was saying there were personal attacks.  The attack itself was an overreaction.  Its one thing to question my point about character claims.  Its entirely different to react the way that they did.  Please go back and re-read how that whole thing went down.

 

 

Always, huh?

 

Mynd, how often have you played with Ithi and Turin together?

 

Enough to get a good meta on both of them.  Turin is very hostile and protective of Ithi no matter what his read.  Ithi takes games very personal.  Once, she went crying to the mod because of my pressure on her.  I not only got a warning from the mod, but others were calling me a meany head and poor Ithi.  I backed off because of this and she flipped scum.  I vowed to never let something like that mess with my reads again.  She sent me a PM saying that her crying about my pressure had nothing to do with gameplay.  Yeah.

 

I suspect that there is a reason you don't see her in many regular DM mafia games, BTW.  Maybe others can speak to Turin and Ithi's reputation better than I can.

 

Again, it was a mistake for me to pull the Gladiator switch.  It was a knee-jerk reaction but I thought everyone else would see the collusion between Turin and Ithi.

[Myndrunner]

 

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction.  Such a co-hesive reaction among two players. 

 

Ithi and Turin are working together.  There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game.  Masons or Mafia.  I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well.  I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

 

dude its ithi and turin. shrugs   its always like that. No matter what team they are on.

 

 

How is that an excuse?  That actually hurts the town more than anything.  If Turin will always see Ithi as town, then when she's scum, he's useless and a distraction.

[Myndrunner]

Here is a link to where the whole thing started.  Would you say that things got aggressive way too fast?

 

LINK

[Hallia]

 

 

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction.  Such a co-hesive reaction among two players. 

 

Ithi and Turin are working together.  There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game.  Masons or Mafia.  I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well.  I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

 

dude its ithi and turin. shrugs   its always like that. No matter what team they are on.

 

 

How is that an excuse?  That actually hurts the town more than anything.  If Turin will always see Ithi as town, then when she's scum, he's useless and a distraction.

 

 

I agree.

[Niniel]

I can´t get a grip of this situation. 

 

Ithi: Thought she was town with her case on Thane. She looked like she really scum hunted. Then she abandoned her read on Thane and turned against Mynd, who was voting Thane. That felt strange. But would mafia Ithi make a case on mafia Thane in the first place? I didn´t like that she asked if I wanted to get her mod killed. 

 

Mynd: I didn´t like how he tried to use Thane´s character claim as a reason for his vote. He accused Ithi of being personal etc that I don´t think was correct. But ... why would he challenge Ithi if he was mafia? 

 

Both assumed things about the set up. Ithi (and others) assumed that there is one vanilla in this game. Mynd assumed that Thane´s character can´t be vanilla. 

 

And my base of this is that Thane is mafia but I might not be right about that. He is the only one I have a strong mafia feeling of though. 

[csarmi]

 

 

 

 

 

 

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction. Such a co-hesive reaction among two players.

 

Ithi and Turin are working together. There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game. Masons or Mafia. I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well. I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

dude its ithi and turin. shrugs its always like that. No matter what team they are on.

How is that an excuse? That actually hurts the town more than anything. If Turin will always see Ithi as town, then when she's scum, he's useless and a distraction.

I agree.

Me too. If I checked the player list carefully and realized it was both of them playing, I wouldn't have signed up.

[Myndrunner]

Here is the thing, I shouldn't have gladiatored, but what is done is done.  right? 

 

If we lynch Ithi now, she either flips scum or town.   Scum? YAY!  Town? That kinda confirms Turin.

[Myndrunner]

Here is the thing, I shouldn't have gladiatored, but what is done is done.  right? 

 

If we lynch Ithi now, she either flips scum or town.   Scum? YAY!  Town? That kinda confirms Turin.

...as in Turin would be a confirmed townie.

[csarmi]

Why the hell would that make Turin town?

 

also: reads from both sides pls

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But I don't see where my questioning the Irene Adler claim drew such a reaction. Such a co-hesive reaction among two players.

 

Ithi and Turin are working together. There are only two ways they could be working together legally in this game. Masons or Mafia. I suspect the latter and a lynch on Ithi will either LOCKCLEAR Turin or prove he is scum as well. I am in no way implying that they are doing anything illegal, just very disturbing mafia game play.

dude its ithi and turin. shrugs its always like that. No matter what team they are on.

How is that an excuse? That actually hurts the town more than anything. If Turin will always see Ithi as town, then when she's scum, he's useless and a distraction.

I agree.

Me too. If I checked the player list carefully and realized it was both of them playing, I wouldn't have signed up.

You were the last player to sign up. The post before yours was Basel asking if people would mind if I played.

 

Turin was already down.

 

If you're all uncomfortable with me playing when Turin is then I can ask Basel to find a replacement.

[Myndrunner]

Why the hell would that make Turin town?

 

also: reads from both sides pls

True, he could still be scum, but the whole defending Ithi is no longer a distraction from any of us.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Was the game where I got upset the one where you were partnered with Kate?

 

If so that was 2012 - and - was quite poorly with PND. You do like to bring up things that will make people think badly of me.

 

It was an open game so all kinds of communication were allowed.

 

I'm still Town in this game. I'm better now so I don't get so easily rattled.

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

Why the hell would that make Turin town?

 

also: reads from both sides pls

True, he could still be scum, but the whole defending Ithi is no longer a distraction from any of us.

Did you mean to say 'for all of us'?

 

Or is this whole turin and ithi conversation actually a distraction 'from all of you'?

 

Interesting turn of phrase.

[Myndrunner]

 

 

Why the hell would that make Turin town?

 

also: reads from both sides pls

True, he could still be scum, but the whole defending Ithi is no longer a distraction from any of us.

Did you mean to say 'for all of us'?

 

Or is this whole turin and ithi conversation actually a distraction 'from all of you'?

 

Interesting turn of phrase.

 

You are really reaching, Ithi.

 

If you truly are town, you guys went way overboard with your reaction.  I don't like how you jumped off Thane so easily when he claimed VT, which is still unlikely, but possible.  BFG also claimed VT, which makes it even more unlikely that there are TWO VTs in this game.

 

I think we can play an honest game without you in it, Ithi.  You are too distracting to Turin if you are town and you reek scum to me even when you are town.  If you are scum, then yay, but without you in this game,Turin's reads will be a lot more clear.  If you are truly town, then you should want Turin to have honest reads, right?

 

Maybe you should vote yourself.  Do it for Turin if nothing else. 

[Ithillian Turambar]

Epic.

 

A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our friends and break all bonds of fellowship, but it is not this day. An hour of wolves and shattered shields, when the age of men comes crashing down! But it is not this day! This day we fight! By all that you hold dear on this good Earth, I bid you *stand, Men of the West!*

 

I don't think I'll be voting myself.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Turin reads me far too well. I've killed him twice as Mafia to get rid of him lol.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Where have all the funny gifs gone btw. I didn't get them all, as probably some American reference - but they were quite regular.

 

See - escalating. I think Mynd wins at that.

[Niniel]

I have a problem with Mynd's latest posts.

 

1. Again assuming that there is only one vt.

2. Ithi's alignment doesn't tell us Turin's.

3. "We can play a more honest geme without you..." Really?

 

I think that some stuff are boardering getting too personal right now.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yes. Mynd has been name calling for a while - but I'm ok. That's why I'm not really responding to him tbh.

[Turin Turambar]

Mynd, csarmi, hallia gfy.

 

I have an idea. Mynd claims to be town. We lynch him hallia let's him for. Then he fan replace if needed.

 

Personally, I think the mods will still be looking.

[Tsukibana]