[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Nolder]

Unvote Vote Ed

 

Why are you still voting for Jon Snow?

[Leelou]

 

22. Leelou (replaced Lessa, Day 1)

 

 

Hi peeps...lemme just catch up in game.

[Songstress]

Welcome, Leelou!

[lolguy26]

hey leelou :D

[Sakaea]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Despo (1) Rand

Verbal (2) LZM, EP

EP (2) Eds, Red,

JLM (1) Basel

Leelou (1) John Snow

Ishy (1) Songs

Ed (2) Cyan, Nolder

Cyan (1) Lenlo

Razen (1) Des

 

Not voting: everyone else

 

With 24 alive, it takes 13 to lynch.

 

Leelou has replaced Lessa.

 

As to the spoiler policy, there is no set time frame, but as I've already said, if you consider it to be a possible spoiler, put it in tags please.

[Leelou]

LOL.

 

It WAS a hint tho. I was right, and my vote helped change it from a hint to a definitive claim. There was nothing scummy about it. I think you think you're a lot more clever than you are, I recognized it for a hint immediately, and ended up being right.

 

And the other part of your "scummy reaction" on me has already been covered: there ARE characters in the series who are bastards who would easily seem antitown.

 

Your vote did nothing but put your foot in your mouth. I had planned to reveal anyways. Get off your high horse already you're embarrassing yourself.

 

Also, ed no unvote after a full character claim? Interesting. I'm on vicodin so playing the doped up card won't really work.

 

Where you planning to reveal this early in Day 1?

[Verbal32]

How often would someone get the reactions they are after if they come out and say "Hey guys I want reactions" Verb, you should know this, I hope you are purposely playing dumb because you are scum otherwise I will be really disappointed in you.

 

You're missing the point. S'ok, just keep plodding along. You can have a seat at the kiddie table.

[John E. Kelley]

EP : "I have a great idea!!"

 

Rest of us : *headdesk*

 

Every. Single. Game.

[Leelou]

EP : "I have a great idea!!"

 

Rest of us : *headdesk*

 

Every. Single. Game.

 

Truth. Can we just make Thursday Lynch EP Thursday?

[Red2111]

my gut is screaming about EP reguradless of his claim. he's not reacting well to pressure, wants to play the "i haven't read the entire series card" then trys to assert he knows wtf he's talking about cannon wise, and this entire nonsense about revelaing; both posting a hint for no reason and then claiming he planned to reveal early anyways.

 

i dislike it, greatly; and my vote remains because be far this is the scummiest play yet.

 

 

Red, the LZM thing had nothing to do with this game, every time there is a reveal LZM flips out all over the game. Kinda illogical.

 

I added Nol's quote due to the fact that I was answering Nol. However, your defense of verbal is noted. I now like my vote where it is. With Red's first post, and then her reactions to my vote I'd suspect Red and Verb are on a team. I'm just a bit of a bastard aren't I?

 

so its a stupid meta grubbing move on Led. gotcha. stupid reason to bulldog imo, but whatever.

 

as to the underlined. now were you answer Nol or were you FoSing Verb?? which is it. becuase right now your claiming it was all abotu Verb. you can't have your cake and eat it too.

 

and now we have you linking people prematurely. infact your linking all over the place. and FYI i FoSd you over two people; so if your gonna go linking people why not also link me to Led in this case? no you shrug that off an focus on verb.

 

 

Where's Despo? I haven't seen him post yet. I'd like to hear from him.

 

Major ping. I never like players asking for other player's opinions, or building up other people's thoughts or ideas. And I am the LAST person people should do this with, considering my thoughts and ideas almost always come off as scummy to everyone else.

 

In fact, I'm upgrading this from a major ping to a hardcore ping

 

^ ditto

 

 

Oh and ftr, I purposely drew attention to push myself into a reveal. I have my reasons, I do like the reactions that I recieved though.

 

Nol pretty much ignored it, until I went back on Desp. Slight town read on him.

Verb, reasonable reaction, but looks bad in association with how Red reacted. I understand that it could be a set up on Verb by Red, but I want to see what plays out between Red and Verb from here on.

Desp: Illogical responses are illogical.

Red Defense of Verb, calling my reason for voting verb a stretch when half of her reason for voting me was for replying to Nolder's comment about Verb's.

Ed Nil read

 

and yes John, I meant Jon, I did mispell it.

 

okay are you skimming? you seriuosly tried to put a bit of suspicion on a mod confrimed townie and then (when reminded of this glaring fact) you go "oh well then everything he says is moot".

 

if your trying to adopt a Mynd style of play, them shoes is too big for you to fill dude and your not accomplishing anything but turing the spotlight to you. if your scum, well thanks for makign it easy; if your being truthful about your claim well good job for making the scums job easy D1.

 

 

So which policy is that? Just to be clear? Is that the EP policy, the role hint policy, the campaign policy, or the D1 policy? Wow the poor guy has a lot against him before we even consider how he is playing.

 

defense of Ep noted right here. and before we even consider how he's playing, are you skimming as well because he's given us plenty to judge his play style over.

 

 

 

I don't think, considering the subject matter, that any group must be considered town.

 

How many different factions have so called rightful claims to the thrown?

 

We had this discussion in detail last advanced GOT game. The possibilities are endless. So even if you are one of the two bastards you aren't off the hook.

 

There's even another angle you could be pushing. You could be neither and an actual scum and be dropping bastard hints trying to make you look town cause a counter claim with 2 options is tough to make.

 

We did have that discussion last game. Thing is, it was mostly scummy wifom generated to help keep town paranoid about everyone. I should know, I was one of the mafiosos pushing that discussion. I said what I said then because I was trying to help my team win. The fact is, I think the vast majority of GoT-themed games will have the Starks as town.

 

^ this. excluding the scratched out which is doing basically what you just chided peace for doing.

 

 

Why role claim or hint so early? Why? I think it's bad for town. It's seemed that way in the games I've been in so far, anyway. Maybe confirmed townies aren't always all good, either, I don't know?

 

major FoS and ping on this one. tryign to put some doubt on a mod confriemd townie. sloppy play imo but i question why you would say this. do you have reason to think the mods are lying to us?

 

i also agree with Ed, this feels like playing the newb card.

 

 

 

You voted me for me saying I'm a bastard, which could have been me saying that I legitimately think I am a bastard. (Ironically as I don't think my biological parents were married it doesn't matter bcus it's true on multiple levels) but yes it was a hint to Jon Snow the most notable bastard in the series.

 

okay, explain the bolded cause i'm confused here. how is Jon a bastard in more ways than one, hes ironically one of the most good & clean characters in thes series, only 2nd to Ned.

 

 

and no, Jon is not one of the most notable Bastards in the series. this is what i mean by asserting you KNOW about the cannon, especially more than those of use who have read up to DwD. either stop being an arrogant jerk about the cannon in this way or stop complaining about spoilers. cause your seriously putting your foot in your own mouth and its this reason mainly why i'm wanting to lynch you. it urks me to no end that people who only watch the movie/tv show or haven't read all the books want to argue about cannon with those of us that have read all the books and likely multiple times.

 

you're very wrong and tbh you don't know what yoru talkign about with this series, so just stop argueing cannon and stick to scum hunting.

 

 

What do yall think about Razen? Yall should vote him, imo

 

aside from his asking wher eyou are, what other reason is there for voting him?

 

 

You're bs "policy lynch vote" just because "hinted at a character" especially since the 2 ppl most known for the status of the hint are what could be considered "good guys" in the cannon.

 

again, you LITERALLY know NOTHING about the cannon. stop talkign like you do. makes me relaly think someone is coaching you on ASoF&I stuff. adn if they are, they're doing a very poor job.

 

also, Jon is known for alot more than being a bastard. maybe if your on Book 1 you'd say this, but thats really low on the list of things the character is known for tbh.

 

 

It WAS a hint tho. I was right, and my vote helped change it from a hint to a definitive claim. There was nothing scummy about it. I think you think you're a lot more clever than you are, I recognized it for a hint immediately, and ended up being right.

 

so your happy about getting a perosn to claim a character o.0

 

major FoS there bro.

 

 

EP, im siding with Des on this one. Your saying his vote on you for thinking a hint was a hint is scummy because you didnt confirm it as a hint until after he voted. Thats some of the most BS logic ive ever read. Im also with Ed when he says that the conversation is completely relevant. Theres only 2 good bastards I can think of and more evil ones. All of the child Baratheons being some of them.

 

Gendry is a one of Baratheon's bastards. (the only one left if I'm not mistaken.) considering we went over the fact that I havent read the series in the last game I wouldn't know very many of these names you guys are throwing out. I don't consider Jeoffery a bastard, I consider him an illegitemate son.

 

Also ed, I'd have to be stupid to claim Jon Snow as mafia in the beginning of the game. Other than that I didn't read your rant, all things within the thread is gameplay,

 

underlined - wrong. in book 1 its stated that there really is no true # known of Roberts Bastards, that he was liekly the last left in Kingslanding, but the series is so much bigger than just Kingslanding. just stop talking cannon, your serioulsy embarrasing your self.

 

theres also Eldric Storm, which is introducted in book 2 and talked breifly abotu in book 1.

 

 

 

and also, seriously. (referring to the bolded and the underlined. you claim that "he's the only one left, if i'm not mistaken" then fling the "oh but ya'll also knwo i haven't read the series so there.

 

if you havent' read the series, then stop arguing flamming cannon like your some authority on it.

 

 

and btw, Stannis and Ned both call Joffery and his 2 siblings Bastards. Jamie even considers them Bastards. by the literal defination of the word they ARE Bastards. it doenst matter what you perosnally consider them, the FACT is they ARE Bastards.

 

 

 

I don't care, point is I don't count Jeoffry as a bastard get over it, not discussing semantics any longer.

 

its not semantics, its literal cannon. stop acting like your some authority on the series and actually know what your talkign about

[Red2111]

seriously, at this point i just want EP gone for how he's acting in terms of arguing with those of us who actually know what were talkign abotu in terms of cannon.

 

its both distracting and utterly infuraiting.

[ed2funy]

Other than that I didn't read your rant, all things within the thread is gameplay,

 

Of course, you're absolutely -

 

I also have my eye on Lenlo for the whole no lynch jab in his first post.

 

 

Riiiiiiiiiight. Sure thing, EP.

And then of course, unless you were skimming and read the end of the post first, you did read it, so meh. You play your silly game, and I will keep my vote on you until someone more scummy comes along.

 

 

Also ed, I'd have to be stupid to claim Jon Snow as mafia in the beginning of the game.

Ummmmm, hmmm....

*cough*

 

 

Unvote Vote Ed

 

Why are you still voting for Jon Snow?

Nolder, are you skimming or just not reading?

Go back here and read.

 

 

 

 

Because I totally wasn't having this "conversation" before Despo came along. And it totally only happened after he voted Verb.

*snort at EP and Mod lady*

[Darthe]

So which policy is that? Just to be clear? Is that the EP policy, the role hint policy, the campaign policy, or the D1 policy? Wow the poor guy has a lot against him before we even consider how he is playing.

 

defense of Ep noted right here. and before we even consider how he's playing, are you skimming as well because he's given us plenty to judge his play style over.

 

 

 

I don't care, point is I don't count Jeoffry as a bastard get over it, not discussing semantics any longer.

 

its not semantics, its literal cannon. stop acting like your some authority on the series and actually know what your talkign about

 

That was pretty obviously a joke about how many things people can pick on EP for before he starts to play sheerly based on his meta. Hence the part in green. I never said anything about not judging him for his playstyle as I think it is highly relevant. I just don't get the point in him claiming yet regardless of his affiliation..

 

For the second, I quoted it simply cause I like it. Lord knows I know that series better than most here.

[JenLenaMom]

I'm glad I'm not the only one thinking that EP seems to be trying to play like Mynd.

 

And really with EP I usually do exactly what I do with Mynd, ignore him unless he starts coming after me, lol.

 

Really though by coming out this early with absolutely no pressure on you I'm having serious doubts about you.

 

Please do remember spoiler tags folks, I haven't read ADwD yet and I'm in the midst of a re-read because I find I have a terrible memory for detail and the series is spoiling my sense of what really happens.

[ed2funy]

Grrrr, Red.

I missed your WoT.

 

*goes to read*

[bgrishinko]

if your trying to adopt a Mynd style of play, them shoes is too big for you to fill dude and your not accomplishing anything but turing the spotlight to you. if your scum, well thanks for makign it easy; if your being truthful about your claim well good job for making the scums job easy D1.

 

 

 

Your supportive of making it easy for scum D1?

[bgrishinko]

*You're

[Red2111]

from the offical companion Wiki for the HBO version (authorized by HBO, which has GRRM working intimately on the series)

 

He is widely believed to be the son of Cersei and the late Robert Baratheon but is actually a bastard of incest fathered by Cersei's own brother Jaime Lannister.

 

 

so i don't relaly give two hoots with what you consider a character EP, facts are facts. you literally know nothign about this series and you need to stop being such a flamming distraction.

 

 

JLM - dont worry, i've not seen anything posted yet which can be considered spoilers for DwD. we all knew of the Boltons Bastard in the 2nd book. and i wouldn't compliment EP by sayign he's playing liek Mynd. he's attempting to immitate Mynds playstyle and doign a very poor job at it imo.

 

 

That was pretty obviously a joke about how many things people can pick on EP for before he starts to play sheerly based on his meta. Hence the part in green. I never said anything about not judging him for his playstyle as I think it is highly relevant. I just don't get the point in him claiming yet regardless of his affiliation..

 

For the second, I quoted it simply cause I like it. Lord knows I know that series better than most here.

 

meh, i'd consider Wert to be the regional ASoF&I authority here tbh

 

i still see it as an early defense of EP, not out right blatant defesne, but subtle laying the gorund work style defense. it was worth noting imo

[Red2111]

no BG i'm supportive of geting rid of a person that thinks they know a series well enough to argue it when they clearly dont and on top of that is being a jerk about it.

 

 

espeically since i think he's doign it on purpose, i dont believe his claim, i think he's tryign to cause a distraction and cause chaos to limit the amoutn of D1 info we can gain and becuase he's not reacting well to pressure and his play is very sloppy.

[Nolder]

Ed: Unless you plan on counterclaiming there is no reason not to believe his claim

[Red2111]

no i'm not planning on CCing him and i have no proof he's not Snow. i'm not buying his claim because of how he claimed, and his actions in game. it pings less as a real claim and more as him tryign to draw out Snow

[JenLenaMom]

Red: I meant what you said, trying to imitate Mynd. Whose playstyle actually makes me crazy but works for some reason only known to his mynd (see what I did there, lol) I do miss playing with him when he can be all in as far as time.

[Red2111]

btw LEELERS!!

 

 

*runs over and glomps Leelou*

[ed2funy]

He said Ed, not Red.

 

And no, Noldy, I don't have to counterclaim to vote him. I don't believe him.

Apparently this is his play style he has picked up throughout all of his mafia games, and it is down right horrible game play.

[Leelou]

btw LEELERS!!

 

 

*runs over and glomps Leelou*

 

<3

 

I see that nickname is becoming more widely used LOL