Enter the Dragon Mafia [Basic] D5: Town Wins!!

[dapianoplay3r]

Actually. The not lee was the soft claim (had nothing to do with actually having a role lol)

The wiff of a case was serious

[dapianoplay3r]

Actually. The not lee was the soft claim (had nothing to do with actually having a role lol)

The wiff of a case was serious

[dapianoplay3r]

Actually. The not lee was the soft claim (had nothing to do with actually having a role lol)

The wiff of a case was serious

[dapianoplay3r]

Actually. The not lee was the soft claim (had nothing to do with actually having a role lol)

The wiff of a case was serious

[dapianoplay3r]

Actually. The not lee was the soft claim (had nothing to do with actually having a role lol)

The wiff of a case was serious

[ReleaseTheEvil]

No but guys seriously. He was really serious.

[dapianoplay3r]

Stupid DM

I even refreshed the page to check if it posted without telling me

[michellem]

 

Not much there, but yeah, it's open.

Can't believe you all bought Mish's case when she was doing the EXACT same things, LOL.

The problem with that is that I'm sure Mish could afford getting you both lynched, she could afford that. You couldn't.

 

Exactly I tried to tell you; the point of a vanilla townie is to die to find scum. If I had to push and push and push so much at you that it ended up with me lynched, great; it would probably mean you lynched the next day!

[peacesells]

I think Tsuki played a reasonably well first game.  Nice job man!

[csarmi]

Yea I think Tsuki played quite well too! Nice job :)

[dicetosser1]

well done town   bad luck tsuki! i thought for a bit you were safe.

 

Those 2 missed NKs killed us.

 

 

TG i still think the town was overpowered compared to the mafia   btw

[csarmi]

Why would a healer + 3x-shot cop, a 1x-shot Vig (with shot ending the day if not used the night) be overpowered? You had a roleblocker and the usual amount of scum.

[Tsukibana]

Thanks. I definitely learned quite a bit, that's for sure.

CS, I think it just felt overpowered to us, when two kills get blocked. Can't stop a DayVig shot, at all, for one.

Healer burned up an RB just cause we couldn't be sure she couldn't self cover. That's the only reason you

got your 3rd shot off. 

[dapianoplay3r]

But that's down to town play

Not balance nessacarily

[Tsukibana]

I know, that's why I said it "felt" overpowered. I think TG did a great job.

[csarmi]

My point exactly. Any setup is overpowered if the doc(!) keeps saving every night.

[Tyler Glembo]

I can see how town would have felt very overpowered given what happened, though without the miracle of Hallia I think the game could have turned out very differently.

 

Imagine the opposite scenario, where instead of town doc pawning, scum gets lucky and kills the doc and cop the first couple nights, and then the 1x shot vig takes their shot at night and kills another townie. Scum would have been halfway to winning within the first two nights.

[Hallia]

I'm just op XD

[Darthe]

Well, that was fun.

[Darthe]

If Hally is telling the truth (almost positive she is) then we now can safely say

 

1. ReleaseTheEvil

2. MisheruSedai

3. Darthe

4. Hallia

5. Tiinker

6. Nolder

7. Tsukibana

8. peacesells

9. dapianoplay3r

10. dicetosser1

11. Tigraine CSarmi

12. Millon

13. RandA lThor, Tournament Fighter, Vanilla town, Lynched D1

 

Furthermore, if the cop has viewed two more people not either of them then he can confirm himself and them.  With 6 confirmed town in the game our chances of catching mafia increase to 50% and we can no longer lose the game if they go one more day.  This was a good time to reveal, hally.  Now you can coordinate with the cop and the mafia is stuck WIFOMing the situation.  If you protect yourself then they will confirm the other person as town anyhow and if you protect the other it can be a two-fer.  Either way the cop will know who not to view.

 

Just read the QT where Csarmi said that this is the post that made him view me and that I would have died anyhow from my scummy play on D4 so he thought the kill was a waste.

 

We seriously gotta have a talk about how to play dude =p  I meant this post above.  It's how I kept off peoples' radar, I kept posting the most helpful things I could for town all game and you still should have revealed me at the start of the day.  

[Millon]

Sorry I was absent for the lastfew days all. Work has been busy, the week end was a crap shoot. Lots of family drama. Not like I offered much anyway but it really sucks to have inactive players and I know that. Any pointers on how I can NOT make myself sound like scum? lol

[csarmi]

Darthe, that post looked like a post that was made to keep you off from other's radar. Or a genuine analyze post.

So I viewed you.

 

You thought you were playing such a great game, well, apparently you didn't. You just thought you did.

 

So in this single game it turns out you have completely misjudged how you would be viewed as scum and apparently you have no idea how a cop should be played with a viewing in hand. Your loss, not mine.

[csarmi]

Earlier I was told by Peace that I have a total lack of self-awareness. Guess what. I'm not the only one.

[peacesells]

Darthe, I agre with Csarmi's handling of the the viewing 100%.  In fact, it's how I've played it almost every time I've been a cop.  I've seen too many town players get complacent when a cop pops in with a scum viewing first thing.  You waste that days interactions.

 

Also, I believe that the way you played this game would have gotten  you lynch near end game even without a viewing.  There were only so many choices left and you were tunneling too hard on Tsuki.  Once he flipped scum, I'd be looking at you.

 

Csarmi, one thing about self reflection is understand when to add fuel to the fire or put it out.  You rarely put out fires.  There's no doubt you are an intelligent person..but smug intelligence is unbecoming...especially on a website where intelligence is not uncommon.  There are 16 year olds here 10 times smarter than I am.  They are probably at least twice as smart as you.

[Tyler Glembo]

As mod I found two things: 1) There were situations I would have played differently were I in player X's situation and B) it was very interesting for me to see how player X played in such a situation.

 

I realize that everyone having a unique playstyle and a unique interpretation of events is (IMO) what makes mafia so very fun to begin with. If everyone played in the same way I do then I doubt I'd ever have any fun playing at all :-)