Monopoly Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Arez Al'Loke]

Well tht I agree on. And if one post is enough to lynch me on then so be it, I am not hurt by that. I do believe this is being blown out of proportion though. I did not suggest that we kill all of the people on the list or that it was half of the things you and Arez seem to be saying for me. I simply said that those people are not likely to make it to endgame. It puts too much potential WIFOM on each of us. I can't blame the town for making the choice to kill each of us as it is what I would do but this ganging is beginning to strike me as pingy.

 

Why exactly did you group me up with Despo?

[bgrishinko]

WOW. I wake up to this? Y'all had me going for a minute there. . .

 

I say we disregard the list entirely, because it presents too much wifom to make anything of it. If we say that there's got to be at least a baddie on that list, then we'll end up lynching all the town on it before we get to the mafia. On the other hand, and disregarding the list, Darthe is pinging like crazy.

 

Also, and I don't know who said it, but someone implied that the list would have different meaning if he were symp versus the goon that he was? What do you mean by that? EIther way he's mafia, to me.

 

This post.... but from my mouth.

[hazelkrs1]

WOW. I wake up to this? Y'all had me going for a minute there. . .

 

I say we disregard the list entirely, because it presents too much wifom to make anything of it. If we say that there's got to be at least a baddie on that list, then we'll end up lynching all the town on it before we get to the mafia. On the other hand, and disregarding the list, Darthe is pinging like crazy.

 

Also, and I don't know who said it, but someone implied that the list would have different meaning if he were symp versus the goon that he was? What do you mean by that? EIther way he's mafia, to me.

 

Well, I know that even if he did flip symp I'm not Mr. Pennybags (or scum at all for that matter), so I would have known that his list was at least partially bs, but many others would have thought that he might have been trying to out his teammates because of spite or something. Being that he didn't flip symp, there's really not a lot of reason to focus on the list at all. Even tho it is possible and even likely that he listed at least one of his teammates, as you said there is too much wifom associated with it.

[David Hermes]

muwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[AndrewLee]

*victory dances*

 

I was right! That's always nice.

[Nightstrike]

Cool, no deaths. This just makes the game more interesting.

 

Actually, David was already pinging me, and honestly this looks like he's trying to make the obligatory "yay, no deaths" post, yet he doesn't offer any speculation whatsoever why it might have happened. Kinda seems like a terse tone too, mebbe his team aint so happy their kill didn't go through.

 

Vote David

 

I still wanna hear from Nightstrike and BG

 

Oh and since we had zero deaths, it just kinda supports the theory of us having a vig even moar, since I doubt a SK would have holstered. Once again tho, they could have just missed the deadline.

I don't think Despo is scum, since he didn't have to say this that soon after David said his part.

[Nightstrike]

OK, time for a full reveal. I'm Luke the symp. I know who the mafia are. And I could tell you who they are.

They are: Despo who is Mr. Pennybags, and his 4 railroad barons Thorum, Dicetosser1, Darthe and Bgrishinko.

 

Vote David.

Could it be that none of those are scum? It'll be hard to ignore the list now when we've seen it.

[alannalynn]

OK, time for a full reveal. I'm Luke the symp. I know who the mafia are. And I could tell you who they are.

They are: Despo who is Mr. Pennybags, and his 4 railroad barons Thorum, Dicetosser1, Darthe and Bgrishinko.

 

Vote David.

Could it be that none of those are scum? It'll be hard to ignore the list now when we've seen it.

That's the problem, Night. It's very probable that at least one on the list is scum, because mafia wouldn't give a confirmed townie list and they also wouldn't reveal the whole mafia team like that. At the same time he could have been thinking that and done something different. That's why the list is a giant wifom and is better ignored for actual scum hunting.

[Basel Gill]

*comes back home from work...* What the bloody ashes? There must be more WIFOM in that one reveal than I've seen in some entire games.

[Nightstrike]

Sorry I haven't posted in a while. A bubble of evil destroyed our tent.

 

Anywho, I'm now all caught up.

 

 

 

Despora, what's the point at this point in the game to vote for anyone, EP or anyone for that matter? My reasoning is that Nolder has yet to post the deadline for day 1. So for a lynch to happen at this point a lot of people will have to unvote on the No lynch and vote someone they found suspicious. Which will take a while. I would be surprised if this day ended without the majority on the No lynch wagon. Then even if No lynch gets the majority we will then have to vote again for which card we want (community, chance or neither). It's alright to post your suspicions and thoughts but isn't it a waste of time to vote for a player at this point?

David is pinged me first back in day one when Despo was talking about putting a little pressure on other players before the no lynch was finalized to get some info. Why would you question wanting to get info unless you're scum and you don't want pressure put on you or your teammates? It's never a waste of time to vote a player and get info from them. Next, when Wombat explained the jailor role because someone asked what it could do, David assumed it was a reveal only to explain later on he miss read. Yeah misreading happens, however, when morning comes Wombat has been nked along with EP. Then, when players are voting Lenlo, David votes Dice for not believing EP was vanilla townie.

 

 

Lenlo pinged me recently with the survivor reveal and Tress' info. The comment of "how is that lucky?" to Dice pings. Personally, I think it's better that town power roles are safe than to have them gone. Yeah it's sucks that we lost two townies but it's the lesser of two evils.

 

So, in conclusion Vote David

Lessa Nikia is probably a townie. David voted dice, so I think maybe dice is a townie too.

[hazelkrs1]

Nightstrike, since you've already got kind of a headstart, you mind giving a brief summary of your thoughts on everyone still in the game?

[Basel Gill]

I am leaning toward ignoring the list David posted altogether. There is just too much WIFOM there, and like AJ, I would rather deal with what else is available from people's posts.

[Blackhoof]

If he is a symp, why would he pick those names? I am pretty certain he would pick at least one mafia to be on his list. I say kill them all in order of scumminess and go with it? I mean, these people will never make it to end game now anyhow.

 

 

So he wasn't a symp. I highly disagree with the idea of completely disregarding the list. I am okay with being who we lynch off of it first since I realize that I am pushing the idea but I feel that if we lynch the scummiest players from it there is probably at least a scum on the list he made. Otherwise it would help the town in the long run.

 

so... do what he wanted us to do, you mean?he clearly knew he would not live even after the reveal, the first non-mafia we lynched in that list would disprove him. lynching everyone on the list? that is what he must have wanted us to do.

[Darthe]

Last I checked you're on the list as well. Why such a problem with dying hoofy?

 

For the record, I do not think it scummy to assume that these people at least warrant looking at and my first thought was to simply use it to aid our hunting. I would think that if this game got down to the wire the list would probably be considered once more. With that in mind I assumed that those of us on it, at least most of us, are going to die. I find it very interesting to see how different ones of you on the list have reacted and how a couple of players have pushed disregarding it. Perhaps it is too much WIFOM but I consider well reasoned thought, along with the near certainty of their being scum on there somewhere, to be worth something.

[Blackhoof]

ummm... im not on the list. but if you thought i was, i can see why you would think i was beign shifty.

 

i still move to completely disregard the list, until closer to endgame at least. i see your point, though.

[Darthe]

Damn B names x.x

[Nolder]

Mod Note: Currently looking for a replacement for Lessa. Day is delayed until a replacement is found.

[Nightstrike]

Nightstrike, since you've already got kind of a headstart, you mind giving a brief summary of your thoughts on everyone still in the game?

What headstart? Those was just the ideas I got from the couple of things I quoted. I don't have any particular scum reading on anyone right now.

[peacesells]

Heads up all. I am going camping for a few days. I doubt I'll have cell phone reception in the mountains. Be back Saturday or Sunday. Will probably be Monday before I completely catch up.

[Nolder]

Sorry for the delay everyone but I'm trying to avoid modkilling

I'm going through the backup list now and if that doesn't work out by tomorrow I'll put out an open call for a replacement until Friday

If I can't find anyone by then Lessa will be modkilled

[Nolder]

Mod Note: Lanthirrhos is replacing Lessa

Deadline is in about an hour and a half so get your actions in if you haven't already

[Songstress]

That was fast

[Lanthirrhos]

Gratuitous profanity (whether disguised by acronyms or not) is not an inherent part of mafia. That being said, I doubt that EP should withdraw over this. He can get Verbal to spank him if he really wants.

 

DM has a mafia quotes thread right?

 

sticking to your guns and keeping your vote where it stood might have been admirable, considering you were one of the few that wasn't completely willing to jump onto the Lenlowagon as fast as you could, but you were voting me, and your case on me was about as weak as one could be.

I hate not having my vote on someone, and I prefer keeping it on someone who annoyed me but had no chance to get lynched, to speeding up the vote train on someone we had no reason at all to get rid of.

You annoyed me because I annoyed you, so I guess we're even in that respect .

 

I feel the need to reiterate this. Lenlo's lynch was worse than useless. It just gave the mafia a chance to look more town by getting on the high horse whilst screaming "scum". No one bothered to ask, but did Lenlo actually DO anything in this QT to direct the town? Or anything that was LEGITIMATELY scummy? So he made a take over the world joke... because mafia ALWAYS walk into random QTs and say they're going to take over the world as a satirical reference to a cartoon.

 

The rest of the reasoning for a Lenlo lynch was pretty weak as well, and to take it further--no one did ANYTHING useful that day. It was a pile on lynch with fairly crap supportive reasoning.

 

OK, time for a full reveal. I'm Luke the symp. I know who the mafia are. And I could tell you who they are.

They are: Despo who is Mr. Pennybags, and his 4 railroad barons Thorum, Dicetosser1, Darthe and Bgrishinko.

 

Vote David.

 

It's likely that atleat oe is scum. It's also likely that these people wont be targets for the mafia NK because A) some are mafia and B) They've been wifomed. The mafia would be pretty silly to clear up the wifom for us. The list is useless. Scum hunt. Actually play the game. Don't count on lists from other players, town or not. Their list doesn't make the game clearer. I never understand how people get sucked into lists. Support your own theories with observation and logic, not random lists.

[Songstress]

Gratuitous profanity (whether disguised by acronyms or not) is not an inherent part of mafia. That being said, I doubt that EP should withdraw over this. He can get Verbal to spank him if he really wants.

 

DM has a mafia quotes thread right?

 

If it doesn't, it should. I can think of a few that need to be there.

[Lanthirrhos]

There was a lot more that I could have replied to, but the ancient history should probably stay there, it's just deadweight to bring it back now.

 

On a side note, my mortgage value is only $60. Worthless. Nol is trying to tell me something.