[DPR Mafia] Call-Your-Shot Mafia- Points being posted...

[WWWwombat]

Nae's post seemed ok to me but Barm's positively stank.

[Naeann]

Did nobody see that I was joking in my reply back to him?  Does Kivam really think two seasoned players would be so obvious?  *shrugs and grins*

[Alys Kinch]

Not defending them, they did get defensive, but again, masons are just as likely to get defensive since they are the only group who know they are all innocent from the start and usually feel the have the best chances to win the thing. Just defensive is not a que for either side.

[Reyoru]

Glad to see I got the reaction l was looking for. And that others see it also.

Come on Nae dont dissemble.

[Kivam]

Yes, Rey.  You have figured us out. ::)  I picked on Barm more than once earlier on in the thread.  He jokingly got irritated about it and said he was never going to talk to me again.  As if that was some kind of threat or something.

 

Nae . . . if you were joking, it really didn't come across.  The eyeroll is not a "jokey" smiley - it's a "that's ridiculous!" smiley

[Naeann]

Don't Diwhat?  :-\  What reaction were you looking for?  Denial of said accusation?  I don't recall what exactly I said.. but I do remember mentioning that we HAVE talked.  I teased him and he playfully said he was never going to talk to me again.  I don't recall that I was that defensive with it.  Merely commenting on your accusation.  Do you ignore suspicions and accusations about you? I "annoyingly pick apart everything people say".  ;D

 

You could also say Alys and FDM MUST be a team.. with how Alys responded to my suspicions of FDM.  I must be a teammate to SOMEONE in this game.  This isn't the first time someone has said so. :)  Then again, many of us are linked to another player with all the psycho and psychologist, firefireter and firestarter roles out there.

 

Edit for new reply:  It was sarcasm.. which was a jokey reply.

[Lavinya]

I have to agree with Kivam on the defensive thing. If you intended it as a joke Nae, your words left much to be desired.

[Talya]

At least we can now get over the role reveal business.

 

HYou speak good common sense alys, which is another reason you set my alarm bells ringing. You are very good at being the voice of reason. It's not something I wopuld like to vote on though.

 

To be honest with all this business of people supposedly working with someone else. You can still get annoyed over those things and be innocent. It seems like people grasping at straws at trying to find evidence of something. On the first day there isn't going to be much unless someone really does make a big mistake, which is unlikely.

 

I didn't like Kivam's reveal suggestion, he did back track, and even he can make mistakes I'm sure. Pale stands out after having read everything that had been done wants it and then even after it being pointed out still tried to give it merit. I can't remember who the other supporter of the Reveal was. I'll have to check.

 

As for Nae's rolly eyes, (I'm not saying you have them!) I saw it more as sarcastic then anything else.

 

I thought Dae acted more like Thorum in the way that he came charging in, I haven't played with him in ages so can't remember if this is normally him. And now he has gone quiet!

 

I do prefer when the game gets narrowed down, because there seems too many people to keep track of at the moment.

[Reyoru]

Don't Diwhat?  :-\  What reaction were you looking for?  Denial of said accusation?  I don't recall what exactly I said.. but I do remember mentioning that we HAVE talked.  I teased him and he playfully said he was never going to talk to me again.  I don't recall that I was that defensive with it.  Merely commenting on your accusation.  Do you ignore suspicions and accusations about you? I "annoyingly pick apart everything people say".  ;D

 

You could also say Alys and FDM MUST be a team.. with how Alys responded to my suspicions of FDM.  I must be a teammate to SOMEONE in this game.  This isn't the first time someone has said so. :)  Then again, many of us are linked to another player with all the psycho and psychologist, firefireter and firestarter roles out there.

 

Edit for new reply:  It was sarcasm.. which was a jokey reply.

 

Yes you reacted and mentioned that you had talked. You should have left it at that. It's the latter part that feels a bit off:

 

I picked on Barm more than once earlier on in the thread.  He jokingly got irritated about it and said he was never going to talk to me again.  As if that was some kind of threat or something.

 

Its almost too neat. As if you drawing suspicion off that isnt there. If you were just joking, you could have easily thrown my comment off straight away. But the overexplanation seems a bit panicked.

 

 

 

[Alys Kinch]

HYou speak good common sense alys, which is another reason you set my alarm bells ringing. You are very good at being the voice of reason. It's not something I wopuld like to vote on though.

Thanks. :D  I always try to be the voice of reason. I also have a policy about lying unless absolutely necessary whether I am evil or not. Glad you noticed. It’s why I don’t know if I really do have a tell.

 

Still, that you keep going “Alys is suspicious” without real reasons will begin to bother me soon.

 

[Naeann]

Nah not panicked.  I understand you have never played with me before so you are unsure of how i'd react but, at the risk of suggesting metagaming, take a look at the charmed game in the white tower.  I don't panic.  I answered your suspicions with sarcasm.  I'm good at that.  It's the rl me shining thru.  

 

 

Alys, I forget if it was you or FDM that made the comment about always finding me suspicious and stuff but, as I've asked Kivam and DPR before already.. I'd love to hear from some of the older players about how I play and get tips or suggestions for improvement. :P

[Far Dareis Mai]

It was me. If I had a pinger, you'd be pinging it. :P

 

 

[Lavinya]

I don't know what they're up to Rey, but it was a very interesting reaction on both sides from the smallest of comments. *looks thoughtful*

[Talya]

Alys, It's because I know you are a good player, which is why I'm not acting on it and because I have nothing. And I'm with you on the lying business. The more you keep to the truth the less you can be caught up in a lie.

 

I also find this business with Nae and Barm as a bit grasping at straws. But then it didn't really strike me as odd.

[Alys Kinch]

I've said what I think on that one. If anyone wants to know, they can go back and read.

 

 

Also on a totally unrelated note, I love DPR. I love DPR. I love DPR. *nods and grins*

[Naeann]

It was me. If I had a pinger, you'd be pinging it. :P

 

 

 

Lol... I guess the feeling is mutual. :-*  I'd like to keep you around a bit longer though and it's not enough to merit a vote anyways.

 

 

I'm amazed at how many of you are all over this suspicion of Rey's just because I couldn't keep my scarcasm out of my reply.  It's kind of amusing.  I didn't see that huge of a reaction from Barm either.. but that might be because I know weather or not he's my team mate.

[Barmacral]

It was me. If I had a pinger, you'd be pinging it. :P

 

 

 

You can ping my pinger any time. :P

[Naeann]

That's what she said?

[DPR]

 

[Alys Kinch]

Back on track, guys. We need to start heading to a consolidated lynch so we can try to improve our nonexistant font of intelligence. Or info if you will. :P

[LilyElizabeth]

Nae, you're starting to remind me of me when I'm trying to prove I'm not mafia.

[Reyoru]

Nae is brushing it away again...

[Naeann]

I still dunno what that word you used earlier means and what is it I'm brushing away?  Do I have something on my shirt?

 

I'm simply enjoying the light banter.  It makes the game more fun.  If riling you up with my sarcasm to your suspicions makes you post more and keeps the game rolling then thats cool. ;D

 

Lily I haven't played with you enough to really pickup on what you'd do but that doesnt mean that's what Joe would do.

 

If I truly was mafia with Barm I wouldn't respond to the suspicion of it by calling more suspicion down on my head by sarcastically telling Rey that he found us out.  I'd likely have just ignored the comment and carried on.  I'd like to think I'm a smart enough mafia player that I wouldn't call attention to the very suspicion that would get not only me, but also a teammate killed right off the bat.

[WWWwombat]

I thought Rey was just poking but he's sure insistent isn't he?

[cosmicpanda]

Nae's mafia. [glow=red,2,300]unvote, vote: Nae[/glow]

 

Mafia's not about light banter, it's about scumhunting. Lynch the scum!

 

(of course, don't forget the Alys - FDM pairing or Lavinya's way of accusing Nae without really accusing her, which looks like it could be bussing:)

 

I don't know what they're up to Rey, but it was a very interesting reaction on both sides from the smallest of comments. *looks thoughtful*