Jump to content
We have a Patreon! Support this website and get exclusive content ×

DRAGONMOUNT

 A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY

Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

wheeloftime13

By wheeloftime13
in DM Mafia Games

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
鲍勃不是我的名字 Experienced

鲍勃不是我的名字

Posted
Posted

 

 

I am town.  I win with town.

 

Still think we lynch from the four players on both town lynches.

 

Mish:  claimed LD

Wombat:  Mish claims to have checked him for lying.  Asserts he is town.

Tigraine:  Have not seen reveal or reason not to lynch.  Anyone want to defend her?

Kraka:  my #1 choice for scum at this point.  Highly recommend we lynch him now.

 

I'm still at this point.  Could also lynch Wombat to verify Mish's LD claim.

 

 

It won't verify her claim.

 

 

Where is your vote currently?

Darthe Spam Master

Darthe

Posted
Posted

I don't think I'm voting anyone.  Certainly don't intend to vote Wombat to not verify shit and ease your confirmation bias.

peacesells Veteran

peacesells

Posted
Posted

 

 

Mish,

 

So now I am completely lost on why you claimed? You had no votes on you. You were at least looking a bit scummy so it was likely you wouldn't get night killed. Being the LD you were in a perfect non-reveal position. What gives?

This is absolutely disgusting. You baited her to reveal with blatant and obnoxious rolefishing and now you're acting like you don't understand why she did?

 

unvote

Vote: Peace

 

 

Good observation.

 

BS.  Considering it looked like Krak was breadcrumbing LD first and Mish looked to be the ST.  Pressuring Mish was appropriate.

鲍勃不是我的名字 Experienced

鲍勃不是我的名字

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

Mish,

 

So now I am completely lost on why you claimed? You had no votes on you. You were at least looking a bit scummy so it was likely you wouldn't get night killed. Being the LD you were in a perfect non-reveal position. What gives?

This is absolutely disgusting. You baited her to reveal with blatant and obnoxious rolefishing and now you're acting like you don't understand why she did?

 

unvote

Vote: Peace

 

 

Good observation.

 

BS.  Considering it looked like Krak was breadcrumbing LD first and Mish looked to be the ST.  Pressuring Mish was appropriate.

 

 

Personally, I thought it was stranger that she revealed with zero votes but I have to acknowledge when the Wombat makes an observation that may come in handy later.

 

Just saying.

WWWwombat Spam Master

WWWwombat

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

 

 

Mish,

 

So now I am completely lost on why you claimed? You had no votes on you. You were at least looking a bit scummy so it was likely you wouldn't get night killed. Being the LD you were in a perfect non-reveal position. What gives?

This is absolutely disgusting. You baited her to reveal with blatant and obnoxious rolefishing and now you're acting like you don't understand why she did?

 

unvote

Vote: Peace

Good observation.

BS. Considering it looked like Krak was breadcrumbing LD first and Mish looked to be the ST. Pressuring Mish was appropriate.

No it wasn't. If you'd thought for a second you would've realized it was just as likely that she was LD and Krak was silvertongue. I can't believe that didn't occur to you. Therefore, I believe you are scum.

peacesells Veteran

peacesells

Posted
Posted

 

 

 

 

Mish,

 

So now I am completely lost on why you claimed? You had no votes on you. You were at least looking a bit scummy so it was likely you wouldn't get night killed. Being the LD you were in a perfect non-reveal position. What gives?

This is absolutely disgusting. You baited her to reveal with blatant and obnoxious rolefishing and now you're acting like you don't understand why she did?

 

unvote

Vote: Peace

Good observation.

BS. Considering it looked like Krak was breadcrumbing LD first and Mish looked to be the ST. Pressuring Mish was appropriate.

No it wasn't. If you'd thought for a second you would've realized it was just as likely that she was LD and Krak was silvertongue. I can't believe that didn't occur to you. Therefore, I believe you are scum.

 

No, if you look how he brought it up he stated Mish was trying to make it difficult for a LD to read her statement...hinting he wanted a clearer statement.

 

You are painting a picture with information that we have since received. If Mish is indeed the ST and not the LD then you are definitely scum.

alannalynn Spam Master

alannalynn

Posted
Posted

 

Yo! Yes, I can be called GF, saves trouble. I see there's some reading to be done.

 

48 hours enough time to contribute or do you still have some catching up to do?

 

^ This. What happened?

 

 

I"m liking not bob.  So much I might start calling him Just Bob. 

 

UNVOTE

 

Tglems...that was one good post.  Very succinct. 

 

Darthe =  a bunch of crap.

 

Vambram still no contribution.  Its like he's faking a bunch of newb questions.  He's not a newb.

 

Krak has had 1 or 2 good moments but generally scum.

 

Wombat convoluted.  Still don't know what he made up that strange reasoning for his case when I summed it up in about 8 words. 

 

Mish still scummy.  Has refused to answer my question several tiimes...although others seem happy to step in for her.  HEY PEOPLE.  LET THE PERSON THE QUESTION WAS ADDRESSED TO ANSWER.  VERY ANNOYING.

 

 

VOTE VAMBRAM.

 

God damn it Peace! I AM the lie detector. Happy now? I've breadcrumbed it enough, but that wasn't good enough for you is it? You just had to make me say it?

 

 

I was on the look-out for people hinting to an LD because I know there is a big chance the mafia has a silver tongue and so knew about me. That's why Krak stuck out to me so, with him pushing on me. Now I can also tell you that Thorum said D1 he was not mafia, and that is true, and Wombat said D2 that he's town, and that was also true. One of them might be the silvertounge of course; there's always that chance.

Peace I was agreeing with your post up until you fishy fished for the LD to come out. It's actually more benefit for the town if um... the LD is not known? Comprends? And Mish Mish Mish... you had no pressure except from Peace... and Krak(?). Why would you reveal unless you found scum anyways? Nobody was really looking at you. Just.. *sigh* These are rhetorical questions.

 

Some experienced players seem baffled about the roles of LD and ST. This is odd to me. It's not like the roles have never been used before. I'm namely FOSing Krak here. You were pushing the LD side earlier, without knowing what you were doing?

 

 

 

Rather: I don't know if he's the ST; I don't have proof either way. He could be, or another of the mafias could be.

 

Speaking of wich... I'm also adding Despo to my pile of suspects. He was the one who started on me with Kaylee with this post:

 

 

 

Sorry for the double post. Stupid DM.

 

Also, since I brought it up, we might as well get it set in stone so there's no wiggle room later:

 

Kaylee and Mish, are you two masons?

 

That's what's Krak been following up on afterwards, what started him pushing on me.

 

So are you saying that your phrasing in answer to Despothera's question was a hint that you were LD, or was it just how you decided to say it?

 

So are YOU saying you picked up on this hint or are you saying that you are a scummy mcscumster? The latter seems more of the case.

 

 

Mish,

 

So now I am completely lost on why you claimed?  You had no votes on you.  You were at least looking a bit scummy so it was likely you wouldn't get night killed.  Being the LD you were in a perfect non-reveal position.  What gives? 

FOS Peace. BAKA. What gives? YOU gives. You're moving up my list the more you talk.

 

 

I am town.  I win with town.

 

Still think we lynch from the four players on both town lynches.

 

Mish:  claimed LD

Wombat:  Mish claims to have checked him for lying.  Asserts he is town.

Tigraine:  Have not seen reveal or reason not to lynch.  Anyone want to defend her?

Kraka:  my #1 choice for scum at this point.  Highly recommend we lynch him now.

Out of these four, I'm most comfortable with the Krak lynch, his 'knowledge' of the LD is a little suspicious, and if he's ST he may confirm Mish (him being ST seeming likely at this point). If Mish is LD, she could be useful to the town. Wombat is just confusing me lately but he's been checked, and Tigs seems to be trying to be legitimately helpful lately.

Besides those four, I'm willing to lynch Vambram today as well.

 

I agree with Mish on Raz's not-logic. Honestly though, her being 'blocked' if she is or isn't actually cop could be any number of things. Right now, I'm content to believe that Hall is the cop without anyone trying to discredit her.

 

With that, Vote Kraka

Tyler Glembo Master

Tyler Glembo

Posted
Posted

 

Mish, can you view part of a post or do you have to view it all?  If so it could affect your readings.

I can do parts of a post. The post from Thorum I checked, I bolded the statement "You're lucky I'm not mafia this game" and asked Time about the bolded part.

 

 

Unless of course Time is inventive and disagrees about luck.

 

Either way, unvote

 

I'll look over the arguments against Krak.

 

Also, Darthe, as for breaking the silvertongue, the silvertongue could either correctly or incorrectly state the number of mafia in the game.

Krakalakachkn Spam Master

Krakalakachkn

Posted
Posted

I don't like the way this is going...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I"m liking not bob.  So much I might start calling him Just Bob. 

 

UNVOTE

 

Tglems...that was one good post.  Very succinct. 

 

Darthe =  a bunch of crap.

 

Vambram still no contribution.  Its like he's faking a bunch of newb questions.  He's not a newb.

 

Krak has had 1 or 2 good moments but generally scum.

 

Wombat convoluted.  Still don't know what he made up that strange reasoning for his case when I summed it up in about 8 words. 

 

Mish still scummy.  Has refused to answer my question several tiimes...although others seem happy to step in for her.  HEY PEOPLE.  LET THE PERSON THE QUESTION WAS ADDRESSED TO ANSWER.  VERY ANNOYING.

 

 

VOTE VAMBRAM.

 

God damn it Peace! I AM the lie detector. Happy now? I've breadcrumbed it enough, but that wasn't good enough for you is it? You just had to make me say it?

 

 

I was on the look-out for people hinting to an LD because I know there is a big chance the mafia has a silver tongue and so knew about me. That's why Krak stuck out to me so, with him pushing on me. Now I can also tell you that Thorum said D1 he was not mafia, and that is true, and Wombat said D2 that he's town, and that was also true. One of them might be the silvertounge of course; there's always that chance.

Peace I was agreeing with your post up until you fishy fished for the LD to come out. It's actually more benefit for the town if um... the LD is not known? Comprends? And Mish Mish Mish... you had no pressure except from Peace... and Krak(?). Why would you reveal unless you found scum anyways? Nobody was really looking at you. Just.. *sigh* These are rhetorical questions.

 

Some experienced players seem baffled about the roles of LD and ST. This is odd to me. It's not like the roles have never been used before. I'm namely FOSing Krak here. You were pushing the LD side earlier, without knowing what you were doing?

 

Baffled is a strong word if you were directing it at me.  I asked for specifics of the ST's role - I've never come across one.  And yeah I pushed the LD, it seemed like Mish was intentionally misphrasing.  I was a LD in the last game I played, so it was on my mind that there might be a reason she was wording her phrase so weird.  I didn't think she would turn out to be an LD.

 

 

Rather: I don't know if he's the ST; I don't have proof either way. He could be, or another of the mafias could be.

 

Speaking of wich... I'm also adding Despo to my pile of suspects. He was the one who started on me with Kaylee with this post:

 

 

 


Sorry for the double post. Stupid DM.
 
Also, since I brought it up, we might as well get it set in stone so there's no wiggle room later:
 
Kaylee and Mish, are you two masons?

 

That's what's Krak been following up on afterwards, what started him pushing on me.

 

So are you saying that your phrasing in answer to Despothera's question was a hint that you were LD, or was it just how you decided to say it?

 

So are YOU saying you picked up on this hint or are you saying that you are a scummy mcscumster? The latter seems more of the case.

 

What I'm asking is if she started breadcrumbing her role all the way back when I first asked her that question on day 1.  I obviously didn't pick up the hint, and it would seem no one else did either as Mish continued to be on suspect lists and people kept pressing her about the LD.  As for myself, looking back, I should not have mentioned anything at the beginning of Day 3.  That was my mistake.

 

 

 

Out of these four, I'm most comfortable with the Krak lynch, his 'knowledge' of the LD is a little suspicious, and if he's ST he may confirm Mish (him being ST seeming likely at this point).

 

 

 

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

About Dragonmount

Dragonmount is a fan-maintained website dedicated to Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time fantasy series. It is an online community of people from all over the world who have come here to experience the series to the fullest.

Twitter

Facebook

Copyright © 2024, Dragonmount Powered by Invision Community

© All borrowed artwork is used with permission. The Wheel of Time books & franchise are © Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

The phrases "The Wheel of Time‚" and "The Dragon Reborn", and the snake-wheel symbol are trademarks of Robert Jordan & the Bandersnatch Group.

×
×
  • Create New...