Who would win in a fight? Jedi or Aes Sedai?

[Lord Monty]

thoughts? ;D

[Red2111]

jedi most certaintly. 

 

aes sedia would be sent into a daze by the pretty colors of a light saber  ;D

[Jemlin]

Lets see,

 

Jedi would run around, waving their pretty glowbats and spouting out droves of meditational babble.

 

The Aes Sedai would either:

1. bind them with air, and fry their butts with *real* lightning (not that force lighting crap).

2. explode the ground around them...can't really reflect THAT witha saber, now can ye?

3. Balefire, Balefire, Balefire  ;D

[Phariah]

i am a fan of both

jedi wins if he can get a hit in but thats seriously in doubt..lets see earth explosion, fireball, balefire, air bindings, just *poof* the jedi's head like a melon, sure there are a few more

[Kaznen]

Two jedi have used the power of a black hole to suit there own purposes.  Let's see an AS do THAT!

[Downplay]

Aes Sedai easy the jedi would have no way to block the weaves plus they could just make the earth erupt

[LedZepMan]

ok, are all of you forgetting the jedi mind tricks. What is to say an AS can deflect that.

 

Jedi mind controlls the AS, and wham, bye bye AS head

[Red2111]

not to mention that AS are bound by the 3 oaths.

 

Jedi's are not dark friends

 

and an AS cannot use the power on them until the Jedi attacks

 

by then the "force" has already been deployed and the AS is at their mercy  ;D

[Ticondrius]

You MUST remember...you have to be able to see to channel.  A Jedi can simply Force Blind the AS and anything she's even started to do would dissipate.

 

Of course, the best defense would be: "I am not the Jedi you are looking for."  *handwave*

[Krakalakachkn]

Jedi could deflect the fireballs with the force, just brush them aside or create a shield with the force.  Jedi can also channel energy through them without damage, how much energy depends on each Jedi, Darth Vader did it in Empire Strikes Back when Han shot his blaster at him.

 

Besides, we see the most powerful application of the force done by the Witches of Dathomir.  They literally sucked the life out of Luke using the force.  I never understood why Lucas or other didn't use the force as a more powerful weapon.  Jedi could literally snap people's necks, rupture their brain, stop their heart, break their hands, the force can be used in so many ways we never saw in the movies.  AS can't block the jedi's ability to use the force, so if they tried to start any weaves, the Jedi could just bind them with the force, stop their heart, mind wipe them, whatever.

 

A Jedi would totally win unless the AS snuck up on him, but that would be hard to do with his Force Sense.

[Ticondrius]

Now, an Aes Sedai with a Jedi warder....that's another thing entirely.

[MierinWru]

Doesn't matter cause whoever wins gets nuked by a photon torpedo sent by Captain Picard orbiting Randland with the Enterprise.

[Ticondrius]

Nope, sorry.  Jedi routinely move Proton Torpedoes around with their minds even in Star Wars...See New Jedi Era book series.  If Yoda can move a starship...you know, Size Matters Not?...a Jedi could force punch the Enterprise out of the star system.  ;D

[Red2111]

a jedi warder... now thats inretsting!!  it has potential *evil grin*

[Ticondrius]

I suppose that would make me the White Towers first then?

[Barmacral]

Naw, Verbal's probably got you beat. He's so far managed to prove himself the most knowledgeable Star Wars person in the WT.

[Ticondrius]

Oh?  I think he's in for a surprise.  :)

[Krakalakachkn]

yeah, i think I could give him a run for his money

[mcs0083]

Nope, sorry.  Jedi routinely move Proton Torpedoes around with their minds even in Star Wars...See New Jedi Era book series.  If Yoda can move a starship...you know, Size Matters Not?...a Jedi could force punch the Enterprise out of the star system.   ;D

PHOTON torpedoes my friend. Photon

[Ticondrius]

Not in Star wars, my backwards Trekkie friend.  ;)

 

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Proton_torpedo

[mcs0083]

Oh

Your right. Sorry. And I actually don't like Star Trek at all. Except for the movie. That was pretty good.

[Covai Seriba]

And then the Borg assimilate the Trollocs  ;D

 

 

Seriously though, which would be stronger?

 

 

Compulsion Vs Jedi Mindtrick 

 

Balefire Vs ......well whatever force lighting stuff you want to use :P

[Ticondrius]

There was a lot more to Force powers than what you got to see in movies.  :P

One of the trump cards was Absorb/Dissipate Energy.  Vader used that power to absorb Han's blaster shots, then used the power absorbed to pull it out of his hand in Cloud City.  Can you imagine what fueling that power with Balefire would do?  Sheesh...

 

The big problem in any Aes Sedai vs Jedi is simple.  Aes Sedai draw on the One Power, made of 5 types of elemental threads.  Jedi draw on the very essence of life, The Force. The resulting manifestation is more of a psychic power than the elemental one that the One Power is.

[Krakalakachkn]

There was a lot more to Force powers than what you got to see in movies.  :P

One of the trump cards was Absorb/Dissipate Energy.  Vader used that power to absorb Han's blaster shots, then used the power absorbed to pull it out of his hand in Cloud City.  Can you imagine what fueling that power with Balefire would do?  Sheesh...

 

 

Now why does that sound familiar?  :P

 

Vader wasn't even that good at absorbing energy.  Imagine what someone like Nejaa Halcyon would do with all that Balefire Energy.  I wonder though, could Balefire be absorbed?  At the very least, I suppose a jedi could move a rock or some other object into the Balefire path.

 

Also, another win for the jedi.  While it doesn't seem like a few seconds is that long of a time to complete a weave, a Jedi can call on the force instantly, which would make a significant difference when facing an Aes Sedai

[Ticondrius]

Heck, Nejaa's grandson, Corran, could make you THINK you killed him...while he was actually sneaking around behind you.  Affect Mind forcepower.