[Advanced] Monty Python and the Holy Grail Mafia (Game Over)

[Sakaea]

From my analysis of Moon's posting, I have concluded that Min and Lia are scum.

 

Vote: Min

 

 

Awesome, 2 cult down!

 

Ok, so we have 4 days to find scum to lynch. Wombat, which post of Moon's are you referring to?

 

Umm what do you mean

 

 

I wanted to know if Wombat was referring to a specific post of Moon's or just her posts in general. I think after reading what's been said since tho, that he meant her posts in general (right?).

 

Also, I would like to know why he thinks Lia is scum. Makes no sense to me ATM.

[keyholder21]

also, i'd like to note that no one has claimed to have been silenced Day 3, so FoS at both Womby & Jack. also, everyone seems to have overlooked GF's slip up of using the title "newting" for someone being silenced.

 

Uh Red, and Jack:

 

I think since we're all aware of Red, she is less of a potential threat. We can always lynch her. Also, the apparent newting of Jack rang to me as a 90% confirmation she was innocent, though I do have beer in front of me. Still, I bet either the red or moon voters feature mafia members for sure this time.

 

Why say newting and not silencing? We don't know that he was turned into a newt. In fact, most of us have been commenting on the suspiciousness of Moon's 'reveal' that she was turned into a newt.

 

I noticed.

[WWWwombat]

This newting thing on GF is a railroad job imo. Also, Tiinker believing that Moon might have been newted points to him as possible scum. Remember, until discovered, to the mafia, a symp seems town. As a symp, I often try to FoS the scum early without making cases on them (of course I often do the same thing as town but that's irrelevant), so that's why I suspect Min and AJ/Lia, especially Min.

[WWWwombat]

Also, linking players is not necessarily bad. I do it a lot as both town and scum in order to gauge reactions and set up lynches.

[Charis alAslan]

@BG I can't really look over the posts like I said I'm on vacation, and my cell phone but I'll pull out what I can from memory.

 

1. Red and Myself were having a back and forth and then Charos jumped in without anyone mentioning her saying "Jack likes to distract, he caused distraction by arguing with me."

 

2. The whole, "I'm scared of night" post just reeked of someone trying to sound overly town.

 

3. Argued over the confusion I was causing yet continued to add fuel to the fire.

 

Those are three solid reasons I have. Another reason backing me, even though you asked what my case was besides the point was Moon's coroner report. Besides if Charis is scum, I think Red may be also. The reason being is when Red and I were having the back and forth, Charos swooped in out of nowhere and tried to make things about her and myself instead of Red and myself.

 

I disagree with this, of course, but you already knew that. I never JUMPED IN on your argument with Red. Did you miss all the posts where I was in a heated debate with Red myself? No one else missed them. Except that without having to reiterate it a hundred and one times, we both backed off each other. And then you just kept coming at me for the same reasons over and over and over and over. Which is pretty much what you did with Red. I didnt make it about anyone, Jack. You just kept making it about you. With both the argument with Red and the one with me, you always make it about you. Hence, you draw attention to yourself and keep the Town from detecting other scum. Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

[bgrishinko]

There are a lot of votes going to Wombat and I haven't really seen a super good reason why. Maybe just gut instinct on some people, it can't be everyone. I'm curious as to why since before today Wombat hasn't had much attention besides a FoS here and there, now there are 3 votes.

[keyholder21]

Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

 

To me that reads like a PR.

[trench]

There are a lot of votes going to Wombat and I haven't really seen a super good reason why. Maybe just gut instinct on some people, it can't be everyone. I'm curious as to why since before today Wombat hasn't had much attention besides a FoS here and there, now there are 3 votes.

 

 

I voted Wombat because he FOS'd someone who had yet to take an active part in the game. How he see's Lia as scum from Moon's posts is beyond me. We lynched Moon before Lia joined the game. That post was worth a vote IMO.

[Minuet]

So, Wombat you suspect me most of all. I find that interesting. Not to mention some of your behavior has seemed odd. People call you on it and you bring up my name. Not meaning to join a bandwagon, but since it is forming I just can't resist. I just hope you really are scum and not just acting scummy. Oh, and if you think it is just an OMGUS you would be wrong.

 

Vote Wombat

[WWWwombat]

Who called me on what? Seems to me like you're looking for an excuse to vote me.

[Charis alAslan]

Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

 

To me that reads like a PR.

 

Bingo!

 

And I'm not happy about it.

[Christine]

Key: That's fair. I have been making a few noob mistakes. I can see why you would think I was scum.

 

Newting: I was responding to Sakaea's quoting. It was a quote fest. I didn't even remember that I mentioned the newting in the day1 quote fest. I am going to say it was just coincidence. No one has died from coconuts, but if they did, would you accuse everyone talking of coconuts?

 

The Jack Thing: I kind of regret pushing for a Jack vote. At the time, it seemed so clear to me that he had to be scum, but the more I thought about it, the less scummy he seemed. I still have my eye on him, but I am thinking that this is just his game play. A lot of people attack Red, but it's just the way she plays. If you aren't used to it, things can seem wrong!

 

 

As for my current vote... Ok screw it. I have been up for 48 hours now, it is morning in Japan, and late at night in the states, and I am traveling, haven't slept on any of my flights, and I need a shower. I will analyze more later.

[Charis alAslan]

Not game-related: My mom called and a close friend of the family has passed, so I have wakes and funerals this wk. Be on as much as I can, but if I dont post, just know I'm still here. Sigh.

[Sakaea]

I'm sorry, Charis . *snuggles*

[Sedai]

I think if we look at the first couple of people voting wombat or someone voting somewhere else. Rite now, we will find our vote switcher. That's an annoying power

 

Didn't someone say they FoS me for being silenced and no one came up today and claimed being silenced? I find whoever said that scummy. Because it looks like they may have skipped a night of silencing to try and set up people.

[Amadine]

I'm sorry for your loss Charis *hugs*

 

There's a lot going on still....

 

As for the death of 2 cult i would hazard a guess that if the characters were twins then they could have had a siblings role? Where if one dies they both die? Makes sense to me - i have seen it before.

 

GF has an odd posting style that does not sit well with me, the newting thing makes me uncomfortable also.

 

I agree with the suspicion of Charis, Red and Christine but Wombat is not setting off my scumdar - which in itself is highly unusual *eyes womby* I also still feel that Jack bears watching - i have nothing concrete but it doesn't feel right.

 

At this point in time i am going to VOTE CHRISTINE and see where the next day or so takes us.

[Red2111]

*Red sneers* Well I'll ask, but i don't think he;ll be very keen ... ah ... he's already got one, you see! *red Nods* Oh yes i'm sure he has one, it's very nice!

 

 

Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

 

To me that reads like a PR.

 

Bingo!

 

And I'm not happy about it.

 

 

Charis, be careful what you confirm on this. when i had my vote controlled Krak told me specifically that i couldn't hint or confirm on thread that i'd had my vote controlled. as this is what you've done and a lack of a MK from Krak on this; it makes me suspect your lieing about havign your vote controlled tbh.

 

 

VOTE CHARIS

[Sedai]

Also, Charis I'm sorry for your loss

[keyholder21]

I, too, am sorry for your losses Charis. Take all the time you need.

 

(Glad to hear the pregnancy is going well though.)

[bgrishinko]

*Red sneers* Well I'll ask, but i don't think he;ll be very keen ... ah ... he's already got one, you see! *red Nods* Oh yes i'm sure he has one, it's very nice!

 

 

Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

 

To me that reads like a PR.

 

Bingo!

 

And I'm not happy about it.

 

 

Charis, be careful what you confirm on this. when i had my vote controlled Krak told me specifically that i couldn't hint or confirm on thread that i'd had my vote controlled. as this is what you've done and a lack of a MK from Krak on this; it makes me suspect your lieing about havign your vote controlled tbh.

 

 

VOTE CHARIS

 

^^ This.

 

I've been forced to vote in other games and it usually follows this pattern. With all the other suspicions that have been piling up, well, I was willing to give you the benifit of the doubt on the Moon thing, but I think Red pinned it here.

 

Sorry for your loss. Maybe we can give you more time to focus on your life by allowing you to step out of the game.

 

Unvote: Vote Charis

[bgrishinko]

Also if Charis flips scum now, this will go a long way to improve my current opinion of Red as I don't think she would have ratted out a teammate so openly.

[Tiinker]

@Key - In my post I wasn't defending Moon. I said that I didn't think that newting and silencing were the same thing. And later Moon said that she just preferred the word newting to silencing. I think..

[Sedai]

Actually IMO BG if Charis flips scum then Red looks scummier. For previously stated reasons.

[Graendals favourite]

I said I preferred the word newting to silencing. However, did we just have a clear mafia-tell? The vote-forcer might even be himself, if he does not know the forcee can't reveal. A chance to lynch a mafia is way too precious to loose. unvote vote charis. (Sorry for the loss, btw!)

[Sakaea]

*Red sneers* Well I'll ask, but i don't think he;ll be very keen ... ah ... he's already got one, you see! *red Nods* Oh yes i'm sure he has one, it's very nice!

 

 

Other than you, of course. I've FoS Jack from the start, but unfortunately, today, my vote has to go to WOMBAT.

 

To me that reads like a PR.

 

Bingo!

 

And I'm not happy about it.

 

 

Charis, be careful what you confirm on this. when i had my vote controlled Krak told me specifically that i couldn't hint or confirm on thread that i'd had my vote controlled. as this is what you've done and a lack of a MK from Krak on this; it makes me suspect your lieing about havign your vote controlled tbh.

 

 

VOTE CHARIS

 

 

I'd just like to remind everyone that Krak said he was gonna be gone for a few days. So the lack of an MK might not be very telling. Also, people are suspicious of Red as well as Charis, so why several of you automatically believe she's telling the truth about what Krak told her is a bit confusing. She could be lying about it so we lynch Charis.