I got dis

1 hour ago, Zander? said:

 

Not sure there's any reason for snark lol.  But for someone whose MO is known as not posting alot and whose Scum tell is to taper off when Wolf to be suspect when posting less than normal and seemingly playing into Scum Meta would be par for the course wouldn't?  Worst part is there's other reasons for the sus and inactivity I don't recall really making a huge deal about so.....#superconfusedbythis response??????!

I wasn't being snarky?

2 hours ago, Zander? said:

 

This is to Darthe again no pressure on either and this is happening when Verb is 3rd Party reasoning locked onto Turin.  I get it COULD be some light distancing but Darthes one of the top Town consensus Town reads ATP and with the amount this happens I'm thinking prolly a decent look for Verb? Thoughts peeps?

 

 

 

QFR as I told Turin I'd investigate this if he flipped Town......lol

 

 

I'm pretty sure tho not 100% reading back she's talking about Darthe here.  She's deadset in Turin top Town and Darthe seems too Scum but she ends up on DPR iirc.  This level of certainty a s correctness is GOAT level....or a Wolf with TMI...

 

 

This is irt to the quoted post above and again I think it's Darthe she's calling You (please correct me if in wrong)

 

 

Yay in hindsight we shoulda realized this but is it just me or does this scream look at me I have to be Town when he flips Town Town and I didn't hammer him.....?????

 

 

If Hallia a Wolf there may be a teammate here.

i was talkign about DPR there

also on weekends my 4 year old matters more than you sorry not sorry

13 minutes ago, Gudrean said:

@DPR   @Darthe    @Zander?    @Verbal32    @keyholder21    @Turin Turambar    @Cass @Ithillian Turambar

 

 @seph    @dicetosser1    @Hallia

 

Come chat with me in here while we wait for the N1 phase to end? Can't talk active game stuff but we can spam and meme and be fun before jumping back in.

 

I'm at the trampoline park with my 4 year old or I would 

13 minutes ago, Gudrean said:

@DPR   @Darthe    @Zander?    @Verbal32    @keyholder21    @Turin Turambar    @Cass @Ithillian Turambar

 

 @seph    @dicetosser1    @Hallia

 

Come chat with me in here while we wait for the N1 phase to end? Can't talk active game stuff but we can spam and meme and be fun before jumping back in.

 

I'm at the trampoline park with my 4 year old or I would 

I'm confused, is it not still night? Why is there game related talk going on?

4 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

You.know.who really.wants.to.hunt 3rd party? Mafia. 

Of your team I think Verb is least likely but I could see DPR for sure

Cass pretty null

14 minutes ago, Ithillian Turambar said:

TURIN - 5  (Cass, Zander, DPR, Dice, Verbal)

CASS - 2 (Darthe, Seph)

DPR- 3 (Hallia, Turin, Key)

 

Not Voting: Gudrean

 

6 votes required for a Majority.

 

We are at L-1

 

This is a Hybrid Hammer/Deadline Game

 

Day 1 is longer and ends 10PM BST (British Summer Time) on Friday 4th April

 

Day 1 Timer

https://stagetimer.io/r/UVDHPDFH/

Interesting that no hammer has happened

Are wolves already all on Turin or is Turin a wolf and teammates are staying off

dundundun

Just now, Verbal32 said:

 

Huh?

 

I assume this was supposed to say "I wanna win with the town", right?

 

If so, did Turin just spew himself 3rd party?  What am I missing here?

ope

if so then i was right and he isn't a wolf lol

4 minutes ago, keyholder21 said:

Was he? Where did you say that? Because he wasn't even mentioned in this post where you are discussing possible wolves.  And when I am looking through your posts courtesy of your profile, I don't see anything that mentions your feeling on him outside of your vote. You do question him at one point saying that you don't like it when people don't provide explanations, but as far as I can see that is the only hint at all and doesn't say much on its own.  And when you voted you didn't say you had been feeling he was sketchy to you for a long time, you said you voted him for his "horrible reason to vote" Turin.  

 

* brackets are my inclusion to make it clearer. 

maybe it was just in my head then lolme

21 minutes ago, seph said:

Ok, I am going to throw some snark bark lol.
Thank you for 10th post this game 🙂
In all honesty, I have never @ ed one person in a mafia game. It's your prerogative to be active or not ❤️

I've had more than 10 posts so this is wrong and rude

good luck you guys

15 minutes ago, keyholder21 said:

 

 

Literally in a post like three up from your comment on this very page???

 

 

 

 

Yes, because yours looks like teammate distancing, imo and I have thought DPR sketchy for a long time.

he was my first sketchy read also

So i have thought he was sketchy for a long time

59 minutes ago, keyholder21 said:

Vote DPR.

 

I would also be willing to vote Cass, but I think DPR's flip would give us more information.

wait my vote is horrid but you JOINED ME??

LOLOK

ded

37 minutes ago, seph said:

My WIM is gone and I don't feel like attempting to play atm. This will probably be my last big post as most of my thoughts are out there.

This was my POE
DPR, GUD, CASS, HALLIA, Turin, Verb..
Cass and hallia are impossible to talk to.
Verb has came in the thread once and I engaged him where I could.
The only people I have to talk to in my POE is GUD/DPR/TURRIN and Turrin has been in such a big debacle with others I haven't reached out and engaged him as much as I probably should.

I focused on the only other two people who actually show up in the thread. DPR sorry if it bugged you but I butt head with people to try and read them, look at literally any town game I have ever played. The fact of the matter is you ruined your slot for me town or wolf. If you are a wolf and made that post I am a little saddened that you need to actually go to such depths here, maybe that's a norm somewhere else, I don't know.
I said I was going to case you, I also said I was going to respond to quotes so I get the response of you calling it flailing to be honest. It was not a case, and I was responding to quotes trying to re evaluate your slot, and the Ugh's in the beginning were because I liked your posts. Re-reading I thought that your providing info, and playing the game even if I didn't like the direction or certain posts I read in a different light. I am unsure where to place you but I would rather lynch Cass today.

If you are a villager I get it, but this is a game and you are one of 3  active slot options I was trying to solve for. It's a game, and I am already remembering why I retired lol. 
GG's and goodluck town, I don't even know if I will be here for EOD. Enjoying wine and a show without this distraction sounds nice.

 

I'm impossible to talk to and yet you haven't @'d me once

mmhm

58 minutes ago, keyholder21 said:

Current reads.  Much of this I have already said in my catch up posts.

 

@Turin Turambar - As I explained in my last post, this is based off emotional investment more than gameplay.  Hate it if you want, but that's where I'm at. If he flips scum somehow then I REALLLLLY don't know what I'm doing and I will understand all the heat I will likely receive.

 

@DPR - Wolf, imo.  I feel like he's misreping/twisting a lot of things, specifically when posts are directed toward him (thinking of my posts and Seph's here).  I also don't understand his continued focus on putting me and Hallia together. His post above is at least the 4th time this game he's put us together. Like this sticks in my brain bad because Hallia and I have played very different games so far and it reeks of tying a townie to a wolf that's taken some heat. I haven't hated all his posts, but I have paid attention to people saying he can replicate his town game as scum.  

 

@Darthe - townread admittedly a lot of it based on old meta, but I don't feel like I'm playing any differently so why should I expect that he is?  I don't see wolfdarthe playing as sloppy or giving Turin an easy out.  I also like a lot of the questions he's posed to other people, and feel that's protown. This is also colored by my feel that Turin is town so lolme.

 

@Cass - scum lean.  Low contributor in terms of volume and then low content when she's here. I don't understand the random dicetown read and I don't remember her actually answering this? I also hate her vote as a pop in and implication that the vote had to be between Turin and Darthe.  Further in the posts she has been here, she's left defense for DPR, although this point specifically hinges on DPR being scum.

 

@Hallia - scum lean.  Low contributor, no explanations, wolfy pop-ins and horrid vote. 

 

@Gudrean - mild town read.  This is mostly off do I see new scum posting like this.  Is it the best reason?  No, but that's what I got. 

 

@Verbal32 - scum lean, just like cass low contributor in terms of volume and low content when he's here.  Many of his posts don't have anything to do with moving the game along, imo, and they look like an attempt to look like he's here doing things but actually isn't doing anything.

 

@seph - town read. I haven't liked everything he's said, but many of our reads are the same and he seems to be coming at the game the same way I am, which makes me feel good about him. He's also followed up on what he's said he would (so far) and that is, in general meta not person specific, to me a townie thing to do. 

 

@dicetosser1 - null atm because I liked/agreed with somethings that he said, but I didn't like others.  I felt like his null list and reasons were meh and even though she has a scum lean for me, he left himself an easy out with his Hally read.  I do like his town list though and reasons, hence null. 

 

people keep saying my vote is horrid but not why

1 hour ago, Verbal32 said:

 

 

I know this wasn't at me, but I can say I did not read up on it.  Theme = flavor, unless the mod says otherwise.  And the mod has not said otherwise.

 

TBH any discussion on this topic is meh at best and gaming the mod at worst.  Or to put it in the terms of the new gen peeps, "angleshooty".

agreed;

who are your top two that you mention

27 minutes ago, DPR said:

Huh. Here I saw it as a really good reason to vote. 

I’ve been away for a while - is WIFOM a good thing now? Are we all supposed to weave the theme into the gameplay now and hint at each other? Or go emo on d1 for no apparent reason over arguments with confirmed townies? 
 

This is a terrible post and vote. 

 

I play somewhere else for the most part now so maybe I've changed, but i don't think emotion is a reason to vote someone; it isn't alignment indicative imo

long hair don't care

55 minutes ago, DPR said:

My vote on Turin is based simply on the fact that he has been WAY too emotional about the game and spread WIFOM like confetti on New Year’s Eve. Regardless of how he plays, he’s been in enough games to know it’s bad for the Town - look how much time we’ve already had to spend discussing it. 
 

Im not in favor of meta replacing the obvious. 

on its face this is a horrible reason to vote someone

SO MUCH SO

I'ma

Vote: DPR

wait why is turin the top wagon

stupid meetings

stupid 55 pages

*grumble*

2 hours ago, DPR said:

The rest of my reads:

 

@Darthe is all over the place playing the provocateur. He's changed his vote more than anyone else and admittedly pushed multiple trains. I still have no idea what his stream-of-conscious post was about and I'd love for him to explain it. It's a little early to call WolfDarthe or TownDarthe, but I'm not a big fan of his coming out of the gate strong the way he has. I called him out for trying to assume early leadership and I see him fill-flopping votes more than making cases or building a core. 

 

@seph is clearly obsessed with pirates. I'm sure I'll be going point by point with him later, but it seems avoidable if he can see himself as tunneling and not actually having a point.

 

@Gudrean It's my first game with Gud and her third game. Multiple players that have played with her before are suspicious of her, so it would be counterproductive to not listen to them. I need to reread her posts because there was something she said in the last 24 hours that made me wonder how she knew it, but I need to find it. It wasn't damning, just subtle, but it stuck out to me. 

 

@keyholder21 and @Hallia have both been fairly inactive. I've seen posts from both that I *felt* like were posts for the sake of posting moreso than actual content. But, I do also understand that it's d1, that the post count has been a PITA to keep up with (looking at you Turin) and that they may very well kick into gear later in the game. Because this is based on a *feeling* I will transcribe my thoughts into Spanish, Egyptian Hieroglyphs and Interpretive Dance versions for dice in case he needs those lol.

 

@Verbal32 and @dicetosser1 are both doig what they normally do. Low activity because of work is nothing new for them. They'll be easier to read on d2 and d3. 

 

@Cass So far she has taken up the least amount of my thinking this game. I don't love some of her posts, but whatevs, d1, etc. Her following Darthe's vote on Turin bothered me because it came directly after his weird post, as if she understood what he was saying. She didn't give reasons or info, just hopped on that train. That bugged me. 

 

At this point, I'm looking to Zander more than anyone else for his reactions. That's what I got.  

 

 

Yeah Wednesdays are my cannot post at all day, I'm in office the one day a week + 4 year old at night

I'm here now; any cliffnotes would be appreciated while reading up

4 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

It still sketches me out every time. And probably will every time in the future. 

#somthinsomthinolddogsblahblahblah

turin remains my strongest town read outside of zander

lolololololololololool

18 hours ago, Darthe said:

Why?  If you disagree then explore that more or explain your stance better or something.  Isn’t that the game?

 

fwiw, I think this is NAI, just generally chatting about the philosophy of it

didn't feel like it would be productive at that time, i'm happy to

*is also

38 minutes ago, Turin Turambar said:

Caught back up and on reread Zander was actually  breadcrumbing the heck out of his role. But he was also.being slightly sketchy about it, lol. Hindsight making it clearer what he was talking about. I still wish he would have held on to it but he gets to play his own game.

 

Still don't like Gudrean on the all town post and her reasoning afterwards.  Also her reasoning that I'm sus because something I did last game feels like a fake easy read.

 

Cass makes me nervous because she has been the only one.really defending means that always.makes me nervous. I'm town, but she doesn't  know.  I think her reasoning makes sense but it always causes me trepidation. 

 

Hallia kinda the same as Cass.

 

Dice has seemed okay so far. Still want more insight. Willing to wait.

 

Key, don't agree with her read on me. Don't really see how she got there so ??? Also she says she reads me wolfy in general.  Did you read the recent games, or are you judging it on previous experience?

 

Darthe was making faces at Zander right up to his reveal  and immediately switched to me. Hasn't given a reason as far as I know. He did unvote but says I'm still low. No like it. Maybe he is just stirring the pot. Well see.

 

Seph: I thought he was riding Zander's coattails bit early. I'll hold judgement on his catchup.

 

Zander: obviously confirmed town

  Reveal hidden contents

I may have thrown up in my mouth just a little,  lolololololol 

DPR: so far so good. I have something I wanted to ask but can't remember rn.

  Reveal hidden contents

Has done a good job, will probably lynch tomorrow,  lolololololol 

I'm missing someone.  I'm getting too old for this.

"only person defending'

"this person is always doing it"

wat

1 hour ago, DPR said:

 

not liking anything happening here

and i'm not liking people saying things without explanations so I suppose none of us are pleased