Ghostbusters Mafia - Game Over - Mafia Wins!

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

 

My point is he could fairly easily avoid the suss by giving a safe read. I think he would be well believed.

 

To face the fire for being blocked is just giving more time for a cc with less value.

 

Anyone gonna admit to blocking him?

Or if Tsuki was mafia he could give any read on a town and be pretty confident that it was right (chance there's a 3rd party who doesn't view town)

It would have to be a town read tho.

 

I only chose myself because I'm the only person I know is town.

Depends, Wombat faked a guilty before lylo on me once sometimes it's just about survival, although generally you're right most faked reads will be town

Well we wanted to win and that was effectively lylo. This was D2 and it would have been convenient and wifom inducing if he got cc'd.

 

(Why is it people keep bringing up games that memorable things happened in which I was mafia??)

[BFG]

 

 

 

 

My point is he could fairly easily avoid the suss by giving a safe read. I think he would be well believed.

 

To face the fire for being blocked is just giving more time for a cc with less value.

 

Anyone gonna admit to blocking him?

Or if Tsuki was mafia he could give any read on a town and be pretty confident that it was right (chance there's a 3rd party who doesn't view town)

 

It would have to be a town read tho.

 

I only chose myself because I'm the only person I know is town.

 

Depends, Wombat faked a guilty before lylo on me once sometimes it's just about survival, although generally you're right most faked reads will be town

 

Well we wanted to win and that was effectively lylo. This was D2 and it would have been convenient and wifom inducing if he got cc'd.

 

(Why is it people keep bringing up games that memorable things happened in which I was mafia??)

 

I wish I could forget that game in it's entirety, it scarred me for a long time

[BFG]

What's your read on Rey?

[Turin Turambar]

As I recall it you played great but your team let you down. Mafia was pretty brash too which can throw off town.

 

I'm nearly off to sleep. You got any questions for me before I go?

[Turin Turambar]

Rey Kinda mixed for Me. I think he goes down more with a town RTE flip.

 

Not sure about his change on Dice. I thought he said he wanted Z yesterday and Dice today. But I think he is now on RTE. Not sure if he gave a reason.

[BFG]

 

 

​...

You wanna know who I viewed?? Are you a decent player at all?? Who was my ONLY real SCUM READ??

...

Lol that's because I'm Town. I try to take a leadership role as town and form a town core if nobody else is stepping up. That's what happens, if you think that's scummy then you got another thing coming when I flip town and I get to say "I told you so" yet again.

 

If you think I'm guiding the game, then maybe people shouldn't be followers and come to conclusions which help the town.

 

I have played in the BT before, been playing mafia on this site since 2010, so I don't know what your dig against me is about, like I don't belong here. I'm trying to win a game and that's it. Why do you keep trying to apply outdated tells to the game? "one scum lurks, one guides, one hangs out" That's not how the spread works. Depends on the player. Example: Matrix mafia: Cory/Alanna hydra, Zander, Dice, Lenlo scum team. 5/6 of these are high post count. All depends on the players, man.

 

I thought you said I wasn't your scum read Now I'm disappoint. Go ahead and view me though because I've got nothing to hide. I'm just frustrated (legitimately frustrated) that the game is lagging and I'm trying to put work into it without much support from other players. It completely takes me out of the game. After all, this is a TEAM game, not every man for himself, we should be working together but I. Don't. See. It.

 

Doesn't matter. I'm out, you can do what you want. I'll check in at next deadline.

 

When did I say you weren't my scum read? You were my ONLY scum read...

true, at one point I said I was feeling better about you, but that didn't magically move you to cleared, or even out of suspicion...

The dig wasn't intended as you don't belong here, it was intended as you should KNOW how the BT works because you've been here...

"...I'm Town. I try to take a leadership role as Town...' LOL, "listen to me spew my self town because this is clearly what I do as town, and so I must be town because I that's what I am doing..." <--- HATE posts like this.

Do you even read and comprehend??

 

But you are 'out' so I guess I shall look elsewhere, right???

 

I know this is a post you'll 'hate', but this is completely null for Laine. We've just been through a game with this exact same argument, Laine was town.

 

So is your read at this point mostly 'shepherding' and 'self_meta'?

[BFG]

As I recall it you played great but your team let you down. Mafia was pretty brash too which can throw off town.

 

I'm nearly off to sleep. You got any questions for me before I go?

In order to stop me tinfoiling, why with your read on Zander didn't you contrast his games between this one and Eldricks? Or did the other stuff just outweigh it?

[BFG]

Rey Kinda mixed for Me. I think he goes down more with a town RTE flip.

 

Not sure about his change on Dice. I thought he said he wanted Z yesterday and Dice today. But I think he is now on RTE. Not sure if he gave a reason.

Ok, thanks

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I'm here hold on.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Hally voted without an apparent reason, and later stated that she didn't see anything to change her mind.

 

Hally has poorly justified all of her votes, especially worrisome when she has been train jumping.

 

Dice sheeped my idea to have rte be the only train and voted him.

 

Don't think this necessarily incriminates him but don't think he's done anything towards solving the game today. Just back and forth with Turin mostly.

 

I voted him because the D1 lynch was screwy and I wanted results by having the only lynch be him. My other reason was his contribution level. Neither are good reasons and I unvoted.

 

Fair. But don't understand what you mean be D1 lynch being screwy. "Wanted results by having the only lynch be him" I don't understand.

 

Lenlo's reason is rte seems to be avoiding topic directly related to him.

 

And not enough activity I think? But as Turin pointed out, not sure what exactly I've avoided, not so much I can respond to, other than I need to just post more.

 

Laine's reason is his contribution level.

 

You would think for all of Laine's casing, attempting to get discussions going, etc., she would be looking for bigger fish to fry than someone who hasn't posted enough.

 

Shad doesn't list a reason. Lists reads on a bunch of players, but as for rte, his only comment is "he can die today".

 

Shad has been so null for so long he's trending scum for me.

 

 

As for which reasons are the worst, no apparent reason is easily the worst of the group (hally and shad)

 

Contribution level and solving what happened with d1 aren't good enough reasons by themselves (dice and laine), and being my only reasons are why I unvoted.

 

Lenlo's reason, that rte seems to be avoiding talking about topics related to him, is the best of the group.

 

 

I agree with that post. But again not sure what I'm avoiding, just that I haven't been here enough.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Responses in bold, evidently.

 

My strongest scum read today is Hallia. Her posts have been very thin, and her reasoning behind her votes even thinner. She's posting enough to contribute, but voting to blend and touting the party line, going with the popular trains.

 

Vote Hallia

[BFG]

Hey RTE :)

 

What's up?

[ReleaseTheEvil]

My character is the Subway Ghost, for what it's worth.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Hey RTE :)

 

What's up?

 

Eh, trying not to die on my birthday tomorrow?

[BFG]

Lol happy birthday for tomorrow!

 

But the day I take anything from a character claim is the day you should lynch me on the spot

 

Can you talk more about Hallia/Shad?

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

Official Vote count

 

RTE (5): Hallia, Dice, Shad, Rey, Sooh

Alanna (1): Tsuki

Shad (1): Turin

Dice (1): Eldrick

Hallia (1): RTE

 

 

Not voting (3): Niniel, BFG, Alanna

 

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to achieve a majority Lynch

 

 

Deadline is Tuesday 19 April @ 21.00GMT (due to the weekend). You can achieve a majority vote at any point prior to this.

 

Countdown to end of Day 2 Deadline

 

22 hours till deadline

[Ithillian Turambar]

And sleepingtons

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Lol happy birthday for tomorrow!

 

But the day I take anything from a character claim is the day you should lynch me on the spot

 

Can you talk more about Hallia/Shad?

 

Fair enough.

 

Hallia: Vote jumping, hasn't done anything to solve the game so much as voting where there was stronger existing trains, not justifying her own votes on her own merit, and not conveying enough of her own opinions, thoughts, and progression to support where she is and isn't placing her votes.

 

Shad has been so null for so long. Makes me feel like much ado about nothing, in a way. I'd compare him to Eldrick for example. Eldrick posts a lot but he goes out on limbs too. His views and votes change, he makes progress, he comments on others a lot more, and in some ways I feel like he sticks his neck out more. I don't get that same vibe from Shad. Shad is more distant, less risky in his posting IMO. I'd have to ISO him properly to get a better read but I feel like his being null to me for this long stands out to me. 

[BFG]

 

Rey, other than governor or x-shot unlynchable how you think to explain the lynch result from d1?

 

saying any combo of roles is impossible (or even unlikely) is not probably going to end well. That is the same trap as neighbors can't be v/v. I would be more likely to surmise that there are more non standard roles.

I don't know. I am not averse to the possibility to there being a governor, but can you think of a scenario were both a governor AND a stump, two pro-town vote roles would be in play? I think its pretty damn unlikely. If Dice really is the stump, he has nothing to fear from being lynched, and it would make us all more confident. It would actually also paint you in a more negative look in my opinion Turin. 

 

I'm prepared to vote Dice, or RTE or Niniel at present. I think a confirmed Stump Dice would clear things up nicely.

 

I'm confused by your actual read here (and above)

 

Do you think Dice is town or mafia?

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Reads from Town to Scummy

 

Turin

Laine

Sooh

Niniel

Eldrick

BFG

 

Tsuki

Rey

Dice

Shad

 

Hallia

[BFG]

Reads from Town to Scummy

 

Turin

Laine

Sooh

Niniel

Eldrick

BFG

 

Tsuki

Rey

Dice

Shad

 

Hallia

 

Why Tsuki?

[BFG]

 

Lol happy birthday for tomorrow!

 

But the day I take anything from a character claim is the day you should lynch me on the spot

 

Can you talk more about Hallia/Shad?

 

Fair enough.

 

Hallia: Vote jumping, hasn't done anything to solve the game so much as voting where there was stronger existing trains, not justifying her own votes on her own merit, and not conveying enough of her own opinions, thoughts, and progression to support where she is and isn't placing her votes.

 

Shad has been so null for so long. Makes me feel like much ado about nothing, in a way. I'd compare him to Eldrick for example. Eldrick posts a lot but he goes out on limbs too. His views and votes change, he makes progress, he comments on others a lot more, and in some ways I feel like he sticks his neck out more. I don't get that same vibe from Shad. Shad is more distant, less risky in his posting IMO. I'd have to ISO him properly to get a better read but I feel like his being null to me for this long stands out to me.

 

I don't hate either of these at an initial glance.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 

Reads from Town to Scummy

 

Turin

Laine

Sooh

Niniel

Eldrick

BFG

 

Tsuki

Rey

Dice

Shad

 

Hallia

 

Why Tsuki?

 

 

That cop claim is unequivocally the ONLY thing he has going for him this game. I don't even know if he's had any other useful post to the game thus far. Or even a reads list...

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I won't be on much, if at all, tomorrow. I should go back and quote Niniel's posts where she collects voting trains. Think those are among the most interesting things to look at, and largely (and oddly) have been ignored today.

 

Not sure what people ever expected me to say about what happened at Deadline on Day 1. As I said, got no information before or after it, so can't shed any light on what happened. Nice way for Mafia to incriminate me though and make sure I'm the obvious train for Day 2.

[alannalynn]

Why are you only just showing up now RTE? Can I also get reasons on your reads list?

 

(Alanna can't sleep and is on mobile laying in bed instead )