[Standard] Chrono Trigger Mafia - Town wins Day 5!

[Niniel]

 

Turin asked how my reevaluation of Dice is different from yours on me, unless I misunderstood.

I.E. - from Turin's POV how is mine not scummy and yours is?

I think that's a pretty spot on comment from his outside perspective and it makes me town read him a little more.

 

 

I see.  So with this in mind...you still think im scummy?

 

 

 

Then stop pussy footing and give one.

I think by now you should have one, one way or another.

 

 

Why should I have one by now?  You havent been normal Boss Town!AJ self atp.

 

I dont know if that necessarily make you scum or not yet as you havent played here in awhile.

 

But I will do as you ask

 

AJ- ???

 

 

But tbh I have some concerns and reservations.  I dont think youve been overly Towny or overly Scummy.  AJ are you 3rd party perhaps?

Ill have a reads list after i get a chance to go back over things.

Did you mention the boss townAJ thing before Yates brought up that he thinks AJ isn't aggressive enough?

 

 

I dont recall but is that even relevant.  I dont fully associate Boss AJ with aggressive AJ.  I associate Boss AJ with, town telling quite clearly, making astute points and observations that i can follow and agree with and making solid reads,

 

Is there a point to your question?

Yes, I wondered if you were just joining in on others arguments. I did not know that this what you think about bossAJ. Thanks.

 

 

 

About Lenlo - I have in my notes that I wondered about post 235 but I don't have time to go back to that now. Daughter time again. Will be back when her favorite tv show starts later.

[Lenlo]

Oh yeah she was...

[Lenlo]

 

I never made a full blown case on Dice. I have mentioned in multiple places that he is off though and doesn't feel like town!Dice. He's more neutral which isn't good. Also a number of his posts have just been weird to me. Like the Zander joke.

 

I agree with the Dice thing but bad reads arent ALWAYS scummy, I mean just in my own case look back my last couple games.

 

Len what is it exactly about Hally thats bothering you?

She is being inconsistent in regards to me/the other "nulls".

[Hallia]

Oh yeah she was...

Annnnnd? You were saying?

[Hallia]

No, I had you as null. I listed different reasonings as why I would or would not vote those nulls.

[Verbal32]

 

 

I never made a full blown case on Dice. I have mentioned in multiple places that he is off though and doesn't feel like town!Dice. He's more neutral which isn't good. Also a number of his posts have just been weird to me. Like the Zander joke.

 

I agree with the Dice thing but bad reads arent ALWAYS scummy, I mean just in my own case look back my last couple games.

 

Len what is it exactly about Hally thats bothering you?

She is being inconsistent in regards to me/the other "nulls".

 

 

For the record, and I know I basically said this a bit ago, but I'm with Lenlo on this one.....

[Zander?]

Zander I would appreciate your opinions on the player list in full.

 

Ill show you mine if you show me yours?

 

 

Im working on it but can i still see yours?

 

[Andrej]

I'll wait.

[Hallia]

I have explained why I am wtl Len and not my two other, how is that inconsistent?

[BFG]

Votecount

 

Dicetosser1 (2/7): Turin, Lenlo

AJ (3/7): Nolder, TinaHel, Verb

Nolder (1/7): Hallia

 

Not Voting (6): AJ, Dice, Leelou, Thane, Yates, Zander

 

 

 

 

Again if anyone thinks I've missed a vote or unvote I'd appreciate a link or a quote <3

[Yates]

 

I guess I am just going to never understand why you would put a non-read as a hello first and have that non-read as town and include real reads under it. You know, maybe just saying hello would have been better?

 

I think you're tunneling a little too much on this.....

 

Disagree. I think it's a valid concern.

[Hallia]

Who are you going to vote, Yates?

[Andrej]

Is it scummy though?

 

That's the real question.

[Zander?]

Yates- Yates has been on point, involved and engaging, he's also been explaining things out and almost acting like an intermediary when theres been a disconnect between players.  That being said Yates is also 100% capable of fooling me but as of now, no one feels Townier then he does to me,

Hallia- Wasnt a fan of the Yates town read joke thing,  But Hallia has picked it up considerably after that.  Hallia like me doesnt always convey things clearly and also like me marches to the beat of her own drum. But Hallia's biggest town tell is volume and presence and I highly doubt Scum!Hallia cant replicate this imo.

Verb- He started off slow but has really picked it up.  And other then Hallia I think were seeing eye to eye on things which makes me feel better about him, 

Lenlo- I still cant believe im typing this.  But after his catch up hes feeling more involved and Lenlolike and fwiw this doesnt feel like Matirx or GnD to me,

 

Lee- Will need to look her over to form a better read.  I dont have a lot of experience with her.

Thane- Once I see his reasoning for reads Ill have a better idea of how to read him. 

Turin- Hasnt done nothing to ping me really so thats a good sign but ive also totally read him wrong the last couple games.  Will need more time to figure out.

 

Tina- Has been weird. but thats not totally uncommon for her. Ive liked her catchup posts more so theres that going for her.

AJ- Well heres the tough spot.  I felt he was defensive irt to me.  I havent liked some of his responses in regards to me.  And I feel like some of the stuff hes tried to sell us on like the constancy thing with Verb, hes backed down on.  My biggest thing is that Im not seeing Boss Town!AJ which Ive come to expect.

 

Nolder- His scum meta is to derp so to speak a bit.  I can kinda see where he came from irt to the Tina thing but still its hard to shake that feeling like hes well into his scum range.  I also think there may be ties between him and AJ.

Dice- Straight up doesnt feel like Town Dice to me.  He's been overly jokey.  No votes as of yet which is kind of uncommon for Town DIce imo.  No strong stances.  And really hes made a few solid game posts but there few and far between.

 

[v] Dice [/v]

 

Not my strongest scum read ever but my reads have also been pretty crappy lately.  Theres still some time left before DL to see what shakes out.  But atp prolly willing to lynch out of my bottom 4.

[Yates]

Who are you going to vote, Yates?

I was going to vote you. But I like your recent posts and actually think you are being harassed a bit right now because you were considered a consensus lynch pool candidate.

 

Probably Dice, tbh. If he doesn't wow me in the next hour or two I'm going there.

[Hallia]

I just wasn't really on. Its hard on mobile, but the boss is away today, so I can be on desktop.

[Clovdyx]

Votecount

Dicetosser1 (3/7): Turin, Lenlo, Zander
AJ (3/7): Nolder, TinaHel, Verb
Nolder (1/7): Hallia

Not Voting (5): AJ, Dice, Leelou, Thane, Yates

[Hallia]

I will say for dice that he hasn't been on in a while.

[Hallia]

Which I don't like.

[Andrej]

Breaking the rules at work.

 

I like your style, Hallia.

 

I also won't be voting you, thanks for picking it up.

[Hallia]

I'm a rebel

[Hallia]

It's my dad in law, what's he gonna do >=D

[Andrej]

I can vote Dice, and will if it means my neck or his, but I'm not thoroughly thrilled about it.

 

If he flips scum, fantastic.

 

If town, well...

[Yates]

So I said te above before reading this:

 

Yates- Yates has been on point, involved and engaging, he's also been explaining things out and almost acting like an intermediary when theres been a disconnect between players.  That being said Yates is also 100% capable of fooling me but as of now, no one feels Townier then he does to me,

Hallia- Wasnt a fan of the Yates town read joke thing,  But Hallia has picked it up considerably after that.  Hallia like me doesnt always convey things clearly and also like me marches to the beat of her own drum. But Hallia's biggest town tell is volume and presence and I highly doubt Scum!Hallia cant replicate this imo.

Verb- He started off slow but has really picked it up.  And other then Hallia I think were seeing eye to eye on things which makes me feel better about him, 

Lenlo- I still cant believe im typing this.  But after his catch up hes feeling more involved and Lenlolike and fwiw this doesnt feel like Matirx or GnD to me,

 

Lee- Will need to look her over to form a better read.  I dont have a lot of experience with her.

Thane- Once I see his reasoning for reads Ill have a better idea of how to read him. 

Turin- Hasnt done nothing to ping me really so thats a good sign but ive also totally read him wrong the last couple games.  Will need more time to figure out.

 

Tina- Has been weird. but thats not totally uncommon for her. Ive liked her catchup posts more so theres that going for her.

AJ- Well heres the tough spot.  I felt he was defensive irt to me.  I havent liked some of his responses in regards to me.  And I feel like some of the stuff hes tried to sell us on like the constancy thing with Verb, hes backed down on.  My biggest thing is that Im not seeing Boss Town!AJ which Ive come to expect.

 

Nolder- His scum meta is to derp so to speak a bit.  I can kinda see where he came from irt to the Tina thing but still its hard to shake that feeling like hes well into his scum range.  I also think there may be ties between him and AJ.

Dice- Straight up doesnt feel like Town Dice to me.  He's been overly jokey.  No votes as of yet which is kind of uncommon for Town DIce imo.  No strong stances.  And really hes made a few solid game posts but there few and far between.

 

[v] Dice [/v]

 

Not my strongest scum read ever but my reads have also been pretty crappy lately.  Theres still some time left before DL to see what shakes out.  But atp prolly willing to lynch out of my bottom 4.

 

This post was basically copy/pasted from my brain. We might be secret masons after all... There is way too much mind melding in here for Zander to be faking it so he just locked himself Town for me in one post.

 

I'm particularly a fan of his Hally read as well as his thoughts on the bottom 5. We may disagree slightly on where AJ is ranked but I completely believe his thought process for having AJ exactly where he does.

[Hallia]

*nodnod* I get it.