Ten days after Samhain, 1057: Night 5 (CONCLUDED)

[Hallia]

and SHUT UP ISHY MY FEET AREN'T HAIRY!

[Hallia]

Erm.  Wrong thread. >.>

[dapianoplay3r]

New voting thing?

Running up trains

 

People used to be so scared of doing it

[Verbal32]

JN strikes again

[Darthe]

It's like an alloy where JN gets screwed and DM grows a little better at the cost of many people's souls.

[bgrishinko]

FOS the 3rd 6th and 9th votes, cause we all know scum vote on the 3's.

[WWWwombat]

It's like an alloy where JN gets screwed and DM grows a little better at the cost of many people's souls.

I think Verbal ran a bastard setup about that once...

[Krakalakachkn]

Csarmi

[Darthe]

The Machine of Souls. Or something to that effect.

 

I wish I had been around to play in it.

[Darthe]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT 2:

 

Salami (10/12): Leelou, Cloud, Nol, Yayes, Verb, Ishy, Razen , BG, Dap, Krak

 

BG(1/12): Salami

 

Not Voting (12/23):

Chuckles, Mish, Hally, Lenlo, Crush, Des, Peace, Tiink, Tina, Ree, Pral, Serra

 

I keep waiting for myself to post a VC in the wrong thread or something.

[Nolder]

It's like an alloy where JN gets screwed and DM grows a little better at the cost of many people's souls.

[Leelou]

lol

[The Crusher]

The Salami train is sad. Reminds me when people at Jn got lazy and would just run people up instead of scum hunting. This place is like a freaking mafia dog crap time capsule. 3 threads of Verb is three too many.  

 

vote verb

[Yates]

The Salami train is sad. Reminds me when people at Jn got lazy and would just run people up instead of scum hunting. This place is like a freaking mafia dog crap time capsule. 3 threads of Verb is three too many.  

 

vote verb

[The Crusher]

 

The Salami train is sad. Reminds me when people at Jn got lazy and would just run people up instead of scum hunting. This place is like a freaking mafia dog crap time capsule. 3 threads of Verb is three too many.  

 

vote verb

 

 

That's what she said.  

[serra]

Hey y'all. I read the three threads and I gotta say that, for the most part, I have to agree with what Nolder, Yates, and people have been saying. We'll probably have about 5/6 scum per thread, which is about 1/4. If we can identify someone who is certainly scum in at least one of the games, our optimal strategy is to start lynching him in the game in which he is scummiest. If he flips scum, it isn't particularly likely that he'll flip scum again, so it's better to refocus on someone else, whereas if he flips town, that only increases the chance of him being scum in the other games.

 

As to Cserna: he deliberately started his three threads in the same manner - with the exact same phrasing, in fact. If he were town in all three threads, his natural thought process wouldn't be to determine how to convince people of the fact that he is the same in all three, but rather he would react naturally and fluidly to what had been posted. His uniformity across the threads is forced as f anything. I'm certain he's scum in at least one of his threads, if not two, so starting by lynching him in his scummiest thread is really our best move at this point.

 

Cserna, would you be willing to claim the game(s) in which you are scum? If you do, we'll lynch you there, and since it would then be disadvantageous for us to lynch you elsewhere, leave you alive in your other game(s). If you do not claim a game in which you are scum, we will start lynching according to popular opinion, so probably with this thread, until we hit scum. Look at this as a compromise:  rather than lose 2 or even 3 slots (depending on how well we read you), you can survive today with 2 slots intact.

 

I very much intend to vote Cserna once I have a good idea about which thread I'd most rather see him lynched and preferably once he's responded to my question.

 

Given the entirely cross-thread nature of the case for voting Cserna, I'm a bit surprised by the difference between the wagons on him (Gosh this is unusual terminology :/). I'll look at his wagons and see whether I can find potential scumbuddies wanting to avoid an early bus. I'll have to rely on you guys for helping me out with meta about that. I assume most of you have played with each other and can at least suggest whether others would join an early wagon to get their scumbuddy lynched. I know Ree and Yates wouldn't hesitate joining an early bus wagon, but I know many people that would.

 

Once I see a useful way to differentiate the three threads, I'll start posting isolated reads for each thread, but from a first readthrough, Cserna was my primary interest, and I think all that remains is deciding where to lynch him first.

[Hallia]

Remind me again why you don't play here more often?

[serra]

I think these are the current VC's for Cserna:

 

Thread 1: Salami (10/12): Leelou, Cloud, Nol, Yates, Verb, Ishy, Razen , BG, Dap, Krak

Thread 2: Salami (7/12): Nolder, Cloud, Yates, Verb, Leelou, Razen, Dap, 

 

Thread 3: Salami (8/12): Nol, Yates, Verb, Leelou, Razen, Cloud, Peace, Dap

 

This is less interesting than I'd hoped. The Peace vote in 3 is the worst, but not by much, really. It's quite likely that Ishy, Verbal and Yates AREN'T Cserna's buddy in the respective game where he RVS'ed them. If he's going to bother maintaining uniformity like that, I'd bet he would also avoid that sort of association with his buddies. Each Cserna-flip would thus come with an additional prob-town slot, which is a pretty good incentive if you aren't convinced yet.

[The Crusher]

Hey y'all. I read the three threads and I gotta say that, for the most part, I have to agree with what Nolder, Yates, and people have been saying. We'll probably have about 5/6 scum per thread, which is about 1/4. If we can identify someone who is certainly scum in at least one of the games, our optimal strategy is to start lynching him in the game in which he is scummiest. If he flips scum, it isn't particularly likely that he'll flip scum again, so it's better to refocus on someone else, whereas if he flips town, that only increases the chance of him being scum in the other games.

 

As to Cserna: he deliberately started his three threads in the same manner - with the exact same phrasing, in fact. If he were town in all three threads, his natural thought process wouldn't be to determine how to convince people of the fact that he is the same in all three, but rather he would react naturally and fluidly to what had been posted. His uniformity across the threads is forced as f anything. I'm certain he's scum in at least one of his threads, if not two, so starting by lynching him in his scummiest thread is really our best move at this point.

 

Cserna, would you be willing to claim the game(s) in which you are scum? If you do, we'll lynch you there, and since it would then be disadvantageous for us to lynch you elsewhere, leave you alive in your other game(s). If you do not claim a game in which you are scum, we will start lynching according to popular opinion, so probably with this thread, until we hit scum. Look at this as a compromise:  rather than lose 2 or even 3 slots (depending on how well we read you), you can survive today with 2 slots intact.

 

I very much intend to vote Cserna once I have a good idea about which thread I'd most rather see him lynched and preferably once he's responded to my question.

 

Given the entirely cross-thread nature of the case for voting Cserna, I'm a bit surprised by the difference between the wagons on him (Gosh this is unusual terminology :/). I'll look at his wagons and see whether I can find potential scumbuddies wanting to avoid an early bus. I'll have to rely on you guys for helping me out with meta about that. I assume most of you have played with each other and can at least suggest whether others would join an early wagon to get their scumbuddy lynched. I know Ree and Yates wouldn't hesitate joining an early bus wagon, but I know many people that would.

 

Once I see a useful way to differentiate the three threads, I'll start posting isolated reads for each thread, but from a first readthrough, Cserna was my primary interest, and I think all that remains is deciding where to lynch him first.

 

 

First off I would like to say this might be the longest post I have ever read in mafia and liked.  So what your saying is we keep lynching people until they admit the game they are scum in?  They tell us the game and we lynch them in that one and let them live in the others?  Works cause your guessing most people will probably not be scum more than once?  Other than having no clue who the hell Cerna is this is the first thing worth reading in all three threads.

[Hallia]

I believe cserna's csarmi

[Darthe]

MOD ANNOUNCEMENT:

A player has asked the following question:

 

"What is to stop a PR such as a Cop etc from revealing their info in another thread if they die in the thread that they are cop in?"

 

The answer is that once you are dead in a thread you are dead and no longer party to the information that you had when you were living.  Thus, that player revealing that would be no different from someone dead in all three threads revealing information that they know.  Additionally, since alignments are variable, it will not help you hunt in other threads.

 

This will be posted in all threads and the Information thread for your convenience.  Thank you.

[serra]

Tomorrow I'll go through the threads individually and hopefully get to post a bit more conversationally with some of you... I suppose I should perhaps try to keep my posts a bit more concise (or at least provide tl;dr's). 

 

Cserna = Csarmi = Salami...I don't know what happened there 

 

Optimally, we decide on someone (in this case Csarlami) that must be scum in at least one of his games. We give him the choice of outting in which thread he is scum or us lynching him one thread after the other until he flips scum. Once we have found one scum game, it is not particularly likely for him to be scum in another (at least not more-so than any other target), so we, for now, leave him alive in the others.

[The Crusher]

Tomorrow I'll go through the threads individually and hopefully get to post a bit more conversationally with some of you... I suppose I should perhaps try to keep my posts a bit more concise (or at least provide tl;dr's). 

 

Cserna = Csarmi = Salami...I don't know what happened there 

 

Optimally, we decide on someone (in this case Csarlami) that must be scum in at least one of his games. We give him the choice of outting in which thread he is scum or us lynching him one thread after the other until he flips scum. Once we have found one scum game, it is not particularly likely for him to be scum in another (at least not more-so than any other target), so we, for now, leave him alive in the others.

 

 

Kinda like Supersizing a reveal?  Crusher likey supersizing. 

[Darthe]

Csarlami

 

[Lenlo]

Is this the beginning of the mod spam?

 

*Puts on sailor hat*

 

Im ready for the ocean.