RAGNAROK AVERTED - TOWN WINS (Including EP)

[keyholder21]

6 hours ago, Krakalakachkn said:

Vote Count

 

Shad: Dice

Sooh: Krak, EP

Ed2funy: AJ, Shad

Kat: Sooh

Hallia: Duke

 

Not Voting (9/16)

BG, Kat, Amega, Hally, Let, Nyn, Len, Ed, DPR

 

~19 hours of day remain.

 

 

I believe this is where we are.

 

  :makeup:  noooooo, that was my favorite emoticon!  

 

Official VC incoming.  

[keyholder21]

Vote Count 1.4

 

Shad: Dice

Sooh: Krak, EP

Ed2funy: AJ, Shad

Kat: Sooh

Hallia: Duke

 

Not Voting (9/16)

BG, Kat, Amega, Hally, Let, Nyn, Len, Ed, DPR

 

 

Vote Count 1.1 | Vote Count 1.2 | Vote Count 1.3

[Nynaeve]

3 hours ago, Leyrann said:

Alright reads.

 

As I mentioned before, liking Dice, also liked his style later on. Strongest town read I got right now.

 

Also liking EP's aggressiveness and a number of his arguments. Lenlo doesn't stand out to me compared to what I'd expect from him, but I don't consider that in itself a town tell.

 

Otherwise I'm just going to need more time, I find it hard to get good reads day 1. Want to see more from @ed2funy and @amegakure, though I realize I am not really in a position to call them out on inactivity.

 

No one pinged you at all?

[Leyrann]

2 minutes ago, Nynaeve said:

 

No one pinged you at all?

 

Not much, it's a general problem with my reads on day one and, to a lesser extent, day two.

 

@Darthe Is a majority at deadline required or is it just "most votes at deadline = lynch, majority = lynch"?

[Darthe]

Most votes at dl, this is not a hammer game

[DPR]

11 minutes ago, Leyrann said:

 

Not much, it's a general problem with my reads on day one and, to a lesser extent, day two.

 

@Darthe Is a majority at deadline required or is it just "most votes at deadline = lynch, majority = lynch"?

 

Personally, I don't count this as "showing up". That leaves the inactive pool at ed, Ameg & Ley

[Nynaeve]

16 minutes ago, DPR said:

 

Personally, I don't count this as "showing up". That leaves the inactive pool at ed, Ameg & Ley

 

I am reading up on them. Did kat too. Gonna hit up on hallia as well.

 

Ed only posted once. Amega twice. Ley a couple of times where he talked a lot about catching up and how he was caught up now and itll be easier to stay caught up lol

 

Kat im conflicted on. She did characterise her town play to how she is this game but its not like as scum she'd be loud and shooting reads out of the wazoo so that did bug me a bit. Cause it's one sided and i would have liked it more if she would have added that too. Would have been more earnest. She also sounds a little too... cutesy.

 

Im reluctant about ed cause his inactivity... as well as amega's really.... is like utter inactivity. Ie feels more rl related then AI cause not playing at all cant get you far. So  would be mostly based on luck if we go there.

[Katiora]

15 hours ago, Duk3star said:

 

The infamous all null read list. 

Yes well it is D1 and my play of Mafia lately has been.... not very much, so I'm pretty rusty. I kinda had a hiatus for a while and I played one game and it's so darn addicting. 

 

15 hours ago, Sooh said:

Vote: Kat

 

So far out of all the leans I've read this is the one I agree with the most, and since I need to do this before I go to bed tonight, here goes.

..... explanation??? 

 

14 hours ago, Duk3star said:

 

But I thought you sucked at scum hunting and the only thing you knew was that you were ALWAYS town?

 

 

No... i said I always know my alignment. No one is ALWAYS town. Though this time I am. 

 

 

12 hours ago, Eternal Phoenix said:

Unfortunately, due to how certain things have been handled I am unable to pursue a case against Lenlo with a clear head, so I will move temporarily to a case I can pursue, Sooh. Once I can revisit my other case with a clear head I will.

Sooh comes in ignoring the one active discussion that is game related. There was literally only one. Mixes up just what is going on after claiming to be caught up. How can you be caught up if you have no clue what the one active game discussion was actually about? So I am fairly certain Sooh is not town. 

 

UNVOTE

VOTE: Sooh

 

I kinda agree with this. She is seeming to get hung up on things that have been at least semi-addressed, but is ignoring the part where it's addressed and won't let go of trivial stuff to make a case on. I'm not sure if this is just busy sooh that doesn't have enough time for the game or scummy sooh that's trying to see if anyone will bite on someone. I'm honestly leaning toward scummy because for her to vote me with no memorable case on me that I can think of besides I said "I hate d1" one too many times is a bit out of character for her for what I remember. But honestly my memory is crap these days. 

 

10 hours ago, Duk3star said:

 

This reaction feels a little ... extra? 

Dice is always extra. Always be worried about dice if he's not extra lol however it is not alignment indicative of him.

 

 

8 hours ago, Andrej said:

I don’t want to lynch Lenlo.

 

Sooh doesn’t really ping me yet either but I’d like some more involvement.

 

Several people have mentioned weird vibes from Kat so I could be swayed that way.

 

Hallia I’d need more concrete info on to decide but currently she’s about >rand to me

 

Ed is absent. Would lynch

Same with Ley

Yes... weird vibes from someone that has played one game in the past year and has had major life changes which have changed her personality somewhat.. probably gonna happen (just throwing it out there) 

 

 

7 hours ago, Krakalakachkn said:

Nyn - why all that posting and no voting?

 

Ley, Ed, Mega(seeds) - come contribute

 

Kat - gun to your head, who do you shoot with the other gun in your hand but that's not the person holding the gun to your head?

 

DPR - are you done squinting?

 

BG - why am I suspicious of you?

 

 

 

Is the answer popsicle? 

 

1 hour ago, Darthe said:

Good morning all!  Looks like mostly smooth sailing, which I want to say thank you for.

 

I think well of each of you, truly.  It's nice to be here with a group, many of which I consider friends, and I am happy to host games so that we can all have fun together.

 

Part of my responsibility in that is too make sure that we uphold site srules, and that we maintain a level of courtesy due to another person.

 

I don't want to have to speak on this a third time and so I won't.  The next offender, and any others, will be force replaced or modkilled.  Worse, you'll be hurting the game for everyone else.  If you've any trouble then P.M. me. You can say whatever you want, however you want, in there.  

 

Thank you for your time, let's get back to the fun part.

 

 

100% this. Come on ya'll this is supposed to be fun. If you don't like someone put them on permanent ignore or something. don't screw up the game for everyone because of a personal disagreement that needs to be handled outside the thread. We're all adults and if you don't like what someone says, it's a forum, not a real life convo. You have every right to ignore them and be the bigger person. I love you all. Please play nice *gives everyone puppy dog eyes* 

 

 

[Katiora]

1 minute ago, Nynaeve said:

 

 

Kat im conflicted on. She did characterise her town play to how she is this game but its not like as scum she'd be loud and shooting reads out of the wazoo so that did bug me a bit. Cause it's one sided and i would have liked it more if she would have added that too. Would have been more earnest. She also sounds a little too... cutesy.

 

 

are you saying I'm not normally cute???

[Shad_]

ok I guess I'm still playing so catching up in a bit

 

sorry for the lack of self-control to derail an on-going game like that

 

ignore is set so there will be no future issues

 

 

 

 

[bgrishinko]

I don't have strong enough doubts about anybody at this point. I'd personally rather go No Lynch than try and force something. 

[Shad_]

No Lynch is intensely boring and I'm against it pretty much always outside of a mylo scenario where the powers in play are known.

[Leyrann]

54 minutes ago, DPR said:

 

Personally, I don't count this as "showing up". That leaves the inactive pool at ed, Ameg & Ley

 

That's fair, I have no illusions about the level of my day one play in general and this game in particular. My reads will get better as the game goes on.

[bgrishinko]

Eh... That may be, but for Day 1 I think it's useful at times as well. 

[Leyrann]

Just now, Shad_ said:

No Lynch is intensely boring and I'm against it pretty much always outside of a mylo scenario where the powers in play are known.

 

Let's just stop talking about no lynch, it was super obvious Lenlo was just trolling when he brought that up. Not sure why anyone even bit that to be honest...

[Shad_]

6 minutes ago, Leyrann said:

 

Let's just stop talking about no lynch, it was super obvious Lenlo was just trolling when he brought that up. Not sure why anyone even bit that to be honest...

 

um

 

BG just suggested it as a serious option in the post I responded to. 

[DPR]

34 minutes ago, Nynaeve said:

 

I am reading up on them. Did kat too. Gonna hit up on hallia as well.

 

Ed only posted once. Amega twice. Ley a couple of times where he talked a lot about catching up and how he was caught up now and itll be easier to stay caught up lol

 

Kat im conflicted on. She did characterise her town play to how she is this game but its not like as scum she'd be loud and shooting reads out of the wazoo so that did bug me a bit. Cause it's one sided and i would have liked it more if she would have added that too. Would have been more earnest. She also sounds a little too... cutesy.

 

Im reluctant about ed cause his inactivity... as well as amega's really.... is like utter inactivity. Ie feels more rl related then AI cause not playing at all cant get you far. So  would be mostly based on luck if we go there.

 

Agreed on "cutesy" Kat. Her responses have struck me as being constructed. Nothing that screams "lynch her with a quickness" but enough to suspect her over others.

 

Agreed on ed as well - ed is famous for not showing up. But, as AJ pointed out, it behooves us to eliminate a no-show earlier than later. If we have a strong case against any player (which may still very well present itself) than voting for scum is always preferable. But if we do not wind up with a strong case, I'm down with voting an inactive off.  

[DPR]

15 minutes ago, bgrishinko said:

I don't have strong enough doubts about anybody at this point. I'd personally rather go No Lynch than try and force something. 

 

Having just made the case for voting an inactive in lieu of there not being a better option, we now have our first serious suggestion to vote No Lynch. 

 

You can't make this stuff up...

[DPR]

There is no world where I vote No Lynch today.

[Nynaeve]

18 hours ago, Hallia said:

Nynners talk to me about Kat, I'm having a blank; does she normally toot her own horn (giggity) wrt being town?  If it was from anyone else, it'd be setting off warning bells

 

Upin reread....Why isnt it setting alarm bells coming from her? You said you couldnt remember if it was a thing she does.

 

I cant decide if this is defense or trying to nudge me in her direction.

 

Clarify

[Nynaeve]

17 hours ago, Hallia said:

Right? XD

I like you  - I kinda feel the same about the Kat thing, it just seemed overdone to me.

 

Not a defense....hmm

[Shad_]

9 hours ago, Duk3star said:

Is ed usually active?

 

Not really; he hasn't had much time to play in his last few games.

 

I mainly went there over amega/ley because he already had a vote on him.

[Nynaeve]

3 minutes ago, DPR said:

There is no world where I vote No Lynch today.

 

Likewise

[bgrishinko]

2 minutes ago, DPR said:

 

Having just made the case for voting an inactive in lieu of there not being a better option, we now have our first serious suggestion to vote No Lynch. 

 

You can't make this stuff up...

 

I'm confused by this. I was opposed to the idea of voting an inactive. No Lynch seems like a better plan to me. 

 

I can understand the problem with no lynch. No Lynch = No Data is the mindset. But inactive lynch also brings no data and statistically much higher probability of a town death, so I don't see how inactive lynch d1 is preferable to no lynch. 

 

 

[Lenlo]

AJ: "That I don’t find him scummy? the claim read to me like he was annoyed with EP and wanted to get him off his back" You understand me so well.