August 9, 2013: CONCLUDED

[Pralaya]

Don't buy that you would think it possible for their to be two town bus drivers for a second, not even long enough to preempt with that possibility.

 

I don't know about other mafia games. This is what I said while thinking about the possibilities.

 

Like I said, that is how I usually post. If you don't believe me, all I can say is that you are playing where the scum wants you to. 

[Krakalakachkn]

Dammit.

 

 

Tink at L-2

 

UnOfficial Vote Count:

Serra (4/8): Tina, Krak, Tink, Praline

Tink (6/8): Verb, Chuckles, Rorsch, Hally, Des, Serra

 

　

Not Voting (5/14):

Nol, Ishy, Razen, Len

[hazelkrs1]

Rorschach = Pralaya Krak. He can't be on both trains at once. So Tink is at L-3

[Verbal32]

Krak, just stop doing VCs, lol.

[hazelkrs1]

Unofficial Vote Count:

 

Derp(derp/derp): Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp 

Derp(derp/derp): Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp

 

Not Derping: No one.

[bgrishinko]

Wait...

 

What if both Serra and Pral are scum? If we believe that Pral is scum, his most consistent vote all game has been Tiinker, voted him Day 2 and today.

 

Think about it... Serra is lynched. Scum down = bad for mafia. Pral lynched as Vengeful = kill a townie at the same time + vet Serra.

 

 Also I think Krak is pushing it a bit too much and overreacting to get Pral lynched. Pral is probably Vengeful. Krak is probably a teammate. My idea about Serra is baseless thinking based on I found him scummy most the game.

[bgrishinko]

Furthermore, Tiink getting lynched if town would be good too for mafia.

 

No matter how many ways I look at it, I keep coming back to Krak, Hallia, and Serra as mafia.

[hazelkrs1]

I'm going to bed. BG, you just seem to be trying to throw us off the scent lately.

[bgrishinko]

Screw it.

 

Vote Tiinker

[serra]

@BG: You really think two scum would fakeclaim the same role, when that just means they can BOTH be cc'ed?

[bgrishinko]

@BG: You really think two scum would fakeclaim the same role, when that just means they can BOTH be cc'ed?

 

 

That's a good point.

[Krakalakachkn]

Krak, just stop doing VCs, lol.

 

[lolguy26]

right, thoughts before DM eats them again

 

For some reason i dont buy the claim or the CC, too much of a coincidence and the fact that after the whole affair, tink is now the leading train where as before it, he was on par with serra, so honestly, i think the mafia are confident enough to run a gambit, and it is paying off, since tink is the only train we have now

[serra]

What are you guys on about? There IS a bus driver...

[Niniel]

Oooh wow was ninja'd by a CC.

 

I believe it too. Came too fast for it to have been scum-motivated imo. Rorschach is way too inexperienced to have it would be a good idea to cc like that, and it came too quickly for it to have been coached.

 

I believe this as well. I don´t think Pralaya would have cc´d right away as scum. 

 

 

When is deadline? 

[WWWwombat]

Official Vote Count:

Serra (4/8): Tina, Krak, Tiink, Pralaya

Tink (6/8): Verb, Chuckles, Hally, Serra, Des, BG

　

Not Voting (4/14):

Nol, Ishy, Razen, Len

[WWWwombat]

8 hours

[Niniel]

Mod - when is deadline?

[Niniel]

Ah, ninja´d. 

 

Is anyone interested in moving to Serra? If not I will have to vote Tiinker but I rather vote Serra.

[John E. Kelley]

I'll vote Serra.

 

Vote Serra.

[WWWwombat]

Official Vote Count:

Serra (5/8): Tina, Krak, Tiink, Pralaya, Ishy

Tink (6/8): Verb, Chuckles, Hally, Serra, Des, BG

　

Not Voting (4/14):

Nol, Razen, Len

 

[Tiinker]

Vengeful Killer? If we lynch a scum and they VK one of us then we lose 2 town for 1 scum (assuming the night action is successful). 14 people alive - means we have 11 AND another scum down.

In thread 2 when 12 people are alive and only one scum down is when the thread concluded. If the game's all have a similar setup in their roles then this shouldn't be detrimental to the town.

 

(Alive) 6 - (Mafia killed) 3;

(Alive)12 - (Mafia killed) 1;

(Alive)11 - (Mafia killed) 2;

I'm quite tired right now but given those numbers, I don't think we'd be at endgame even with a VK. If we lynch wrongly however then the score goes down to 12-2 without a miracle doc save and the thread concludes. So I strongly suggest voting Serra. We're given a 50 50 here with pral or Serra and you guys are going to let WIFOM play the game for you..

 

[bgrishinko]

Vengeful Killer? If we lynch a scum and they VK one of us then we lose 2 town for 1 scum (assuming the night action is successful). 14 people alive - means we have 11 AND another scum down.

 

In thread 2 when 12 people are alive and only one scum down is when the thread concluded. If the game's all have a similar setup in their roles then this shouldn't be detrimental to the town.

 

(Alive) 6 - (Mafia killed) 3;

(Alive)12 - (Mafia killed) 1;

(Alive)11 - (Mafia killed) 2;

 

I'm quite tired right now but given those numbers, I don't think we'd be at endgame even with a VK. If we lynch wrongly however then the score goes down to 12-2 without a miracle doc save and the thread concludes. So I strongly suggest voting Serra. We're given a 50 50 here with pral or Serra and you guys are going to let WIFOM play the game for you..

 

 

 

Pretty logical to me.

 

Unvote: Vote Serra

[Verbal32]

Unofficial Vote Count:

 

Derp(derp/derp): Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp 

Derp(derp/derp): Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp, Derp

 

Not Derping: No one.

 

I LOL'ed.

 

 

 

Wait...

 

What if both Serra and Pral are scum? If we believe that Pral is scum, his most consistent vote all game has been Tiinker, voted him Day 2 and today.

 

Think about it... Serra is lynched. Scum down = bad for mafia. Pral lynched as Vengeful = kill a townie at the same time + vet Serra.

 

 Also I think Krak is pushing it a bit too much and overreacting to get Pral lynched. Pral is probably Vengeful. Krak is probably a teammate. My idea about Serra is baseless thinking based on I found him scummy most the game.

 

@BG: You really think two scum would fakeclaim the same role, when that just means they can BOTH be cc'ed?

 

Exactly.  One of serra and Pralaya is scum.  We can't vote Pralaya.  People seem too eager to vote serra, which makes me want to vote Tiinker instead.

[Verbal32]

 

Vengeful Killer? If we lynch a scum and they VK one of us then we lose 2 town for 1 scum (assuming the night action is successful). 14 people alive - means we have 11 AND another scum down.

 

In thread 2 when 12 people are alive and only one scum down is when the thread concluded. If the game's all have a similar setup in their roles then this shouldn't be detrimental to the town.

 

(Alive) 6 - (Mafia killed) 3;

(Alive)12 - (Mafia killed) 1;

(Alive)11 - (Mafia killed) 2;

 

I'm quite tired right now but given those numbers, I don't think we'd be at endgame even with a VK. If we lynch wrongly however then the score goes down to 12-2 without a miracle doc save and the thread concludes. So I strongly suggest voting Serra. We're given a 50 50 here with pral or Serra and you guys are going to let WIFOM play the game for you..

 

 

 

Pretty logical to me.

 

Unvote: Vote Serra

 

 

Not really.  A VK and then a NK mean a 2-1 swing for scum, which very likely would end the game.  The only plausible explanation for serra to be scum is if he isn't the VK, so scum wanted to out a PR while trying to get us to lynch neither.

 

Which would probably make Hallia scum, lol.