GoT Mafia "A Song of Wolves and Villagers"

[Ironeyes]

4 minutes ago, Songstress said:

Also, just to throw this wrinkle out there.

 

There is either a vanilla-izer or some sort of role thief in the game.

[Ironeyes]

IF this role is non-town, I sincerely hope it's a role deleter rather than a role thief, since I outed myself so early... Three kills out of town hands is so much worse than two

[Ironeyes]

Also are you sure that whatever it was that tipped you off wasn't just Blackhoof's role block? And am I sure I should be going off on this tangent rather than solving the game? Are you sneakily appealing to my weakness for mechanics discussions? Are we human? Or are we dancer? 

[Andrej]

Tiny dancer

 

in my hand

[Songstress]

Just now, Ironeyes said:

Also are you sure that whatever it was that tipped you off wasn't just Blackhoof's role block? And am I sure I should be going off on this tangent rather than solving the game? Are you sneakily appealing to my weakness for mechanics discussions? Are we human? Or are we dancer? 

 

I had a role D1.  As of the start of D2 I was informed that I am now vanilla town.    

[beadsman]

Huh. Weird.

 

@Ironeyes Care to explain your mechanical reasons for Darthe and Hallia being town? I'm mighty curious.

[Ironeyes]

Just now, beadsman said:

Huh. Weird.

 

@Ironeyes Care to explain your mechanical reasons for Darthe and Hallia being town? I'm mighty curious.

They aren't mine, they're borrowed. Hallia and Nyn left hints in D1 

[beadsman]

How exactly do you mean?

[Songstress]

There was a pretty extensive conversation a little while ago about Darthe being Nyn's N0 peek.

 

And Hallia said very openly during D1 that she can clear herself whenever she wants to.

[beadsman]

Just now, Songstress said:

There was a pretty extensive conversation a little while ago about Darthe being Nyn's N0 peek.

 

And Hallia said very openly during D1 that she can clear herself whenever she wants to.

Hallia saying that; does it mean we should automatically believe it? I just want to be really sure before actually writing someone off.

[beadsman]

It's possible I'm just missing something about game mechanics here. If someone is really convincing about Hallia, I'd be ecstatic to be that much closer to the real culprits.

[Andrej]

I imagine Hallia could prove it herself given what she said.

[Ironeyes]

Just now, beadsman said:

It's possible I'm just missing something about game mechanics here. If someone is really convincing about Hallia, I'd be ecstatic to be that much closer to the real culprits.

There's a role called an Innocent Child, which is basically a mod-confirmed vanilla town. Some of them are revealed at the game's start, while others can reveal at will by PMing the mods. It's a believable claim IMO

[Ironeyes]

Or rather, a believable hint

[Songstress]

1 minute ago, beadsman said:

Hallia saying that; does it mean we should automatically believe it? I just want to be really sure before actually writing someone off.

 

She's not 100% clear until she does it - but if pressured she'll have to.  It's not smart to make promises like that unless you can back them up.

 

[Ironeyes]

Yeah, what they said

[Hallia]

1 hour ago, dicetosser1 said:

 Kaylee   TOWN COP

2. Kat 

3. Cory

4. AJ

5. Blackhoof     SCUM RB

6. David Hermes     (mia)

7. Tress

8. Krak             (mia)

9. Hallia

10. Iron

11. Beads

12. Darthe   

13. Dice

14. The Sociopath 

15. Bard Babe    TOWN DOC

16. Nyn               TOWN SEER

17. BFG           (mia)

 

 

so if beads is off the table for today that leaves  BFG, Iron, Me Krak, tress, illian,aj and cory

 

 

• BARD BABE- (7)- NYN, CORY, HALLIA, TRESS, SOCIO, AJ, KAT

 

so im wanting to look between cory aj tress and kat

 

1 hour ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

becauswe i doubt scum all sat on socio. we KNOW hoof was scum

 

I KNOW im not scum

 

irons claimed vig mshot on kaylee

 

and beads has claimed something or other

 

1 hour ago, Andrej said:

 

That’s fine in a nutshell.

 

still doesn’t explain to me why you’re trying to wrench control of the narrative, which I don’t think I’ve ever seen you do before.

 

you’re entering villain complex territory, as I like to call it. I think anyone who was paying close attention to D1 would see Hoof’s death and think Beads shot him, as I did. Instead you presented the narrative that Kaylee was the vig kill and Hoof the SK for low info before it was revealed that Marsh shot Kaylee. Bad guys like to monologue. I don’t think you’re partners with Hoof but you make a pretty solid SK in my eyes.

 

52 minutes ago, dicetosser1 said:

 

lol im trying not to do that with you.

 

having read you so well for so long i tend to overreact when you arnt as i expect and so far its blown up in my face every time i think.

 

so either you need to go back to being Ned or I need to reign in my expectations and reactions.

 

 

48 minutes ago, Andrej said:

 

or I'm correct and you're scum and you are instead trying to reason with me instead of just digging in and being obstinate?

 

Just these snippits here and ffff.  I like how Dice has been posting but AJ makes good points...and Dice being reasonable seems so odd to me. XD

 

18 minutes ago, Ironeyes said:

Kaylee

Bard Babe

Nyn

Ironeyes

 

Town for trusted mechanical reasons

Hallia

Darthe

 

Town reads

Kat 

Cory

AJ

 

Town leans

Dice

The Sociopath 

Beads

 

Currently WTL

Illian

Tress

Krak

BFG

 

Blackhoof

 

 

I  like this, except Kat being down in the WTL for me 

Just now, Andrej said:

I imagine Hallia could prove it herself given what she said.

I can indeed

[Blackhoof]

Go scum.... Boo whomever killed me..... Cersei.... will be.... MINE!!! *dies*

 

 

[beadsman]

11 minutes ago, Blackhoof said:

Go scum.... Boo whomever killed me..... Cersei.... will be.... MINE!!! *dies*

 

 

Also, did anyone else think Hoof's avatar looks like the symbol for Hydra?

[Ironeyes]

4 minutes ago, beadsman said:

Also, did anyone else think Hoof's avatar looks like the symbol for Hydra?

Random lol. 

[Andrej]

15 minutes ago, beadsman said:

Also, did anyone else think Hoof's avatar looks like the symbol for Hydra?

 

So that's why you suspected him.

[BFG]

Hello friends<3 sorry I, uh, missed day 1 I'll see what I can do to catch up<3

[Krakalakachkn]

2 hours ago, Cory Caboose said:

Krak have you ever read me as a villager? lol

 

lol I'm pretty sure.  There have GOT to be some games I would think.

[Krakalakachkn]

2 hours ago, Andrej said:

 

Raisins?

 

Beads read as reactionary and windblown especially wrt Cory and AJ as everyone was saying how core town they could be

Cory read as backseat driving (which is almost always the case and frustrating but the nice part is that those times I'm right about him I've been 100% confident and those times I was wrong no one listened to me so it didn't matter.)

umm BFG....

 

Marsh was playing a certain way that combined with something else didn't look good to me.  Imma keep that in my pocket for now.

 

darthe bc Nyn

Hallia bc she said so

Dice because I'm reading him town (he and Nyn are my 90% secure soulreads)

I really liked Socio's reactions and methodical responses yesterday

AJ seems authentic

 

basically a fair amount of blah blah blah, mostly surface level atm

[Krakalakachkn]

2 hours ago, Songstress said:

 

I had a role D1.  As of the start of D2 I was informed that I am now vanilla town.    

 

Did you use your role N1?