Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[csarmi]

Told you guys to NK Hally.

 

Why U no listen to me?

[csarmi]

Remember that time I said I had more shots? I do. I allllllmost used it on him. So glad I didn't!

Him not claiming, talking just giving a "go town" was a giveaway to me.

[Niniel]

Great! Not that I had anything to do with it. 

 

I guess I will have to admit that Krak looks better now. :D 

[csarmi]

Bored. For 20 minutes anyway.

[csarmi]

Len is still scum.

[csarmi]

Perturbed about my scum reads following my trains (Des then Tina) but at least I was right on Des.

 

Still wary of Turin/Pray but I'm gonna work with Len/Tina.

 

My lock clears are still town.

[csarmi]

And my townies suspect Tsuki.

[Lenlo]

Len is still scum.

You still a LLL.

 

Now that the formalities are out of the way, anything new? Or should I just go back to page 70 to get anything new from you?

[Lenlo]

Your*

[csarmi]

Hally, gut reads?

[csarmi]

Well you can play you know.

 

Like commenting on game events and scum hunt and such.

[csarmi]

Y u no hunt Len?

 

You used to be better than this at scumming.

[Lenlo]

 

Len is still scum.

You still a LLL.

 

Now that the formalities are out of the way, anything new? Or should I just go back to page 70 to get anything new from you?

 

This was actually completely unnecessary and im sorry. Rough day at work so far and I dont mean to use that as an excuse to insult you.

[Pralaya]

Man this stuff is amusing.

 

Krak is NOWHERE to be seen now that his goose is cooked. Don't worry Krak, it will all be over soon

 

Csarmi is in full #damagecontrol mode, which is hilarious considering how many times he said earlier in the game how his activity level would never go any higher this game, not no way, not no how (yet he's all looking for spew and trying to say the derail on Thane D1 should be looked into.... even tho it was Mynd, who flipped town, who caused the derail lulz)

 

Oh and el oh el @ his "I'm practically confirmed", like a Miller is GUARANTEED to be in a role madness game. That tickled me to a great extent.

 

Yup, those two are CONFIRMED all right, as in CONFIRMED SCUM.

 

I thought Pray was in #damagecontrol mode too there for a bit and that Hallia might be derptown, but with Csarmi's recent wifom defense of Hallia (saying she would Governor save a symp as scum- laughable. Would lock her in as scum for everyone else, and don't forget his "she might be third party" lol) I'm pretty much ready to lock her in as scum as well.

 

Lenlo is on my radar however, for that catch by Turin about the three scumreads listed thing. Also think it was Turin that pointed out that strange "scumread" of Lenlo by Chae D1 could have actually been distancing, which is supported by the fact that she shot Turin instead of Lenlo.

 

Speaking of Turin btw, it's been insane how much we've been able to wreck scum together this game. See what we can accomplish when we don't tunnel on one another bro?

 

 

And I dont find Ithi and Turin's switch on Thane all that alarming from D1, it seemed to come naturally from their suspicion of Mynd. They didn't recalibrate their read of Thane after that like they should have, but regardless I can see where they would have arrived at the conclusion that Thane was lynchbait. So they're both still LOCK CLEAR for me.

 

Soooooooo much more I wanna say atm, but we're starting audit now. Will have to go into moar detail later, and start going back through to see if I missed anything. Not too sure Thane knew who his teammates were, since his reads seemed to shift so much, and it looks like I was right in that him calling out the roles was his signal to teammates. Chae/Krak is scum JOAT, and thinking Hallia is GF with a Governor shot perhaps, and Csarmi a goon.

 

Toodles for now!

 

This is after the Thane lynch on D2.

 

I have a feeling that everyone he has mentioned in this post is town. He calls some of them scum, some of them town. But, looking at who he has missed in this post - BFG, Tina, Tsuki and Dice.

 

Then some *spam*, *spam*, *spam*

 

Srs do. We will NEVER know exactly how much Thane knew about his team.

 

But consider this-

 

Thane, an admitted newbie who is still learning the ropes of this game (<3 you tho bud, don't quit on us, just get a mentor or something that can help you out a bit), comes into a ROLE MADNESS game, and starts acting like he thinks he has a handle on what roles will be in the game (and lists JOAT and GF).

 

 

Someone else (Chae) comes forward after initially soft defending him, and hardcore defends him because she thinks he has extra information bout the setup EVEN THO HE HAD ALREADY CLAIMED VANILLA (Irene Adler VT but let's not go down that road again)

 

 

She THEN clarifies later on that she is, in fact, a JOAT which is why she defended him like she did. One of the roles he named the scum team would have.

 

 

And then he flips Symp

 

-____________________________________________-

 

It could not get ANY MOAR obvious imo that Chae's team realized he was a symp, so she kind of sillily tried defending him. It worked too, for a while, till GOATDESPOT showed up and smacked some sense into yall.

 

Any who refrain from voting Chae/Krak from this point forward will be claiming scum in my eyes.

THen goes hard after Krak. He makes up stuff like he is a scum JOAT and he knew NotBob's role and so on. Which we can now clearly assume Des role-copped NotBob. This kind of clears Krak. Note how he starts saying that anybody who doesnt go after Krak is scym. Heh.

 

I´m still willing to vote Chae/Krak, Lenlo and Hally. I could also go with Csarmi. 

 

[v] Krak [/v]

 

It´s not only that Chae defended Thane. She wrote that strange list, she claimed JoaT (a role we now know that Thane pointed out as possible mafia role) and then self voted. In the end Thane defended her as well. 

 

 Lenlo went even higher on my list because of the "three mafia".

You make a good point regarding them both, Tina.  I left work early, so I'm just sitting by the phone, will be trying to formulate some more thoughts, but in the meantime

 

Vote Krak

Tina and Hally start voting Krak after this. The timing of Des' forceful post and these votes makes me feel one of Tina or Hally is scum. Given that Hally did not save Des today, gives me a town feel on her. That leaves Tina, who is anyway my suspect.

 

I forgot about the countertrain yesterday as well- Tsuki is likely LOCK CLEAR since scum tried saving their symp

Truer words were never spoken. Guess who tried "saving their symp" by voting Tsuki - Dice

 

[v]Chak[/v]

 

Wanna see something...

And, Tsuki "sees something". It is either Tsuki/Dice who is scum at this point

[Pralaya]

But then,

 

why do i have a bad feeling we just lynched town?

Trying to influence Hally, eh?

Dice is lock scum.

 

We just need to find the rest. Tina is leading the rest, followed by Len.

[Pralaya]

Those are my reads and while I am good at getting the scum, I am bad at convincing others. Hopefully, others will follow my leads and get the win ffor us. I will leave the convincing part to Turin, since he is my strongest town lean at the moment and he is the best at it.

 

So, either me or Turin is going to get NK tonight.

 

Fortunately, we got the strongarm and the roleblocker. So, Turin, it is up to you, man. Use your judgement well for the NA tonight. We have to end the night with no town death !

[Tsukibana]

 

[v]Chak[/v]

 

Wanna see something...

And, Tsuki "sees something". It is either Tsuki/Dice who is scum at this point

 

 

Actually, I wanted to see if Hallia would immediately jump off the train if someone else jumped on.

[csarmi]

Hally not saving Despo doesn't mean anything alignment wise. A scum governor can't have more than one shot.

[csarmi]

She's town tho and she seems to be able to prove it.

[Hallia]

Right now my gut says it's between Tsuki, Tina, and Dice.

[Turin Turambar]

I would really like to get full reads from everyone no later than with their first post of the next day phase.

[Lenlo]

I would really like to get full reads from everyone no later than with their first post of the next day phase.

So if someone were to, theoretically, put it in their second post, what would be the punishment for such an action?

[Turin Turambar]

My ideas on people at this time. Many of these are conflicted because the fact Despo was mafia and is devious. If I forget anyone remind me.

 

Csarmi: still not liking his play but it is possible Despo spews him town.

 

Hallia: would like more than the limited attempts to help solve. Plus the lack of answering Tina for a while and still not answering the follow up. Either answer or don't. Possible that she was spewed town also. Hopefully so.

 

Pral: town. It isn't morning yet.

 

BFG: pretty sure she is town. I still have a bit if doubt because of the manner of her claim. Also not as much #work as I would like out if town bfg. But I'm busy too.

 

Dice: starting to think he is mafia and I was right about X on D1. Looking back I could see what I was taking as third party play as that of a GF looking to get viewed. We have no clue if he was. Also a few things I noticed. First the two posts recently where he hints at hallia to save Despo(good catch Pralaya) and the damn Despo post of being fooled looked forced. Additionally earlier when I FoS him and also when tsuki? Did his reaction was odd to me. I was concentrating on someone else then but now thinking back it pinged. If someone could check that out I would appreciate.

 

Len: very conflicted. I think he might be the teammate Despo was keeping a suspicion on but never getting around to pushing. Did des ever really push Len? But Lens interaction with Thane seemed real and town. Also the quick hammer was a little odd.

 

Krak: I think Despo flipping mafia JOAT makes krak look more town. I wish we had some confirmation of any of his actions.

 

Tina: very quiet. I still don't have much of a feel for her posts yet. ?????

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

I would really like to get full reads from everyone no later than with their first post of the next day phase.

So if someone were to, theoretically, put it in their second post, what would be the punishment for such an action?

Speedlynch

 

Smart alecky kids... Get off my lawn!!!

[Turin Turambar]

Forgot tsuki. I think his penchant to argue is natural. I am at a loss there Tbh. Probably why I didn't list him to start.

 

 

Right.now I think dice is where my vote will go in the morning pending any new information.