[TOWN WINS!] BG's Basic Wheel of Time Books Mafia

[Gabriel Kross]

He could have just forgotten to vote.

 

Also, I dont shut up in a mafia game that often as you can see by the post count.

 

Why does everyone feel the need to defend me in games, I had already answered Ithi then you go and defend me with a wrong reason? You trying to get town cred the wrong way Rand.

[RandA lThor]

Um, not just you, I'll defend anyone who I dont think has a legitimate case on them, including me. :)

[Gabriel Kross]

Well it's not wise to do when the question was already answered. Not to mention there was no case on me. Ithi asked a reasonable question. I answered.

[Alanna]

I find this sudden shift of attention to Wombat sketchy. For what apparently was just him changing his mind. It's clunky.

[RandA lThor]

Well it's not wise to do when the question was already answered. Not to mention there was no case on me. Ithi asked a reasonable question. I answered.

 

Actually, I half answered your question, the teacher started talking, I put my phone away, and when I pulled it out, I didn't refresh. I just answered after all you guys posted.

[Gabriel Kross]

I find this sudden shift of attention to Wombat sketchy. For what apparently was just him changing his mind. It's clunky.

 

*shrug*

 

It could be him changing his mind or it could be him deciding that he'd like Ithi gone. A little pressure is good when things are uncertain.

[michellem]

I'l unvote for now, as I don't want to be stuck with a joke vote.

[hazelkrs1]

I find this sudden shift of attention to Wombat sketchy. For what apparently was just him changing his mind. It's clunky.

 

This is a huge ping right here. Sudden shift of attention? I think 2, maybe 3 people had mentioned his 180 on Ithi. Why would you find that sketchy? This raises my suspicion of Wombat and makes me highly suspicious of Alanna

[Ithillian Turambar]

Ok - possibly the first and last time you will ever see this - but here is a real genuine multi quote casing ... Part 1 because I don't know how many quotes you can do at once.

 

Thanks, guys for the compliments.

 

I'm not seeing anything I'd like to vote on yet. Ithi does seem pretty aggressive, which I'm not used to from her, but I haven't played with her for a long time. Actually, It's been so long I don't remember a game we played in. I do remember modding her once though. Gotta watch this girl and her really good fake claims. ;)

 

Warns people about me - but clearly says doesn't see anything that would cause her to place a vote. But a nice little prodding post to keep people looking at me.

 

The more Ithi flails around accusing everyone, the scummier she looks.

 

Vote Ithi

 

Ithi, you're going to call this OMGUS, and that's fine. It's legitimately not liking your play.

 

Lily seems to think I would call this OMGUS, but as I am not currently voting her, I don't see why I would. Apparently I am Flailing and accusing everyone. Note the use of the word SCUM. Basically a lot of flannel that looks like thought out reasoning, but is just a lot of key words strung together to paint a nice picture for everyone of how Mafia I obviously am. She provides no evidence to back any of this up remember. Just uses the key words. And at this point I had voted for two people fir doing specific things, and had not just called them scum lol. Mafia peoples find it difficult to make real cases because they are fibbing lol.

 

I've felt the same way, Ithi - that I got voted just for playing. That's not why I'm voting you. I'm voting you because you seem bent on accusing everyone, and that says to me that you don't care who you can get lynched. That's scummy.

 

I know it's a bit weak, but it's day 1. There isn't that much to go on.

 

Now she says her vote on me is actually weak, whereas before I was the scummiest thing known to man or fish. And clearly I do care who I get lynched, which is why I gave my reasons without needing to resort to weak generic terminology.

 

I am watching Rand, too. I may put pressure there to see if we can get a scum slip out of him. But that doesn't change my feelings toward you. I'm thinking 3rd party for you.

 

Now she says she is also suspicious of rand, and actually she does not think I am Mafia now, I am actually 3rd party

 

My vote was not bandwagon. In fact, I hesitated to place it because so many others were voting her. But her scumminess is the most suspicious thing so far.

 

Not a bandwagon vote and was hesitant to place the vote, when she has previously said I was sure to be scum, and then actually it was a weak vote, and then I was a 3rd party ... and now she didn't want to place it at all. But hey look ... I am scummy again, so I must be Mafia. Still no quotes or actual non generic keyword reasons as to why I am scummy.

 

She's not even halfway to lynch. What do you think of her behavior?

 

Must keep up the momentum on Ithi ... everyone look at her!!!

 

Wombat, you always think I'm scum, darling.

 

Peace, I don't know what to say. How am I scummy?

 

Annoyingly fluffy post, with the typical trait of why do people think she is Mafia - didn't someone say the Mafia are more concerned with proving themselves innocent than risking themselves to do good mafia hunting like a Town would. Also a bit pot vs kettle when she hasn't given reasons for calling me scum - not that i care. It's more funny when you let the mafia lynch themselves I think. Like the eye of Sauron, she stops talking about me for a seconf when she gets a bit of attention from others, and tries to deflect with the fluffy kiss thing, bleurch.

 

It's a legit question. You lay down a vote. What do you have to back it up?

 

She really doesn't like being voted does she? She really needs to know what she is doing wrong before she attracts any more votes.

 

Really? I don't think it depends on my alignment as much as how many games I'm playing and how busy I am in general. I'm definitely more active in basic games because I like them more. I sometimes find advanced games too confusing. Take the Avatar game for example. I never did figure out what was going on in that one.

 

Thanks for answering. *blows a kiss*

 

More I'm not a mafia honest fluffy kissing, and trying to discredit valid reasons, that also did not contain weak generic terminolgy - always nice to see.

 

 

And, you, Tink, didn't answer my question. You have a lot to say about the things surrounding her. What do you think of Ithi's behavior?

 

Everyone stop looking at me and look at ITHI! lmao

 

 

OK - let me go and get my next lot. :)

[Ithillian Turambar]

Has Lily actually said anything this game apart from Noooooooo don't look at me, look at her!

 

Lol.

 

Anyone who says someone is just 'scummy' is just being a lazy bones. That would be like me saying someone is Mafia because they is Mafia.

 

Yes. I made a case on you and I don't care if people look at me, as long as they give me something to rebutt. You are being far too aggressive and making me like my vote more and more.

 

Her case was that I was scummy lol And had voted for people.

 

I'm def starting to lean more and more to a Tiinker vote, but I'm not quite ready to let up the pressure on Ithi. The fact that she has gone from ultra aggressive to meek and defensive still worries me.

 

My thoughts exactly. Now, get out of my head! It's dangerous in there. You don't have your protective clothing on. OMG! You don't have any clothing on

 

Okay, you can stay......

 

Here she buddies up to Despo because he has said something she likes that will help to get me lynched. Like I said earlier, I've never liked Despo, not never - and he isn't stupid at this game. If Lily is a Mafia, then I'm thinking he might actually be a Town. She seems to be trying to be linked to him and has been encouraging his cases of me. More flirty fluff to show how non threatening she is.

 

You know what Ithi? Two people reaching the same conclusions doesn't make them working together. It might make them right, even.

 

Lily doesn't seem to have actually reached conclusions, she just likes to echo what other people say.

 

I origninally voted you for your flailing around and FOSing a number of people. It looked like you were trying to put attention anywhere but at you. You've gotten more focused now, but that may be because you were called out on it. I like my vote where it is. Very much.

 

Here she starts her insane post about me trying to deflect attention, when I had no attention lol. What a mistake to make. If you are going to make stuff up to get people to vote me, at least make it half right. Despo also calls her out on this - because it was just total garbage.

 

I didn't mean to imply that you were turning attention from yourself, Ithi. Bad wording on my part. I meant you are using offense to keep from needing defense. Or you were, anyway. Now, I'm not sure what you're doing.

 

I am certainly not tunneling. Feeling defensive much? I'm not liking Tiinker's play much more than I like yours. I'm just not ready to come out with a case there. And I'm watching Rand, but I'm not as convinced that there's anything there, yet.

 

Oh no ... she realises she has stuffed up and tries to wriggle out and explain what she actually meant to say lol. Some weird stuff about me being defensive, when I haven't really tried to defend myself at all - I'm more an explain why someone else would be a better bet than me in this game - because I would rather catch a Mafia. Now she starts to get rready to broaden her horizons a little, because the fast build up on me seems to have stalled. Oh dear - and it was going so well.

 

I might be missing tomorrow. RL stuff. I'll probably be okay, but just in case, I wanted to let y'all know.

 

And then she vanishes ... kind of difficult to pull her up on stuff she got wrong if she is not about eh? Well I won't let that stop me I think with all of that in mind I shall

 

Unvote - Vote Lily

 

Which will probably get me lynched, but at least when you want the next person to go for, you will already know who it should be :) and won't have to build the case yourself. Oh - and the fact she is being so actively posty whilst talking such obvious rubbish means she isn't that worried about being found out by conventional means ... if you know what I mean ;) She is definitely not playing very cautious - she probably thinks she is very safe indeed lol.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Thank you for letting me complete my post.

 

 

That was my first ever multiquote casing ever.

 

Despo will be so proud of me.

[peacesells]

That was one very nicely laid out multi quote ithi. And I agree.

 

The one thing that really sticks out to me is her stating that you aren't usually aggressive. I've always found your play aggressive..and unique.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I'm totally going to take that as a compliment.

 

[LilyElizabeth]

Ithi, all you did was twist my words. Nice going.

 

We're back from the vet now, and I'm going to be active again.

[LilyElizabeth]

And if you were implying that I'm using real life as a tactic, I find that insulting and outside the spirit of the game. I would hope none of us would do that.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I think it's quite clear I quoted your words.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I clearly didn't say that. I don't know anything about your real life to be able to say that.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I was just saying I wasn't going to be polite and wait for you to say you were back. I don't have enough time on the laptop to be polite about stuff like that.

[Nightstrike]

Wow. I've got a really hard time figuring out who's what in this discussion. Although I guess there might be clues once more pieces fall into place later. Ithilian and Lily probably aren't both on the scum team, right? Otherwise they've sure fooled me.

[michellem]

Thing is, they might both be, putting on a darn good show to confuse everyone. I'm not saying they are, I don't think so, but never take anything for granted.

[Tiinker]

Sorry for being quiet guys. Trying to get used to this game; it's already a lot more advanced than my first game, wich was much more relaxed.

 

I don't really have a good feeling about anyone right now, so I'm still on the fence.

 

What do you mean by advanced? It's been very basic so far.

I think she means it's more serious. If I'm not mistaken, her first mafia game was in the WT (I thought they didn't even ALLOW mafia there? ), and that game was crazy vanilla. As in, not many really knew what they were doing lol

They allow one a year. Everyone has to be nice. I chose not to play.

 

Yes, this XD it was the HP Week-mafia, with tons of new players, so it was very soft and un-serious :P So I'm still adjusting to this very serious thing XD

 

Although, Despo, how did you know what my first mafia was? I don't think I've met you properly before now :P

 

Thing is, they might both be, putting on a darn good show to confuse everyone. I'm not saying they are, I don't think so, but never take anything for granted.

 

 

For someone who claims to have been only in one other basic mafia game at the WT where people apparently "didn't know what they were doing" (:p) this seems to be a pretty bold statement. Or did someone mention something like that on your qt?

[RandA lThor]

Love your new avi Tiink! /spam

 

From what I have seen between Ithi and Lily, I am fairly sure that one of them is scum, there has been a lot of attacking on both sides, a lot of sarcasm, and the two main things I can think of is one scum and one townie or two scum playing a huge gambit right now. I am inclined to think the former since the latter is a little overboard and scum usually distance by some arguments, not a full on barrage. I originally thought Ithi was scum, but her case on Lily is also very good. unvote for now so I can look over it later.

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm backing away from this. I've said all I have to say. Y'all can read how she twists what I say for yourselves. I think Ithi has showed her true colors in that case she made. At any rate, it's up to y'all to decide. My vote stays where it is.

[RandA lThor]

Hmm, I don't really like that statement, at least when I have seen you, not in mafia but in general, you aren't really easy to beat and you don't back down easily.

[RandA lThor]

Ithi's already done a case on Lily, so I think I might do a case on Ithi since she is also on my list, and then I could use that to compare to what Lily's case was.

 

Prepare for....

 

MY FIRST EVER WoT!!!!

 

Sorry, I am really excited. :)