Mafia - A Christmas Tale - Mafia Won

[WWWwombat]

Actually it might not have helped that much lol; I just like to know things.

[Reyoru]

Lol

Cryptic Mafia

[WWWwombat]

It's the best kind!

[LedZepMan]

good lord, seven new pages while i was work for..........10 hours. jeesus.

 

Ok, its simple. there can be more than one mason group. a double voter is kinda like a role. see? simple.

 

alrighty then. I know you guys are new, but you two are really getting on me scumdar with your "I dunno, im new" routine.

 

especially you rey. with your.. "i cant explain" stuff goin on.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Rey[/glow], scumdar seldom lies.....

[Alanna]

NOOOOOOO. This breaks of my streak of never being lynched or nightkilled til endgame!

 

Bah.

[mmeeshal]

Okay, Zep, way to misinterpret.  Rey's played a few games, he's not "new," and he hasn't said anything about being new.  So as far as that goes...you're not reading the game thread right.

 

For the "I can't explain" thing, he specifically said he might be modkilled for something he'd said.  That doesn't sound like newbie uncertainty or anything, that sounds like he's claiming a restriction of some sort from the mod.

 

Pretty much two or three people have mentioned "I'm new" and only one or two with any regularity.

 

Please try reading the thread again, Zep, since you're obviously not really paying attention to it.  I know I'd like it if people voted carefully toDay, since we're basically at Lylo.

[LedZepMan]

i only read the last seven pages.....im not going through forty more lol.

 

as to the i cant explain thing, that smacks alot like pete in the resurrection game. just the opposite of what pete did.

 

maybe i should actually check the Op

 

 

[mmeeshal]

I think it's irresponsible not to read the whole thread if you're going to play in the game, Zep.  You won't know what we're talking about most of the time, then.  You'll be more of a hindrance and less of a help, and we would've been better off with a pretty much inactive Wolfie in that case.

[LedZepMan]

well meesh, excuse the hell outta me.

[mmeeshal]

:D I'm not trying to be mean; I just really care about this game and I don't want people to mess it up because they don't know what's going on; if someone messes up the game for the Town I want it to be something that we couldn't really have prevented.  Knowing that someone made a dumb decision because they didn't want to take the time to be properly informed is a LOT more frustrating and feels more unfair to the group as a whole.

 

So again, I'm not trying to be mean; I have a very strong opinion and I'm taking this seriously so I'm coming down hard.

[Al Jenn Mael]

  Quote

Did you mean to say something more after "Hopefully night can start"?  It had the sound of an accidental post or you forgetting to go and finish your sentence.

 

You're right it wasn't finished, had to go save the world from terrorists...ish.

Anyhow, I was going to go on and say hopefully the game could get moving on since not much was happening.

But I come back from my mission and the world has gone upside down.

 

Well unlike you I thought Alanna would have been the 4th Mafia person. Also Lily saying Pale is innocent, well my guesses are completely gone now.

 

Rey I'm surprised you haven't been struck down by the gods. I trust him. Try not to be so blatant, m'kay.

 

Well I'm not nearly as suspicious of you as I was and I'm now more inclined to trust you. More importantly though I agree with all you are saying. 6 vs 4... worst case. Makes any action critical right now. I didn't realize there might not be a finder or doctor, sigh. Well time to post my thoughts.

 

Lily-It was a bold move revealing day one, for either Mafia or Townie. I don't think the Mafia would take such risks so early. I'm still inclined to believe her, but my trust isn't what it use to be.

 

Mesh- I was really suspicious of until her current active beneficial role in directing us and more importantly Lily's announcement of pale.

 

Pale- Well either Lily is Mafia which I find... unlikely. Or you are good to go (Unless there is another ability, but that is starting to get over the top which Tayla wouldn't do)

 

Wombat- I had thought was innocent. I thought that since he was new all the roughness was from that. I'm a little more skeptical now, with the earlier overstatement of 'I don't know' (I can quote if you would like the multiple posts) and current play. However again I'm going to have to re-evaluate things.

 

Rey- I trust

 

Elli- Wasn't going to say my suspicions earlier, but I don't think it matters any longer. I thought she was the doctor. I had thought Talya would balance the Mafia/Townies experience wise and with my old suspicions Ellie would have helped balance it out. Currently she hasn't posted much and I don't know what to think any more. I'll elaborate below.

 

Led/Wolfie- Few posts and a newcomer. Not much to go on but again I'll elaborate below.

 

Meercat- I didn't find suspicious really, but with everything that has happened I'm going to go back and look at his posts. I'm inclined to trust Meeshs arguments.

 

Me- Well I trust myself obviously and I trust Rey and I think some people have shown sound reasoning.

 

Locke - A spammer who hasn't posted much or added anything of value. I'll elaborate below.

 

 

Elaboration - Ellie, Locke, Meer, and Led/Wolfie really haven't posted much to analyze at all. That in and of itself isn't suspicious but like Ellie said at an earlier point, if you didn't have time to play why sign up. It is... annoying.

 

Meesh I'm putting aside my suspicions for now since you are being very helpful/logical and keeping everything on track. I'm going to look back at your earlier posts and those 4 mentioned above and see what I can figure out. Things are dire right now and this next lynch is vital that we get it right.

 

 

Locke is number 1 on my list but I'm going to go look at Meer. What do you think of Ellie.

 

 

O' Led you didn't answer me, are you a townie? Do you have a role? And please listen to meesh and read through the 50ish pages because this next vote is important. Also please post your thoughts a fresh mind might be useful and turn something up.

[LedZepMan]

vanilla, like the extract.

 

yeah, well, after reading almost all of these dam pages, i changed my mind. and for reasons in just the last post

 

Rey- I trust, and pray tell, why is that, mason group much? i don't recall seeing much of a argument between you two until the confusion period was on. Ploy maybe. i dunno, but it seems you two are townies.

 

so that leads me to...............

 

Shaq!!!

 

off to work...........

[Reyoru]

[glow=red,2,300]Locke[/glow]

[WWWwombat]

I'm down with that.  [glow=red,2,300]Locke[/glow]

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm sorry, guys. DM refuses to let this thread notify me, and I keep forgetting to come check. I wish things would just work right. I don't have the best memory in the world, and I'm juggling multiple games.

 

I've addressed everyone's suspicions of me enough already, so I won't waste your time there.

 

Clearly, Rey and Al Jenn are hinting at being masons, and it seems to ring true. So does the inability to tell us. Pandy did that to Meesh and me once, when we were Millers, or something similar. So, they are low on my suspect list for now.

 

Pale is at the bottom of my suspect list, for now. So is Meesh. Not sure why. Just my gut.

 

And speaking of my gut, Zep, darling, you're pinging my scumdar loudly, but it's just my gut feeling. I trust my gut, so I'm voting you for now.

 

[glow=red,2,300]

Vote LedZepMan[/glow]

 

Tell me why I should change my mind....

 

 

 

[meercatman]

Here is my sort of analyisis:

 

Rey: Hinting at being a mason. THerfore a townie. I think.

 

Lily: I trust her. Noone else has claimed to be another cop, so she seems pretty trustworthy.

 

Locke: Not much happening (i cant say anything my self), but still suspicious.

 

Pale: SLightly pinging my scumdar, but just a very inexperienced gut feeling.

 

Elli: Not much happening, too hard to tell, most likely townie.

 

Ledzepman: Pretty new, hard to tell, but still pinging my scumdar.

 

Wombat: Not sure about him. Am suspicious, but if Locke turns out to be mafia, then I'll have to say his innocent, cos of his vote ^

 

Meesh: Was very suspicious about her for a while, but now not so much now. Just gut.

 

Meercatman: Im pretty sure iim innocent  ;)

 

Al Jenn: Hinting at being mason with rey, not so suspicious.

 

Just a question for ya'll: Could it be possible that there are only 3 mafia in the game?

[Locke]

It seems that either both Lily and Pale are both either innocent or both mafia.  I find it hard to believe that they're both mafia so I'd say they're both innocent.  At this point, I believe Rey.  So that leaves 6 of you, with, say 4 mafia. (excluding myself naturally)

 

So of Elli, Led, Wombat, Meesh, Meer, and Al Jenn, only 2 would be innocent.  Practically nothing to go off for Led or Elli.  Wombat has gone up and down and up and is kind of leveled off right now.  His latest vote of me could be an innocent thinking I'm mafia or mafia trying to take out another innocent.  Hard to tell.  Meesh has been the most active in this mafia game and appears to be trying to root out the mafia like a good townie, but you never know.  Still, she's more towards the bottom of my suspicions. And then finally, I'm not sure about either Meer or Al Jenn.  Could go either way for each. 

[Reyoru]

I trust Al Jenn

[Locke]

Care to elaborate on that Rey?

[Reyoru]

Locke, either you missed it earlier, or you're just stirring the pot.

[Locke]

???  What's wrong with me..... ohhhh... never mind....

[Reyoru]

You've pinged me. Hear that little pinging sound? *cataclysmic sonicboom PING*

 

That was my scumdar.

[WWWwombat]

I agree with Meesh's interpretation of the facts and think we are at lylo.  We need to get it right this time.  Locke is pinging me big time atm but Rey could be scum with Al Jenn and be trying to get us to lynch innocents.  I'm more inclined to believe Rey that he is innocent though.

[Locke]

Obviously; you already voted for me. 

 

 

[Reyoru]

;)