Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

Hallia · June 17, 2014

Insofar as me claiming early - I will always if I feel it'll help. It forced a loopy more conversation than would've happened if I hadn't

I ain't changing my ways!

Hallia · June 17, 2014

Insofar as me claiming early - I will always if I feel it'll help. It forced a loopy more conversation than would've happened if I hadn't

I ain't changing my ways!

Hallia · June 17, 2014

Also, I personally think I'm being hella active and forthcoming with information, which is great for me!

Basel Gill · June 18, 2014

While we're waiting on night actions, I present you with a badass bar fight!

Mrs. Cindy Gill · June 18, 2014

ya that about sums it up :laugh:

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

So for those it still isn't clear. Turin would like every one of us to make a read list where there are definite (x is town) type of sentences about each player. Might help lie detectors or roles like that.

This is a wise thing to do.

can that work for a Ld? i thought it had to be a statement about me. didnt think me stating what someone else was would work. great thinking if it does yho!

Your mafia reads coincide with mine, Des, but I'm mafia? That makes no sense.
Did you actually give a full set of reads? I must have missed it.

No, still on mah mobile at work, but I did have Thane AND Tina listed as scum reads.

Meh, if they kill me fine, I'll flip town and I'll be validated.

If not I still have my shots

is this post correct?

Tsukibana · June 18, 2014

You mean the part where she says "still have my SHOTS" (plural), but earlier she claimed 1x... or am I arguing semantics again :P

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

no what ure doing is opening ure mouth when u shouldn't! headdesk

Tsukibana · June 18, 2014

And why the bloody hell should I keep my mouth shut??

Turin Turambar · June 18, 2014

@dice, any statement may be checked. if the player knows the facts of that statement then a true or false answer should be given. Therefore If I was mafia and I said, "dice is town" but i KNEW that you were mafia because you were on my team, the check would come back as a lie.

Also, you shouldn't have bothered to ask the correct question if you didn't think someone would follow up on it. by noting that there might be discrepancy it was as good as calling it out directly. The mafia are looking for hints too.

The thing I find more interesting was that Hallia noted she was still on mobile at work then but hasn't posted a list since. Unless her first post was at the start of her shift. I dunno.

What are you guys reads?

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

i was kidding tsuki dont get upset.

the idea was to see what Hallia said without any influence by someone else

Hallia · June 18, 2014

Just got home, we had a celebration after work for my sis's new place.

Hallia · June 18, 2014

That was attempt at WIFOM without realizing I'd already said how many shots I had.

Reasons Hallia can't be mafia #342

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

i did think someone would follow up on it turin. namely Hallia. I HOPED others would realize to not respond

Tsukibana · June 18, 2014

Like you expected any other response than the one she gave. The one rule of being cryptic:

Either you were so cryptic NO ONE got it, not even who you intended, or EVERYONE gets it.

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

wanna quote that hally?

dicetosser1 · June 18, 2014

Tsuki she may not have even seen what was wrong with it.

She may have given reasons why she said what she did.

she may have tried to just blow it off.

these are some possible options.

Thane Vakarian · June 18, 2014

so, yeah. I have read that people requested i return to the game. I have asked the mod if it was ok, and here i am.

Now that things in the thread have calmed done, and myself too, here's a few thoughts:

Thunderdome.... wow... i followed through notification and ... wow... Mynd flipped town. I am surprised. I voted him before i self-voted. I do strongly believe that Ithi is town. I still have a little doubt about Turin being town with Ithi, because they seemingly always play like this together and it could well be a ruse for scumTurin to hide behind.

i am quite curious to see what will happen this night. I'll try to be around (when not at work, then i will only read notifications) and will try to get my act together and help town win this game.

My apologies to all i might have offended or disappointed.

game on