Avatar The Last Airbender Town and SK wins!

[Turin Turambar]

[seph]

Ithi in that post I was just pointing out another possibility you missed. Which is just as likely as the others.

 

If you like me to i can go quote them as I mentioned my reasoning earlier. I am on my phone now, so each quote will have a seperate post. He has shown no intention of trying to solve this game.

Iso him and tell me what you think?

[Ithillian Turambar]

Bugger.

 

What did I admit to seeing? I don't remember anything like that.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Yes I know I came and posted here before I came and said hello to you. I'm terrible

 

Also my eldest is still thumping around hmph.

[Andrej]

For those who care. It's almost 9 PM. I've been up since 5.30. I get home from work after six. Make tea. Do homework. Make swords. Read stories. Put do bed. Wait for silence. Do laundry. Wash pots. Pick up toys. And finally it's this time of night and I have about an hour before I sleep.

It's well known I'm usually not available till this time. AJ seeks to use my prioritising of home life as something negative no doubt.

Yeah, we get it. You have a life outside of MafIa. Most of us do.

 

You're here now. Is there anything you want to say besides "I think I'm right" ?

[Turin Turambar]

is okay.

 

naughty eldest. Hope they sleep soon.

[seph]

Let me try and remember and summarise the Seph thing. He jumped in after Tress vote. He thought I was mafia. Then he thought I was town. When I didn't move my vote off him he thought I was mafia again. I think he also voted and then re voted me.

 

His syntax is strange sometimes ... but maybe now I've had a quick look back it makes his posts more honest.

 

He seems very reactive but so am I. If I change my perspective from my usual everyone is mafia to everyone is town I can see an unhappy pressured town behaving like that. It is true that Dice would caution him from provoking me if he were mafia. .. but that could also be a good way to hide.

 

Eldrick defence of his posts still causes me some concern.

 

Sooh did make a case on me that seems to indicate she thinks I'm mafia. I usually vote for people I think are mafia and so I'm still thinking that case was built as a nudge or to look like she's actively casing someone. Not actually voting me could be because she's worried I'll look at her more.

 

AJ has got a lot more in depth and involved since I posted his previous work. He was very unhappy that I did not think I was town. There was a lot of discounting and Ithi you are just wrong!

 

Too much perhaps for two votes. I would have thought a proactive town would have gone fair enough and continued to play and give alternatives with reasoning.

 

I'm still confident with my vote on him. My other choices would be Eldrick and Sooh. Seph has moved down. I have Tress as Town.

 

.

this is the post I was referring to ithi.

I also took out the dice part for dice lol.

[Turin Turambar]

 

For those who care. It's almost 9 PM. I've been up since 5.30. I get home from work after six. Make tea. Do homework. Make swords. Read stories. Put do bed. Wait for silence. Do laundry. Wash pots. Pick up toys. And finally it's this time of night and I have about an hour before I sleep.

It's well known I'm usually not available till this time. AJ seeks to use my prioritising of home life as something negative no doubt.

Yeah, we get it. You have a life outside of MafIa. Most of us do.

 

You're here now. Is there anything you want to say besides "I think I'm right" ?

Actually, an "I think I'm right." From Ithi is like dice's gut, a solid read.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Ithi in that post I was just pointing out another possibility you missed. Which is just as likely as the others.

 

If you like me to i can go quote them as I mentioned my reasoning earlier. I am on my phone now, so each quote will have a seperate post. He has shown no intention of trying to solve this game.

Iso him and tell me what you think?

When will you all learn I can't do the iso thing. I just kind of see things and store. I remember Sooh saying I wasn't playing like Town me cos I didn't do the multi quote thing and I was like bahahahaha like when have I ever done that.

 

Basically snow has made little contribution, isn't helpful and isn't aj or seph.

 

The top two reasons could also go for not bob and nolder content wise and they are also not you pair.

 

Why snow in particular. Give me three closing arguments on the case. I don't need quotes. Just reasons

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

Let me try and remember and summarise the Seph thing. He jumped in after Tress vote. He thought I was mafia. Then he thought I was town. When I didn't move my vote off him he thought I was mafia again. I think he also voted and then re voted me.

 

His syntax is strange sometimes ... but maybe now I've had a quick look back it makes his posts more honest.

 

He seems very reactive but so am I. If I change my perspective from my usual everyone is mafia to everyone is town I can see an unhappy pressured town behaving like that. It is true that Dice would caution him from provoking me if he were mafia. .. but that could also be a good way to hide.

 

Eldrick defence of his posts still causes me some concern.

 

Sooh did make a case on me that seems to indicate she thinks I'm mafia. I usually vote for people I think are mafia and so I'm still thinking that case was built as a nudge or to look like she's actively casing someone. Not actually voting me could be because she's worried I'll look at her more.

 

AJ has got a lot more in depth and involved since I posted his previous work. He was very unhappy that I did not think I was town. There was a lot of discounting and Ithi you are just wrong!

 

Too much perhaps for two votes. I would have thought a proactive town would have gone fair enough and continued to play and give alternatives with reasoning.

 

I'm still confident with my vote on him. My other choices would be Eldrick and Sooh. Seph has moved down. I have Tress as Town.

 

.

this is the post I was referring to ithi.

I also took out the dice part for dice lol.

That's my post ...

 

What's dice got to do with it?

[seph]

If you think I am wrong on snow please convince me otherwise. I just dont see it.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Oh right. The other one you quoted was in response. Okies

[seph]

I thought this post

Bugger.

 

What did I admit to seeing? I don't remember anything like that.

 

Was in reference to this post

Lynching aj is a bad idea day one. Ithi lists alot of probabilities but one she doesn't is the aj is simply town and spotted a townie. He was making reads un biased and looking past the words with intent.

I may be wrong but I am pretty sure after he asked ithi to do the same, she started to come around. If aj isnt town, he is playing Damn well.

So that is were the last quote came from. I think it wasn't directed at me then lol

[Ithillian Turambar]

If you think I am wrong on snow please convince me otherwise. I just dont see it.

You haven't told me why you think you're right. I already said I got nothing on Snow. You're the one voting him so your the one who must have the best reasons. I just want to know what they are. If I missed them it's ok to re quote.

[Ithillian Turambar]

No. It was to aj who said I'd admitted to seeing something he said I should have seen.

 

I don't know what he meant.

[seph]

I am out of the house currently and it was quite a few pages age....I can only go back one page at a time.

[Sooh]

 

Lynching aj is a bad idea day one. Ithi lists alot of probabilities but one she doesn't is the aj is simply town and spotted a townie. He was making reads un biased and looking past the words with intent.

I may be wrong but I am pretty sure after he asked ithi to do the same, she started to come around. If aj isnt town, he is playing Damn well.

I find it very difficult to believe anyone is town. I don't have anything on Snow as he's not someone I've been really paying attention to. What are the top three reasons he seems to be mafia?

 

If people are starting to think of using the consolidation reason for voting I'd rather they did it on aj.

 

I find it very interesting that none of the trains that have occurred in this phase have gathered much traction and a relatively new one has appeared close to end of day.

 

That always makes me think I had it right maybe as I'm well known for pushing the lynch I want through ... but no one has really gone with any of my choices and have actually been persuading folks to back off. I still actually think aj and seph might be mafia.

 

I'd rather have a mafia lynched that a no lynch.

 

Can you just clarify one thing for me Ithi? You don't think anyone's town yet?

[Sooh]

Also Tress? You have Ithi as your most suspicious but no vote?

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

For those who care. It's almost 9 PM. I've been up since 5.30. I get home from work after six. Make tea. Do homework. Make swords. Read stories. Put do bed. Wait for silence. Do laundry. Wash pots. Pick up toys. And finally it's this time of night and I have about an hour before I sleep.

It's well known I'm usually not available till this time. AJ seeks to use my prioritising of home life as something negative no doubt.

Yeah, we get it. You have a life outside of MafIa. Most of us do.

 

You're here now. Is there anything you want to say besides "I think I'm right" ?

You're the one who implied I was silent for other reasons. I was correcting your misperception - especially as when I did post as soon as I was able you also made another post that seemed to imply I'd only popped up because I'd been mentioned.

[Nolder]

 

 

The one I am most suspicious of currently is with Nolder.

Haha what?

How can you be this obvious?

You weren't even talking about me until I came in and voted you and now I'm #1 suspect?

What happened to John Snow? Now suddenly it's me, AJ, and maybe Notbob?

 

Another misrep by snipping out the context. The line above what you quoted talks about convos AJ had that I saw w/w potential in. At least I am pretty sure of that. On mobile so can't verify. If that group yours was and is the most troubling.

 

I'm still voting AJ if that means anything to you.

 

You're really going to argue that I'm misrepping you by taking the quote out of context?

Ok let's go over the context.

 

Here's the full quote.

I did case tress and vote her early. I left my vote there because she hadn't done anything to cause me to remove it. She was gone for some time. The first post she came back with was explaining her crankiness due to hormonal issues(her words). I have never known her to play about her RL when stuff comes up so I didn't push her. I figured she would reply when ready. Not really much yet but I am being patient.

 

You will note that one of the things that perked my ears if you will about tress was her banter with ... Wait for it... AJ. That suspicion was on both of them. AJ has had other similar incidents during the game. The one I am most suspicious of currently is with Nolder. There was some small convo and AJ immediately puts Nolder as a green read. He lowers Nolder on his published read list for being inactive but doesn't include Nolder in the let's lynch pool. Now he is giving credit to Nolder for being clever and noting something(I assume the false connection Nolder made between me and NotBob) that is a misrep.

 

You yourself noted how he pushed himself as lock clear. anyone trying to proclaim themself lick clear sets my teeth on edge. When it happened I was still distracted with Ithi so I didn't bring it up but I did note it. you also note his Seph defense. AJ admits he doesn't know Seph from Adam. This is the first game they have played together. I don't see going from suspect to solid town in this case was genuine. There were lots of little defenses along the way. I think these were intended as AJ would have seen Seph as lynchbait but more valuable to make himself look good in the long run.

 

Right now I think mafia are AJ, Nolder. Not sure of the third yeT.

 

if both of them are then I would look at NotBob on the chance Nolder slipped.

 

Now let's go over it.

 

I did case tress and vote her early. I left my vote there because she hadn't done anything to cause me to remove it. She was gone for some time. The first post she came back with was explaining her crankiness due to hormonal issues(her words). I have never known her to play about her RL when stuff comes up so I didn't push her. I figured she would reply when ready. Not really much yet but I am being patient.

None of this has to do with me or the point I'm focusing on which is that you're supposedly most suspicious of me. So I snipped it.

 

You will note that one of the things that perked my ears if you will about tress was her banter with ... Wait for it... AJ. That suspicion was on both of them. AJ has had other similar incidents during the game.

This next bit has to do with Tress and AJ. Again, nothing to do with me.

 

The one I am most suspicious of currently is with Nolder. There was some small convo and AJ immediately puts Nolder as a green read. He lowers Nolder on his published read list for being inactive but doesn't include Nolder in the let's lynch pool. Now he is giving credit to Nolder for being clever and noting something(I assume the false connection Nolder made between me and NotBob) that is a misrep.

Here is the exact quote in it's proper place in context. Do the sentences that follow add anything? I don't think so. The point is that you're suspicious of me. We get that from the first sentence. I don't care why you say you're suspicious of me which is all this is. Something about how AJ is giving me credit (that's my fault how? How does that make me scummy again?) over a misrep. All that matters here is that you're saying you are most suspicious of me. I could of course go over why it is and try to refute that but the fact of the matter is, again, I don't care why. You are so suddenly suspicious of me that it is that suddenness which is my point, not the reasons you try to justify it with.

 

You yourself noted how he pushed himself as lock clear. anyone trying to proclaim themself lick clear sets my teeth on edge. When it happened I was still distracted with Ithi so I didn't bring it up but I did note it. you also note his Seph defense. AJ admits he doesn't know Seph from Adam. This is the first game they have played together. I don't see going from suspect to solid town in this case was genuine. There were lots of little defenses along the way. I think these were intended as AJ would have seen Seph as lynchbait but more valuable to make himself look good in the long run.

This is again all about AJ not me. One might take from this that you're lying about me being your number 1 suspect and that you're just saying that.

 

Right now I think mafia are AJ, Nolder. Not sure of the third yeT.

 

if both of them are then I would look at NotBob on the chance Nolder slipped.

And here's where you tie it all up saying you think it's me AJ and maybe Notbob but we already established that you think it's me from the sentence that I originally cut out.

 

So why don't you explain what context you think was missing and how it added anything because I'm not seeing it which is exactly why I cut out all this nonsense in the first place.

[Nolder]

btw the fact that you're still voting AJ just further proves my point.

How can you say I'm your #1 suspect while you're voting someone else.

Doesn't make any sense.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I find it very difficult to believe anyone is town is what I actually said.

 

I start with everyone is mafia.

 

Very gradually I may start to trust some players. The only player I've thought is probably town so far is tress. I have said this several times.

 

Not sure why you'd re - angle my post like that.

[Ithillian Turambar]

I am out of the house currently and it was quite a few pages age....I can only go back one page at a time.

I know the feeling. I don't even have my super fast easy to code blackberry any more.

[Andrej]

 

 

For those who care. It's almost 9 PM. I've been up since 5.30. I get home from work after six. Make tea. Do homework. Make swords. Read stories. Put do bed. Wait for silence. Do laundry. Wash pots. Pick up toys. And finally it's this time of night and I have about an hour before I sleep.

It's well known I'm usually not available till this time. AJ seeks to use my prioritising of home life as something negative no doubt.

Yeah, we get it. You have a life outside of MafIa. Most of us do.

You're here now. Is there anything you want to say besides "I think I'm right" ?

You're the one who implied I was silent for other reasons. I was correcting your misperception - especially as when I did post as soon as I was able you also made another post that seemed to imply I'd only popped up because I'd been mentioned.

I wasn't implying anything when you popped up. I just found it ironic hence my ironic comment. You didn't need to go and spell out your entire schedule for us and throw in the little snippet about your home life at the end.

 

Anyway - have you even read the thread since you last posted?

[Songstress]

Also Tress? You have Ithi as your most suspicious but no vote?

Read my post. I said why I wasn't voting.