[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[keyholder21]

 

I figured the cop would view me or Kaylee, so I thouhht it was weird when Cloud said it. Wasn't going to question an un cc'd cop though. Good way to get speedlynched lol.

I fully advocate questioning un cc'd cops if they still seem scummy, btw. Not a fan of auto-clearing someone after they claim when the setup could be wildly different than you imagine (no cop, multiple cops, etc.)

Fair enough on the different setups, but in every game I have ever played, the player/s that question the uncc'd cop get called scummy or lynched. Unless the real cop comes out to end it.

[hazelkrs1]

I had Ishy as strong town, his reads seemed to mirror my own. Fooled me good.

[Andrej]

I was reading Ishy as Town too

 

I knew something was off with Dice though so I was a little gratified after looking at the dead thread for confirmation.

[hazelkrs1]

@Mish: all the replacements would have hurt town, but I think we still would have pulled through. Might have been a good idea to just Modkill Luci. And I wish people wouldnt say they can replace in if they can't commit either, really just exacerbates the problem.

 

@Key: that trend seems to slowly be changing. Town has been burned enough by clever mods and setups to not take everything at face value so much anymore.

[keyholder21]

@Mish - idk. The game would have gone on and our relationship might have changed. They might have buddied up or backed off. As it stood right now, no, probably not. Ishy and dice tried pretty hard to get me lynched heh.

 

@des - I'm glad to hear that it's changing. I haven't played in a long time, other than vaca mafia and we disn't have that happen so I don't have the same knowledge of what's going on around here. Good to know though :).

[peacesells]

 

I hand Ishy to the town team on a platter and you guys don't lynch him. Shame, shame, shame. Wow.

Not sure what you are referring to here. I knew he was mafia though *g*. Perhaps why he kept calling me scum lol, because he knew I could read him like that.

 

 

Night 1 I implied I was the cop and was gonna view Ishy.  I had strong scum read on him.  No one even wondered why I was night killed?  Seriously?  I set it all up on purpose that way. 

[keyholder21]

It was WIFOM and Kay gave him a great out the next morning.

[csarmi]

ZOMG @Despo being a fairy... again :D

[Tommyrod]

Cloud and Dice became really obvious at the end. I have a policy to give Cop claims some breathing room, but you guys should trust Tom a little more. I tend to get there in the end.

Darthe: wow. Lol

[Tommyrod]

Can't believe tommy was town.

I try to change it up but I can't believe you were so off

 

I was convinced you were mafia/survivor just because of how opposite your reads ended up being

 

 

[csarmi]

@Tom - one of the most awesome catchup post series I saw, was fun to read

[Tommyrod]

@Tom - one of the most awesome catchup post series I saw, was fun to read

After you play X number of games you get a good sense for what is someone's actual thought process and what was forced 

 

I am bad at differentiating newer players from scum (Luci) but am trying to get better

[csarmi]

You looked pretty much town zo me on your catchu. But I was just peekign in from the outside.

[michellem]

ZOMG @Despo being a fairy... again :D

 

LOL I KNOW :D I laughed my ass off. Generally, random did a good job on this, I couldn't have designed the player list better myself!

[Darthe]

Yeah dude I was far afield this game.

[dicetosser1]

until this final day when tommy started on me I thought id done a good job of seeming town and staying the hell away from cloud.

 

its all tommys fault!   

[Tommyrod]

I'm just bluffing I have no idea what I'm doing 

[Kaylee]

 

@Tom - one of the most awesome catchup post series I saw, was fun to read

After you play X number of games you get a good sense for what is someone's actual thought process and what was forced 

 

I am bad at differentiating newer players from scum (Luci) but am trying to get better

 

You were the first to say you thought I was town. Made me feel better because I was getting frustrated doing all those cases and having no one read or comment on them!

[Krakalakachkn]

Thanks for all your effort, Mish. I enjoyed it while it lasted.

[michellem]

Here's the mafia QT:

 

http://www.quicktopic.com/50/H/6TKKibvquUbR