Wheel of Time Mafia Game Thread

[Myndrunner]

Based on that, a lynch of either Amadine or Alanna (not AJ) would be smart. The scum might try to NK the one who is innocent in order to discredit the whole A-list thing, but that is too big a risk for a veteran player to try.

 

Is Amadine still even in the game?

[Moon Sedai]

After a review of the thread, I am beginning to doubt my previous suspicions of Mynd, and I think I know who you are.

 

Our lynch to curt was because of overreactions and the like.

 

I suspect Drew. You are right, Mynd he has been pretty suspicious.

[bgrishinko]

BG was under the impression night should have ended by now.

[trench]

(I really thought the day would have started already but since I went to the trouble of putting this case together I will post it now)

 

OK here is who I think we should go after next. Amadine. This quote is why.

 

Based on Aemon's results and what we've been able to narrow down with Mynd's "A list", Amadine is the choice for today.

 

Vote Amadine

 

I suspect Aust used his ability on Amadine and the NA came back as Mafia. He came out quickly and voted for her. I think he used his NA on Amadine in response to Mynd's A list.

I think the Mafia figured out he was a cop because Amadine is indeed Mafia.

 

Mynd I thought you'd be excited that your letter A tip would be put to use. It really has been narrowed down to Amadine - why the hesitancy now?

 

When he was pushed, he said this. I think this is where he tipped his hand to the Mafia, which lead to his death that night. Because at this point the list was not narrowed down far enough to be sure enough for a vote that early in the day, unless he had other info.

 

For the sake of odds and logic, let's assume BG and Adella are telling the truth. Unvote

 

Occam's Razor (I prefer Gilette Quatro) would suggest that the Mafia have not been the ones doing as much of the accusing as the others. I can only go by what info I get due to the nature of my character. This is what I know, where can we go from here?

 

There could be certain artifacts in the game, some of you may have experienced it before, where you can ask three questions to some snakelike people and get three responses, though they may not be what you want. For example, suppose you asked "Who is mafia?" and the reply was something like "Someone whose name begins with the letter A" wouldn't be much to go on by itself, but it does produce a list of people we can narrow down.

 

Players who begin with the letter A (7): Aust, Amoondah, Alanna, AJ(alannalynn), Aemon, Amadine, Adella

 

With the whole mess with the compulsion, Red, and the finder stuff, I think we can all agree that Aemon is town. Aust and his silencing make him less likely to be scum and BG vouches for Adella being on a mason team with him. That leaves Amoondah, AJ, and Amadine if we are to go with logic and the odds and believe everyone else. From my casing, I've read little from Amadine, AJ is acting a-typical but was quick to point out her name was missing from the list of A's, and Amoondah has been "going with the flow" - quick to vote but not providing solid reasoning.

 

Right now, I'd say we lynch Amoondah.

 

Thoughts?

 

I bring this up again because it was the whole basis of Mynd's logic yesterday, and much of the basis in lynching Amoondah. The case on her was fairly weak - but with Mynd's tip it seemed like a promising lead and I would have gone with it myself it I hadn't been compelled to vote Nae. Today Mynd has abandoned this line of thought altogether - which surprised me because we've narrowed his list down to one name. I'll ask again Mynd - why did you completely drop this? Particularly when it seems like it might actually pay off?

 

Here again he reiterates that an Amadine lynch is an assured Mafia lynch. We still were unsure of a few names on the list. But Aust as a cop was able to narrow it down further. Again he further tips his hand as a finder. At first I thought his assertion that AJ was innocent was how he tipped his hand to the mafia. But durring this reread, these posts jumped out at me. Aust kept his vote on Amadine for the rest of the day, only switching it to Vambram in order to achive a majority.

 

Many people distracted and pushed the disscusion away from this topic. If we lynch Amadine today we will have more leads as to who to hunt next, by looking into the people who tried to divert this lynch.

[Talya]

He has also stated that AJ was innocent, so with what you are saying Trench and with that he could very well have given himself away to the Mafia as Finder. The only way to trust that theory would be to go with Amadine.

 

I thought night was supposed to end hours ago? If people don't get their night actions in in time, tough! At least that is my thought... >.>

[dapianoplay3r]

I thought thats how it worked but like the day we need the Mod to make the phase official

[Talya]

but on the first page it says Thursday 4.30pm EDT And I think that is 8.30pm my time, and still nothing happened...I don't like to wait, lol.

 

Womby my sweet...we want to get on and play...pwease!

[WWWwombat]

Be silent. Keep your forked tongue behind your teeth. I did not pass through fire and death to bandy crooked words with a witless worm. Okay, just felt like saying that... >.>

 

<3 Gandalf

 

Btw, sorry I'm late. didn't get online yesterday.

[WWWwombat]

Thom sat with his back to the wall, trimming his fingernails with a knife. He took a sip from his wine and thought about the events of the past few days. He hadn't wanted to get caught up in all this, but here he was, with the fate of the world in the balance. Thom heard a noise at the door and looked up. He was staring at a man with eyes of fire. Thom flicked his wrist and his knife flew at Ba'alzamon. The Heart of Dark waved his hand and the kinfe stopped in midair. Thom flicked two more knives at the fearsome figure. They both stopped as well. Thom leaped up, kicked the table over and drew two more knives. He didn't get to throw them. A fireball took him in the head.

 

Trench, Thom Merrilin, Vanilla Townie has been nightkilled.

 

 

It is now Day 7. With 22 alive, it takes 12 to lynch. You have until 8 PM on Monday to lynch someone

[Verbal32]

Understood, but given the size of this game, it's not impossible to have multiple scum teams.....which could mean some scum are just afraid to say anything incriminating and therefore are silent.

 

Either way, inactives don't vote, and make it harder to reach a majority. I'm aware of the math regarding the lynches of probably townies.....but I'm also aware of playing this game to have fun. It is not fun when half the game is silent. Sign up, be active, let's have fun. Sign up, be inactive, and you should get lynched on general principle.

I agree on inactives, and I'm definitely guilty of this during this game for RL problems, but I don't think wasting lynches on inactives so far into the game is the best idea. I would say it's the job of the mafia to kill off the inactives. A) It doesn't give much information, B) it helps everyone, mafia included. But maybe that's just me... lol.

 

Actually AJ, I would not consider you one of the inactives. You've posted enough (in my mind) to not be on my inactive list.

[WWWwombat]

Krak is returning to replace TMD.

[Talya]

At least some of the inactives are being replaced.

 

so on with the game.

 

BG

[Krakalakachkn]

wadupppppppppppppp

[alannalynn]

Understood, but given the size of this game, it's not impossible to have multiple scum teams.....which could mean some scum are just afraid to say anything incriminating and therefore are silent.

 

Either way, inactives don't vote, and make it harder to reach a majority. I'm aware of the math regarding the lynches of probably townies.....but I'm also aware of playing this game to have fun. It is not fun when half the game is silent. Sign up, be active, let's have fun. Sign up, be inactive, and you should get lynched on general principle.

I agree on inactives, and I'm definitely guilty of this during this game for RL problems, but I don't think wasting lynches on inactives so far into the game is the best idea. I would say it's the job of the mafia to kill off the inactives. A) It doesn't give much information, B) it helps everyone, mafia included. But maybe that's just me... lol.

 

Actually AJ, I would not consider you one of the inactives. You've posted enough (in my mind) to not be on my inactive list.

Well that's bloody wonderful, I feel inactive, and THAT is all that counts Verby!

 

Welcome back Krakenlachanananan

 

 

 

[Quibby]

Vote Mynd.

 

As awesome a player as you are, you've led us astray way too often. I don't know whether you're scum or just getting your vibes screwed up somehow, but you're becoming more of a liability as the game goes on. (Granted, I really wanted the Curt lynch, so I'm about as guilty of this as you are.)

[Krakalakachkn]

In all fairness, Curt did look really suspicious.

 

Also, I haven't been keeping up, so I have no idea what happened between page 80 and whatever page we're on now. I require time to reacclimatize!

[Quibby]

And I wouldn't argue that at all. However, Mynd has also led the charge on several of the other innocents that we've lynched. In fact, the only guilty party who died via lynching, he forgot to unvote in order to actually lynch. He's been playing the game well: casing people, baiting people, and otherwise making himself a pain in the butt like only Mynd can do. I will be the first to admit it. However, he's becoming a liability.

 

This vote is subject to change,but I honestly believe that it might end up being in the town's best interest to do this.

[Krakalakachkn]

Well, I'm all with you. I can't really talk about Krak 1.0, so yeah...

 

I'm all for a Mynd lynch.

 

Vote Mynd

[killuliu]

Does anyone wonder the odd coincidence that Trench got killed after he made his analyze? (look at the previous page) I agree that Mynd hasn't been the most successful when "leading" us (which is kind of unfair to say, because we all should be able to think for ourselves), but Trench made some very good points in his post.

[DrewRiley]

This is fishy. Trench makes a good case against Amadine based on Aust's findings, which seems pretty damn valid to me. Quibby defended Mynd yesterday and we lynched Curt. Now today, Quibby all of a sudden wants to dump Mynd? Your reasons are valid, Quibby, and everyone knows I'm down for a Mynd lynch, but this doesn't smell right. We know Aust was a cop, we know Trench was a townie, so this seems like a solid case to me.

 

Vote Amadine

 

Why the switch, Quibby? Why dismiss Trench and Aust's Amadine tip for something we're not 100% about? I'm really asking because you might be privy to something (and I'm not asking for a reveal!)

[Quibby]

There is no other information. This late in the game, if I had some other source of information, I would share it. For me, the switch is because I feel as if we've been led by the nose, and it has pretty much been the doom of us all (though the inactives who have been touched by the Modly Lightning have not helped us). Like you noted, we should be able to do our own casing, but I don't feel that we have been, myself included (recently). Instead, we have been relying on others to do our work for us, and we can all see how disastrous it has been. I'm voting for Mynd because his casing has led pretty solidly to innocents dying.

 

As for me defending Mynd yesterday, it's a matter of public record that I really wanted a Curt lynch, and have been pushing for one since Day 2 or 3. Of course I'm going to defend somebody whose casing and findings agree with mine. As has been mentioned numerous times, Curt really didn't help his case too much, and I don't feel bad, per se, for the lynch on him.

[alannalynn]

This is fishy. Trench makes a good case against Amadine based on Aust's findings, which seems pretty damn valid to me. Quibby defended Mynd yesterday and we lynched Curt. Now today, Quibby all of a sudden wants to dump Mynd? Your reasons are valid, Quibby, and everyone knows I'm down for a Mynd lynch, but this doesn't smell right. We know Aust was a cop, we know Trench was a townie, so this seems like a solid case to me.

 

Vote Amadine

 

Why the switch, Quibby? Why dismiss Trench and Aust's Amadine tip for something we're not 100% about? I'm really asking because you might be privy to something (and I'm not asking for a reveal!)

Or.... you're mafia and framed Amadine by lynching Trench? This is why I don't vote based on the NK...

[Quibby]

Oh, forgot to address a point. I'm not dismissing their points, merely aggressively opening another avenue of discussion.

[hotpocket2006]

Amadine Out of the A names left she is the most suspicious, and it makes sense when someone pointed out what Aust said.

 

I also don't vote based on the night kill. That's a wifom nightmare. There's no way you can actually glean any real info from a NK.

[Myndrunner]

Let's get to business first......the best lynch for info is definitely Amadine.

 

Krak 2.0 is definitely mafia, just sayin. The Master Dude always struck me as that barely active mafia player who chimed in right at the last minute to vote and avoid a modkill. Case him in this game and tell me he doesn't strike you as being prodded by his scum team to get his ass posting? Now Krak takes a "crack" at his role and immediately jumps on the Myndwagon.

 

Quibby, you totally 180'd here. Is this a last ditch effort to steer us off the Amadine lynch? CurtDragon lynched himself and failed to reveal his power role when his neck was on the block. I hope it was due to a misunderstanding of the rules and not a sour grapes post, but he cost us a valuable player. You can't say with one breath that I lead us anywhere and then agree that lynching Curt was the right thing to do.

 

Amadine today to finally once and for all clear up this A-List garbage. Then, we can deal with Quibby and Krak.

 

Thoughts? We can lynch Krak or Quibby instead and put Amadine off for later. They are more active.

 

*** Also, it is interesting to point out the specific use of Balzamon in the death scene. ***