Create-Your-Own-Role Mafia 7: Everybody Wins *game over*

[LilyElizabeth]

I agree with Alanna that Christine does seem pretty town.

what seems town about her?

 

I don't really have time right now to go back and look, but Alanna said something about how Christine is playing that seems like she wants to protect her role. I also think that eliminating the LD wouldn't be a good idea. On that same note, we need to keep the Scholar around, too. Those two are the closest to a cop we have.

[LilyElizabeth]

I think some of the votes on Christine bear looking at, because she has the Lie Detector role, which mafia would certainly want to get rid of. Nolder's seems the most notable to me. The first 2 votes were mosty likely joke votes, and Wombat's was likely to see who would jump on that train.

 

Christine is the one who brought up looking at anti-town roles, though, which would put her in the clear today being that she has a very town role. Also of note.

 

I made the time to go look. I took this statement to mean that Christine was performing a townie action which made her seem more town. And I agreed.

At any rate, she's not a candidate for lynch today, in my opinion, because we need that role.

[Alanna]

Oh, I see. Actually, my intention behind that statement was actually the opposite; I thought Christine bringing that up could have been to purposely throw suspicion off her. I was actually looking at her suspiciously when she said that. At first, anyway.

[Christine]

Ummm... Ok.

 

 

Sorry that I was the first one to bring up look into the Anti Town Roles?

 

 

Regardless, Anti-Town roles need to be taken out before they get into Scum hands.

[LilyElizabeth]

Assuming they aren't already. Big assumption there.

[Christine]

If they are in the Mafia hands right now, then we HAVE to take them out today. After today, we will not know where they go.

 

 

Tonight, the Scum will likely take out the roles that hurt them the most. We have to be proactive today and take out the role that will help the scum the most.

[Niniel]

I´m happy with my vote for Mynd. I have never played a game were a busdriver was good for town.

[Ironeyes]

I agree with Alanna that Christine does seem pretty town.

what seems town about her?

 

I don't really have time right now to go back and look, but Alanna said something about how Christine is playing that seems like she wants to protect her role. I also think that eliminating the LD wouldn't be a good idea. On that same note, we need to keep the Scholar around, too. Those two are the closest to a cop we have.

 

So therefore you won't kill me? Sweet.

[LilyElizabeth]

I agree with Alanna that Christine does seem pretty town.

what seems town about her?

 

I don't really have time right now to go back and look, but Alanna said something about how Christine is playing that seems like she wants to protect her role. I also think that eliminating the LD wouldn't be a good idea. On that same note, we need to keep the Scholar around, too. Those two are the closest to a cop we have.

 

So therefore you won't kill me? Sweet.

 

Not today, anyway ;)

[dapianoplay3r]

If I use my role it makes the person vanilla for the whole game and takes the role they have out of rotation

 

So I could potentially do it on my self and end the roll. However the person who has it won't know who has the role they want gone after today so it might be better to take another role out?

 

Also christine.

Im not sure when the NK comes in the line of NAs. Do they get to kill people before the actions get switched (taking out potentially known roles) or after the switch (so a random role)?

[Basel Gill]

8) Basel Gill’s Role: Suicide Bomber

 

At night, you may – if you choose – pick a player to kill. They will die, but so will you.

 

Eight, It will remove itself from the game... but, if scum has it and has a target on their back, they could take someone town out... but still not bad.

 

When I was looking through roles to submit, the wiki discussed this as being generally useless for scum, since a one-for-one trade is better for town due to the numerical advantage. The scenario you mentioned is brought up as a rare time when scum can use it to good effect. What I've really been curious about, that won't be settled in this game since there seems to be just the one scum team (given the number of players), is whether scum would find it more useful against other scum.

[Christine]

If you are scum, and looking to be the next day's lynch, why not take out someone with you?

 

 

 

That would be good to know, when people switch roles, but I was assuming that the role you have during the day is the same one you have at night.

 

 

So, Day One and Night One, I am the LD.

 

On Day Two and Night Two, I have role B

 

Day Three and Night Three, I have role C

 

 

 

 

Pandy, when do roles switch?

[cosmicpanda]

Pandy player mode:

 

Christine, I liked your exchange with Piano. Have two points.

 

~~~

 

Pandy mod mode:

 

- Roles rotate after every other night action has happened, including the mafia kill (so, at dawn). If the mafia kill somebody, their death will be processed before roles rotate.

 

 

Votecount 5:

 

Wombat: 1 (Ironeyes)

EP: 1 (Christine)

Christine: 1 (Mynd)

Mynd: 3 (TinaHel, Lily, Nolder)

Tina: 1 (Alanna)

Nolder: 2 (Basel, Wombat)

Piano: 2 (Blackhoof, Thorum)

 

Not voting: EP, Pandy, Piano

 

 

Deadline. With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch!

 

 

 

Pandy Points Count:

 

Christine: 3

Ironeyes: 2

Nolder: 1

Lily: 1

EP: -1

Mynd: -1

[Ironeyes]

Shoot, she's ahead of me!

[Blackhoof]

thank you Christine, for that detailed analsis of the roles.

 

Mynd's role seems to be the most dsangerous and confusing, sicne it can and likely wil be negative in both town and mafia hands, while other roles are only bad in mafia hands.

[Christine]

I don't want bloody points if they aren't good.

 

 

Also, do people get to give out points tomorrow if they get your role?!

[cosmicpanda]

Yes.

[Nolder]

I am awake and around but I have nothing new to add

I still think we should lynch Mynd to get rid of the Bus Driver role

[LilyElizabeth]

Just a head's up. The next four days will be busy for me, so I might not have the activity level I'd like to.

 

I don't have anything new to comment on right now, game-wise.

[cosmicpanda]

You guys are boring. I could shorten the deadline?

[Nolder]

You guys are boring. I could shorten the deadline?

I am ok with this

[Gabriel Kross]

doooo it I'm not voting purposefully (obviously) I'm hoping that since in theory there are more townies my role passes to a townie :)

[Thorum]

It's alled weekend.

[cosmicpanda]

Good point. And, you know, you guys could just lynch without waiting for the deadline if you really wanted to.

 

 

Pandy player mode:

 

EP, it seems that if you didn't vote today, you'd end up protecting Piano tomorrow - unless he dies tonight. In that case, you'd protect Mynd - unless he's lynched today. In that case, you'd protect Alanna. Are you okay with potentially protecting all of these people?

[Gabriel Kross]

Player could use his ability on himself to keep it out of mafia hands which what he does with his ability will either vet him as town or mafia, that way Mynd could be lynched to eliminate his role and when we find out tomorrow who lost their role and is now vanilla we can determine what Player did. I do not have a read on Mynd or Alanna as far as alignment I just dont think it would be wise to let Mynd's role stay in.