[Mafia, "The Inn" Edition] Movie Madness: Places everyone.. the show has begun!

[Alanna]

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote[/glow] Krak for now. Thinking about lynching Pandy, but I'm not sure yet. Wombat's idea sounds good to me.

[Krakalakachkn]

How about a show of good faith.  If Red thinks someone is mafia besides me, I'll vote for them.  How else can I prove my innocence?  Unless this is a bad idea (tell me if it is), I don't know how else I can prove I'm not 'scum'

[Red2111]

Deadline

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.  You have until a majority is reached or friday at 11 am

 

Vote Count

Krak(7): Red, Ed, Verbal, Min, Tigs, Pookie, TMD

Red(2): Pandy, Krak

Pandy(2): Rey, Wombat

 

no vote(4): Aust, Talya, Player, Alanna

 

 

[Talya]

talya i'm more inclined to lynch krak because i'd rather us do away with another mafia member and worry about a solo winner another time.  for me, lynching scum is more important that a person with a solo win condition, especially if the solo winner isnt a killing role like a vig or SK.

 

i keep saying i'm not sure he's mafia and that i'm going off of his actions alone.  that said if i survive and he isn't lynched i'll know for sure on Day 4 if my hunch is correct. 

 

tayla, everytime you defend krak, you move yourself up higher on my list of suspects.

 

 

wombat, i like your idea.  the only problem i can forsee is if the person has their ability removed if you revive them.  can you see if Nae will clarify that point. 

 

 

He could well be and I don't really care you thinking I'm scum because of it. I go with whjat i see and how i feel about things. Krak could very well be Mafia, I don't know. But to say he is Jack Sparrow and that makes him scum is just off in my opnion. If you had said Captain Babosa (sp) then It's more believeable. As i said before the bad roles seem to be bad (and I mean nasty) people from the movies. Of course he could be black beard? 

 

I wasn't sure if he was admitting his role was the freeze person or not. And you did say earlier that Lily would be only frozen for a day, how do you know that it isn't for a day and a night?

 

If you are also not sure he is mafia, then why would what I say make you more suspicious of me. why should I take what you say (even though you aren't sure) as fact. I haven't defended Krak at all, I'm questioning your logic.  After that is what I'm supposed to do as a townie, question the belief of others to try aand see if I can kind mafia, it's what we all do (except Mafia).

 

It could also be that if Pandy is another solo winner, that would make two, maybe Krak is one too, if he is Jack Sparrow, that would make another one. And you seem more releuctant to lynch a solo player and rather go for Mafia!

[WWWwombat]

Just heard from Nae.  She refuses to answer Red's question.  I can't say I'm surprised given what she usually writes in her rules but for some reason didn't this time.

[Talya]

Masybe because there are twists added and she doesn't want to let on unitl the power is used, that i can understand. :)

[TheMasterDude]

Well there may be the fact that there are two finders or two cops. For my roll was somewhat like a finder though I was supposed to find one person.

 

There may be more twists like that and red and pandy may BOTH be telling the truth, except they have a twist on their roll. So I say that we should at least look for the mafia and leave the solo wins alone for now.

[WWWwombat]

I said I wasn't surprised.  My plan doesn't seem as bulletproof as it did before.  I still think we shouldn't lynch Krak though.  No one has claimed to have a viewing on him and Jack Sparrow is not a slasher killer.

[Red2111]

all this is in answer to talya.

 

  But to say he is Jack Sparrow and that makes him scum is just off in my opnion.

 

you twist my words.  i never said that his character made him scummy.  i said his actions and ability do.  you need to go back and re-read.

 

I wasn't sure if he was admitting his role was the freeze person or not. And you did say earlier that Lily would be only frozen for a day, how do you know that it isn't for a day and a night?

 

krak said it in so many words, but i guess you were too buisy arguing against my logic to read his own words.

 

Jack Sparrow did whatever was best for Jack Sparrow. Lily washn't gunning for me, otherwise I would have tried to kills her.  Lily got drunkses with me because she knew everyone knew she wash innocent and wouldn't vote for her.  If all my role is, is "freezing" someone for a day, then how could freezing Lily benefit the mafia?  In effect, she just can't talk for one day.

 

again you need to pay attention tayla.  in nae's post she said the lily was passed out drunk.  pandy was also passed out drunk and his only lasted till night fall.  go back and check post #206 for verification from the mods post.

 

It could also be that if Pandy is another solo winner, that would make two, maybe Krak is one too, if he is Jack Sparrow, that would make another one. And you seem more releuctant to lynch a solo player and rather go for Mafia!

 

your last part makes no sense.  i'm around 85% sure that krak is mafia because of his actions.  which is why i started the lynch on him and why i haven't switched my vote from him.

 

- why would he freeze a suspected innocent person?

- why would he want to kill a suspected innocent person?

 

why ... because its a scum tactic and beause they wanted to take out the bigger role reveal which was pete's role blocking ability.

 

this is why i'm more after him than pandy, who is a solo winner.

 

[Krakalakachkn]

 

- why would he want to kill a suspected innocent person?

 

Exactly.

 

If I was mafia, why would I freeze the one known innocent person?  All that would do is create a bandwagon against me...like there is now.  No one was going to lynch her, and freezing her hardly constitutes killing her; she will be back soon.

[Aust]

Let's settle this. We lynch Krak today and I hide with either Red orPandy tonight. Sound good? If I die they then who I hide with is mafia. Sound good? After all what is a suicide hider for? I won't reveal to you all who I am hiding with till toward the end of night. End of discussion!

 

No more back and forth I am right you are wrong. You have both stated your cases and I don't think we need another 4 pages of the crap.

 

 

Everyone is suddenly revealing all these interesting powers!! Was anyone granted the ability to make a good mixed drink? No?

 

Well, this is a lot to try to sort through - but I have to say Min's idea makes a lot of sense to me, and is based on good logic. Initially I was a bit skeptical of Min but I think I was mostly just confused about understanding her and everyone's ability... but her plan is so nicely thought out I think her intentions are good! And Min's role makes her so important that if something goes horribly wrong and she does die Wombat could could revive her!

 

I will vote [glow=red,2,300]Krak[/glow]

[Krakalakachkn]

Avast Aust!  Why be ye condemning me to a hangin' matey?  We had some good times together, my right arm but we have!

[cosmicpanda]

Fine, I'll claim. I'm Harry Potter. TMD's claim that I'm supposed to be from the Dark Knight clearly ties in with Red's claim that I'm the Joker and therefore mafia. I'm thinking they're scum together.

 

I'm good at this game, right?

[Red2111]

*shakes head*  pandabear, i will say this. you never fail to amaze me.

 

 

considering that both ron and hermy are in here and hermy is a mason i've peiced together that if harry is in this game he will be the third mason.

 

 

[WWWwombat]

I had Ed pegged as Harry Potter.

[Alanna]

Well...put it this way. Since Ron and Hermione are in the game, it's obvious Harry is, too. So, he would be a pretty stupid role to fake claim, since the real HP could counterclaim.

 

Although I thought that as well, Wombat, after what he said about Hermione.

[WWWwombat]

Well we don't know Hermione is in the game but I don't see Ron being in the game without Harry and Hermione also being in it.  Furthermore, Ron was a mason, so I see them being in the game as a mason group of 3.  The fact that Ed has been gunning against Pandy means they are probably not both in this mason group.  It is possible that they are, but that would mean Ed has been misdirecting the hell out of us.  Assuming they are not both in the mason group, then either Pandy is lying or Ed's hint was complete BS.

[Minuet]

So, we are back to the back and forth claiming. Sorry, I still like my idea. If we get enough votes for Krack we can get on with it. Oh, and Krack if I don't die and you turn out to be innocent we can bring you back buddy.

[Krakalakachkn]

well that's something.  Hopefully you won't die  :D

[Alanna]

Yeah, I like your idea, Min. Vote [glow=red,2,300]Krak[/glow].

[Red2111]

 

Deadline

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.  You have until a majority is reached or friday at 11 am

 

Vote Count

Krak(9): Red, Ed, Verbal, Min, Tigs, Pookie, TMD, Aust, Alanna

Red(2): Pandy, Krak

Pandy(2): Rey, Wombat

 

no vote(2): Talya, Player

 

[WWWwombat]

If Krak flips innocent and has an unimportant role, should I bring him back?  I don't know.  I think I want to save this baby for someone important.

 

Once again, voting Krak gains us nothing.  Why wait on your night action, Min, when we could have gathered info faster by lynching someone who was actually likely to be scum?  KRAK IS NOT LIKELY TO BE SCUM AS HE WAS HINTING JACK SPARROW.  Whatever, the hammer has fallen, the decision is made.

[ed2funy]

Is this a hammer game?

Pandy. You are a LLL....a horrible one too.

 

You are either a Solo Win...or just a really dumb mafioso. As I would like to think you are smarter...I am thinking SW.

 

 

[Alanna]

Oh wow, I didn't realize I was the hammer. I don't like being the hammer lol.

[Minuet]

Unvote

 

Vote Krak

 

There Alanna you weren't the hammer. I was.

Red isn't Lily still in the game? I would wait for Naeann to see what the vote count is. I am not paying attention to it myself.