[ADVANCED] Forsaken in the White Tower: Town wins!

[Talya]

Tg...I was on about testing the claim about being in the tower..

[Tyler Glembo]

Ah.   I thought Darthe was advocating a mass name reveal.  I understand the claim testing for whether or not certain people are in the WT.

[Lenlo]

What would Min be doing in a hunt for the Black Ajah?

 

Min sounds like the fakest claim so far. She's no ones warder and she's not an Aes Sedai.

[Darthe]

Exactly.  We need clarity.

 

Also popcorn = you reveal your name and then you choose who goes next based on your read on them.  

[peacesells]

Exactly.  We need clarity.

 

Also popcorn = you reveal your name and then you choose who goes next based on your read on them.  

huh?

[Tyler Glembo]

Exactly.  We need clarity.

 

Also popcorn = you reveal your name and then you choose who goes next based on your read on them.  

 

First, I dont' like this suggestion.  It gives too much power to mafia for finding power roles.  Second, we need to focus on a lynch with the few hours left.  Not on asking everyone to come into the thread for a name reveal.  This distracts from the most important issue currently.  

[peacesells]

I suggest lynching me, ish, cloud, lenlo or rand.   One of those is the best.  Actually, I think Cloud would test the in the tower not in the tower theory.

[Tyler Glembo]

So, let's go in this order then.  Lynch Ishy, then tomorrow take a close look at Cloud to test the name-claim.  I am okay with letting your Min claim stand for the day.

[Tiinker]

I'd be okay with that. I think Birgitte would be my first choice of lynch. Can someone lay out why they've prioritized the way they have? I'd totally do it myself but I'm jumping between house-viewings all day and frankly I'm exhausted.

[John E. Kelley]

Time to remove some of the lingering WIFOM from Day One.

 

Vote Cloud.

 

Would like to take a much harder look at Tayla, Tina and Kay tomorrow.

[John E. Kelley]

So, let's go in this order then.  Lynch Ishy, then tomorrow take a close look at Cloud to test the name-claim.  I am okay with letting your Min claim stand for the day.

And seriously, the tunneling is getting weak.

[wheeloftime13]

What would Min be doing in a hunt for the Black Ajah?

 

Min sounds like the fakest claim so far. She's no ones warder and she's not an Aes Sedai.

 

the Min claim could be true if only because of her gift and how it "helped" Siuan...

[Niniel]

Ishy, why don´t you take a look at Talya today? 

[peacesells]

 

So, let's go in this order then.  Lynch Ishy, then tomorrow take a close look at Cloud to test the name-claim.  I am okay with letting your Min claim stand for the day.

And seriously, the tunneling is getting weak.

I think he has tunnelled pretty strong imo.  He's never left the tunnel. 

[Tyler Glembo]

 

 

So, let's go in this order then.  Lynch Ishy, then tomorrow take a close look at Cloud to test the name-claim.  I am okay with letting your Min claim stand for the day.

And seriously, the tunneling is getting weak.

I think he has tunnelled pretty strong imo.  He's never left the tunnel. 

 

I would have said my tunneling was pretty strong.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Wait - are you suggesting a mass name claim Darthe - I thought that was being sarcastic, but are you being honest about that.

[Talya]

I would have thought either Cloud (Thom) or Lenlo (Brigitte) would be the best choices. Lenlo would probably provide more info after the starting of the two trains yesterday and then the stalling. 

 

Min I think out of those three (two mentioned above) is more likely to be in the game, she was for a time at the WT...there does seem a kind of timeline here, if that is so. 

 

The thing about all these claims is that we have had no role claims (except Cloud because he knew he would have been found out sooner or later). They have only been the character they have been given. 

[Lenlo]

I'm pretty sure I said I was Vanilla Talya.

 

And I'm against lunching someone just to test their claim and see who might be in the game. Fake claims are a real possibility and they are more than likely to have someone who was in the tower.

 

I think we should ignore characters and focus on gameplay. Going after people based on their character is stupid IMO.

[John E. Kelley]

Going after people based on their character is stupid IMO.

Says the guy smack in the middle of the character controversy?

[peacesells]

I would have thought either Cloud (Thom) or Lenlo (Brigitte) would be the best choices. Lenlo would probably provide more info after the starting of the two trains yesterday and then the stalling. 

 

Min I think out of those three (two mentioned above) is more likely to be in the game, she was for a time at the WT...there does seem a kind of timeline here, if that is so. 

 

The thing about all these claims is that we have had no role claims (except Cloud because he knew he would have been found out sooner or later). They have only been the character they have been given. 

Actually you are right.  Lenlo makes more sense than cloud.

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE LENLO  The man in the middle.

[Talya]

We don't have much time again, I do not want to have another no lynch, we need to make sure there is a lynch today! We need information and even better get a mafia. 

 

We all seem to be talking about the characters, which is why I thought it a good place to start. 

 

I know you said you were vanilla, doesn't mean I have to believe you though, not sure what to believe which is why I would like information. 

[John E. Kelley]

I could switch to Len, as long as some of the Day One questions are cleared up.

[peacesells]

GAWD people..vote for someone.   Hopefully someone with some kind of train going.  Anyone of us is a good choice.

[Tyler Glembo]

GAWD people..vote for someone.   Hopefully someone with some kind of train going.  Anyone of us is a good choice.

 

This.

[John E. Kelley]

We need a current VC. Badly.