[Standard] - Hitchhiker's Game to the Galaxy - Game Over

[ReleaseTheEvil]

never ever does for me. Really can't go anywhere when it comes to Hallia and I'd rather not get into that unless it is for consolidation. Been burned so many times by this little lady.

 

Pral - Still. Not. Convinced. I also

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 think town would, by now, feel less bitter by the fact that I thought he was scum whereas Pral, IMO, still has eyes mostly for me. That persistence to me to the grave seems not only uncharacteristic but a bit much given 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

he keeps saying he'll come back to casing me but hasn't yet. Not my strongest scum read but I don't have much sign he is town really. Every post since Day 1 has had an OMGUS tinge to it and he just

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 seems really upset about everyone who voted against him day 1 and isn't dead, and that's how he's forming his scum list basically. To me that isn't pro-town play.

 

Dice - I'm at a loss with Dice. There were a couple situations 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I was contemplating where I thought maybe he could be town but they seem to be narrowing and narrowing, as his posting is by no means helping him at all. Just weak and poor reasoning, and weak posts. Would like to see 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

something of sustenance. But most importantly right now the self-target watch really irks me. Can't put my finger on it at all. Dice you need to get in here and look like you're playing to win and catch scum. Right now all 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

we have from you is you're a sketchy watcher with poor reasoning and poorer posts.

 

I know there is another scum out there but right now I'm struggling. Again, between Des and Corey I think Des looks much more town but at 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

the same time I do have a town lean on Cory. Changed player since the emo outbreak. Actually more grounded than he was before it too and seems to have town's interest in mind, except for when he always comes back to

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 Des. It's getting a bit old... But he has been sharing his views and notes and looks town to me as well. It's a shame Leelou has been busy lately because I would like to hear a lot more from her now.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 With Nyn gone, her main interactions will probably be with Verbal and that will be very valuable from them both as they slip into the null read category for me. I don't know Vos but looks alright to me. I believe Thane.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 I want to hear more from Tina. One of my solid town reads but has gone a little too quiet for my taste. BFG is town in my books at this point, although that switch from Pral being scum to town was 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

a bit more... sudden than I'd have liked, but it is what is. 

 

Going to [v] Dice [/v]. Can move to my other scum reads but I think this is the place to start. Will be a bit scarcer from now till deadline

[nervositee]

From what I've gathered so far I'll [v]Hallia[/v].

 

With dice and verb as runner-ups to the throne as it stands

[dicetosser1]

Lazy is off for me, with his current headings.... dice's night action doesn't make sense..... for me, two scum there. Now the other 2...

 

So you see no logic in my decision at all? Try to remember I am an info gather type role. more info = good for town.

 

 

RTE  dont really know what more to tell you.

 

 

AJ  I can agree with your ISO on Hallia. I had already noted her popping up when her name was mentioned ....watches for hallia now.....but that ISO cemented it for me.

 

Vote Hallia

[Cory Caboose]

Got into work at 7am

 

Leaving now

 

Yay

[Cory Caboose]

I needed to go to the bank today

 

I would assume they are closed now

[Hallia]

I'm suspicious of the people not voting me.  I'm an easy lynch, as I've made myself.  (No, I would not have really shot Tina, given the opportunity.)  I'd say the people pushing hardest on me today are quite safely town, (IE AJ.)  I'm most suspicious of RTE, as he is never afraid to vote me.  I'm normally the one person he latches onto.  Instead, he picks Dice over me, whose claim I do believe.  And also regarding Pral, this from D1 was pretty suspicious.

 

 

Also, inb4 one of the townies says "So long and thanks for all the fish" in his Bah post..

 

There, you all lost your one creative reference idea. 

 

It sounds, though a joke, like he is addressing townies as if he isn't one.  That on top of the stalled lynch today make me confident he's scum

 

 

Vote Pral

[Hayl3y]

Votecount 2.03

 

Thane: 1 - Despo,

Hallia : 5 - AJ, Leelou, Thane, Vos, Dice

Dice: 1 - RTE

Pral: 1 - Hallia

 

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch

 

Not Voting: Lazy, Tina, Cory, Pralaya, BFG, Verbal


 Deadline Thursday 8 pm GMT - Day 2 Deadline

 

[BFG]

 

Lazy is off for me, with his current headings.... dice's night action doesn't make sense..... for me, two scum there. Now the other 2...

 

So you see no logic in my decision at all? Try to remember I am an info gather type role. more info = good for town.

 

 

RTE  dont really know what more to tell you.

 

 

AJ  I can agree with your ISO on Hallia. I had already noted her popping up when her name was mentioned ....watches for hallia now.....but that ISO cemented it for me.

 

Vote Hallia

 

The problem is that it's unlikely that you'll 'see' a mafia role visiting you. A Role blocker visiting you is going to role block you so you won't get a result. Nor will you be able to share results of somebody killing you... so chances are high that the person you 'see' is going to be Town. This is why watching yourself makes sense from a mafia pov.

[BFG]

I'm suspicious of the people not voting me.  I'm an easy lynch, as I've made myself.  (No, I would not have really shot Tina, given the opportunity.)  I'd say the people pushing hardest on me today are quite safely town, (IE AJ.)  I'm most suspicious of RTE, as he is never afraid to vote me.  I'm normally the one person he latches onto.  Instead, he picks Dice over me, whose claim I do believe.  And also regarding Pral, this from D1 was pretty suspicious.

 

 

 

Also, inb4 one of the townies says "So long and thanks for all the fish" in his Bah post..

 

There, you all lost your one creative reference idea.

 

It sounds, though a joke, like he is addressing townies as if he isn't one.  That on top of the stalled lynch today make me confident he's scum

 

 

Vote Pral

 

This does nothing to address the case that AJ made.

 

So why did you say Tina if you didn't mean Tina?

[dicetosser1]

and yet having that info can be good for town as it can help stop mislynches

 

it allows at least me more info to clear people with.

 

Obviously there is a flip side as shown with Des.

[Pralaya]

Pral - Still. Not. Convinced. I also think town would, by now, feel less bitter by the fact that I thought he was scum whereas Pral, IMO, still has eyes mostly for me. That persistence to me to the grave seems not only uncharacteristic but a bit much given he keeps saying he'll come back to casing me but hasn't yet. Not my strongest scum read but I don't have much sign he is town really. Every post since Day 1 has had an OMGUS tinge to it and he just seems really upset about everyone who voted against him day 1 and isn't dead, and that's how he's forming his scum list basically. To me that isn't pro-town play.

 

Well, RTE, this post is just an example of why I am suspicious of you. Here you are presenting a blatant misrepresentations of events in the thread. Either you have not read the thread or trying to twist the facts intentionally.

 

Coming to specifics,

1. I had you as a scum long back at D1 in this post. Much before you started FoSing me. So, how is that OMGUS? If anything, you are the one trying to portray me as scum because I named you as my scum suspect

2. If you missed my views in the game, I have BFG and Leelou as my town reads currently. Only you and Hallia are my scum reads among those who voted me. So, I fail to see how I am making my scum list out of all those who voted me. Naturally, I am going to suspect some of them as scum based on the context of the votes because it sure cannot be a pure-town train. in this case, yours and Hallia's votes are quite suspicious, which I have elaborated yesterday

3. I have indeed pointed out the posts where I find you suspect. Especially in this post and this post and this post. So, I fail to see how you are saying that I am not casing you.

 

Essentially, none of your points on me are true and you are just picking it off thin air. Neither have you replied/responded to any of my posts where I have cased you. Why would that be? 

[Pralaya]

and yet having that info can be good for town as it can help stop mislynches

 

it allows at least me more info to clear people with.

 

Obviously there is a flip side as shown with Des.

 

Disagree. Catching scum > catching town.

 

First, I don't know how it stops mislynches if we are not convinced that you are town in the first place.

Second, the number of scum is much less than the number of town. So, catching scum is always better because town can afford some mislynches.

[nervositee]

 

and yet having that info can be good for town as it can help stop mislynches

 

it allows at least me more info to clear people with.

 

Obviously there is a flip side as shown with Des.

 

Disagree. Catching scum > catching town.

 

First, I don't know how it stops mislynches if we are not convinced that you are town in the first place.

Second, the number of scum is much less than the number of town. So, catching scum is always better because town can afford some mislynches.

 

 

I agree(ish). To the first point, even if one town knows that one other is town - its beneficial. Could also claim (no claims are certain, but fake-claims are quickly found out). 

 

So, if we were about to mislynch a town PR, then he could come and say "eyh! Town PR here! Lets look elsewhere!" without that player having to claim a specific role. 

 

Other than that, I do agree it's not the best course of action. Killing scum is still better than protecting town PRs. 

 

As I said earlier, we're gonna have to decide if he did a stupid thing or a scummy thing. While I can somewhat understand the action, I haven't been too fond of his defense. 

 

Dice, what are your reads now?

[Niniel]

I'm suspicious of the people not voting me.  I'm an easy lynch, as I've made myself.  (No, I would not have really shot Tina, given the opportunity.)  I'd say the people pushing hardest on me today are quite safely town, (IE AJ.)  I'm most suspicious of RTE, as he is never afraid to vote me.  I'm normally the one person he latches onto.  Instead, he picks Dice over me, whose claim I do believe.  And also regarding Pral, this from D1 was pretty suspicious.

 

 

Also, inb4 one of the townies says "So long and thanks for all the fish" in his Bah post..

 

There, you all lost your one creative reference idea. 

 

It sounds, though a joke, like he is addressing townies as if he isn't one.  That on top of the stalled lynch today make me confident he's scum

 

 

Vote Pral

 

You are suspiciouos of people not voting you? So you agree that you have played scummy? Why did you mention me out of the blue, especially since you didn´t mean to kill me?

 

 

 

 

Verb - no, you are not alone. Cory´s usual mantra is that town should show that they are town. He did not do that yesterday. In fact, I will go back to my vote on him.

 

[v] Cory [/v]