Pokemon Mafia III: The Treasure of Heart Island--GAME OVER--TOWN WIN

[Ithillian Turambar]

Well ... Folks need to decide and get on with it. I've already claimed proper - so don't worry about the 'any last requests rubbish' for me.

 

As Darthe has claimed 1 shot instaview I would like him to confirm his pokemonalso - cos he is vanilla now. He hasn't done that already has he?

 

And now shower, boys ready and safari park. I'm so glad I don't have to try and figure this one out lol.

[suchmadness]

Thats a very small chance ithi (10% to be precise)

I think its worth it

 

also i dont mibd being called player but on mafia if you call me that i sometimes miss questions cos it looks like they are ambiguously saying player rather than talking about me

 

Sorry but I really liked that name Player. I meant it as a compliment.

 

In every regard and especially in relation to the game.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Not nervous.

 

But I don't think a Mafia would throw this out on D1 just to defend RTE and get me Lynched.

 

It seems more likely he got a false view - which means 2 dead Town.

 

Please don't paint me with false emotions.

[dapianoplay3r]

I said seem. Its jst how iit looks

 

plus you keep pushing the two dead town really hard.

 

But just so you.know, id agree with you normally (darthe kept alive and you lynched) except the "scummiest player in the game" (as you so dubbed him) seemed to know of the role vefoore it was revealed

[Ithillian Turambar]

So Lynch RTE still.

 

If the information seems incorrect - go with what seems right?

 

I will continue to post what I think about this situation - yes. Try paint that bad if you will.

 

Apart from I do really have to go. Animal pictures on FB later

[dapianoplay3r]

I want to lynch RTE as well. But one lynch a day unless you are DPR. So Farthe gives the most info

so ynch

[Ithillian Turambar]

If this was a Win the best info Game - you would be correct.

 

But this is a Lynch the Mafia Game. We should do that.

 

Because the best info would also be locating a Mafia, yes?

 

But you seem unhappy about doing that.

[dapianoplay3r]

Darthe gives pretty solid info

rte not as solid

 

Lynch him tomorrow

 

lynching him today leaves darthe WIFOM floating around all night and into the next day

 

lynching darthe removes that

 

i see no good rrason not to lynch darthe. All yo have is RTE is probably derp mafiia

[Ithillian Turambar]

You do keep lining them up Dap. You got three in a row now. Does that mean you win?

[dapianoplay3r]

If only it took three to win

 

We probably have 6 mafia IMO

[Aiel Heart]

Official Vote Count
With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch
Kronos (0) : Hallia
berf (0) : berf, Ithi, Piano
Ithi (1) : RTE, Darthe
RTE (7): Piano, Cloud, Panchi, Razen, BG, Ithi, berf, Hallia, Turin, madness
Piano (2): Des, Krak
WoT13 (1): Chuckles
Chuckles (2): RTE, Razen
Mawth (0): Ley
Darthe (1): Piano
 
Not voting: Mawth, Kronos, Tina, Luci, Dav, BG, Ley, WoT13, Cyan, Hisoka
 
Deadline
 
If I missed something just point it out--I'm running a bit low on sleep. And for the record I am not going to be around in the next 36 or so hours--will try to pop in to give a VC at some point!

[Turin Turambar]

Piano says lynch darthe over RTE. Wanna give him "one more day"

 

So what if Darthe flips town. Tomorrow you say let's lynch Ithi cause Darthe viewed her. RTE gets another day.

 

My opinion is that Ithi is telling the truth regarding her alignment. Also that darthe is more likely telling the truth but got a false read. I remember one of the games had the possible double kill that had percentage chances and it didn't work as well as they hoped.

 

I still prefer the RTE lynch

[Turin Turambar]

If only it took three to win

 

We probably have 6 mafia IMO

So we have RTE, dap and maybe time. Half way there.

[bgrishinko]

 

 

Unvote Vote Ithi

 

No Brainer. Ithi's fighting it hard which seals the deal. The nice thing is, this 90% works both ways. If Darthe is town, there is a 90% chance of lynching scum by voting Ithi. If Ithi flips town, 90% chance Darthe is lying.

 

Lynching either Ithi or Darthe are the only smart choices today.

[Turin Turambar]

If you were town and thought someone had a bad view on you, wouldn't you defend yourself? To go down easy only gives the mafia a free lynch.

 

Percentages are there for a reason. 1 in 10 is not statistically insignificant. Ask anyone that has been denied the true power in a battle.

[bgrishinko]

Also that darthe is more likely telling the truth but got a false read.

 

 

False. It is only a 10% chance that Darthe is telling the truth and got a bad view. The scenario you described is by definition highly unlikely.

[bgrishinko]

90% chance of getting scum on day 1. I'm happy with those odds. Ignoring the percentages is wishful thinking.

[Turin Turambar]

My opinion is that Darthe is telling the truth in so much as he viewed Ithi. However since I believe Ithi town and there is a percentage chance that his view was false by his own admission. It fits my views the best.

[Turin Turambar]

So tomorrow do you vote Darthe if Ithi flips town?

[bgrishinko]

Probably, yeah.

 

Why do you feel so strong Ithi is town? Why do you feel so strong Darthe is telling the truth?

[bgrishinko]

I'd be okay voting Darthe first for the info as well. Darthe or Ithi are the only town moves right now as far as I'm concerned.

[Turin Turambar]

Also dap, earlier I noted how you soft claimed vanilla town which you also admitted. In the same post you stated it was okay because you didn't actually claim. The two seem to be mutually exclusive. But that will be for after RTE.

 

 

So of Ithi, Darthe and RTE, which do you think is most likely mafia? And why?

[suchmadness]

Just thinking out loud here if you know what I mean...

 

piona just doesn't gel in my head for some reason. dapiona still no...How about play3r? It has all the elements plus three :)

Because you're really an expert player and I cant seem to get a read on your alignment dap(if you insist so I will bow). Still suspicious as to your motives...

 

Darthe is just too elusive for me. He blows in claim insta view then disappear. His explanation can be dismissed easily as Dap has shown.

 

Meanwhile Ithii does protest too much and defending Darthe's claim, which doesn't make sense as darthe prposed we lynched him. Also really pushes RTE on the sacrificial pire a little too hard.

 

I'd be interested in knowing about Darthe a bit more before deciding wheter or not he's town or mafia. Anyway I found him intriguing.

 

Sad to see RTE go though. Would like to see how his game plan evolved.

Don't know whether I want to change my vote so late in the day or could I?

[suchmadness]

We lynched Ithii is Darthe's insistent I mean.

[dapianoplay3r]

My opinion is that Darthe is telling the truth in so much as he viewed Ithi. However since I believe Ithi town and there is a percentage chance that his view was false by his own admission. It fits my views the best.

 

Why do you believe him?

What evidence is there and why then would RTE guess such an unlikely event occurred with all his "did you have a day one action" and stuff?

 

 

Also dap, earlier I noted how you soft claimed vanilla town which you also admitted. In the same post you stated it was okay because you didn't actually claim. The two seem to be mutually exclusive. But that will be for after RTE.

So of Ithi, Darthe and RTE, which do you think is most likely mafia? And why?

Actually I didn't soft claim vanilla. I didn't soft claim anything

All I said was lynch me and I can sub back in

 

The only thing that soft claims is town

 

Now if you think I wouldn't say that as a PR, well that's your opinion. I would, I'd say that as PR or vanilla

Either way I didn't mean it to be a soft claim and you shouldn't take it as such